|
12th June 1846, Page: 4, Column: 3 The Alston Mining CaseFinal DecisionHudgill Burn Company c. Galligill Well CompanyThis long pending suit has just been brought to a close. The facts are as follow:— The Hudgill Burn Company, in January, 1833, filed a bill in Chancery, and a supplemental bill in 1834, against the defendants, the Galligill Well Company, claiming the Galligill Well Mine, and all the ore they had been getting since 1824, amounting to several thousand pounds sterling, and the Hudgill Company prayed the Lord Chancellor to grant an injunction, or prevent the Galligill Company from working their mine, and that a receiver might be appointed, &c, &c. To these bills the Galligill Company answered and denied altogether the claim set up by the Hudgill Company. After tedious proceedings in the Court of Chancery, it was perceived that in that court no result could ever be come to; therefore, with the view of obtaining a decision of the question, it was determined to submit the matter to reference, and Mr. Benjamin Johnson was chosen by the Hudgill Company, and Mr. Crossby by the Galligill Company; Mr. Johnson leaving the country, a new reference became necessary, and it was ultimately agreed to refer the matter to Robert B. Armstrong, Esq., Q.C., Recorder of Manchester. The learned arbitrator held his court at Carlisle, in September, 1844, and sat upon the arbitration nine days hearing evidence, the Hudgill Company being represented by Mr. Watson, Q.C., and Mr. Bainbridge and the Galligill Company by Mr. Baines, Q.C., and Mr. Drinkwater. In December, 1845, the arbitrator made his award that the Galligill Company had a clear right to their mine — that the Hudgill Company's claim was quite unfounded (except for a portion of ore, amounting in value to £326, got by the Galligill Company in an adjoining vein, in the same way as the Hudgill Company had in 1827, got some ore belonging the Galligill Company, which they had to pay for and return); and that the Hudgill Company were to pay all their own expenses, and all the law expenses of the Hospital incurred about the matter, and that they were to pay the Galligill Company £1,100. The Hudgill Company being dissatisfied, they obtained a rule in the Court of Queen's Bench in January last, to set aside the award, and it came on for argument on Thursday the 4th of June instant, when Lord Denman and the Court of Queen's Bench confirmed the award made by Mr. Armstrong, which decision, in favour of the Galligill Company, ends the proceedings in the Court of Chancery and Queen's Bench in this long pending suit.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||