Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

2nd November 1848

Dreadful Explosion — Thirty Persons Killed

Whitehaven, Tuesday, Midnight.

The population of this extensive mining district, among whom casualties arising from gaseous explosions are by no means uncommon, have been thrown into a state of consternation by a catastrophe more than ordinarily destructive of human life, as far as the pits immediately surrounding us are concerned, and by which, with one truly wonderful exception, the whole number of hands engaged in the Whinny-hill Pit, leased by the Hermatite Mining Company, have been killed. Of these men 17 were married, and leave behind them each a widow, and, in the whole, 52 children ; while 13, three being lads of the tender age of 12 and 13, were unmarried. The mine at which the accident occurred is about three miles from this town, and within the Lordship of Egremont, a circumstance which has given rise to a conflicting question of jurisdiction between two coroners, before whom, from Monday morning until late last night, a succession of inquests have been held, each eliciting a multiplicity of facts relative to the probable causes of the accident, and giving rise to a rigid inquiry into the condition of the mine, in reference to which no disinterested party gave any testimony until a renewed investigation held here this evening.

The rivalry between the coroners of the manorial district and the county is this — the former (Mr. Bragg) contends that the scene of the catastrophe being within his jurisdiction, the bodies of all persons found dead in the mine from the consequences of the late explosion ought to be subject to his disposal in reference to an inquest ; but the latter (Mr. W. Lumb) urges that several bodies, on being recovered from the pit, having been removed by the relatives to houses strictly within his district, the law requires that he should hold inquests on the bodies, and not the coroner of the manorial district. The consequence of this has been an unusual degree of activity on the part of each functionary, both of whom, however, have persevered in their assumed right with every regard to public decency ; and whilst giving considerable employment to medical men, parish constables, and jurors, by the frequency, length, and strictness of their investigations, have each manifested a disposition to bring to light any circumstances tending to establish or disprove the rumoured foulness and bad ventilation of the pit in question.

The accident took place between 6 and 7 o'clock in the morning. The number employed in the pit was 31, only one of whom escaped — the furnace man, stationed in the shaft, having also succeeded in saving his own life. Eighteen bodies were brought up, some in a dreadfully mutilated state, and on these Mr. Bragg has held an inquest at Cleator-moor, the parish in which the pit is situated. They were as follows :— John Barwise, aged 28, wife and two children ; Alexander Davidson, 23 wife and child ; Daniel Lochery, 32, ditto ; Charles Lochery, 21, unmarried ; James Dowie, 18, ditto ; John McLoughlan, ditto ; James Thompson, 26, wife and four children ; Robert Clark, 13 ; Henry Mash, 12 ; Richard Lawson, 46, wife and seven children ; John and Richard Lawson, his sons, aged 16 and 12 ; Thomas Aiken, 39, wife and five children ; his son, John, 17 ; John Hall, 30, wife and three children ; W. Lish, 23, wife and two children ; Patrick Kelley, 31, wife only ; John Cummins, 24, wife and two children.

A young lad named Ward, aged 13, was the only sufferer brought from the pit alive ; but he expired in a few hours afterwards from the severe burns he had sustained about the face and mouth. Upon this body Mr. Lumb held an inquest in the adjoining parish of Hensingham, as also upon the bodies of four others, namely John Atkinson, aged 32, wife and two children ; James Millby, aged 26, wife and two children ; his brother John, aged 18, unmarried ; and James Harrison, 29, also single. These inquests were held on Monday night, but as the proceedings left the question of ventilation only partially disposed of, the subject was conclusively investigated on the following evening (Tuesday), when Mr. Lumb changed the scene of his labours to Whitehaven, and sat upon two other sufferers, named William Dryden, aged 23, single man ; and George Watson, aged 19.

The evidence, which was most voluminous, established these leading facts :— The explosion took place from some workmen taking off the top of their Davy lamps to light their pipes, which fired the inflammable air of the pit ; and out of 30 persons engaged in the works one man only, named Bradley, engaged in the furthest working from the shaft, succeeded in escaping with life. After the accident safety-lamps were found with their tops off, which practical men depose could not have been occasioned by the force of the explosion, but must have been removed in the way and for the purpose described.

Edward Bradley, the person who made so miraculous an escape, was examined at each inquest, and on every occasion made a dogged resistance to being sworn, stating, that being a Roman Catholic he would not be sworn on the Testament ; that if sworn on it he did not consider he was bound to speak the truth ; and that the book itself was not his book, but an old ballad. Having been sworn, the following facts were elicited from him :— I am a hagger at the Whinny-hill pit. I went to work there on Saturday morning at half-past 4 o'clock. My fellow partner was John Cummins. We went down to work in the Bannock-band. We got up to our place of working, where we were sitting when John Atkinson's underman (Daniel Lochery) came and had some words with Cummins, and said he would knock his brains out with a hammer. In a quarter of an hour afterwards Cummins left me, and I never saw him again alive. I heard an explosion between 6 and 7 o'clock. I was lifted off my feet, and then made my way to the shaft, 300 yards off. As I proceeded along I found the choke-damp getting stronger. I saw plenty of dead men about. I got up by the rope, and into the basket, which was empty. I shouted as hard as I could to the banksman, and was taken up immediately. I was weak and stupefied when I got to the top. I walked home in about two hours. We work with Davy lamps. I have worked with the tops off. We never went without the work being examined before us, by the master or shiftsman. We have been ordered by the shiftsman to be careful. I examined the working myself, I think the pit was fired within 20 or 30 yards of the shaft by a naked light, but I do not know by whom. There is no candle used in the pit. There were no horses in the pit — we have had them.

How do you do without them ?

Witness. — We make horses of ourselves ; if the horse can't do the work a man is forced to do it. The pit is sometimes dirtier than other pits. The ventilation is sometimes good and sometimes bad ; it is often so. I never made a complaint of the pit being foul and dirty. I came out when the air was too foul. When I went down into the pit that morning the air was as usual, but as I passed the place where I think the explosion was it was something adulterated — it was middling. I lost my lamp where I believe the explosion was. I was trampling over dead bodies. The upper end of the pit where I was was in a good state of ventilation.

Alexander Berry. — The state of the ventilation of the pit was just in a middling way. During the time I worked in the pit it was all sorts of ways. Was now working in the shaft. The pit had a worse name before the furnace to cause a better air, was put on three or four months ago. If the furnace had not been put on, the pit could not have been worked. Had complained to the late overseers. Had frequently burned candles himself in the shaft close to the steer-head, but never saw any in the workings. Had worked with the lamp top off, but not recently. It was a great advantage to workmen to do that ; they got a better light and more money. There were about 31 lives lost by this explosion. Never had any fear to go down and work in the pit.

Robert Foster sworn. — I am the head overman of the collieries on Cleator-moor. On Saturday morning, about a quarter or 20 minutes past 6, an explosion took place at Whinny-hill pit. I was at home, but went on to the pit. When I got there, Gambles, another overman, and I went half way down the shaft. We could not get further for the styth. We then put the furnace out, which is nearly half-way down the shaft. After that I had the shaft repaired, and a temporary ventilation of air was caused by throwing water down. I then went down the pit with Gambles and another, taking lights with us to get the bodies out. When we got down to the five foot eye, where the coals are hooked on, we saw the body of a man hanging over into the shaft. His legs were entangled with 10 other bodies, which were all within three feet of the edge of the pit, and where there was only room for a man and a basket without the stage. We crept over the 11 bodies, and got to the top of the steer, to find if any were living. Gambles found a little boy named Ward. He brought him up, and I remained down the shaft. We then went further, and found the remainder of the bodies, 19 in the whole, at that time, with the exception of the little boy, who made 20 ; all were dead. They were sent up the pit. Two men were sent down Dryden's drift, where two men should have been working, but nothing was found but their clothes. We could not get further than 50 yards into the workings, owing to the styth. I think the men must have been smoking. They are all provided with safety-lamps. There is not a candle allowed in the pit except when I go to survey. The men have been in the habit of taking off the tops of their lamps to light their pipes, notwithstanding orders are given to the contrary. I cautioned some. The pit is in good working order. I saw nothing dangerous, or I should have stopped the men from going down. The ventilation of the pit is conducted by a partition from the top to the bottom of the shaft, and two internal shafts from one band to the other. I have been employed in collieries for 12 years. Four men were found since my first search up to Monday morning. The works were all viewed, I believe, before the men went down ; it was the duty of four men who were sent down for the purpose, and have been killed. Before I entered upon my present engagement, three week's ago, my brother, who is part proprietor of a pit in Lancashire, and a practical viewer of mines, went through the pit in which this explosion was, and pronounced it safe, and allowed me to enter my engagement with the mining company.

Several of the workmen spoke of the pit as being in good working order.

One witness gave a very positive opinion as to the pit having been fired by the man Cummins, who was much addicted to smoking.

Medical testimony having been adduced, showing that three of the men were so severely burnt as at once to account for death, that others had had their thighs broken, some had been killed by falling in the shaft when overtaken by choke-damp, and others had been suffocated,

The Coroner (Mr. Lumb) proceeded to call in the opinion of a disinterested practical man as to the state of the pit, upon which public rumour had circulated some serious imputations.

This witness gave his name as John Armstrong. He said — I am overseer at Wellington Pit, Whitehaven, belonging to the Earl of Lonsdale. I was in Whinny-hill pit on Saturday evening last. I have been connected with coalpits for 25 years. When we went down at 7 o'clock, we were sent back by the foulness, but subsequently found four dead bodies. I have carefully inspected the pit and workings as far as I could get. I think the pit was fired at 30 yards, or thereabouts. Judging from the way the blast went, that is my opinion. I can't say how the pit was fired. It would not be fired by a davy-lamp if the lamp were good. It might be fired by a pipe. A pipe has never been known to fire a pit in the ordinary course of smoking, but I think it possible ; there must be a flame to set off the explosion of gas in a pit. Supposing the tobacco in a pipe to be red hot, that would not set off the gas unless there was strong foulness in the pit. If it were very strong, a pipe would set it off without a flame. Supposing a man to have lighted a pipe at the pit top, and to have smoked it in the ordinary way in the workings, nothing but great foulness then would cause it to go off and explode without a flame. I am of opinion that this pit was fired with a naked light in the main road. Some men in collieries do walk along the main roads, which are considered safe, without the lamp tops being on. From what I have seen of the pit, I should not be afraid to work in it. It is quite workable with ordinary care. The pit is properly found with materials to make it safe. I know of nothing that is wanting. I should say it was a well found colliery.

Verdicts in the several inquests were taken differently ; but in all they amounted to the ordinary form of "Accidental death."

The Coroner (Mr. Lumb) alluded to the state of the law, which provided that if any person wilfully smoked a pipe in a coalpit and ignited the same, so as to cause death, he was liable to be indicted for murder — if incautiously, and causing death, of manslaughter. There was, however, a provision made, by which colliers smoking in pits were subject to certain punishment on summary conviction before justices, and it would be most advisable that some cases should be selected, when opportunity might offer, for mine proprietors to take up the matter on the ground of humanity, and as an effectual warning against the continuance of a very common and dangerous custom.

Other inquests are to be held before the rival coroners tomorrow.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Aiken, John      
Aiken, Thomas      
Armstrong, John      
Atkinson, John      
Barwise, John      
Berry, Alexander      
Bradley, Edward      
Bragg, —      
Clark, Robert      
Cummins, John      
Davidson, Alexander      
Dowie, James      
Dryden, William      
Foster, Robert      
Gambles, —      
Hall, John      
Harrison, James      
Kelley, Patrick      
Lawson, John      
Lawson, Richard      
Lish, W.      
Lochery, Charles      
Lochery, Daniel      
Lonsdale, Earl of      
Lumb, William      
Mash, Henry      
McLoughlan, John      
Millby, James      
Millby, John      
Thompson, James      
Ward, —      
Watson, George      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whinnyhill Colliery  Whinnyhill Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
28 Oct 1847  Frightful Coal Pit Explosion, Thirty Lives Lost (Annual Register for 1848)
31 Oct 1848  Dreaful Colliery Explosion, Thirty Lives Lost (Cumberland Pacquet)
02 Nov 1848  Dreadful Explosion — Thirty Persons Killed (The Times)
02 Nov 1848  Dreadful Colliery Explosion, Thirty Lives Lost (Ulverston Advertiser)
04 Nov 1848  The Explosion at Whinney Hill Pit (Whitehaven Herald)
04 Nov 1848  The Awful Explosion at Whinney Hill Pit, To the Editor of the Whitehaven Herald (Whitehaven Herald)
04 Nov 1848  Awful Explosion At Whinney Hill Colliery, Loss Of Thirty-One Lives (Whitehaven Herald)
11 Nov 1848  The Late Explosion at Whinney Hill Pit (Whitehaven Herald)
18 Nov 1848  The Late Explosion at Whinney Hill Pit (Whitehaven Herald)
23 Nov 1848  The Late Explosion at Whiney Hill Pit (Ulverston Advertiser)
16 Dec 1848  News (Whitehaven Herald)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Cleator Moor, Whinny Hill
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print