30th October 1844
Letters to the Editor
Colliery Explosions
Are They, Or Are They Not, Unavoidable ?
To The Editor Of The Times.
Sir, — The commanding influence of The Times newspaper and its reputation, so nobly earned, as the friend of "the poor oppressed," give me encouragement to hope that your columns may not be closed against the discussion of the case
of the poor colliers in these two northern counties — Durham and Northumberland. I mean more especially in reference to the state of the ventilation of the mines, and not to any real or imaginary grievance which may subsist between the men and
their employers.
We have lately had a fearful explosion at Haswell colliery, by which 95 persons have been destroyed ; and such calamities are now of ordinary occurrence ; and, from their frequency, have become mere "matters of course," tending greatly to blunt
that susceptibility of excitement, which, in the public mind, was more apparent when these catastrophes were less common.
The continuance of such a system of ventilation, involving in its principles the necessity of explosions, is a consideration truly distressing to all persons who believe there is a mode of working collieries which exempts the miners from such fatal
contingencies.
I allude to the method recommended by Mr. James Ryan, F.S.A., invented by him as far back as the year 1806, put into practice by him, in Staffordshire, in 1808, on which he lectured before the Royal Institution, in London, in 1810, and for which,
in 1816, the Society of Arts presented him with a large gold medal and 100 guineas, besides enrolling him a Fellow of their fraternity. I might also add, that when Mr. Ryan had finished his lecture before the Royal Institution in 1810, the late
Sir H. Davy (then Dr.) rose up and stated, "That so clearly had Mr. Ryan explained his principles of ventilation to him (the Doctor), that he should consider every life lost in future by explosion, as a manslaughter." How Sir
Humphrey forgot this when he invented his lamp does not appear. But so effective was Mr. Ryan's principle of ventilation, that it converted some of the most fiery mines in Britain into a state of perfect safety, no life having been lost nor
injury sustained by any one from the ignition of the fire-damp.
Mr. Ryan also asserts that his principle is as applicable to these mines as it is to those in Staffordshire, and he is ready to put it in force in any of our collieries, provided any influence could be created to induce our mine proprietors to
afford him an opportunity to prove to them its benefits ; but as he has been repeatedly here upon this errand of philanthropy, and has hitherto been repulsed, it is to be feared his present visit will be equally fruitless, unless public opinion be
brought to bear on the question.
Now, in Mr. Ryan's system science is transparent, comprehensible, and practical. You see the reason of everything ; and everything supports its pretensions. There being no gas left among the workings there can be no explosions, nor contaminated
air, injurious to respiration. Neither is there any limit to the quantity of quality of the light which the miner may prefer to illuminate the darkness of his cavern ; consequently, no "Davy" or other lamps are required as a
"protection" — no trapdoors, or dams, or stoppings — no want of good air, because if the bad be all removed, what remains ? Why nature never knew a void — nothing but the pure breath of Heaven.
The expenditure of the works also becomes diminished in the ratio of the simplicity of the management, and those painful sympathies and numerous claims upon our charity cease to be urged upon our better nature.
I have paid much attention to this question, and have frequently expressed my surprise to persons connected with the management and proprietary of mines here ; but I have never heard or found in any book any argument or valid objection to Mr.
Ryan's system, although the one in practice here, in all its bearings, is one of consummate complication, equally destitute of science as it is of every quality which can be honestly placed to the credit of a rational education or common humanity !
I am, Sir, your obedient servant,
Newcastle-upon-Tyne, Oct. 26.
Histor.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Davy, Humphry, Sir | | | |
| Ryan, James | | | |