Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

29th August 1851

Washington Colliery Explosion

Adjourned Inquest

The adjourned inquest on the bodies of the unfortunate sufferers by this explosion was held on Wednesday, in the National School-room, Washington.

Mr. Matthias Dunn, the Government inspector of mines, was present to watch the proceedings.

William Hartley, hewer, was the first witness examined. He said he left the pit about 4 or 5 o'clock on the night of the explosion. He left because he had burnt more candle than he ought. He had plenty of air, but it was mixed with gas and "stife." He did not think the pit more dangerous than usual. He had always had a fear for the last four or five weeks, as his candle had burnt heavy. Witness was in the first rise, the farthest board. There was nobody beyond him. Did not complain to any overman of the pit being in an unsafe state. Was afraid to go into the by-places, lest his candle should set fire to the gas which was hanging about. The deputies, Tommy Todd and Tommy Barras, knew of the gas hanging about these places. On Monday he told the back-overman, Charlton, that the air was mixed with gas. Charlton said he knew it was mixed, but did not say whether the pit was safe or unsafe. Where witness was working there was as much brattice as he wanted. Had worked there more than a fortnight. Witness's father worked a little lower down. His father always had a fear upon him. Witness found a standing fire on Anty Henderson's tub about a month ago. Witness thought the pit was not in a proper state for a man to be in when he saw the fire on the tub.

By the Inspector. — The gas mostly comes from the bottom of the seams. Did observe that the air was different on the Monday from what it had been for some time past.

Benjamin Hartley, hewer, brother of the last witness, said he went down the pit on Monday morning, at 2 o'clock, and came up at half-past 11. He was working in the head way board by the south dip side. He had worked in that part of the pit about six weeks, and had been two days in that board. The pit had not been in a good state during these six weeks. If he took a "lowe" into the high nook it "clicked" from the gas. The mine was making a good deal of gas in all the places witness had been in. Witness thought the gas had come from the stoves. The candle burnt just like an oil lamp, with a good deal larger light than usual. Witness was frightened, and had been for a good while. Was afraid of getting himself burnt at that flat, it was in such a bad state. The only place where he found a good air was in the first air. There was no brattice in the place where he had been working for the last two days. There ought to have been a brattice there. Had never asked for brattice. Charlton had been in that place both on the Monday and the Friday previous. Did not ask for brattice because he thought the overman knew better than he about it. They were there for the purpose of putting in brattice where it was wanted. Spoke to Charlton about the pit making gas, and Charlton tried his lamp in the high nook, and told witness it was making gas, and he (witness) had to slip it. Charlton did not tell him to get a lamp. The last day he was working at that place, which was on the Friday, his candle was three inches from the thill, and the gas clicked at it. Witness did not tell anyone about it, for he had nearly done his work. When witness was working in the west board, the gas clicked at his candle. This was about six weeks ago. He told the deputy, Tommy Barras, that the air was bad. Barras said it was very good. He did not see the click at witness's lowe, but witness had told him about it. The place was bratticed close up. The morning of the misfortune Peter Morgan, who lives near witness, came to witness and asked what had happened. Witness told him Washington-pit had fired. Morgan said he had expected it for some time past. Morgan went to Pittington on Tuesday.

By the Inspector. — He could not tell whether it was from the general air of the pit or from the gas from a fissure that his candle clicked, but thought it was the general air. The flame would be five inches long and three inches square. The flame stood and burnt on the thill, and witness put it out with his cap.

By Mr. Forster. — Had hewed in another Hutton seam, at Broomside. Never knew the gas to click there, but witness believed it to be a common thing to click in that seam.

W. Lamb said he had been a deputy three weeks last Monday. Was in the pit on the Monday of the explosion. Went down at 1 o'clock in the morning, and left at half-past 10. He was all the time in the Polka flat. It was in a good state when he went in, and continued in a good state all the time he was in. Found no gas there. There was a fall straight down from the flat. There was no gas on the side of the fall next the flat. Had not been there since the Monday previous. The last time he saw Robert Todd there was the Friday before it fired. Said nothing to him about gas. Todd said something to him about stones, and witness said he had no time to take the stones out. That was all that passed. The air was clear of gas in young Robert Todd's board on the Monday morning. That was the in-by side of the fall. Nobody ever complained to witness that it was not clear of gas then.

By the Inspector. — The boards where the Todds were working were not bratticed. They needed no brattice, because there was a hole about ten yards from the face in young Todd's board. The hole went into another board, and round to another place. The air would go through that hole. It gets far further down than that hole without any brattice to force it. It is a dip-board. This board was driven further in than the others. It was driven ten yards further than the board next to it. The air will travel in a dip-board 30 or 40 yards. Never heard Robert Todd say he wanted a brattice because the board was so much before the others.

By the Inspector. — The air would naturally tend to go straight along the headways, and pass Todd's place.

By Mr. Forster. — There would be a current of air sufficient to keep Todd's place clean coming through the stenton.

By the Coroner. — The stenton is 15 or 20 yards above Todd's board. The holing in that board put witness's candle out on the Friday by the force of the air current.

By the Inspector. — Witness's duty was to see that all places are clear of gas, to take the bottom up and lay the plates. He examined the boards regularly before the men went to work. Had heard men complain of the way their candles burnt in the cross-cut flat, where the pit fired. They said their candles burnt fast away. It was about three weeks since he last heard these complaints.

By the Coroner. — There are perhaps 30 lengths of plates in young Robert Todd's board, but cannot say exactly. There was a good air going over the fall every morning. Was in Todd's board early on Monday morning, and the air was good then.

Robert Todd, sen., who was examined on Wednesday last, said his son's board was driven 27 or 28 yards. There was nothing to force the air down that board.

The Coroner then asked Mr. Cruddace if he was prepared to give any information as to the place where the fire occurred.

Mr. Cruddace mentioned Mr. Nicholas Wood as one who was prepared to give information on the subject.

Mr. Nicholas Wood, colliery viewer, of Hetton, was then sworn. He examined the pit on Monday last. Witness was informed that the general ventilation of the colliery was the same as when he went down. Witness's opinion was that the firing took place in the second east board beyond the dams in the cross cutway. There was no indication of the fire having been large. It is a very dusty seam, and some of the men were probably choked with the dust. The stoppings were all restored when witness went down. In the place where the fire was supposed to have taken place William McNare's body was found, and a lamp was also found there with the top off. Witness himself picked up the bottom part of the lamp ; and he was told by Charlton that that lamp had never been removed. This led witness to suppose that the fire was caused by the top of the lamp having been taken off. Witness thought something must have happened to check the ventilation of the mine at the time it fired.

Mr. Thomas Emerson Forster, viewer. — Went down the Washington pit on Monday last. Had heard Mr. Wood's description of the place where the firing occurred, and perfectly agreed with Mr. Wood's statement. Does not consider it necessary to brattice the dip-boards.

Mr. Wood here remarked that in the Monkwearmouth pit he had observed the air go along the boards with a strong force when there was no brattice. This current arose from the difference of temperature between the lower and the upper air.

Mr. William Anderson, viewer, of South Shields. — Was down this pit on the 17th of April last, as well as on Monday. He confirmed the previous witnesses as to the general ventilation of the mine.

Mr. Charles William Anderson, viewer, son of the last witness, said that on Monday he traced the firing from the cross cut to the Polka flat.

Mr. George Southern, viewer (Kibblesworth), who went down the pit on Monday, agreed generally with the previous witnesses as to the cause of the explosion.

Mr. William Barkus, jun., and Mr. Laws, viewers, said they also agreed with Mr. Wood.

Mr. Samuel Wood, viewer, gave similar testimony.

Robinson Todd. — Had been a hewer two years at Washington pit. Worked in the same board that McNare worked in. Went down about 9 o'clock on Monday morning, and came up about 4 o'clock in the afternoon. He thought the pit made a little more gas that day than usual. Witness had no one working near him that day, and he was frightened. The candle showed a little more danger than it had ever done before. He was working at the dip. There were about 12 yards of brattice where he was working. From the top of his board to the bottom would be 42 or 43 yards. He had not too much air. His candle had always shown danger. Would rather have had more air. If the brattice had been put down to the face of the working, he would probably have had more air. Never asked any of the overmen to put in more brattice. Told Charlton to try his candle. Charlton did so, and then said it was a good deal better than it was the day before. It was not in a good state the day before. Witness was down on Monday with the gentlemen who had been examined to-day. George Charlton sent him down. Did not go so far as his own board, and cannot tell where the pit fired. Was down again on Tuesday with Mr. Dunn, the Government inspector. Was in his own board, and went up to the face of it. From the examination he made he thinks the pit fired in the place mentioned by Mr. Wood. The fire had been so severe there that it burnt the coal. Witness goes past this board every day.

The Coroner inquired if the men had examined the pit on their own account, or if any person had done so on their behalf.

Mr. Cruddace said Mr. Joseph Jude, Mr. Thomas Todd, and Mr. Robert Smith, hewers, were down on Saturday.

Joseph Jude being sworn said, that he had been a viewer at Washington pit three weeks previous to the fire. He worked at the second headways board. He went down the mine at 2 o'clock in the morning of the day it fired, and came up about half-past 6 the same morning. He observed nothing unusual in the burning of the candles. He had been working about a fortnight at that flat. The first day he worked at that flat he was alarmed at the spurious top on his candle. Thomas Barkus came with a lamp. Witness said he was not afraid of an explosion then ; but if there was a fire at another part of the mine, the consequences might be serious. The air itself was not capable of exploding at the candles, but it was alarming to look at. The air coming in was sufficient to sweep anything away. The west board was well kept up with brattice. The coal board was not so, but there was less occasion for it, the boards being to the dip. If the air had turned slack, there would be apprehension of danger. The gas principally came from the bottom, or thill, and not from the coal itself. Witness went down again on Tuesday morning, after the explosion. His supposition of the cause of the accident was that the boy coming in with his pony to take away McNare's coals had incautiously fired the thill with his candle, and left it burning several seconds unperceived by McNare.

After an adjournment of an hour.

Thomas Todd, hewer, was examined. — He went down Washington-pit on the Monday before it fired, about half-past 8 o'clock in the morning. He left about 8 at night. Was working in the Polka flat, in the southernmost board. The air was in a good state there. There was no brattice in that board, and no occasion for any. Was next down on the Saturday afternoon. Was in the first east board in the Cross-cut-flat. Could not tell the cause of the fire.

Robert Smith, hewer, said — He worked in the far cross-cut. Heard Mr. Jude tell the master that if something was not done, he (Jude) would be obliged to leave.

John High, shifter. — Was working last at the fall at the end of the Polka flat, opposite the stenton. Had plenty of air there. He was at the straight-in board on Friday night. It was the south rolley way board in the first cross-cut. He did not like the appearance of the candles that night. They were blazing up. This was owing to the gas. He believed it came out of the coal as well as the bottom. There was some brattice in witness's board, but he thought not sufficient, because the air was quite slack on the face of the board. The brattice was 12 or 14 yards from the face. Witness considered it dangerous. He did not name it to the overman or deputies. It had been named before.

Edward Ramsay, hewer. — Was last down Washington pit on Friday night. He was in the cross-cut flat at the first headways in the west side board. Considered the pit was in a very bad state there. The air was very much loaded. The candles showed danger. The tops were bluishy and three or four inches long. Some of the gas came from the bottom ; his candle flashed at the bottom. He told the deputy, Thomas Hall, about it, Told Thomas Urwin on the Friday that the pit was unsafe. Tommy Todd was trying it in the top nook in Urwin's board with his lamp, and it fired at the lamp. Todd was the deputy who was lost. Witness had plenty of air that night, but it was loaded with gas. Six weeks ago he observed in his candle signs of danger, and he put out the light. Witness told Peter Horn he believed the pit would fire. Peter said it would not. William Hall came in after that ; witness complained to him about the state of his board and said he was afraid it would fire. Willie Hall tried it with his lamp, and said it was not very clean, but it would not fire. Witness asked Hall for a lamp, and Hall would not give him one. Willie Hall was a careful man; he was one of the killed. One night, about three weeks ago, the air was rather cooler than usual ; generally speaking, it had been charged with gas during the last six weeks. Witness had a dread upon him every night from the appearance of his candle.

George Wilkinson, under-viewer of Monkwearmouth Colliery. — Went down Washington pit on the day after it fired. Thirty-two bodies had been got out when McNare's body was found. Witness and Brown went past the tub, and Brown said, "Here's a lamp-gauze." Witness picked it up and inserted its number "48" in his book. The lamp was within a yard or two of the face. McNare was lying about 25 yards from the face. He was burnt very much on one arm. McNare was employed at Monkwearmouth Colliery ; he was a steady man, but was discharged for taking the top of his lamp off in December last year. It was quite plain to witness that the fire had originated here, and gone south and west. Witness at once stated his belief that the firing had been caused by that man taking off his lamp top. There was a great deal of gas making in the face of McNare's board when witness was down. Gas was making in other parts, but not so much as in McNare's board.

By the Inspector. — The air courses were not generally inflammable, but gas was lodging about the face of some of the workings. The weakening of the general air-course had made McNare's board worse than it would have been.

John Dawson deposed to his finding the bottom of the lamp on Friday, after the explosion, about five yards from the face of the east board, where McNare had been working. McNare would have nothing to hang his lamp by when he took the top off, but he might place it on his "cracket."

By the Inspector. — There was no accumulation of gas in McNare's board on the day of the accident.

George Wilkinson. — Having heard where the bottom of the lamp was found, was strengthened in his opinion as to where the explosion originated. Would not say positively where the gas came from, but thought it came from the face, and fired at the lamp in McNare's hand.

George Charlton, overman, re-examined. — Was of opinion there had been some sudden check of the ventilation on the Monday night. He had examined every place about six hours before the mine fired, and found it in a good state. The candles had a brownish top. That did not show much gas ; the brownness might be caused by the candle being bad.

By the Inspector. — The men made no complaints to him of the pit being dangerous. Observed no gas at the brattice stoppings near the face on Friday.

Mr. Cruddace put in a copy of the regulations at Washington pit, which were read by the Coroner. They were of a very explicit character, pointing out the duties of the overmen and deputies to take every precaution to obtain a good ventilation and avoid explosions.

John Hunter, engine wright at the colliery, deposed that there was plenty of material for brattice at bank, and there was plenty before the explosion. When the overman gave orders for brattice witness made it, and it was sent down the pit. It was better not kept ready-made, as it was apt to give in the joints.

Mr. Matthias Dunn, the Government Inspector, having expressed a wish to give some statement on the subject, was then sworn. — He said he had examined the pit since it fired. Had not examined it before. Examined it yesterday. Quite agreed with the opinion expressed that the fire originated in McNare's board; but was also of opinion that there had been a deficiency of ventilation in the eastern quarter. This might arise partly from three causes — first, a temporary obstruction caused by the falls which had been spoken of, supposing they took place before it fired. Another cause might be a temporary disregard of the rolley way door leading south, or the door leading to McNare's place. Has no reason to suppose they were neglected. A third cause would be the slackening of the furnaces. It certainly did not come under the denomination of a fiery pit. If the men working at this colliery had acquainted him with the facts which they had stated on this inquiry, he would have felt it his duty to examine the pit. He wished this to be understood by pitmen generally.

The evidence closed about 7 o'clock, when the Coroner intimated his intention to adjourn to the following day, as he had all the evidence to read over.

The Jury strongly objected to this adjournment, and the Coroner ultimately agreed to adjourn for an hour and a half.

On the re-assembling of the Court, the Coroner read the evidence at length.

Newcastle, Aug. 28.

The Jury did not arrive at their verdict till between 11 and 12 o'clock last night. It was as follows :— "We are of opinion that William Hall and the 32 others named in the depositions came by their deaths by the firing of the Washington Pit, in McNare's board, on the 18th of August inst. ; and we are of opinion that the air, having been highly charged with gas previously, and probably receiving a sudden check, had caused the fire to increase outside this board ; that lamps ought to have been used instead of candles ; and there should have been more brattice, as recommended by Mr. Dunn."

It should be remarked that Mr. Dunn's recommendation was made after the explosion, as appears from the evidence, he not having examined the pit previously.

A subscription has been started on behalf of the unfortunate men killed, of whom there are 35 altogether.

The inquest on the two furnacemen who went down the pit after the explosion will be held on Monday next.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Anderson, Charles William      Whos Who Page
Anderson, William      
Barkus, Thomas      
Barkus, William, jun.      
Barras, Thomas      
Charlton, —      
Charlton, George      
Dawson, John      
Dunn, Matthias    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Forster, —      
Forster, Thomas Emerson      Whos Who Page
Hall, Thomas      
Hall, William      
Hartley, Benjamin      
Hartley, William      
Henderson, Anthony      
High, John      
Horn, Peter      
Hunter, John      
Jude, Joseph      
Lamb, W.      
Laws, —      
McNare, —      
McNare, William      
Morgan, Peter      
Ramsay, Edward      
Smith, Robert      
Southern, George William      Whos Who Page
Todd, Robert      
Todd, Robert, sen.      
Todd, Robinson      
Todd, Thomas      
Todd, Thomas      
Urwin, Thomas      
Wilkinson, George      
Wood, Nicholas      Whos Who Page
Wood, Samuel      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Washington Colliery  Washington Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
18 Aug 1851  Colliery Explosion At Washington, Thirty-five Lives Lost (Annual Register for 1851)
21 Aug 1851  Destructive Colliery Explosion (The Times)
22 Aug 1851  The Washington Colliery Explosion (The Times)
23 Aug 1851  Dreadful Colliery Explosion At Washington, Loss Of Thirty-four Lives (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
29 Aug 1851  Washington Colliery Explosion, Adjourned Inquest (The Times)
30 Aug 1851  Perils Of Coal Miners (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
30 Aug 1851  The Washington Inquest (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
30 Aug 1851  The Explosion At Washington Colliery, The Adjourned Inquest (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
30 Aug 1851  Explosion At Washington Colliery, Subscription on Behalf Of The Sufferers (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
06 Sep 1851  The Washington Colliery Explosion (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
06 Sep 1851  Explosion At Washington Colliery, Subscription on Behalf Of The Sufferers (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
13 Sep 1851  Explosion At Washington Colliery, Subscription on Behalf Of The Sufferers (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
20 Sep 1851  Explosion At Washington Colliery, Subscriptions On Behalf Of The Sufferers (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
27 Sep 1851  Explosion At Washington Colliery, Additional Subscriptions (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
04 Oct 1851  Explosion At Washington Colliery, Additional Subscriptions (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
11 Oct 1851  Explosion At Washington Colliery, Additional Subscriptions (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
18 Oct 1851  Explosion At Washington Colliery, Additional Subscriptions (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
22 Nov 1851  Gateshead Board Of Guardians (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
22 Nov 1851  Explosion At Washington Colliery, Additional Subscriptions (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Washington
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print