|
Whitehaven HeraldArticle from the Whitehaven Herald, 4th November 1848 The Awful Explosion at Whinney Hill PitTo the Editor of the Whitehaven HeraldSir, — An account of the awful explosion which occurred on Saturday morning last, on Cleator Moor, has been laid before the public, and whilst the result has filled every mind with the most appalling sensations, I think the details connected with the melancholy circumstances are calculated to invite reflection, as some of them, if duly considered, might possibly be turned to a good account, and be the means of preventing the recurrence of such awful calamities in future. During the eight or nine years that I have resided in this locality, independent of innumerable casualties and misfortunes of minor note, there have three tremendous explosions in three different pits in this neighbourhood — one near Harrington, another, not long afterwards, at William Pit, and that which has just occurred on Cleator Moor, the awful consequences of which so many bereaved families have been left to deplore. By the three calamities to which I have alluded, upwards of one hundred of the individual portion of our fellow creatures have been consigned to premature graves! These are indeed awful consequences, and the important question presented for consideration is, whether or not they cannot be avoided — whether or not the discoveries made in modern science will enable the miner, with no more that the exercise of ordinary care and prudence, to secure both his own preservation, and also that of his fellow-labourers. A variety of arguments might be advanced in support of the assertion, that the advantages derived from modern science does enable the prudent miner to secure his preservation in the mine, were it not for the imprudence of those with whom he is associated in his labours, and whose careless conduct alike exposes not only themselves but others to danger and to death; but instead of advancing any argument of my own to prove the tenable position I have thought proper to occupy, I will maintain that position by deductions from the evidence of the miners themselves. In the melancholy occurrence now before the public, two men only, out of upwards of thirty, have been saved, and the evidence of both has been recorded, as well as that of Foster, the overman, and I think the evidence of these men present features which a regards for humanity would forbid us to overlook. It appears on all hands that the gentleman who compose the Hematite Iron Company have not only expressed the deepest concern for the safe condition of their works, but that they actually had them in that condition, and that everything had been done by them, as far as human foresight could be rendered available for the accomplishment of so desirable an object. But of what avail is all the care of the proprietors — all the caution of the overman — or all the advantages which science can bestow, if they are allowed to be counteracted by the culpable conduct of even one careless miner? Three of the witnesses who were examined stated that all the men were cautioned not to take the tops off their lamps on any pretence, and another goes as far as to say that if the advice of the master had been followed, the explosion would not have taken place. This really seems only to make the case more melancholy. Why was the advice of the master not followed? This very admission proves the position I have assumed; and I remember a similar admission being made by some of the witnesses in the case of the dreadful explosion which occurred in William Pit. It is evident that there is a want of subordination in the management of mines. The preventive is known — caution would ensure safety, but the master cannot induce the servant to adopt it. It would seem that the miner is so stolid a being that neither a wish to obey his employer — a regard for his own life — or a desire to preserve the lives of others, can induce him to comply with the reasonable request of the master who provides him with that employment by which he is enabled to minister to his own earthly comforts. What then must be done? Why, the remedy is a short one. Enforce obedience to the regulations by which the mining operations are conducted. The employer (and the operative miner too) knows that his "Davy" will protect him if properly used, and where the miner cannot be induced to obey the orders of the overman, he ought to be compelled to do so. Let every pit owner insist upon the dangerous and improper practise of smoking in the mine being entirely abolished — and let him also insist upon every miner keeping the top on his Davy lamp, and there will at once be an end of the matter. In every instance in which these injunctions are disregarded, let the miner be dismissed and punished. Last week an operative miner was discharged from one of the pits near Durham for smoking his pipe in the mine, to the great danger of his fellow-workmen, and the same offender was moreover taken before the magistrates, who committed him to solitary confinement for seven days for the same flagrant offence. If a perfect understanding existed amongst the owners of collieries (and they owe it as a duty both to society and to themselves) the dangerous conduct of the miner, and his disregard of life and property, would soon be only known as a proverb, without illustration, except in the past history of the mine. The Davy lamp can be locked, and the use of it in the mine without the top ought to be strictly prohibited in every instance by the owners of the mine; and on this principle I certainly condemn the conduct of Foster, the overman, for allowing the men to take the tops off the lamps to light their pipes, when he knew that smoking was prohibited in the mine. He was there to carry the orders of his employers into effect — to preserve their property, and to see that no imprudent workman placed the lives of his fellow labourers in jeopardy, and yet he knowingly permitted indulgence in a practice, the dangerous consequences of which he admits by stating in his evidence that he had frequently cautioned the men against it! I fear, sir, I have already trespassed too much upon your space for one week, but in your next publication, if agreeable, I will resume the subject. The interests of humanity have a common claim of the hands of all, and need only be fairly laid before the public to ensure attention. I am, Sir, yours, &c., MINA
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||