|
14th October 1844 The Late Explosion at Haswell CollieryHaswell Colliery, Friday Night. Professor Faraday and Professor Lyell, accompanied by Mr. Scutchbury, a colliery viewer from Bristol, went down the Haswell Little Pit yesterday, and examined the workings, Mr. Forster, the viewer, being present to afford explanation when required. They were engaged in the examination several hours, and were very minute in their inquiries as to the general state and management of the colliery. The three gentlemen took their seats by the side of the coroner on the opening of the court this morning. The whole of the jurymen having answered to their names, Mr. George Hunter, colliery viewer to the Marquis of Londonderry, was called and examined. — Reside at Belmont and have been a viewer about 25 years. Have not been engaged in many collieries, but on extensive ones, Lord Londonderry's principally. On Monday last, in company with Mr. Nicholas Wood, examined the Haswell Little Pit. Was present when Mr. Wood gave his evidence on Wednesday last, and quite concur with him in opinion, having myself assisted him in making the calculations. In respect of the cause of the accident I slightly differ from him. It is my opinion that in working the pillars you may always expect gas to remain in the "goaf," if it be in the mine at all. Agree with him in thinking the explosion took place near Williamson's "jud." Cannot see any other cause for the explosion than the damage done to the lamps. (Damaged lamps produced.) Any of them would have caused the explosion. Think the gas had come from the "goaf," but drawing the "jud" might not have caused it to come off. Has seen it come off from the "goaf" to show upon the lamp. When the barometer has stood high for some length of time, a sudden fall will set the gas off from the "goaf." Have frequently seen this. Do not think the explosion took place from any want of ventilation in the pit. Consider the ventilation extraordinarily good ; and I think the plan of laying down the colliery, making the furnaces, air-courses, and other things, is better than I have ever seen, and must have been made at great expense. Nothing could have been done that had not been to prevent the explosion. Think there has been fire at the Brockly-whins "goaf," but that there was only one general explosion which would have fired the gas at that "goaf," if there had been any there. Saw indications of fire there. The principal indications are at the Meadows flat near Williamson's "jud." Examined the three boards which Thomas Chambers, who accompanied us, pointed out as the three in which he thought the explosion had commenced. Examined two of the boards in particular; and my opinion is the explosion did not commence there. There are indications of fire there, but I think they have been caused by the explosion passing through them into the Brockly-whins "goaf." The nearest point where candles are used is at such a distance, and so situated, that in my opinion the gas from the "goaf" could not have reached them. The candles are in the Mothergate board. Do not consider it dangerous to work with candles at that board. Think there could have been no accumulation of gas there to have produced this explosion, if there had been even such a quantity there as to have produced similar effects. Observed a fly-door, but that in my opinion had nothing to do with the explosion. It was not dangerous to have a fly-door there. Mr. Roberts entered at this period, under a misunderstanding that the inquest had been adjourned till 10 o'clock, instead of 9, and not having heard the evidence, asked no questions in examination. Mr. Cleugh, who had been present from the first, then cross-examined. — Think fly-doors are efficient as trap-doors. When pushed open by a current of air they close of themselves. Am not aware fly-doors are considered by the pitmen inferior to trap-doors in directing a current of air. Had read the bond sent in by the pitmen at the last strike, and think there was a clause requiring the abolition of fly-doors. But am not positive as to that. Mr. Roberts requested that that answer should be taken down by the Coroner, who refused, as having no reference to this inquiry. Examination resumed. — Have not seen fly-doors knocked down, and have had no complaints of them. The common trap-doors were used before fly-doors were introduced. Consider fly-doors and trap-doors, attended by a boy, equally safe. A person might go through a fly-door in a dangerous place and no one see him. If a boy were there and it was a trap-door the boy might not be able to prevent the person going through, or might not see him. The fly-door in its position in Haswell pit I consider quite as safe as a trap-door attended by a boy would have been in the same place. Do not think a man to watch the trap-door would be preferable to a boy 10 or 12 years of age ; on the contrary, the latter would be most obedient, and few men could be got to attend to so insignificant a job without extra pay. In main waggon ways where the pressure of the air is great a man would be preferable. Never knew an instance of a boy being asleep without his door being closed in its proper position, and then have had to waken him up to open it. The lighter the atmosphere the more readily gas escapes from the "goaf." Do not consider it unsafe to use a candle at the Meadows-flat, the current of air is so great. Cannot form any correct estimate of the gas which escapes from the "goaf," sometimes there is none visible for weeks together, and at other times it will show itself on the lamp. An accident to one lamp might cause the explosion, and the others might be injured in consequence. May not expect gas from the drawing of a broken "jud ;" if there be gas in the "goaf," it is liable to be thrown off by a fall of the roof, which may occur in drawing a "jud." In working the "broken" all the coal possible is taken away, in order to produce a good fall, so as to leave little cavity as possible when the roof falls. The Hutton seam on the river Wear is not generally prolific in gas. Some colliers in the Hutton seam on the south side of the Wear make very little gas — on the north side they make more. Thinks the Haswell mine does not produce much, judging from the current of air at the furnace ; but the current is so strong it is difficult to determine. Thinks it better to work the "whole" and the "broken" together, than to work the "whole" first, and the broken afterwards ; it is quite as safe to work them together as separate ; and by working them together a better current of air is secured for ventilation. Have known an explosion in the "broken," after the "whole" coal had been worked out. That was in the Plane-pit at Rainton, in 1828. Candles were not allowed to be carried into the "broken," but they had been ; it was supposed some one had gone with a candle beyond the distance allowed. Cannot say whether three pillars distance is near enough for near enough for the "broken" to be from the whole ; but it depends upon the ventilation. Thinks that "deal stoppings" are sufficiently strong to separate the two columns of air between the "whole" and the "broken." When a heaving occurs deal stoppings are much sooner repaired than brick ones. One is quite as safe as the other. It is better to throw a fresh current of air upon the "goaf" than one that has circulated through the workings," but it is not in all cases possible to do that. The air in the return from the "goaf" would not be more liable to explode there, with a current of fresh air passing through the "goaf" than a lax one. Where shafts could be sunk so as to throw the fresh air on the "goaf," I would recommend that it should be done ; but it is not always practicable. Would not recommend one to be sunk in Haswell Colliery. The impracticability arises from the expense. Two small pits are better for the purposes of ventilation than a large one "bratticed." There are two in Haswell Colliery. Know collieries where there are several pits for the purpose of ventilation, and, notwithstanding, the ventilation is not as good as this. By Mr. Faraday. — In every case the ventilation depends on the quantity of air sent down, and the quantity of gas generated. The size of the "workings," or headways, must also be taken into consideration. The inclination of the seam should also be considered. By the Coroner. — Thinks all these considerations have been attended to in Haswell Colliery. By Mr. Lyell. — The inclination in Haswell pit is one in 24 feet. By the Coroner. — Think it easier to ventilate a pit when the seam is horizontal that when it is inclined. By Mr. Cleugh. — If the ventilation were sufficient would not recommend the sinking of additional shafts. Have every reason to think the Davy-lamp a safe one. Never used any other. Was with Sir H. Davy in 1816, when he first tried his experiments in Wallsend colliery ; and from that time until his death I was connected in collieries with him. Think a person might light his pipe through a Davy-lamp gauze, but never saw it done. If it were done it would be by drawing the flame through the gauze, and if inflammable air surrounded it an explosion would be caused. Cannot say whether it be possible for him to light his pipe through the gauze without drawing the flame through ; think it would. The gas would not be ignited without drawing the flame through. Do not think the oiling of the Davy-lamp gauze would cause an explosion ; if so, explosion would frequently occur. Never saw a current of explosive air in a mine that would drive the flame through the gauze. A current passing three or four feet per second certainly would not, in my opinion. Not aware that Mr. Buddle made the experiment. By Mr. Faraday. — Have seen the gauze of the Davy-lamp red-hot frequently in dangerous parts of the mine. Would trust my life on the Davy in such cases, and in every case, where necessary. By Mr. Cleugh. — The glass inside a Geordy-lamp would prevent a person lighting a pipe through the gauze. But the size of the cylinder in the Geordy-lamp renders it less safe when the glass tube is broken, than the Davy. It is impossible for the gauze to become oiled where the glass tube is used. It is equally impossible for a strong current of air to cause the flame of the lamp to pass the meshes of the gauze. Do not remember the instructions given by Sir Humphrey Davy to Mr. Buddle when he delivered that gentleman the lamp. Mr. Faraday. — Sir Humphrey was not infallible. He was not a practical miner, and therefore such instructions could only be a matter of opinion. A large portion of the coal now worked could not have been worked had safety lamps not been invented. The lamp I think has not put the candles further back than they used to be from points of danger. By their use we are now enabled to get into the waste, and to render the ventilation more perfect. The safety of the men in the pit depends on the viewer and those under him. The subordinate officers in the mine are all experienced pitmen. By Mr. Faraday. — The viewer is the person who decides upon the regulations of the mine in respect to ventilation. By Mr. Cleugh. — Some viewers have many different mines to attend to, and when they are absent the under-viewer attends, and the latter is there daily. It is the duty of the overmen and deputies to inspect the mine to see that the passages are safe before the men go into work. By Mr. Faraday. — Every coal hewer knows the indications of gas, and when they observe them they are required to give information immediately to their deputy or overman. By Mr. Marshall. — We do not allow smoking in the pit, and certainly do not allow the men to light their pipes at the gauze. Have felt smoke in going through the mine, but could not detect the person smoking. By the Coroner. — When a man has been ascertained to have been smoking he is reprimanded, and on repeating the offence discharged. By Mr. Roberts. — The introduction of Davy-lamps has not prevented or impeded the improvement of the ventilation. The daily exudation of gas in working the mine is what we have most to apprehend danger from in the pillars. Think a current of air moving at the rate of 10 feet a-second is not liable to cause the flame of the Davy-lamp to pass through the meshes. Indeed, no current we have underground would do so. The air travels 1,200 yards from the shaft before reaching the "goaf," but it takes up no gas in passing over that distance. Have not a doubt of the fact in this case. I could swear to it. If all the "whole" coal were worked first, candles would not be taken into the "broken," but they would be used at the flats, as they are upon the present system. Remember an explosion in Thornley Colliery in 1841 ; was called upon to examine the mine after it occurred, and was of opinion it had been caused by the neglect of the boy at the trap-door. Did not try the air at Williamson's "jud." By Mr. Marshall. — It would have been hazardous to do so. As a precaution it would have been improper to explode gunpowder there. By Mr. Roberts. — Have seen "juds" with very few props in them. In some cases they are set very thick, perhaps 100 in a "jud," and in other case very few. They are frequently put as a warning. Would take all the props out in drawing the "jud," if I could get them ; because the props are useful again, and it is no use leaving them there. The prop is knocked out in removing it, and the men in doing that are obliged to look carefully for falls of the roof, so that they may get out of the way, and prevent it. Do not think the props could be drawn by machinery. Am not aware in my experience of many explosions having arisen from drawing a "jud." (Mr. Roberts here put several questions about the use of dam-doors and swing-doors, which were objected to, as irrelevant, by the coroner.) The witness continued — Do not consider it necessary that the under-viewers and other subordinate officers should undergo a system of preparatory education ; experience is the best teaching, and none but experienced pitmen are employed as under-viewers and overmen. The viewers are educated men. Do not know that the gas found in the mines of this district will explode with a hot iron. By the Coroner. — Do not think it necessary for all the men to be out of the pit when a "jud " is drawn. It cannot be done at all times. There is no particular danger to the men working in that part of the mine if the lamps are kept safe. By Mr. Marshall. — It is sometimes necessary to draw the "jud" instantly. It is much better for the ventilation of the mine to remove the whole of the props. That allows the roof to get down, and there is less room for the accumulation of gas. John Scott, the under-viewer, on being recalled, stated that the mine was now in the same state that it was in when it was examined by Mr. Wood and Mr. Hunter. Nothing had been done since the explosion but replacing the stoppings that had been blown down. Samuel Scutchbury. — Am surveying agent to the Somersetshire district of mines belonging to the Prince of Wales as Duke of Cornwall, and have charge of Lord Waldergrave's mines and others in the same county. Have been sent to examine the Haswell pit on the part of Government. Examined it yesterday. At the time I examined it knew nothing of the circumstances attending the recent explosion. Professor Faraday, Mr. Lyell, Mr. Forster the viewer, Mr. Taylor, and some men in subordinate offices accompanied me. It was not Mr. Hugh Taylor, one of the owners, but Mr. Thomas John Taylor. My opinion of the cause of the explosion is entirely dependent on my own examination. Had formed my opinion before I had obtained any knowledge of the circumstances of the explosion. Have since read the evidence given on the first day in The Times ; and I have had part of the day's evidence read over to me, and have heard that which has been given to-day. The reading of that evidence and what I have heard to-day confirms my previous opinion in almost every essential point. The technical terms used in the south are different from those used here. Was taken along the "rolly-way" and Mothergate from the shaft, and through the Meadows flat. Examined all the appearances, to see from what part the explosion came. Traced them till we came to Williamson's "jud," the evidence of an explosion being increased as we proceeded to that point. Came to the conclusion from examination afterwards of the various boards and the face of the "whole" coal and the props as we returned to the High Brockly-whins "flat," that the explosion had radiated, as it were, from a focal point which would carry it back to Williamson's "jud." Also examined the "waste," or "goaf," as it is here called, of the High Brockly-whins flat. There found some partially burnt coal dust, but not coked or charred, if I may use the term, as it was at Williamson's "jud," proving to me that the force of the explosion had reached thus far, carrying with it fire, or the dust which had been fired from the neighbouring parts, by which I mean Williamson's "jud," and as my attention was called to it, I particularly examined with a view to ascertain if there was a second explosion at that point, that is, at the "goaf" in the High Brockly-whins flat, and my opinion is that there was not a second explosion. It is my opinion the explosion was the result of accident, of such an accident as could not have been foreseen. Found that nothing had been left undone that could have been done for the safety of the workmen. I draw these conclusions from finding that in passing along the ways till I arrived at that point, the whole of the work appeared to have been carried on so perfectly as to show me that there had been no common or ordinary expense spared. Along the main ways the ventilation was very powerful, stronger than I had ever seen before; and after passing various "splits," that there was a still sufficiently good air course ; in my opinion, quite sufficient for the safety of the mine under ordinary circumstances. It is my opinion there has been an accumulation of gas in the "goaf," which would be one of the best receptacles or reservoirs of such a gas as you could possibly have in the mine. The falling of the roof naturally gives a hollow dome, or receptacle for the gas, and the cause of the explosion I consider to have been an escape of gas from the under-level of the roof or ceiling passing from the edge of the "goaf." If injured lamps were found there, and the injury had been caused before the explosion took place, that would have been likely to produce the explosion. If there were neglect at al it would have been with the person who had charge of the lamp, unless the injury it sustained had been caused by an accident over which he had no control. Have no evidence of anything having been left undone which, if done, would have prevented this explosion. Consequently, I do not attribute blame either to Mr. Forster, the viewer or any one connected with the pit ; most certainly not. That is to say, excepting the unfortunate man whose lamp might have caused the explosion. Mr. Lyell. — Both fly-doors and trap-doors are used in the Bristol district, but trap-doors, I may say, have almost entirely gone out of use. I do not suppose, in the 17 collieries I visit, that more than half a dozen trap-doors are attended by boys. Fly-doors are considered safer upon the whole, for this reason among others, — when a person with a train passes through one of these doors they know that if they do not hear the door slam the current of air upon their return would be prejudicial to their own comfort. Have compared those of South Wales and those of Gloucestershire with those in the Somersetshire district. Have never been connected, professionally or otherwise, with the mines of the north of England. Had attended to the coal strata geologically before I did professionally. Consider a shale roof safer than a sandstone one. The ceiling of the Haswell pit differed in places. Along the main way the ceiling was the best I ever saw in a mine, in many parts being sufficient to support itself. Never before saw so large an extent with so few "dykes" or troubles" indeed ; they could not show me one. If I had seen the mine previous to the explosion, would have said there was no danger. By Mr. Faraday. — Went all through the Meadows-way and High Brockly Whins-way, and the ventilation in that part seemed to be good. The mine can be taken care of without difficulty, in consequence of the extreme flatness of the measures. I do not observe that any expense has been spared, or that there has been any defect in laying out the works from the first; on the contrary, it is very far superior to what is generally observed in regard to appearance and stability. There does not appear to have been any remissness in working it. By Mr. Roberts. — At the present moment cannot say that anything could be done for the future safety of the men that has not been done. Have some crude ideas, but they are not matured. Will bend my mind to the subject on going from here. Ventilation is the principal point, but cannot say in what respects improvements might be made. Not much troubled in our neighbourhood with explosive gas, more troubled with choke-damp. The shallowest of the mines with which I am connected is 74 fathoms, the deepest 248 to the bottom of the "sump." Known the mines in my district 14 years, professionally four or five ; but visited them frequently before I became connected professionally with them. Do not recollect of any lives having been lost by explosion in South Wales and Somersetshire. Thinks it, therefore, more necessary to guard against the presence of carbonic acid gas than against that of carbureted hydrogen. Carbureted hydrogen is extremely rare in the mines of those districts. We might adopt a less efficient means than they do here to get rid of carbureted hydrogen. It is quite evident to me that the owners, by insisting on the use of the Davy lamps, and using candles only in certain parts of the mine, have taken every precaution to provide against an explosion. It is a proof they have directed their minds to the subject. After the accident that has happened cannot consider a similar one as not likely to happen again. Cannot suggest anything to prevent a similar accident occurring, but in my opinion every man of feeling would immediately direct his mind to the subject with a view of discovering such a remedy, if possible. By Mr. Marshall. — Gas might accumulate in the same place again, and if an accident happened to the lamp under such circumstances, as in this instance I mean, that would cause a similar explosion. It is the combination of circumstances. If you prove to me that the flame would pass through the meshes of the gauze, then I should say a strong current of gas coming against the lamp might cause an explosion ; but unless you prove that the flame will pass through the gauze, I should say an explosion would not be so caused. Nothing less than mechanical force that would make each hole a "blowpipe" would cause the flame to pass the "meshes". No current of air would cause the flame to pass. Mr. Roberts was proceeding to ask some questions relative to Mr. Scutchbury's knowledge of various lamps used in coal-mines, when the Coroner interfered and prevented the question being put, as foreign to the inquiry. It was a fit subject for investigation by a Parliamentary committee, but they were sitting now with reference only to the late accident. Examination resumed. — Do not know that any person was present on behalf of the workmen, when I examined the mine ; I should say we were most of us "on behalf of the men." Mr. Forster and Mr. Taylor were our guides ; but we took whatever direction we pleased. They followed, implicitly, our desires. Think it worthy of a thought, whether a door in the form of a portcullis might be so placed above the "stoppings" as to be opened by an explosion., and descend immediately after it. Such a door might preserve the men from being killed from choke-damp, but I do not think it would preserve the men from being killed, for the current of air would be kept up so as to preserve the combustion, and thus the pit would be fired and the persons burnt. The gauze might be made red hot in half a minute, when the meshes are filled with hydrogen. Small coal or sulphur might cause this. By the Coroner. — Do not know that sulphur occurs in coal mines in this district. By Mr. Roberts. — The appointment of Government inspectors of mines might do good ; it could do no harm. An examination of mines by men of scientific ability might be productive of benefit if they were met in a proper spirit. Do not think it necessary for the safety of the men that the pit should be cleared of the workmen when a "jud" is drawn. The combination of circumstances that occurred in the present case can hardly be taken into account in future operations. If the men were withdrawn from the mine, all except those immediately engaged in the "jud," every time a "jud" was drawn, the expense would be so great that the mine could not be carried on profitably, at least in my country. After this witness's evidence had been read over, the jury said they had heard sufficient to enable them to make up their minds as to their verdict. The Coroner then ordered the court to be cleared, on which Mr. Roberts made application to the court that witnesses that he was prepared to produce on behalf of the men might be examined. The Coroner did not think that necessary now, and again ordered the court to be cleared of all except the reporters. That having been done, the Coroner said, the foreman of the jury requested him, after hearing the evidence of Mr. Scutchbury, a person perfectly disinterested in the matter, to state that the jury had heard sufficient to lead them to a proper conclusion on the question. The Jury having expressed themselves perfectly satisfied with the evidence, the reporters withdrew, and the jury, after consulting together a few minutes, agreed upon their verdict. The reporters were then again admitted, having been absent only about seven minutes altogether. The Coroner then, addressing the foreman, asked if the jury had agreed ! The Foreman. — Yes. The Coroner. — How do you find the persons named came to their death ? The Foreman. — Purely by accident. The Coroner. — By that you mean that you attribute blame to no one ? The Foreman. — Certainly ; to no one. The inquisition was drawn up in due form and signed by the jurymen, which terminated their proceedings. The subscriptions in aid of the sufferers amounts to upwards of £1,800.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||