|
11th October 1844 The Colliery Explosion at HaswellAdjourned InquestHaswell Colliery, Wednesday Night. The adjourned inquest on the bodies of the sufferers in the late colliery explosion at Haswell, in the county of Durham, was resumed this morning before Mr. Maynard. On the opening of the court, the Coroner said he was happy to inform the jury that Professor Faraday and Professor Lyell had been sent down by the Government to assist in the inquiry. Both gentlemen were present. William Chilton was then called and examined. — Am a pitman living at Haswell, and have charge of the Davy-lamps. Do not know how many lamps were in the little pit on the day of the explosion. Four lamps, now produced, were brought to me after the explosion, but not on the same day. Know the lamps by the numbers. Each man had a particular number. No. 94 belonged to Hans Ward, No. 91 belonged to Thomas Turnbull, No. 95 belonged to a boy named Matthew Clough, about 12 years of age, and No. 51 belonged to John Curry. Don't know where any of these lamps were found. They are in the same state now as they were when they were brought back to me. These were brought to me where I clean them, at the lamp-room in the pit. When the lamps were taken from me they were all in a perfect state. They were taken from me on the Saturday morning. I was not down the pit at the time of the explosion. By Mr. Roberts. — It is not my duty to clean the gauze. The men leave the bottom of the lamp with me, and take the gauze to their own houses. Each man takes his own gauze, and cleans it himself. There is a person appointed to look at the gauze to see it is properly cleaned and all right before the lamps are given out. That is the duty of the deputy "overman." My attention is exclusively confined to the bottom, that part which contains the oil. When the man comes to me, he brings his own gauze, and I give him the lamp ; he then puts the gauze on himself, and goes to the deputy, who locks the lamp. James Scott, deputy-viewer, sworn on a previous day, was called, and stated that Hans Ward's duty was at the low side of the Brockly-whins-flat. His lamp was found in the ninth board. Thomas Turnbull was a "putter," between the Meadows-flat and the broken workings. Cannot tell where he was found. Matthew Cleugh was a plate-cleaner, between the Meadows-workings and the Meadows-flat, over the same ground as the other was a "putter." John Curry was a hewer in the ninth "headways" course. Curry was found in the ninth "headways," at the place where he worked. Found a lamp with the plug out ; but am not certain of the number of it. Found it at the "jud." Cannot speak as to any other of the lamps. By Mr. Roberts. — Eleven is the lowest age at which boys are allowed to carry lamps. Cleugh was above 12 years of age. He is set down in the list at 10. It is part of my duty to caution the men as to the carrying of their lamps. There is a general order given to take all care possible of their lamps, but there is no particular rule laid down, except that they are ordered to do nothing to the lamps after receiving them. Never saw the flame pass through the gauze of a Davy-lamp. By Mr. Faraday. — It was my duty to see the pit was clear from gas, test the presence of gas by the lamp, and judge from the appearance produced upon the flame. Never saw the atmosphere of the mine so impregnated with gas as to produce a permanent effect on the lamp. Never saw any indication of gas in the mine, either in the workings or at the upcast. Davy-lamps were used as a pure matter of precaution, and not from there having been any previous indication of gas. Have seen lamps in places where they might be affected by "fire-damp." Think a concussion would cause the flame of a Davy-lamp to pass the gauze, even in the ordinary atmosphere. Would think it might be easier done when the air was mixed with fire-damp. By Mr. Roberts. — Am next in rank to Mr. Forster, and when he is absent I have the entire superintendence of the mine. Mr. Forster is never absent for a long time together. He is generally home every night. He had been away a fortnight previous to the accident. Between 200 and 300 is the largest number of men and boys I have in charge in the mine at one time. About 180 of that number are men, the remainder boys. Mr. Forster goes down the pit once-a-week, and sometimes twice. He is never more than a week without going down. John Thompson examined. — Am employed on the "rolly-way," in the Haswell pit. Clean the way and keep the plates in order. My duty extends from the shaft to the first "siding," about 400 yards. Was down at the bottom of the shaft at the time of the explosion. It was about a quarter-past 3 o'clock. There was a boy came to the shaft, and said to me he believed something had happened. It was either Richardson or Joicey. He said there had been such a wind come as nearly to blow him from his work. Went into the "rolly-way" as fast as possible, and when I passed the first "siding" I heard a boy coming out, and saw he had no light. That boy's name was John Coates. Went further along the "rolly-way," and found some falls had taken place from the roof. Had nothing but my candle, and I sent some of them away for a lamp. Tried my candle at the two way ends at the beginning of the stone drift, to see if the air was going the right way. Found it was going right there. Went further in and found another fall ; and just as the parties I had sent were bringing the lamp to me, Mr. Scott and Mr. Thompson and Mr. Miller came up. We went together 20 or 30 yards further, to Dickenson's-way end, where we found a large fall from the roof, and about 20 yards further we found a horse and 15 tubs jambed in the way by the force of the explosion. There was no fall there. Made a road past, and proceeded to the old way-end, where we found a large fall from the roof. Removed the stone and Scott and Miller got over it. I came back to the outer end of the stone drift, and then went up the old way to Dickenson's-way end. About 200 yards from the stone drift end found a crossing blown out. Thompson came in the contrary direction, and met me there. The effect of that crossing being blown out was, that the fresh air was returned to the furnace instead of being sent through the workings. Found no difference in the air when the boy alarmed me, till I got to where the stoppings were blown out. The current of air was slack there, for want of the stoppings. By Mr. Roberts. — Am 50 years of age and have been 43 years a pitman. Have been frequently employed in drawing a "jud." It is not considered more dangerous than a common whole "board" to those who are accustomed to it. It is usual to employ experienced men in drawing a "jud." They do it by the aid of light from a lamp. Do not know any colliery where they draw the "juds" only when all the other men are out of the pit. Cannot say whether that is or is not desirable. The stoppings are made of bricks and lime. Believe the board end stoppings are made of wood. Cannot say what thickness. We do not generally expect gas to come off when a "jud" is drawn. Davy-lamps are used as a precaution. Don't take candles, because when we go in we cannot tell what may come. Two or three hours elapsed after the explosion before the first body was brought out. Could not get at the bodies for choke-damp. Got rid of the choke-damp by putting in the stoppings and directing the air in. It is very usual for stone to fall when a "jud" is withdrawn. By the Coroner. — Have frequently removed "juds" at Haswell, and never observed gas coming off. Had there been any should have been sure to observe it. Never knew fires take place in mines without gas being present. By Mr. Roberts. — When boys work where candles are used they use candles, and they use the lamps where men use lamps. Never saw boys use lamps where men use candles. Thomas Chambers. — Am a pitman, and live at Haswell Colliery. Have been requested, since the explosion, to make an examination of the mine on behalf of the miners. Have examined the whole of the little pit. Did so at the request of the workmen in the whole colliery. We proceeded from the furnace and examined the waste all through. Found most excellent ventilation, there being two courses for the return air all the way we went. There were 11 other workmen along with me. We then proceeded into the workings to ascertain, if possible, where the explosion had taken place. We could not be certain as to the place, but it is my opinion the explosion did not take place at Williamson's "jud." Think the gas had caught a candle in another part of the mine — in one of three "boards" running into the Meadows-way, between the Meadows and Brockly-whins-flats. Form my opinion from the fact of two of these "boards" having been stopped at the high end, so as not to allow the air to circulate round to prevent the accumulation of gas. There are slight indications of fire there ; in my opinion as strong as they are at Williamson's "jud." Some of the props there are charred a little on both sides. Cannot say whether those that were with me concur in that opinion. That place might be about 150 yards from Williamson's "jud." There was a stopping between in the "headways" end. That stopping was blown down. By the Corner. — It is my opinion the explosion was the result of accident, and not of negligence. There was nothing omitted that could, in my opinion, have been done to prevent it. Have worked about two months in the little pit. That was eight months ago. The ventilation was excellent then. Was employed as deputy, and frequently had complaints of the current of air being too strong, the men requesting me to keep the "brattice" back. Think the pit was in the same state on Friday when I examined it as it was in previous to the explosion. Always considered the stoppings sufficient. They are placed there for no other purpose than to keep the air on the right course. There would be no advantage in having them stronger. By Mr. Faraday. — Judge the explosion took place where I have described, from the charring. There had been a slight fire at Williamson's "jud." Could not trace where the explosion went out. Have seen symptoms of gas in the workings in the little pit. The gas appeared to be between the "brassy" part of the bottom coal and the coal itself. Worked in it as usual. The ventilation was as good then as now. Think the gas occurs in the Haswell pit as much as generally in others. There are some worse. Think the late explosion had not been from a large quantity of gas. The falls described in the ways were caused by the explosion; but, notwithstanding, I think it arose from a small quantity of gas. After the stoppings and crossings had been blown out there was no way for the fresh air to get in to the men, so as to overpower the choke-damp, and that in my opinion accounts for the great number killed by the choke-damp. There was no other way for the men to get out but by passing through the choke-damp. By Mr. Roberts. — If the current of air had been strong enough where I supposed the gas had accumulated, that would have carried it off. If candles were used there they would not be nearer than 150 yards from the "broken." There was a door between that place and the "broken." It was a fly-door, which is not attended by any one. It is frequently pushed open in the ordinary course of working the pit. It is never propped open. The explosion could not have been caused from a fall of stone having forced the gas from the "broken" to where the candles were being used; because, I don't think any gas could be in the "jud" before it was drawn without being seen, and the "jud" would have to be drawn before the gas would be forced out. Had there been gas in Williamson's "jud," it could not have been forced out to where the candles were. Have been four years a deputy at Haswell, and never saw gas escape on drawing a "jud." The "waste" is a dangerous part of the mine if not taken care of. Have heard the men complain of strangers being employed in the "waste." By the Coroner. — Am satisfied the present explosion did not take place in the "waste." By Mr. Roberts. — It is an opinion generally entertained by the men that inexperienced persons ought not to be employed where the lamps are used. Those who use them ought to understand the care which should be taken of them. Recollect that about eight months since a deputation was sent to Mr. Forster from the men working in the colliery respecting two strangers working with Davy-lamps in the Brockly-whins "broken." The deputation did not see Mr. Forster. When they went to the office Mr. Forster was not there, and they did not go back any more. I was one of the deputation. Am aware of the men having lately murmured respecting the employment of three strangers in the "waste." That was before the explosion. The current of air is equally strong in all parts of the pit. If the air were travelling at the rate of eight miles an hour in one part, it might not travel half so fast in other parts. It will travel slowest in the "broken." It will be weak in the "goaf." We generally look for gas in the "goaf." I think the current of air passing round and through the "goaf" is sufficient to carry away all the gas the "goaf" will make. There is also a sufficient current in the "broken." The "board" end stoppings were replaced when I examined the mine on Friday. They are made of wood. There is a natural tendency in the roof to fall and the floor to rise. The wood stoppings are liable to warp when that occurs. Think the wood stoppings safer than the stone ones in that part, because should the "creep" come near the stopping to injure it, it would do more harm to the brick stopping than the wood one. The force of the "creep" on a brick stopping would crush it so as to force it out. As deputy had nothing to do with the cleaning of the gauze, except on the lamp I used myself. Nicholas Wood. — Live at Killingworth, and have been extensively engaged as a colliery viewer. Examined the general state of the ventilation of the Haswell pit, in company with Mr. G. Hunter, yesterday. Examined both pits, and commenced by ascertaining the quantity of air going down the down-cast shaft. There are two shafts, one down-cast, and the other up-cast, both used for the purpose of ventilation. Two shafts I consider a great advantage. The ventilation is produced by two furnaces ; in some cases there is only one. Found the quantity of air going down 37,028 cubic feet per minute. At a point between the shaft and the workings there is a split, and there 11,621 cubic feet are taken to the north inclined workings, leaving 25,407 for the workings of the little pit, which consists of what is called three ways, viz., the Meadows-way, the High Brockly-whins-way, and the Low Brockly-whins-way. At each of these three ways, the whole coal and the broken are being worked, a system of working in which the pillars are taken away immediately succeeding the working of the whole mine. 25,407 cubic inches of air are about equally divided between those three ways, perhaps rather more to the Meadows-way than to each of the other two ; that makes 8,469 cubic feet for each of those ways. The air is subdivided in each of those ways, about one half being taken into the "pillar-working," and the other into the "whole." That is done by what are called "regulators." In the Meadows-way, the air into the "pillar-workings" is taken through what is called a "scale," or opening about a foot square, in two doors near the Meadows-flat ; and the remaining portion of air going to the Meadows-way is taken through a swinging door between the sixth and seventh pillars of the Meadows-flat. When that air gets in it spreads itself in the workings between the "pillar-working" and the "goaf." The separation between the "pillar-working" and the "whole" is done by stoppings, brick stoppings in the Mothergate, and wood stoppings in the boards between the face of the coal in the "whole" and the pillars. That is precisely the same system pursued in the other ways. Consider that there is quite a sufficiency of air for the purpose of ventilation, considering the state of the mine. Measured the air going into the big pit, and found it 37,200 cubic feet per minute, so that the whole quantity of air coming down the shaft was 74,228 cubic feet per minute. That is the largest quantity of any pit within my experience. Have not examined the whole of the workings in the little pit, but have examined enough to enable me to form an opinion as to where the explosion took place. Am of opinion it took place near the "goaf," between the "goaf" and the Meadows-way. Am led to that opinion by observing the way which the gas has evidently taken, and in which stoppings have been blown. Think it occurred at Williamson's "jud," as the greatest effect of the fire is along the face of the "whole" coal east of the "goaf." Then, I think the explosion had extended to the Brockly-whins "goaf," where it got a trifling accession of gas, and that had caused a trifling explosion in the opposite direction. That is shown by the charring being on both sides of the pillar. We came to the conclusion that the first explosions took place in the "jud" because all the stoppings were blown out in the direction of the Brockly-whins "goaf." There were 20 or 30 stoppings blown down in that direction, and others in a contrary direction. I think the explosion obtained an accession of gas at the Brockly-whins-flat, and that caused a reaction in the opposite direction, Which accounts for the way in which the latter stoppings were blown down. Thomas Chambers, the last witness examined, went with us in our examination, and pointed out the place he supposed the explosion to have originated in, and assigned his reasons for that opinion; but, after careful consideration, I differ from him in that opinion. I think the explosion did not take place there, because I think it very unlikely there could have been an accumulation of gas there on the day on which the accident occurred. The bottom coal had been taken out on the previous Thursday, and there was no continued discharge of gas in the board, which we examined very carefully with a candle. Beside, if the explosion had occurred there, the quantity of gas that could accumulate there would not be sufficient to produce the effects we witnessed, it could only have done so by communicating with other gas at the "goafs," and if it had been strong enough to do that it would have blown the stoppings in the contrary direction. Am of opinion the explosion arose from accident. It could not, I think, by any possibility have happened from any of the candles used in the pit, because I think the current of air going where the candles are used is too powerful to allow any discharge of gas that was in the "goaf" to back out to the candles. At the time of the accident, there was no whole coal working going on, so that the only candles used were at the Meadows-flat, which the gas could not reach. Think the pit a well ventilated one. Think everything has been done that is usually done in the coal trade. Think the accident must have happened from some fall in the upper part of the "goaf." A portion of air goes through the "goaf," but the roof is high in some places, and the gas might accumulate there out of reach of the air. The roof falls in a sort of cone, and the fact of the air going through the "goaf" is no proof that there is not an accumulation of gas in the upper region. An accumulation of gas may remain there for some time, and give no indication of its presence in the air coming over. The rumbling noise heard on the morning before the explosion might have been caused by a movement in the strata above ; the withdrawing of the "jud" would assist the settling down of the stone, and the fall might cause a "bag of gas" to rush out. Gas pent up, in a highly condensed state, in the roof of the "goaf," is called a "bag of gas." The withdrawing of the "jud" would not alone be sufficient to account for the explosion. Think the quantity of gas exploded had not been large. The fire had not extended into the low Brockly-whins-flat, and only about half over the Meadows and High Brockly-whins workings. My opinion is the explosion took place at the "jud," not in it, but somewhere near it. The indications of fire were strongest near the "goaf." None of the men, I believe, were found in the "jud," but a few yards from it. The falling of the stone in the "jud" might bring down a portion of gas, a column, to the edge of the "goaf," and it might be thrown upon the lamps and so ignite. By Mr. Lyell. — The workings are in the Hutton-seam, which is about four feet seven inches in thickness, and the bottom giving out the gas 17 inches. The roof consists of shale principally. The depth is 156 fathoms. I think a roof of the "goaf" is more liable to fall from the expansion of the air between the strata of the coal when the super-incumbent strata is large. The dip of the coal strata is very trifling. The system of removing the pillars enables us to take out the whole of the coal. It is the practice now to work the "broken" and the whole simultaneously ; and I think with proper care that it is as safe a plan as any other. That plan is not generally adopted in the coal trade. I do not think it makes the "goaf" more dangerous. The ventilation of the "waste" is more perfect on this plan than under the old one. The waste is less under the present system, and the current of air is stronger in proportion. The boards are 4 feet 6 inches in height in the workings, and the horse roads about 7 feet. The pillars are 16 yards wide by 22 in length. The roof of this pit is contrary to a dangerous one ; it is quite free from "troubles." By Mr. Roberts. — Was examined by the Committee of the House of Commons on Accidents in Mines. Recollect that "withdrawing a jud" was referred to in the course of that examination. The distinction should be drawn between pillar-working, where there is a great discharge of gas, and where the "goaf" is entirely filled with inflammable air, and here where the "goaf" must be nearly, if not entirely free from it, except perhaps in the upper portions. Recollects Mr. Buddle mentioning that "bags of gas" were very common in the mines of Northumberland and Durham ; and have frequently known them myself. "Bags of gas" are places where the gas is highly condensed, some suppose in a fluid state, in a cavity of the roof ; and when a fall takes place it rushes out, and expands itself. It is a fact that, in every mine there are portions where the current of air is so strong as to blow a candle out, and in other places the air is perfectly still, or nearly so. It depends upon the quantity of the roof that falls whether it has the effect of forcing the air away in all directions. The air would be agitated in the immediate neighbourhood of a fall of roof equal in size to the half of this room, which is double the size of an ordinary room. Think there has been no alteration made in the pit since the explosion. The furnaces have not been altered, I am certain. Some mines are more subject to escapes of gas from the roof than others. If the roof be of sandstone, the gas which escapes from the coal gets into the pores of the stone, and comes off again at intervals. The shale roof is more impervious ; the gas is therefore more kept in the coal than with the sandstone roof. Am aware of a plan proposed by Mr. Goldsworthy Gurney for lighting mines by means of reflected mirrors, instead of lamps or candles. Think the plan is not practicable. It was considered by practical men so utterly impossible that it was never attempted. In practice, I think, with proper care, the Davy-lamp is safe. I do not think a current of air moving at the rate of 300 feet per minute would drive the flame of the Davy through the meshes. Have tried the lamp by moving it with great rapidity through a body of inflammable air taken from the mine for the purpose, without producing an explosion. Enlarged the apertures till it did go through. Sir Humphrey Davy gave directions as to the carrying a lamp through a current of air, but I have been unable to drive the flame through the gauze by any artificial current I could produce by ordinary means. It is a different thing gas being thrown upon a lamp, and the lamp being moved through still air. Practically, when the current is strong and that current inflammable, shields are used. My impression is, the lamp found in Williamson's "jud" must have been injured before the explosion took place, and that it would not have taken place with a perfect lamp. Have used the lamp called the "Geordy-lamp," and consider it in some respects preferable to the Davy and in others not. The glass tube protects the flame from any rush of air, and in that case that is one of its advantages. Employ both lamps, but consider there is so little difference that I generally leave the under-viewers use to which they think proper. In some places the men consider the Davy-lamp surer, and in Killingworth they consider the "Geordy" safer. If I were venturing my own life I should consider myself just as safe with one as the other. In walking rapidly through an explosive mixture I would take either the Geordy-lamp or the Davy with a shield. The Geordy-lamp is the larger of the two, and if the glass be broken the quantity of heated air it will contain will then be more than the Davy, and would be more liable to an explosion. The men have orders immediately the glass is broken to come out of the pit with the lamp ; never had the glass of the "Geordy" broken in my experience ; but if subjected to the same violence as injured the Davy lamps produced, the glass must have been broken. Believe the shield used with the Davy-lamp quite sufficient for all practical purposes. Examine the lamps produced, and believe them to be made of the best materials and make. The manufacturer of inferior lamps was complained of in the Parliamentary report on coal-mine accidents, but that complaint has been obviated by employing only manufacturers of known character. Mr. Buddle introduced two or three of his improved "stoppings" at Wallsend, but after the first serious accident in that colliery they were not generally adopted, though an accident subsequently occurred. That showed he was not satisfied of their utility. Referring to 2,296 question in the committee's report, I am of opinion that Mr. Buddle did not apply his observations to "stoppings," but to "dam-doors." A "dam-door," such as Mr. Buddle described before the committee, could not be applied in a wide "board." If practical men thought such doors safe or necessary, there would be no hesitation as to adopting them. Do not think the "swing door" described by Mr. Buddle would have been of any use in this case, nor can I recollect any case, within my knowledge, where they would have been of use — I mean, to have preserved the men from the effect of after-damp. There is not much difference between the "dam-door" and the "swing door," excepting that one is supported by stanchions and the other from the roof. Cannot say at what rate the air was travelling in the "broken" near the "jud," but it was what in pit language we call "very good air." Many suggestions were made to the Parliamentary committee for the improvement of the safety of the men, and all of them have received the consideration of practical men. The system of ventilation has been gradually improving within the last 10 years, and at that period the ventilation of this mine would be considered very extraordinary. Consider "fly-doors" an improvement on the former system of having them attended by boys. "Fly-doors" are never used in the main air-courses. Gave an opinion before the Parliamentary committee that boys were preferable to men for watching those doors, and am of that opinion still. Mr. Roberts was proceeding to read portions of Mr. Wood's evidence before the committee, when the coroner interposed. At the termination of Mr. Wood's examination The Jury, after deliberating a while, agreed to adjourn till 9 o'clock on Friday morning. Professor Faraday and Professor Lyell have arranged to go down the Haswell-pit to-morrow to inspect the workings.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||