|
26th July 1851, Page: 5, Column: 2 The Coal And Coasting TradesSeveral years have now elapsed since Mr. James Mather, of South Shields, penned and published a pamphlet, the main object of which was to show the danger that menaced the coal-coasting trade from the assumed superiority of railway over maritime transit. Whilst awarding due meed of praise to our talented neighbour for his ingenious speculations and benevolent intentions, so far at least as this district and its leading interests are concerned, we never felt those paroxysms of alarm which appeared then to to have seized the author and considerably impaired (as we then thought) the strength and clearness of his judgment. Within the last few weeks, however, we have had something like a resuscitation of that gentleman's opinions and fears, writers, metropolitan and local, vying with each other in attempts to frighten the ship-owners out of their propriety by asserting and attempting to prove that very speedily the railways will engross all the carrying trade to the southern markets, and there will be an end of the employment now afforded to that class of vessels known by the appellation of colliers. Of course, the Tyne and Wear would become nearly deserted — another heavy blow would be given to the keelmen, the occupation of coal-fitters would be almost gone, and nothing but ruin and devastation would remain. Somewhat scared by the dreary prospect, our brethren of the broad-sheet have confined these articles to the locality of "correspondence," and a Sunderland Saturday's journal, after fretting the spirits of its patrons last week, by the gloomy vaticinations of "a Colliery Agent," soothes their sorrows by the consoling dictum that "after carefully reading our correspondent's letter we remain of opinion that the collier has nothing to fear from a railway starting direct from this coal district." Turning to the letter, which is replete with statistical lore and arithmetical calculations, we find "the practicability of the railway system," which the writer tells us it was his only object to show, rests on the condition that a double line of railway, for coal traffic only, shall be constructed from Newcastle to London, and that another line shall be laid down from this town to York ! It quite evident this Colliery Agent never looks at the share-list, and he must have forgotten, if he ever knew, that the Direct Coal Line to London, which was started in the very height of the scrip mania, never reached beyond the issue of a prospectus and the formation of a provisional committee, being regarded, indeed, as about as rational a scheme as a railway to the moon ! We hope, therefore, that none of the good people of Sunderland will hastily consign their craft to destruction; let them wait, at all events, until the new lines are made, or at least until the capital is subscribed and the works let. But there is a class of alarmists who consider that the coasting trade will be entirely ruined by the existing railways, and certainly if the statement put forth by what the Times justly calls "respectable authority" be well-founded, namely, that a ton of coal can be carried a hundred miles for a shilling, with profit, the controversy must be regarded as closed. We are very far, however, from being satisfied on this point. Neither facts nor figures have been given to support it; and a letter from Mr. Lindsay in the Times of Thursday somewhat qualifies the statement, for it alleges that there are contracts at present in force for the conveyance of coals, inclusive of waggons and all other charges, at the rate of one farthing per ton per mile, or two shillings and one penny per ton per 100 miles; it adds a confirmation of the important statement, by various gentlemen whose opinions in such matters Mr. Lindsay feels he is bound to respect, viz. that "when the arrangements are complete for conducting an extensive trade," the great trunk lines will be enabled to carry coals at the rate previously given. In either case he considers the days of our coasting trade numbered, and forthwith counsels the Legislature to throw open the trade to foreigners, in order that British ship-owners may be permitted to share in the valuable coasting trade of the new world. Leaving the shipping interest to settle the latter point, we confess that we should have liked greater detail and fuller explanation as to the former — such, for instance, as the companies with which these contracts have been made, how long they have been in existence, what conditions are annexed to them, and the length of line to which they apply. We know that a halfpenny per ton per mile, exclusive of waggons, has hitherto been deemed a very low charge, and this would make the cost of haulage to London something like 12s 6d per ton, or above double the freight now paid, and there is nothing in the present aspect of railway receipts and dividends to lead to the belief that the directors of these undertakings will be able or willing to reduce very materially their charges. Of course these remarks have reference entirely to the Northern coal-field. From the Midland Counties a great quantity of coal unquestionably finds its way to the London market; it is inferior both in point of excellence and economy to the produce of the Durham and Northumberland mines, and from inquiries made in the neighbourhood of the coal-depots both of the Great Northern and North Western Railways, we recently ascertained that even in Somers Town, Camden Town and Islington seaborne coal can be purchased in small quantities as cheaply as from the rail way-depots: but its introduction will and must have some effect on the quantity shipped from the ports of this coal-district. Recent returns show that this effect is, as yet, very limited, the vend coastwise for 1850 being indeed larger than the preceding year; but should it be more extended, we would not have the ship-owners despair. The coal and shipping interests of the North must heartily co-operate, and increase their exertions in proportion to the exigencies of the times. They have a good article, and both the producer and carrier must still strive to obtain a fair remuneration for their capital and industry. But if ships are to compete with railways, they ought to be lightened of some of their burdens. First and foremost, the heavy city dues must be abolished ; the charges for lights must also be reduced, and a joint effort made to expedite the passage by shortening the period of detention both in the Northern ports and the Thames. If all parties interested in our great staple trade would only lay their grievances fully before Parliament and the country, we cannot doubt that they would receive prompt attention and complete redress. At all events this would be a wiser course, both on the part of ship-owners and colliery proprietors than filling the columns of newspapers with dark pictures of coming woes.
|
|||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||