|
4th October 1844 The Colliery Explosion at HaswellAdjourned InquestHaswell Colliery, Wednesday Night. The adjourned inquest on the bodies of the sufferers in the colliery explosion at Haswell, in the county of Durham, was resumed this morning, before Mr. Maynard, when the following witnesses were examined :— Robert Thompson, master-wasteman at Haswell-pit, having been sworn, said — It is my duty, after the air leaves the working part of the pit, and enters upon the "waste," to see that the "waste" is in a safe state, and wrought to certain dimensions. Was in part of the "waste" on Friday night. Was last in the skirt of the Meadows-flat-waste on Wednesday night, but was not through the whole of it. When I was at the "skirt" I was quite satisfied that at the return the current of air was sufficient to ventilate the Meadows-flat workings. Cannot tell the quantity of air that was circulating per minute. Cannot go into every part of the "waste" daily ; nor do I or my employers think it necessary. The men working in the "waste" are directed in the first place to preserve their lamps, and I have often told them that self-preservation was a duty they owed to themselves. They are also directed to work to a certain size ; and if they should come in contact with any gas, to withdraw instantly, and to remain away till they give notice to me ; but I never knew an instance at the colliery when this had to be done. Since the explosion I have been through the Meadows-waste, and I think the explosion has not taken place there. I swear positively that is my opinion. There are not the least indications of the explosion having happened there, as there is no injury done to the stoppings, and no more dirt or dust than usual. I examined the whole of the return "drift" this morning, and on Sunday night I examined as far as the pillars, but did not then think it prudent to go further, as the after-damp was coming off from the "Meadows" so strong at that moment. This morning I found the whole of the "waste" in a perfect state. I cannot think, after examining the "drift" that the explosion took place for want of ventilation. At the time of the explosion I can positively swear the ventilation was perfectly good. Have two men employed as "wastemen" who have not been so employed before, and another new man, who had been previously so employed. Do not think it at all dangerous to employ these men, as three experienced "wastemen" accompany them, and have charge of them. The explosion has not happened from any defect in the "waste." I have been employed as a "wasteman" above 9 years. Never heard any complaints among the men at this colliery of a want of ventilation in the entire colliery, but, on the contrary, they have frequently complained of too much air. By Mr. Roberts. — Was never in a pit at the time of an explosion, but am well aware of the measures that should be taken to prevent it. Cannot say how long before an explosion the gas would indicate danger on the flame of a lamp, — it might be a day or a week. In such a case as this the explosion would be instant. The indication and the explosion would be simultaneous. If there is foul air in a colliery it will naturally be found on the "waste." There were no candles at all used in the Meadows-flat workings — lamps only. There is no communication between the "waste" and the place where candles are used at the Brockly-whins-flat, except by the "rolly-way," where there is a "man-door." Foul air from the "waste" would have to travel 300 yards before it came to where candles were used. The Brockly-whins-flat dips a little, and inflammable air flies to the highest point. I think foul air could not accumulate in the "waste" without my knowing it ; but cannot account for what may come off at an old "goaf," where the roof is let down, and where foul air may accumulate. It is my duty to examine the air course at the "goaf." Have never seen but once gas appear at the "goaf," where there was a small quantity which just tailed off at the lamp, barely sufficient to be observed. Gas may be both generated and accumulated in the "goaf," but not in the "waste," without my knowing it. Am absent from some parts of the "waste" for hours together. Cannot be in all parts of the "waste" at once, but always leave every part I visit in a proper state. The "waste" is protected by a current of air passing through it. If it were not for that current of air, the "waste" could not be kept free from the gas. If there were no current of air, there would be a rapid accumulation of gas. Go from place to place in the "waste" during the day, remaining at each as long as may be required. From some places in the "waste" I would venture to stop away a week without fear of danger, but I never do so, but I make it a practice to go over all parts of the "waste" frequently. If I saw danger from the careless working of any man, I have power to report it to Mr. Forster, the viewer, and the man would be discharged. If any incompetent man were kept at work, it would be my fault. The "waste" is now in the same state as it was before the explosion. Men are now at work in the pit, making preparations to resume work again. They began on Sunday night or Monday morning to put in the "stoppings." The bodies could not have been got if "brattice stoppings" had not been put in. I dare go in now, and hew coal with a lamp, at the place where the explosion happened, the ventilation is now so good. It is not in my power to suggest any plan to prevent future explosions, from the experience I have had on this occasion. Cannot say whether or not it is possible for a similar accident to happen as soon as the men resume work, but do not think it probable, because I think something happened out of the common order when this explosion took place. I firmly believe the ventilation of the pit cannot be more perfect and secure than it is. By Mr. Cleugh. — The nearest point to the "goaf" from the Meadows-flat is 100 yards. The boy at the flat had a candle when he was last there, which is about a fortnight since. By the Coroner. — If anything went wrong, there would be danger in a boy having a candle in that place. Never saw anything else but candles used by the boys at the flat. By Mr. Marshall. — There would be no danger in the use of a candle there if the ventilation were kept up the right way. There are two trap-doors between the flat and the working. By Mr. Cleugh. — There is not an open communication between the "goaf" and the flat. The doors are sometimes open together, and when this is the case it is a benefit to the men working in the "juds," who receive a better current of air. Cannot say whether there was a large "goaf" standing or not at the time of the explosion. It is the overman's duty to see to that. Considers he would be a very clever fellow, if he could ventilate the "goaf." It is his duty to ventilate the "goaf" at the return. All that can be done is to ventilate the "goaf" at the shore on the outside. This has always been done in Haswell-pit, and is as much as is sufficient to ventilate it, as a sufficiency of air comes over it. By the Coroner. — I cannot see that anything more can be done to ventilate the "goaf" than what has been done. By Mr. Cleugh. — If a tremendous fall came in the "goaf" it might force away gas that came off on the candle used at the "Meadows-flat" if the two doors were open. Was one of the first men to get to the Meadows-flat after the explosion took place. Cannot say in what state the separation was in. A little boy was there dead severely burnt, but cannot say whether he was the "flat" boy or not. Assuming that the explosion had taken place at the Meadows-flat, I think the crossing would have been injured, and the fire would have come under the crossing. When the fire came to the crossing it turned the crossing out at each side and filled the space. It would expand there because the crossing is weaker than the wall sides. Have not yet got that experience to erect a crossing that would withstand such an explosion. The Brockly-whins-flat is a pillar and a half from the whole, the distance about 44 yards. By Mr. Marshall. — There is a stopping between the men working in the "broken" and those in the "whole," which I think would be a protection to the men taking down the "jud," but it would be better taken down when the men are not working at the "whole." By Mr. Cleugh. — The "broken" and the "whole" are ventilated by two different currents of air. There is not a communication between the "broken" and the Brockly-whins-flat by means of a door, but there is a communication between the "broken" and the "whole" a short distance from the "flat" by doors, and the "broken" is ventilated at those two doors. The doors have nothing to do with the "whole," The deputy's chest stood, the last time I saw it, between two doors at the Meadows-flat. Considers the Davy-lamp a perfect safety to the miner. A strong current of air might blow the flame through the gauze of the lamp. Shields are used to the lamp to prevent such an occurrence, and also to keep the light burning. By Mr. Marshall. — The men are now employed putting in the same stoppings that were in before, to make the pit ready for working. By Mr. Roberts. — I mean by "the common order," things that do not usually happen in the working of collieries — that are mysteries altogether. The cause of the explosion is involved in mystery. I think it desirable for the safety of the men that the mystery should be cleared up, if possible, but do not think the mystery would be cleared up by an examination of the mine — it would be only conjecture at the last. Thomas Emmerson Forster — Is a viewer of Haswell Colliery, and has been so since the commencement. Was down the big pit on the Monday previous to the explosion, but have not been in the little pit where the explosion took place since August. Have been ill, and that prevented me going down. When down the big pit was able to know how the ventilation was going on in the little pit. The downcast shaft is 12 feet in diameter, and the upcast shaft 9½ feet, they being about 40 yards apart. At the bottom of the down-cast shaft the air is divided into two columns, that of the little pit being 37,730 cubic feet per minute, that of the big or engine-pit 35,000 feet. The column of air that goes into the little pit proceeds about 600 yards from the shaft to the north-east, along the main "rolly-way," at which point the air is again divided ; about one-fourth of it goes to the north, for the purpose of ventilating the northern and western "wastes" of the pit. From that point three-fourths of the column proceeds to the Meadows-way-end, at which point it is again divided, and about one-third of that goes up for the purpose of ventilating the Meadows-flat, the other part of the air going into the Brockly-whins flat. At the face of the Mothergate-flat the air is again divided, one portion going to the boards on the left, and the other to the district on the right. The working of the pillars to the right and left of Brockly-whins-flat is aired by a scale from the air, which works the boards on each side. At the Meadows-way about one-third of the column goes directly up the face of the Mothergate, with the exception of a scale that goes through the doors at the Meadow-flat. This air proceeds up the Mothergate, and immediately distributes itself into the headway courses at that district. The air at that flat is also assisted by the air which ventilates the Brockly-whins-flat at the left side, which air presses over the crossing a short distance from the Meadows-flat ; both this and the air that goes up the Mothergate being by a regulator placed in the highest headway-course. A regulator is a sort of door placed in the headway-course to check the air, and force it through the "goaf." That air having done its duty at the Meadows-flat, and a portion having gone through the "goaf," the remainder discharges itself into a free air course, and completely surrounds the "goaf" at that district, and then joins the other air that passes through the "goaf." The diameter of the pit is sufficient to supply air for the ventilation of the whole colliery. The quantity of air that goes down the Haswell pit is unprecedented in the coal trade. I state this without fear of contradiction. It is, in my opinion, sufficient for the ventilation of the mine. There have never been any complaints made to me of the ventilation being imperfect. I have frequently had complaints of the current being too strong. The men were fairly starved. Have had on more than one occasion to fine men for preventing the air going up to the face of the board where the men were working. As far as I know, nothing had been left undone which could have rendered the ventilation of the mine more perfect. In fact, when I heard of the accident I could not credit it. I have examined the air courses since the explosion. On Saturday, when the explosion took place, I was at Newcastle. It might have been 8 or half-past 8 when I received the information, and I proceeded immediately to the pit. Went down, and to the Meadows-flat. I think two of the bodies had been then got. Proceeded four pillars up the flat, at which point I saw the dead bodies of several men who had been brought there. Three of them were burnt. Did not see where those men had been brought from. After remaining there for some time, I was able to get up as high as the ninth headway course, where I felt the after-damp so strong I was obliged to return. I then went from that point to Brockly-whins-flat to bring the unfortunate sufferers from the low side. 14 of these were found. Hall, the deputy, was brought out of that side of the flat, and his watch was going, showing there had been no fire on that side of the pit. I am enabled to swear positively that there had been no fire at that part of the pit — by fire, I mean explosion. He was then so ill that he came back between 2 and 3 o'clock ; returned at 7 o'clock. Before going to "bank," they had found 47 of the sufferers, and when I returned at 7 all had been found but two. I, with Scott and others, went and searched for the bodies of Mark Davidson and Thomas Buttons. Davidson was found shortly after in the "headways" course of Brockly-whins-flat, on the left hand side. They had not been burnt. Thomas Buttons, who was found either in the fourth or fifth "board" in the same "flat," appeared slightly burnt, or had got a blow. The fire did appear to have been at the high part of the Brockly-whins-flat ; but slight. The appearances were not sufficient to show that an explosion had taken place there. I then turned my attention to the Meadows-flat, and on examination of the ninth "headways" course I found the fire had originated at that point, because the props of the timber in the immediate vicinity were very much charred, showing the fire had been the greatest there. I think that after Williamson had drawn the "jud," the fall of stones and the explosion were simultaneous. My opinion is, there had not been an accumulation of gas there. The gas, in my opinion, had been thrown off by the fall. As soon as ever the stone fell, the gas got vent, and rushed out upon the lamps. I think the Injured lamp, which was found near the "jud," had been injured by the fall of stone, and a sudden blow on the lamp had forced the flame out at one side, and it had thus ignited the gas. The fire appears to have been heaviest in the Meadows-flat. In fact, the "stoppings" having been blown out in the direction of the Brockly-whins-flat, convinces me that the explosion originated in the Meadows-flat. The "props" were all charred on the side next the Meadows flat. If the explosion had taken place in the Brockly-whins-flat, the props would have been charred on the contrary side. Have no doubt the explosion took place at Williamson's "jud." Have been in the "air courses" since, so far as to convince myself that they are now right, and also that the ventilation had been good previous to the explosion. I believe the ventilation before the explosion was perfect. I consider the ventilation of the "goaf" is sufficient to prevent danger from an accumulation of gas there. I know of no other means than what I have already stated by which the ventilation could be improved. The ventilation in the entire pit is as perfect as can be accomplished by any known means. I know of nothing that could have been done to prevent this explosion. I heard one of the witnesses speak of having heard a rumbling noise in the "goaf." I attribute it to the superincumbent stone easing itself down on the pillars of coal, they no being sufficient to sustain its weight. It might arise from some pent-up gas. It is my opinion that by an investigation of the mine by scientific and practical men the cause of the explosion could not be obtained with certainty. Have done every thing for the protection of the men that could in my opinion be done. By Mr. Roberts. — Is not an owner of this colliery, nor beneficially interested in any colliery. Believes an accumulation of gas in the "goaf" was impossible. The "workings" extend over about 250 acres. The longest distance from end to end of that surface is better than 1,600 yards in a direct line. The number of yards the air has to travel between entering the pit and the coming out of it might be about four miles — half a mile more or less. The shafts are each 312 yards in length. Do you think any man, however scientific he may be, can see more as to the cause of the explosion, by examining the mine, than I have myself done. Was last in the pit this morning, and have been over the whole of the Meadows-flat with a naked candle. Have no objection to any other viewer in the coal trade. Am not aware that Mr. Mathias Dunn was ever in any way connected with this pit. Mr. Marshall said he might recall to the notice of the coroner that he had stated the owners had no objection to any one the coroner and jury might appoint. Mr. Forster resumed. — My reason for objecting to Mr. Dunn is an apprehension that, from a private pique he has to me, he might do an injury to the owners. Think Mr. Dunn could do me no injury by examining the pit as proposed, if he told the truth. Mr. Dunn has been a viewer. He is a practical viewer. If I might observe, he has unfortunately had many serious accidents in the mines under his charge. Mr. Roberts said — "A burnt child dreads the fire ;" on which the coroner remarked that he should allow of no such observations. Mr. Roberts repeated the expression, and persisted in making other improper remarks, on which the coroner ordered him out of court ; but, on promising to conduct himself properly, he was allowed to continue the cross-examination. Examination resumed. — Mr. Dunn comes with the definition of a "practical man." Have no other reason to object to Mr. Dunn than what I have stated. The Hetton colliery is larger than this. The Lambton, Rainton, and other collieries are larger in respect to the workings. There are many smaller. This may be considered as an average large colliery. Have heard of an accident at another colliery from a sudden discharge of gas, but not exactly under similar circumstances to this. The gas generates from the coal, but it frequently comes off with the stone. Should not think from a large quantity of gas being found in the roof that it had exuded from the sides and accumulated there. I don't think the discharge of gas in this case has been large. I judge this from the little damage done to the pit, and the small extent to which the fire has gone. Cannot form any opinion as to the number of cubic feet of gas exploded. It is the duty of inspectors and overmen to guard against accumulations of gas, and attend to the safety of the men. If there had been an accumulation of gas the neglect would have been with some of the witnesses examined on this inquest. By the Coroner. — I don't mean if there had been an accumulation of gas above the "jud," but in any part of the workings. If an accumulation of gas had taken place during the back shift it would have been the fault of the deputy who has been killed. The lamps are locked by the deputy to prevent the men removing the gauze. I am not aware of any practice of turning one lamp to another. If it be done one of the lamps must be placed nearly horizontal. To do that it is necessary to draw out the plug that confines the oil. It depends upon the quantity of oil and the wick whether the external air in doing this will pass through the tube, and so communicate with the flame. If in doing that carbonated hydrogen came in contact with the flame it might explode, and undoubtedly would, in the inside of the gauze, but I cannot say whether or not it would extend to the outside. Cannot say whether or not the present accident might have arisen from such a cause. Though the flame would be thrown against the gauze by placing the lamp in a horizontal position, I do not think it would go through the gauze without considerable pressure, or the gauze was very oily. We do all in our power to prevent it getting oily. The flame would ignite the oil, and so communicate with the outside. The men are desired to keep their lamps as clean as possible, and if a man present his lamp to the deputy to be examined, and the latter found it oily, he would not allow the man to go to his work. If a lamp got a blow it might get oily. Know of no other cause to make it oily. Am not aware that it is usual for such an accident to happen to a lamp ; having given orders that the lamps should not be oily when the men go to work. Have seen the Geordy-lamp. Know very little about it. Have never seen it used. Believe the Geordy-lamp is used at two or three collieries ; it is used at Killingworth and at Springwell. Know nothing of the opinion of those who use it as to its efficiency. Have given great attention to the means of preventing explosions. I consider good ventilation and great care with the Davy-lamp, when it is necessary to be used, the best means. Have heard of no suggestions from other parties for the general improvement of the ventilation in mines. Have read the report of the South Shields Mining Committee, but do not recollect any suggestion by them to the effect that the diameter of the works should not be more than half a mile ; but I recollect that it was stated before a committee of the House of Commons, when the works were larger, that more shafts should be sunk. I don't think if that had been done in this instance it would have been better for the men. In general it would be so. I certainly do not think from 4 to 5 miles too long a distance for the air to travel for safety. The air became very little damp in the Haswell-pit ; only that portion which comes up by an engine where there is a reservoir of water. A discharge of gas may possibly come off when the men return to work, but I have no means of judging whether it be probable or not. Do not think it desirable or necessary for the safety of the men that a stronger current of air should pass through the pit where men work with lamps. Experienced men could not have a contrary opinion, if aware of all the facts as to the situation and the quantity of air passing through. Believe every man in the colliery has full confidence in me. I think it would be more satisfactory to the living, and to the friends of the deceased, if persons chosen by themselves without reference to any pique of mine were allowed to examine every part of the pit. It is in the hands of the coroner and the jury whether they think it necessary for Mr. Matthias Dunn to examine the pit or not. I say he should, I have no objection. Will go myself with any of the pitmen who may require it, and show them anything. Will not consent that the pit shall remain in its present state till an inspector can be sent down from Government to examine it, but will put the pit into the same state it was in before the explosion took place, and it may be examined by an inspector, should the Government think that necessary. By Mr. Cleugh. — Am acquainted with the seventh headway at the Meadows-flat. There is a door in the wall between the Mothergate and the first board in the sixth pillar. The distance from that door to the nearest verge of the "goaf" is 88 yards. I am aware that candles are taken up to that door, and consider it safe to do so. It is a "fly-door" put up for the benefit of the men in the sixth, seventh and eighth headways. If it were a "fly-door," as I believe it was, there would be no wages paid to any one for keeping it, because it would be self-acting. Am not aware of any dislike by pitmen to "fly-doors" on account of any danger arising from there. Am not aware that such a complaint was one of the causes of the last strike. Am aware that in the bond sent in by the men to the masters there was a clause that there should be no "fly-doors." There was nothing but the pressure of the air between any foul air in the "goaf" and the Mothergate, beside that door. Every one in the pit knew they had not to go through that door without a candle. Would think an old man would have more sense than to go through a door than a boy placed there to prevent him. The door itself would warn a man not to go through. The door could not be left open, as it would shut itself. It is not suspended from the roof. Never had a complaint that the doors were left open by the "putters," but I have known doors left open by the "trappers" falling asleep. "Fly-doors" are better than doors having boys at them. The boys are paid 10d a-day ; but it not for the expense. I think "fly-doors" are safer. The fewer doors and the fewer boys the better. Am not aware of one of the doors having been propped open on Saturday. Am aware the deputy's chest stands between two doors. A naked candle is used there, and if the door were open there would be no stopping between the naked candle and the "goaf." If a quantity of gas were thrown off in the "goaf" it might reach the place where the candle was, if there were not a sufficient current of air to resist the gas. Believe it would not have gone out at the Meadows branch if the stoppings and crossings had not been blown down. She relieved herself by blowing down the stoppings. That gave more room for the expansion of the air. Saw a horse and waggon fastened in the "drift." There was a road past them when I got there, But, granting they had been ever so tightly stopped in that would not have prevented it reaching the Brockly-whins-flat and Meadows-way, if the stoppings had not been blown down. Have never heard of a stopper constructed with a flap and a prop, so that if the prop were blown out the flapper would come down and fill the stoppings again. Do not know that ever Mr. Buddle recommended such a stopping. My opinion is, it would be of no more use than a piece of paper. By Mr. Roberts. — Should the Government determine to appoint inspectors of mines, as of factories, I should have no objection myself, but do not consider it desirable. Know other mines, but decline to give an opinion as, foreign to this inquiry, whether the appointment of inspectors would insure greater safety to the men. In some instances it might. By Mr. Cleugh. — Have not heard of a candle being found in Williamson's "jud." By Mr. Marshall. — Am not of the opinion that the inspectors appointed by Government could have done anything to secure the safety of this mine that I have not done. Have no reason to believe there was any neglect on the part of Williamson, the deputy who was killed, to cause this explosion ; on the contrary, I believe him to have been a very careful man. There was only one lamp found without a plug in it. Oil could not be poured from one lamp to the other without two plugs being out. By Mr. Roberts. — One plug might have been replaced after the oil was poured out, and the air might have gone through the plug-hole, and so caused the explosion. By Mr. Marshall. — That is possible, but not probable. It would depend on what supply of oil was in the wick, and how long the lamp burned after the oil was poured out. Cannot say whether or not I have given positive orders that the men should not pour oil from one lamp to another. The boys hanging lamps at the trap-door are none of them below 10 years of age, but from that to 13 years. Have had occasion to discharge boys for having neglected to shut the doors. Have had sufficient experience of the Davy-lamp to give an opinion as to its safety. In my opinion it is perfectly safe, unless some damage occurs to prevent it. Have seen it used for months together, day after day, in places where there were large quantities of gas, with the lamp constantly on fire within the gauze, and very frequently the top of the gauze red hot. It was then used with perfect safety. At the conclusion of this evidence the room was cleared, and the jury, having consulted together, agreed to adjourn till Wednesday in next week. They were also of opinion that it was desirable to have the mine examined by practical men, and it was determined that the Coroner should request Mr. Nicholas Wood and Mr. George Hunter to examine the mine in the interval, and report to the jury at their next meeting. Mr. Roberts applied for Mr. Matthias Dunn to be appointed, but the jury did not consider it necessary to include him. Mr. Roberts put it to the Coroner several times, who at last gave a positive refusal. He intimated, at the same time, that Mr. Mather might, if he thought proper, accompany the gentlemen appointed by the jury. Mr. Roberts left the room. The inquest was then adjourned, and the several jurymen bound in their recognizances to attend on Wednesday next. It was understood that the pit would be left in the same state as it was after the explosion, except as to the replacing of the "stoppings," and repairing other damage. All pit work will be suspended, so that the viewers will have every opportunity that can be had of forming a judgement on the matter.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||