|
6th September 1845 Letters to the EditorJarrow Colliery ExplosionTo The Editor Of The Times. Sir, — If it be necessary for every one before making a public statement to ascertain as distinctly as possible the facts of the case, and to use the utmost caution in representing them, and in arguing from them, how much more necessary is such caution in an instance like the present, where the statements are made under the authority of a name so great as that of Professor Ansted, and where the feelings of all parties are wound up to the highest pitch of excitement ? I do not pause to notice any of the professor's remarks on accidents in mines generally, but I confine myself to what he has advanced with reference to the late lamentable occurrence here. Mr. Ansted writes — "I am almost certain, from the accounts I have seen, that nearly 30 of the unhappy sufferers in the late accident at Jarrow (those in the lower seam) would have been saved certainly had there been two shafts." Now, it is in evidence that the explosion happened in the low main seam, and that all the poor fellows there were more or less burnt, and that to the great majority death must have been immediate. How then would two shafts have been the means of saving nearly all, if not all, in the lower seam ? Was the extra shaft required in the present case as a means of escape after the explosion, when all but the three in the stone drift, and possibly even those three, must have been killed on the moment ? Would an extra shaft have prevented the explosion ? No one on the inquest even hinted that it was caused by an insufficiency in the quantity of air carried down. The low main workings, it was shown, are all in the whole coal, and are in extent about 19 acres, with the current of air sweeping through this district at a rate of 25,000 cubic feet per second. We were told that the current was "inconveniently strong," that "it had little to do," that a "sudden outburst of gas must have taken place," as it was well expressed, "beyond a poor man's comprehension to prevent." No one I think will say that a body of air could be taken round sufficient to dilute below the firing point every sudden outburst of carburetted hydrogen it came in contact with any naked light, and therefore it would appear that in a seam subject to such sudden outbursts of gas the Davy lamp is the only safeguard. Under this impression it has been determined for the future to prohibit the use of candles in the workings of the mine. It is a satisfaction, though a melancholy one, to be able to place in opposition to the dictum of Mr. Ansted the opinion of men as intelligent, and infinitely more practical, — the opinion of those gentlemen whose humanity and kindness took them down the pit after the accident, that the result would have been the same with any of the shafts. I make no further comments, merely regretting that such a man as Professor Ansted should not have looked more closely into the evidence before venturing to express an opinion, however qualified. Jarrow, Sept. 1. J. D. Brown.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||