Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

23rd November 1850

The Colliery Explosion at Houghton

Houghton, Thursday.

The inquest was resumed this day, before Mr. Maynard, the coroner for the county.

Mr. Tremenhere, having been appointed by the Government to investigate the circumstances attending this melancholy sacrifice of human life, was present.

Thomas Crawford, a viewer under the Earl of Durham, stated that he was well acquainted with the Houghton Colliery, which was commenced in the year 1828 ; it was "laid in," or stopped, in 1838, and reopened in December, 1849. He was last down the pit about six months previous to the explosion. He examined the state of the ventilation at that time, and found quite sufficient air going through both for the ventilation of the workings and the safety of the men. The whole coal was worked with candle ; the pillars, or "broken," with the Davy-lamp. He produce a plan of the mine. The "goaf" consisted of four plots, two of 18 acres in extent, one of seven acres, and one of four acres. One goaf is at the eastern extremity of the pit, another at the southern, another at the western, and the small one, of four acres, in the centre. Most of the men at the time of the explosion were working on the west side of the western goaf.

By Mr. Tremenhere. — It was his usual habit only to visit the pit once in six months, and he considered that sufficient, with the communications made from time to time by the resident viewer. The pit was not in a more dangerous state since it was reopened in December, 1849, than it was before it was closed in 1838. The ventilation was kept up all the time the colliery was laid in.

By the Coroner. — I have no stated periods of receiving reports from the resident viewer, Mr. Rutherford, but I generally saw him once or twice a week.

By Mr. Forster, who, at the request of Mr. Tremenhere, examined this and other witnesses. — If there had been anything extraordinary in the working of the pit, he should have expected a special report from Mr. Rutherford. He received no such communication.

John Rutherford, resident viewer of the Houghton pit, did not consider it a dangerous pit. He had never observed gas oozing from the edge of the goaf into the pit. Never measured the air passing through the mine, but he knew there was a sufficiency from never having received any complaints. He was at home on Monday, the 11th inst., when he heard of the explosion. He immediately proceeded to the mine. It was about 7 o'clock ; three or four men were down then. He went down and joined them ; they proceeded up the south incline, which is in the direction of the workings. Found the first body near the top of the incline ; it was John Kelty‘s ; he was alive when found but is since dead. That would be between 20 and 30 yards from the shaft. He died about 18 hours after being brought out. He continued to proceed along the main air course till he came to a large fall of stone from the roof, which stopped his progress ; they then got more assistance, and commenced making a road through it. It extended between 70 and 80 yards. They got through the fall in about 20 minutes afterwards ; and then they found a number of men alive. Beyond the fall the road was clear. About 120 yards beyond the fall they found a horse dead. They repaired the crossing so that the air resumed its natural course. They then proceeded onward, and found several dead bodies ; they appeared to have been killed by the afterdamp. He could not form any opinion, from what he saw, as to the cause of the explosion.

By Mr. Tremenhere. — Though he did not measure the quantity of air, he examined the velocity of the current every time he went down. He did this by holding a candle in the current. When they measured the velocity of the air yesterday they found it about 3 feet per second at the cross-cut. Examined it about three weeks before the explosion. When down on the 31st was not near that part ; there was no working there. Between the 31st of October and the 11th inst. He was not down so frequently as usual ; was not down in that interval. Did not consider the place where Watchman was to be more dangerous than where the rest of the men were. The rest of the men were working nearer to the edge of a goaf than Watchman was.

By the Coroner. — Believed if the man working there had been working with a lamp the explosion would not have taken place. It was his opinion the explosion did occur there from being unable to find any indications of its having taken place elsewhere.

By Mr. Tremenhere. — Had great confidence in Hunter. Cannot account for his having allowed the neglect apparent in this instance.

Ralph Elliott was called and examined. — Lives at Pensher Colliery, and is a viewer for the Marquis of Londonderry. Has had nearly 40 years' practice in ventilating mines. On Monday the 11th inst., received a special message from Mr. Rutherford. Went down the pit along with Mr. Rutherford, and could corroborate all that he had stated with respect to the condition in which they found the workings. Agreed with him that the explosion took place where Watchman was working. The mine does not generate much gas. Had much gas been in the mine at the time of the explosion, none of the men could have been saved. Should say the general ventilation of the mine was good. Was of opinion the explosion arose either from a naked candle or a broken Davy-lamp. Did not think any one so likely to have been the cause of the explosion as Watchman himself. The gas fired at his light.

By a Juror. — He had known Mr. Rutherford, the viewer of the colliery, for about 10 years, and considered him decidedly competent to have charge of the pit.

By the Coroner. — This explosion might have taken place in the hands of the most experienced viewer.

In reply to questions, the witness stated that the current of air after it was split was not sufficient to prevent the gas escaping from the goaf, and therefore lamps were used as a precaution ; but that, although the air was not sufficient to prevent the gas escaping, it was quite sufficient, under ordinary circumstances, to carry the gas off into the return drift.

John Coar. — I was lamp-keeper at Houghton Pit. The lamps are kept in a cabin near the bottom of the shaft. I went down the pit at 12 o'clock on the Sunday night before the accident. Between that time and 2 o'clock I supplied 19 lamps to different workmen, but did not supply one to the deceased Watchman. He could not have got one himself without breaking the cabin open, and it had not been broken open when he left the pit, about a quarter past 4 o'clock. He had a naked candle. He had his candle by the side of him when witness left. The candle was burning quite bright and clear. He was working two or three yards from the Mothergate board, where the air is split. I know the deceased overman John Hunter. I saw him at about 1 o'clock with a person of the name of Parkinson. He asked me for a candle. I gave him one, and told him a lamp was ordered. He went away with it. He went towards a back drift, where a person of the name Parkinson was to work. On returning he said there was no need for the lamp, but as it was ordered the person was to have it. A boy of the name of Anderson was there, and by Hunter‘s direction, witness told him to go and assist Watchman. I was about seven minutes in conversation with Hunter. He was quite sober. He bore a good character with the men, and was considered a careful steady man.

By Mr. Tremenhere. — I afterwards saw the boy Anderson working along with Watchman, taking the coal away. I made no remark to Watchman about his working with a candle. The place felt quite pleasant.

Ralph Mackintosh. — Is an "onsetter" in Houghton pit. Went down about a quarter before 2 o'clock on the morning of the accident. All went well till about half-past 5 o'clock, when there was a "break up" of waggons on the incline. After putting it right he went to the top of the incline, and there saw Edward Hodgson, and Hunter, the overman. They went together into the cabin, and he returned to the shaft. While there, shortly after 6 o'clock, there was a strong gust of wind from the workings, which showed that an explosion took place. Hunter was perfectly sober.

Anthony Winship. — Is a wasteman in Houghton pit. His duty is to examine the various places where the men are going to work previous to their going. Was in the pit on Sunday night, and found all the places in a good state. Was present when Mr. Rutherford pointed out where the cross-cut was to be made. Hunter was also present. Mr. Rutherford said the men working it were to use lamps. That is about a month ago. Had some men employed at the Mothergate-end, about 40 yards from where the cross-cut was to be made. The men had both candles and lamps. There were no indications of gas. They had lamps as well as candles, because, if they should have occasion to go any further in beyond that point where the air is divided, they might have the lamps ready. It was perfectly safe to work with candles up to that point.

By Mr. Tremenhere. — They use the Davy lamp, and they are always locked when given to the men.

William Parkinson. — Is a pitman, and was working at Houghton-pit, at the end of where it is split, in the eastern district, on the Sunday night. The air was perfectly good. They had both lamps and candles. They used the lamps when we went further in. Past the first boarding there were no indications of gas.

By Mr. Jude. — Was assisting in preparing the way for this working, and they used candles then. That was about a week ago.

By Mr. Tremenhere. — Never went past the first board with the naked candle, or saw any one else do so.

William Errington. — Worked with Parkinson at the Mothergate-end on the Sunday night, and gave similar evidence as to the state of the mine at that part.

At this point the inquiry was adjourned until the following day.

(By Electric Telegraph.)

Friday Night.

After the examination of several other witnesses, whose evidence seemed to show that the system of ventilation adopted is sufficient for the working of the mine and the safety of the works,

The Jury retired, and, after an absence of about 20 minutes, returned a verdict to the effect that John Watchman and others, all pitmen in the Houghton pit, came to their deaths by the effect of an explosion of firedamp ; that such explosion took place at a naked lamp which had been negligently or improperly used by the said John Watchman, either contrary to orders given to him, or in consequence of William Hunter, the overseer, not having given such orders.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Coar, John      
Crawford, Thomas      
Durham, Earl of      Whos Who Page
Elliott, Ralph      
Errington, William      
Forster, —      
Hodgson, Edward      
Jude, Martin      Whos Who Page
Kelty, John      
Londonderry, Marquis of      
Mackintosh, Ralph      
Maynard, Thomas Christopher      Whos Who Page
Parkinson, William      
Rutherford, —      
Rutherford, John      
Tremenhere, —      
Winship, Anthony      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Houghton Colliery  Houghton Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
11 Nov 1850  Fearful Coal-Pit Explosions (Annual Register for 1850)
13 Nov 1850  Awful Colliery Explosion (The Times)
14 Nov 1850  The Explosion at Houghton Colliery (The Times)
16 Nov 1850  Weekly Retrospect, Colliery Explosions (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
16 Nov 1850  Destructive Explosion At One Of Lord Durham's Collieries, Twenty-Six Lives Lost (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
23 Nov 1850  The Colliery Explosion at Houghton (The Times)
23 Nov 1850  The Late Colliery Explosion At Houghton, Coroner's Inquest (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Houghton
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 19 Jan 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print