27th September 1850
Letters to the Editor
The Colliery Population
To The Editor Of The Times.
Sir, — You have lately made the condition of the mining population the subject of remark, taking as the text of your observations the valuable reports of Mr. Tremenheere, the inspector under what is usually called Lord Ashley's Act.
I agree generally with your remarks, and am surprised at the knowledge you evince of the habits of life and tendencies of so peculiar a class. I do not, however, altogether agree with either you or Mr. Tremenheere in the belief that no perceptible
advance in intellectual or moral culture has been made during the operation of that act. I am confident that this stricture does not apply to the case of the workmen in the Great Northern Coal Fields, while at the same time I regret its justice as
regards their condition in other districts. Assuming therefore, a stationary position as regards improvement in the colliery population with the above exception (such position, compared with the advance of other classes, being virtually retrogressive), I
address you in the hope of being able to point out how under the working of a recent legislation, a better state of things may be anticipated. The "economy" (if it may be so termed) of the mining classes, from the secluded nature of their
employment, is singular and strangely obstructive to all innovation ; their whole knowledge has hitherto been confined to a practice unknown to any but their own brotherhood. Hence a delusive conceit of superior intelligence has originated much to their
disadvantage. Vaunting their own knowledge, they ignorantly plume themselves on the technicalities of their trade and refuse to receive instruction otherwise conveyed ; thus, equally despising and despised by other operatives, they almost universally
present the aspect of a large community surrounded by and interspersed with other classes, and yet preserving a constant and inviolate barrier against the interchange of information. Again, although pursuing their operations with energy and to the best
of their ability, they are from a like cause (i.e. the nature of the work) solely dependent in many parts on the mining knowledge of their own peculiar district for information.
Hence the vast disparity — of the system employed in our coal field, as compared with another in attention to just principles — of the means used to protect life, and of facilities afforded for mental culture. In the great collieries of the
North — with vast interests at stake and circumstances of unequalled difficulty and danger — the science of mining has advanced to the highest state of known perfection in the world. Their viewers or mining engineers are men of very superior
education, obtaining high remuneration for their services. Acquainted with their systems pursued in other districts equally as well abroad as at home, and capable of availing themselves of scientific knowledge, they have devised or collated that practice
which, varying with each natural difficulty, offers the utmost known security to the interests confided to their charge, whether as regards the pecuniary welfare of the proprietors or the safety of the workmen.
Under them, introduced to facilitate their system, schools have been fostered and the character and intelligence of the population are still imperfectly yet progressively advanced. But in other districts (of course with individual exceptions) the mining
agent is a man of little education ; he is the "practical man" alone, as he is silly enough to boast. Under him that system, which is the habit of the district, is carried out, unassisted by the knowledge of other methods or the appliances of
other districts. According to the measure of his own individual ability, so is the increased or decreased safety of his workmen, unaffected by the example of superior precaution elsewhere ; often coarse in his own tastes and desires, and having a
contempt for other knowledge than what he himself possesses, he considers (and, perhaps, rightly in their state) the least intellectual pleasures the most adapted to his workmen and any but the rudest learning unsuited to their position.
Such are the extremes of variation under which coal mining is conducted, unexaggerated, and borne out by every syllable of evidence given before the Special Committee on Coal Mine Accidents in 1849, or contained in the reports of each commissioner
instructed to inquire into the question for the last 20 years.
It has been left to Sir G. Grey to adopt that course which had long been felt to be so necessary for the proper protection of the workman by those few persons who had examined the subject without prejudice and with a proper amount of practical
knowledge to be able to for a right judgement. Conferring much honour upon himself by his disinterested conduct, Sir G. Grey, although intimately connected with the colliery districts, introduced and carried an act last season authorizing him to
appoint inspectors of coal mines.
This the more rebounds to his credit, inasmuch as the section opposed to such a measure were among the most influential members of both Houses, while those few persons who understood its imperative necessity were of infinitely less weight. Nevertheless,
by an almost obstinate adherence to his convictions the measure was carried — giving no powers beyond those necessary to secure a proper examination of each mine. The act at the same time affords an assurance to the workman that suggestions will be
supplied calculated to place him under the same circumstances of protection as his fellow pitmen in the best districts, while the agent will be enabled to inform himself of the practice of those districts and be put in a position to equal their
progression.
Doubtless the inspectors will also be instructed to exercise the utmost care in their intercourse with the agent or owner, to impress, where necessary, on him the importance of good schools, supported and influenced by their assistance and countenance ;
and it is in carrying into execution this branch of his duties that I believe the inspector will be enabled to give a lasting impetus to the proper education of both the workpeople and also agents (where required). If he courteously and without arrogance
apply himself to convince the various agents in his district of the urgency of such measures, and at the same time be possessed of that practical knowledge which entitles him to their respect, he will find, I am convinced, many willing to adopt his views
; their example will influence others, even the most reluctant more or less, till gradually it will come to be considered an evidence of neglect if no school supported as above exists in each colliery. A desire, moreover, to equal the most educated
mining engineers would, with the knowledge of their acquirements, arise among the agents themselves. I cannot in the space of this letter enter into the subject of their education, but should you permit me at a future time I will refer in another
communication to the opportunity presented by the institution of the Museum of Practical Geology for the establishment of a Mining College, where the higher or more scientific branches of the profession might be studied — having also through its
graduates a salutary influence over the local schools.
I have the honour to be, Sir, your obedient servant, and
Morley's-hotel, Sept. 26.
A Viewer.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Grey, George, Sir | | | |
| Tremenheere, — | | | |