|
16th June 1849, Page: 3, Column: 1 The Hebburn Colliery ExplosionAdjourned InquestThe adjourned inquiry into the cause of this dreadful explosion, by which thirty-three persons lost their lives, was held at the Ellison Arms, Hebburn, at ten o'clock on Wednesday last. The chief points of inquiry, as will be seen by the evidence given below, were, as to whether the overman had made a proper examination of the workings before the men entered, whether the general condition of the mine was satisfactory, and if sufficient precautions had been taken. On the former point, it was proved that the deputy, Richard Lowes, whose duty it was to examine the mine, went down with the men, and this was stated to be a usual practice, the custom in the case being, that on their arrival at the first workings in which gas could possibly accumulate, the men sit down till the deputy goes forward and explores the district, and returns to them with his report. In this case, both Lowes and the whole of those who were with him were killed, and therefore no one is able to give authentic information; but the presumption is, that as he was there for the purpose of doing his duty, that his duty was done. Another favourable supposition is, that the body of the deputy was found a considerable distance beyond those of the men. In reference to the state of the mine at the time, we have not only the testimony of the men who had left work at four o'clock, but also that of Mr. Robinson, who said that he had passed twice through the undulations, where the explosion is supposed to have originated, that morning, and had observed nothing particular. He also says that it was not customary for gas to be lodged there, for only a few days before he had repaired the roof, being lighted by an open candle. Respecting the general character of the mine and its ventilation, perhaps the most explicit evidence is that of Mr. Liddell, who says he always was accustomed to consider it "the model colliery of the north." There appeared to be but one opinion respecting the place at which it had fired, the indications being that to the east of the undulations, the wood and coal were charred on the west side, and to the west of that part on the east side — plainly indicating that it had travelled east and west from this point. It was also stated that considering it to have originated in the manner supposed, the adoption of Mr. Gurney's principle could not have prevented it, as it could not be considered to have arisen from any deficiency of ventilation. The coroner, Mr. Favell, first proceeded to call James Heppell, who deposed : he was at the stone work in Hebburn pit, on Monday night; was working on waggon-way at the east end of the up-cast, levelling the ground for George Laverick and others to come to lay the plates, at four o'clock in the morning. It was 6½ feet in height, the undulations were about thirty yards west of him, and consequently the air went from him to them. Had plenty of good air, and was working with candles. He had never used lamps, nor had any complaints been made of his using candles, was under Mr. Robinson, who superintended the stone work. It was not Robinson's duty to examine the state of the pit, that was the duty of the deputies. When he left at four o'clock it was quite safe. By a juryman — James Wasburn had been through that part that morning, and it was his duty to look after the gas. There was gunpowder down the pit, but it was carefully put away to the south of the place. Richard Brock said he was a shifter in the pit, and left at four o'clock on Tuesday morning; had been working with Heppell. Had worked five months in that part of the pit; the air was always considered good, and he had never heard any complaints of the air. He worked with candles, and would not have been afraid to have gone into the workings with one. — A juryman asked witness some questions as to the parties whose duty it was to look after the pit, and whether he had seen them there that morning. Witness answering that it was possible for Mr. Clark or Mr. Robinson to be there without having seen them, the coroner suggested that they should call Mr. Robinson himself. James Robinson said he was a master sinker; his duties to look after the stone work and the shafts. He had nothing to do with the working of the coal or the gas. Went down the pit at four o'clock that morning. [Witness here explained by the plan the road he took in going through the workings.] He was twice through the undulations after four o'clock, and stopped about an hour with the plate layers. The air was good; he had a candle in his hand about three or four feet high, but he never tried above his head. Had never heard of gas accumulating in the undulations. It was about ten days since they were repairing the roof of the undulations, and they then worked with candles. Had never heard any complaint made to Mr. Easton of the state of the mine. He had come out a few minutes before six, and immediately afterwards the explosion took place. Thomas Blackburn, banksman, said he went to work at a quarter before five that morning; the men had gone before him. [By a juror.] — He did not let any of the overmen down, but Mr. Clarke was down before him. George Pattinson said there was powder down the pit at the time of the accident, but there was not more than 10lb. left. It was taken down on the Friday week previous, and had been put out of everybody's way, in one of the holings. No one knew but his "marrows" where it was hid, no boys could get at it, and no one could pass down that way with a light, by which to set fire to the powder. [The coroner here said, that as no bodies were found near where the powder had exploded, is was evident it had not originated there.] James Davison, engineman, said he went to his engine at three o'clock in the morning. The men that were killed went down at half-past four. Richard Lowes, the deputy, and one of the sufferers, went down along with them. Could not say whether he went first or not. Clarke, the overman, and Peel, the wasteman, went down at four: they were first down. Robinson went down at the same time as the men. Thos. Clarke said he had been overman 21 years. It was his duty to examine the whole of the pit; and, on the morning of the explosion, he went in at four. He went first to the east district of the workings, and was on his way to that part where she fired at the time the accident took place. He was knocked down by the wind, and on getting up and going forward, he met with the first man, but could not rescue him for the after damp. The air was always considered good. Edwd. F. Boyd, colliery viewer to the Dean and Chapter of Durham, said he had twenty-five pits to go down and examine. He went down Hebburn pit about 5 o'clock on the evening of the explosion ; from the observations that he made, he was of opinion that the explosion had originated somewhere in the undulations and had travelled west and south from there. Mr. Easton had measured the air passing into that part where she fired, and it was 16,882 feet per minute, the total going down the pit was 45,776 feet. From the small number of workings he should consider that this quantity was far more than sufficient for the efficient ventilation of the pit, the workings were comparatively narrow and therefore safer and more manageable. There was more air for the number of workings in this, than in any other pit with which he was connected, and the boreholes into the seams below, and the drifts into the seams above for the letting off of gas, was a more than usual precaution. The borings were all properly bratticed. Judging from the quantity of air passing through, the small number of workings, and the means taken to force the air through them, it was scarcely possible to foul there. He thought it most probable that by some means, probably partly on account of the peculiar state of the atmosphere on Monday evening, a quantity of gas had lodged in the undulations above the regular current, and that on its being forced out and coming in contact with the candles it had exploded. George Southern, colliery viewer, living at Kibblesworth, said, he went down about two o'clock on the day after the pit fired. He was of opinion that the explosion had taken place about the west part of the undulations, as they were higher there, and as he heard that there were frequent discharges of gas where the men were laying the rails. He was of the same opinion as Mr. Boyd respecting the pressure of the atmosphere, according to the state of the weather, the efficiency of the ventilation, and the accumulation of gas in the undulations, as being the cause of the accident. Matthew Liddell, colliery viewer at Benton Bridge, went down and through the workings on Wednesday evening after the fire. He was of opinion that the fire had originated a short distance to the west of the undulations. In consequence of this opinion, he supposed that the pit having been off work for two days an extraordinary discharge of gas had been generated, either from the walls or from the thill (or ground), and had accumulated in the upper part of the undulations. Supposing this to be the case, than the trams and horses passing along in an opposite direction to the air would, for a moment, obstruct the regular current, and force it more rapidly through the undulations, and carry out any gas that had accumulated in them, and that the gas had ignited at the first candle. He had always considered this to be a model colliery for ventilation in the north of England. The air he considered more than sufficient for the thorough ventilation of the mine. James Easton's second examination — He had measured the air passing down the shaft since the fire, and would consider it precisely the same as hitherto, and found it to be 45,776 cubic feet per minute: passing in the first north headways 8,542 ; and second north 8,340 — total 16,882 feet. He is still of the same opinion that the fire had originated a little west of the undulations and that it arose from the cause then stated ; he thought the undulations could contain between 4000 or 5000 feet of gas above the level of the current of the air, or 5½ feet. It was the custom of the wasteman to go through the workings when the pit was off work, in this case they were not sure of going to work till two o'clock in the morning and then a caller went round and called the men to their work. Lowes had to inspect the part and he went down either with or before them. [Mr. Liddell here further explained that it was customary for the deputy to go down with the men, and on their arrival at the first workings for the men to wait till the deputy went forward and examined the state of the mine.] The jury after an absence of about an hour, returned, and Mr. Todd gave the following verdict :— "We are of opinion that Thomas Young and 32 others were killed by the firing of the Hebburn pit, on the fifth day of June instant, by the accumulation of gas in the undulations of the north-west way and igniting with the candle, accidentally caused their death thereby. We strongly recommend that the deputy or others having charge of the workings of the pit, go down at least one hour previous to the pit starting work, and that in future lamps be entirely substituted for candles."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||