Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

26th August 1848, Page: 8, Column: 1

The Late Dreadful Colliery Explosion

Last week we gave the particulars of a lamentable accident which occurred at the Murton Colliery, near Seaham Harbour. On Monday last, an inquest was held at the house of Mr. Wm. Burgess, at Murton New Winning Colliery, before T. C. Maynard, Esq., on the bodies of Edward Noble, overman, and Edward Haddick, a boy, aged twelve years, who came to their deaths — along with thirteen others, namely nine men and four boys — by the explosion in the Polka Pit, on Tuesday week. The jury having been sworn, the first witness called was

Mr. H. Pace, overman, who said, Christopher Raffle, one of the boys who were severely burned, lived only two days, having died on Friday last. (At this stage of the proceedings, Mr. Edward Potter produced a plan of the workings, showing where the explosion had occurred and the bodies had been found). The witness then resumed :— I am overman of the Polka Pit; the explosion took place at the south-east part of that pit. The workings extend from the shaft about 660 yards to a place called the East Way. Was in the pit about an hour and a half before the explosion. (Here the witness pointed out the various boards, and coal workings on the map). The air returns at the end of the five boards, which are the only ones working at the east end of the pit. There are only three pillars; the air comes along the headway course; the area is about forty square chains; there is no gauge in the pit at all, no part of the pillars having been worked. There is a dyke at the east end of the workings; the coal is only worked up to the face of the dyke at one place, but not where the men were working. There is a division between the east working and the north part of the pit. There is no communication without going back to the headways course. The coal was worked up to the dyke about six months since. Saw it opened in the next board to where the explosion took place; it is separated by coal a chain thick. No gas came out when we bared the dyke. Found the air quite clean and pure about an hour and a half before the explosion. There was a strong current of air, quite sufficient, in my opinion, to work the mine. Seven coal-hewers were working in the east part, and three coal-putters, one back-overman, a boy that carried the compass, and a deputy-overman. There were between thirty and forty men working further south. They were all working with candles; we considered it safe and prudent to do so. I left the pit about an hour and a half before the explosion took place. Was sent for when the accident occurred, and went down the pit again, and proceeded from the shaft along the east-way ; was accompanied by the waste-man, A. Hunter; we proceeded to a stopping at the south, and knocked it down, for the purpose of sending in fresh air to the men, and so enabled us to get to them. On proceeding, found a good deal of after-damp, but it was soon forced out. The two doors were knocked down ; the current of air was taken off by the explosion. The doors were near the gauging-board. In the south-east workings I found Thomas Lawson, a boy, lying between the two doors which were blown down ; he was alive, but died next morning; he was not able to speak a word. Then found three more boys, namely, C. Raffle, T. Robson, and D. Rumley ; two of these are dead since. We went up the three boards on the headways course, and found Thomas Lawson much burnt, and Wm. Raffle; and then found Matthew Besom, a boy. He was lying at the second board end, and John Dickinson was lying at the end of the wall, about twelve yards farther north ; they were all dead ; the two boys were severely burnt ; Raffle was not burnt ; he had died from the after-damp. We proceeded South and found Thomas Stobbs lying at the fourth board, where he had been working. He was not burnt, but had his shirt collar round his head to shield him from the after-damp. We went into the face of the wall, being the end of the headways course, and found the body of James Hall, the deputy overman; he was not burnt. We proceeded to the north five yards, and found Edward Noble, back overman; he was severely burnt. Further south, in the same course, found Edward Haddick, a boy, severely burnt. Then went to the five board, further south, and found Joseph Tones, Ralph Dawson, and Richard Bloomfield; they were not burnt. The explosion took place (to the best of my judgment) in the second south-east board, and extended both north and south; in the north-east working it had passed to the westward, and taken the station pillar door off; it had extended two pillars farther north, and taken a part of the air crossing; it extended no further. The men who were working in the south came by, taking the west headways course. Have examined all the works since they commenced, and have never previously seen any appearance of gas. There could not have been any without my observing it. The explosion occurred in the second board; a large quantity of gas and water had come off suddenly from the roof, where there is a leash or main dyke. Am of opinion that every possible means had been applied to prevent the accident. It would be safer to work with lamps in all cases, providing they are properly taken care of. If the Davy Lamp is not taken care of, it is extremely dangerous. The lamps cannot be used in all cases, the principal reason being that the men cannot see so well with the lamps as the candles. In fact, they will not use them if they can get off. By a Juryman; There is no water in this pit; there are two headway courses off, there is a door near the north end of the second headways course, and two stoppings in the second and third boards, all of which were blown down. The damage done to the pit is very trifling.

Anthony Gray: I live at South Hetton, and am deputy overman of the "Polka Pit." Left the pit about ten o'clock in the morning. Had charge of the pit in the south-east working. It was my duty to see the pit properly ventilated. Travelled the way at half-past two o'clock, and again at half-past nine o'clock on Tuesday morning, and found the ventilation in a good state. There was a strong current of air passing through the south-east workings. Saw no appearance of gas. Considered the pit so well ventilated as to be safely worked with candles. Left the pit at ten o'clock on Tuesday morning. Went down the pit after the explosion had taken place, about two o'clock in the afternoon, and assisted in getting up the bodies of the sufferers. Have examined the south-east working since the explosion. The accident appears to have occurred in the second board by a "blow," or jet of gas in the pit; but only considered it trifling. If there was gas in the pit, Davy lamps would be safer. The pitmen object to work with lamps when it is safe to work without them, because the candles give a better light. The men have objected to work with Davy lamps in the "Polka Pit." The reason that they gave was, there is no danger. If the pitmen chose to work with lamps, neither Mr. Potter nor the owners would object to their doing so. Do not think the accident could have been prevented. The gas had been suddenly given off. By a Juryman: The brattice has been carried up within a yard of the faces of all the boards; they were carried up as close as they could be to the coal.

John Robson: Am a pitman, and was at work in the Polka Pit on the morning of the explosion, from between three and four o'clock until nine; during that time the gas gave a "flisk," or light, at the lowe (the candle). Did not name that to the overman. My brother, John Teesdale, was with me at the time, and we thought the "flisk" was a mere trifle. (The Coroner here addressed the witness in a most emphatic manner saying, "You did very wrong not to mention this affair to your overman.") When we left the pit the ventilation was very good. My brother observed that "the air was better than it was the day before." We did not consider that there was any danger when we left the pit. Have been down the pit since the explosion. We don't use the Davy lamps when the pit is in a workable state. The reason we use the candles is because they give a better light. We object to use lamps when there is no danger. We cannot blast the coal when we work with Davy lamps; thought that the Polka pit was so safe that there was no call for the Davy lamps on Tuesday morning. By a Juryman: We told our marrows about the "flisk" when they came in to the board. The air was always good, and we considered it perfectly safe to work the pit with candies.

John Teesdale. Am a pitman, and live at South Hetton. Was working with John Robinson at the south-east board, on Tueaday morning last. The gas gave a bit "flisk" on our candle. We put it out directly. John Robinson was in the act of setting a prop at the left side and I was standing on the right side of the board. His candle was about two yards behind him. My candle was standing at the brattice end. The gas came out of a nick at the back part of the coal; and while Robinson was setting up the prop, the gas fired at the candle and extended about a yard straight from the face of the coal in a flame. We put it out immediately with our jackets we told Thomas Lawson, one of the sufferers, about the "flisk." We did not tell the overman or deputy overman. We thought there was no danger when we left. We have orders to acquaint the overman when anything takes place, but thought nothing about the "flisk;" it seemed so trifling an occurrence. [The Coroner: "It was grossly negligent on your part not to inform your overman of the apparent danger."] We got orders to work with candles. Some men refuse to work with Davy lamps, when they consider it safe to work with candles.

James Dixon, a boy; Am a wood leader. Was the last boy that got out of the way of the explosion. A few minutes before 10 o'clock in the morning heard the explosion at the bottom of the shaft. The sound appeared to come from the east part of the pit. Ascended the shaft immediately and gave notice. Had been in the south working about 25 minutes before it happened. When I left, just before the men changed there was gas upon the lowe. There was a little gas on Anthony Grey's lowe about three o'clock. Saw gas on Wm. Raffle's lowe about an hour before the explosion. Went straight from Raffle's board when I left the pit. Saw no gas when I left. The blower had come off before I left. There was water running off from the place. The gas did not then light at the candles. Raffle then went for James Hall, the deputy, who went in and brought the men out of the board. But two men, viz. Raffle and Lawson said they would fill anther tub. James Hall said they could not as the water was rushing out. The water was coming out of the roof and a stone fell down from the roof. By a juryman: James Hall told them not to work any more there. They were sitting at the end when I came away.

Mr. Wm. Anderson: Am a viewer at Wingate Colliery. Was sent for by Mr. Potter to inspect the district of the pit where the explosion had taken place; went down this morning with the master wasteman. From the various indications I observed, could trace the track of the explosion. On reaching the air crossing, two pillars north of the going way of the south-east working, found the air course partly damaged. This was an indication that the explosion had had much power there. Found a deposit of small dust on the whole surface of the coal, and followed those indications until reaching the flat, where the double separation door was found to have been blown down, and the air crossing damaged. Found the second door literally smashed to pieces, though it had been replaced. Passed through this door and found a strong smell of after-damp. Went up the first board and found the tops of the first wall considerably charred in the south side, where the "blow" is said to have taken place. Then proceeded to the next board and observed it charred on each side. Went down as far as it was practicable for the water, and heard a small feeder of water coming down from the roof. The brattice in that board had been blown out, and tried with my Davy lamp, but could find no blow or set of gas. They went down the headways course and beyond the second board, and found the props charred on all sides, and observed also that the stoppings were blown down towards the west. On coming down the fourth board, the fire seemed to have been less intense there. Observed the fire took place in the second or third board. There appeared to have been a great and sudden ebullition of gas from that board, by what is technically called a blower. There was a considerable current of air in all the five boards. Thinks that the discharge of gas must have been instantaneous to cause the fire. Blowers are very uncommon in the Hetton Seam, but are found generally in the Bensham Seam. When gas does come from a blower, it comes forth suddenly as if from a great pressure above. A blower is a sudden eruption of gas, previously pent up in some vacant space in the coal or 'trouble.' It is very often accompanied with water, which comes out first. On examination found that 5740 cubic feet of air were passing every minute at the south-east cross cut. That I consider is a very ample current of air for such a working as this. Under ordinary circumstances would have no hesitation in carrying a lighted candle through a great part of the workings at present. If Davy lamps had been used on this occasion the accident would not have occurred; but it is impracticable at all times to use Davy lamps ; for instance, when the coal is blasted, the deputy must be provided with candles to fire the shots. During these operations fires are going on a great part of the day, and if any of the boards were foul, an explosion would take place immediately. Thinks it very wrong to put Davy lamps into the hands of men when the pit is safe ; because, when real danger comes, they might prove careless. It is totally impracticable to use Davy lamps when the coal is blasted. It is a general rule throughout the collieries to supply the men with Davy lamps only when there is danger, and not till then. Have seen jets of gas daily in the Bensham Seam at Jarrow Colliery, and have seen them lighted from the shots or the candles used by the men while working, but I do not consider these to be any indication of a blower.

Thomas Jones, Thomas Graydon and Wm. Robinson, pitmen, working in Polka Pit, were next examined, but nothing new was elicited from them. They agreed with preceding witnesses in thinking that the pit, up to the time of the accident, was quite safe, and attributed blame to no one.

Mr. John Wailes, viewer of Hetton-le-Hole, was examined : I went down the Polka pit on Tuesday last, and examined the south-east workings. The first indication of the explosion was at the south-east air-crossing. Had that not been built up in a substantial manner, the sacrifice of human life would have been much greater ; for if it had not withstood the pressure, it would have taken the current of air from the men working farther south, when it would have been quite impossible that they could have been got out alive. I am of opinion that the explosion took place in the face of the second board, where the water now is. I suppose the gas fired at this place at the candle of the waggon driver — at the going headways course. I am of opinion that the explosion was caused by a blower, or large jet of gas coming from the sudden pricking of a large reservoir of hydrogen gas, in the trouble or dyke ; and that the explosion was quite accidental, and no precautions could have prevented it. It is utterly impossible to foresee such accidents.

Mr. Edward Potter, viewer of South Hetton, and also of Murton Colliery. There are three pits at Murton Colliery, divided into three independent shafts, viz., the East or Polka Pit, Middle Pit, and West Pit, each having an area of 75 square feet. The West Pit is 16 feet diameter, and used as an upcast shaft. In the road, from the shaft of the Polka Pit, the area for fresh air is fifty square feet: this is subdivided into three divisions, one going west, another south, and the other south-east, so in the event of any explosion taking place in any of these districts it would be confined to that district alone. The quantity of atmospheric air passing through the Polka Pit was measured last March, and found to be 54,112 cubic feet per minute; the air courses had the same current on the day of the explosion. The quantity of air passing south is 24,750 cubic feet per minute. A great number of pits are not so well supplied with air as this pit was. Was down the pit on Monday last, the day before the accident, and examined the south-east workings, and found the ventilation extremely good and perfectly free. Considered the pit to be in a perfectly safe state to be worked with candles. Went in and saw the dyke bared off the coal the day before. Saw no signs of gas. Went about four hundred yards north, and found no gas. There was no indication of gas in any of the workings.

The Coroner, in addressing the jury, said that, looking at all the circumstances, it appeared that the explosion, which was the cause of the death of the fifteen persons, was purely accidental. They would observe likewise that the men who were at work at the time of the explosion declared every precaution had been taken.

A Juryman here observed that there appeared a discrepancy between the evidence of James Dixon, the boy, and Anthony Grey, the deputy overman, the boy asserting that there was gas at Grey's lowe, and Grey asserting to the contrary.

The Coroner recalled Anthony Grey, the deputy-overman, who said he saw no gas on Tuesday morning in the pit: there was no show of gas at his candle. By Mr. Potter: When my candle was at the second board there was not the least sign of gas. The boy James Dixon was never in the board with me. I never let a coal-hewer go in the board until the air is tried.

The jury, after having sat about seven hours, retired, and returned in about a quarter of an hour with a verdict of "Accidental death." The foreman observed that the jury were unanimously of opinion that no blame whatever could be attached to any person.

We are glad to learn that a subscription is about to be entered into in behalf of the widows and children of the unfortunate men who have perished by this explosion.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Anderson, William    Viewer  
Besom, Matthew   16   Deceased, Individual Page
Bloomfield, Richard   20   Deceased, Individual Page
Burgess, William    Innkeeper  
Dawson, Ralph   31   Deceased, Individual Page
Dickenson, John   12   Deceased, Individual Page
Dixon, James    Wood Leader  
Gray, Anthony    Deputy Overman  
Graydon, Thomas    Miner  
Haddick, Edward   12   Deceased, Individual Page
Haddick, Edward   12 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hall, James   40   Deceased, Individual Page
Hunter, A.    Wasteman  
Jones, Thomas    Miner  
Lawson, Thomas   41   Deceased, Individual Page
Lawson, Thomas (jnr)   21   Deceased, Individual Page
Maynard, Thomas Christopher    Coroner  Whos Who Page
Noble, Edward   23 Back overman  Deceased, Individual Page
Noble, Edward   23 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Pace, Henry    Overman  
Potter, Edward    Viewer  
Raffle, Christopher    Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Raffle, William   32   Deceased, Individual Page
Robinson, John    Miner  
Robinson, William    Miner  
Robson, John    Miner  
Robson, Thomas      Deceased 
Rumley, David   12   Deceased, Individual Page
Stubbs, Thomas   27   Deceased, Individual Page
Teesdale, John    Miner  
Tones, Joseph   66   Deceased, Individual Page
Wailes, John    Viewer  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Murton Colliery  Murton Colliery
Wingate Grange Colliery  Wingate Grange Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
18 Aug 1848  Dreadful Colliery Explosion (Newcastle Courant)
19 Aug 1848  Dreadful Colliery Explosion, Loss of Fourteen Lives (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
26 Aug 1848  Dreadful Colliery Explosion, Fourteen Lives Lost (Yorkshire Gazette)
26 Aug 1848  The Late Dreadful Colliery Explosion (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
29 Jun 1942  A Former Disaster (Sunderland Echo and Shipping Gazette)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Murton, Polka Pit
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print