|
2nd October 1844 The Late Dreadful Colliery ExplosionInquest on the BodiesHaswell Colliery, Monday Night. A dreadful explosion of fire-damp took place at this place on the afternoon of Saturday last, when the lives of 95 men and boys were sacrificed. The particulars of this melancholy event (of which a brief account has already appeared) will be found fully set forth in the evidence of the witnesses examined at the inquest, given at length below, but one or two introductory particulars are necessary. Haswell Colliery is situate in the very centre of the great Durham coal-field, about seven miles from the city of Durham, and nine from Sunderland. It is the property of Messrs. Clark, Taylor, Plumer, and other wealthy coal-owners connected with the district. It is 150 fathoms deep, and the workings are in the well-known Hutton seam. The character of the mine in respect to ventilation has always stood high. During the pitmen's a few of the off-hand men were employed as hewers, and a few new men introduced; but, since the termination of the strike, none but experienced workmen have been employed under-ground, the others being employed at bank. It is unnecessary to enter into the heartrending details of individual suffering caused by this dreadful calamity. The reader must be left to his own imagination. Not a soul has been left to tell the mournful tale of how the accident occurred, the whole of the men employed in the working having been swept into eternity without a moment's warning. Four men who were at the bottom of the shaft escaped, by the fire having knocked itself out before it reached them. The inquest was held this day before Mr. T. C. Maynard and a respectable jury, when the following witnesses were examined :— Cornelius Brown, under-viewer at Shotton Colliery. — On Saturday last, with other men, I went down the pit at Haswell, having heard that an accident had happened at half-past 4 o'clock in the afternoon. Mr. Scott, another person, went down with me, and we found, about 300 yards from the shaft, that an explosion had taken place, as a number of tubs were upset, and a horse and "rolly-driver" were found dead. We proceeded a certain way, and on reaching the "Meadows," we found a boy lying dead. We went up the "Meadows" branch for about 250 yards, when we found the air so bad from choke-damp that we were compelled to return. We came down to the end of that branch, and Scott returned into it again ; and I went up the "Brockly-whins" way to within 50 yards of the station at the "sidings," where the air was so bad I could proceed no further. I was then satisfied there could be no person in the pit alive. Seeing that nothing could be done to save life, we immediately began to put in air-stoppers, and had to wait till a current of fresh air was got in. After getting the air in, we proceeded on to the Flatts station, in about three hours after, where we found 14 dead bodies, which were laid aside. We took 95 dead bodies out altogether. The explosion took place in the ninth headway course of the Meadows way. I saw that a "jud" had been drawn there by the deputy-overman. A "jud" is part of a pillar of coal, left to support the roof after the working, and is afterwards removed, and I think the removal of the "jud" had caused the explosion, as the effects of the fire were more visible there than in any other place. Three men had been working there, and were found dead. Did not find their Davy lamps. Saw nothing which indicated the cause of the explosion. The deputy, Williamson, had been in the act of taking the "jud" away, and was found within 20 yards of the place, dead. He had been at work at the jud when the explosion took place. The gas in some cases is found in considerable quantity, sometimes suddenly on the removal of the coal. That part of the mine was worked by Davy lamps. There was not a candle used there. It was not considered a dangerous pit ; but, indeed, one of the safest in the trade. I have known it from its commencement, and up to the 14th of August was in it for about three months almost daily. I have not been in the pit since that time, till after the explosion. I am of opinion the ventilation had been good up to the time of the explosion. In my opinion the explosion would not have taken place if a Davy lamp had not been injured. At the "jud" some stone had fallen from the roof, caused by its removal. The lamp might be injured by the fall of stone, and that was probably the way in which the accident occurred. This witness was cross-examined by Mr. Roberts, commonly called "the pitmen's attorney-general." He said it was not usual for a Davy lamp to be injured by a fall of stone. In some cases the fall gives notice, and the lamp can be got out of the way. Never saw such an occurrence, but have heard of one or two, and in these instances there were explosions. Between 40 and 50 dead bodies were found at no great distance from the "jud ;" the rest were in different parts of the working. Have seen explosion several times during the last 20 years, but never one so great as this. Sometimes fire and at other times choke-damp is the cause of death. There are more men killed by choke or after-damp than by combustion. The greatest distance from the "jud" to where a dead body was found was about 300 yards. The after-damp is only conveyed to certain portions of the pit. By the Coroner. — The explosions extended over the north, west, and east portions of the pit. We made two attempts to get into the pit, but the after-damp was so strong that considerable delay ensued. Out of the 95 lives that were lost, only 15 of the bodies were burnt. There was a communication between the "distance" and that part of the pit where the explosion took place. After the explosion the ventilation was interrupted by the air-stoppings having been blown down. By "air-stoppings," I mean barriers placed to throw the air into the workings for ventilation. I should think there had not been a large explosion of gas. If the stoppings had not been broken by the explosion, those on the other side of it would have been saved. The stoppings are made of brick and lime, and it is usual for an explosion to break them down. I have not been down from Sunday morning, but the pit might now be viewed with safety. Davy lamps are a sure protection when uninjured. I have seen fire in a safety-lamp, which was supported inside the gauze by foul air. The Davy is the best lamp. Another lamp, called the "Geordy lamp," with a glass, has come under my notice, but I do not think it is so safe as the Davy. Cross-examined by Mr. Marshall, solicitor, of Durham, who appeared on behalf of the owners of the colliery. — 15 were killed by fire, and the remainder by after-damp. It was possible for the mine to be safe previously to the fall of the stone at the "jud" where the explosion took place. A quantity of gas sufficient to cause an explosion might escape in a short time. An instance occurred in their pit two days before, where the gas carried away a large portion of the coal. Candles were used in the whole or solid part of the pit, but the explosion did not take place there, I am sure, as there was no indication of fire there. The safety of the Davy lamp consists in confining the flame within the gauze, and its gives an intimation of danger, when it can be removed. When there is an appearance of danger the instructions are to remove the lamp, and lamps are not then used. The gas is removed by means which are taken. Cross-examined by Mr. Toobock, surgeon, of Sunderland. I have never known an explosion take place on the removal of a lamp on the appearance of danger by the current of air forcing the flame through the gauze. It is not possible to make the stoppings close enough to resist the force of such an explosion as this. James Scott. — Is under-viewer at Haswell Colliery. About 3 o'clock on Saturday afternoon I was in the colliery-office, when one of the "off-putters" came and said he believed the pit had fired. I went as quickly as possible down the pit, and along the "North rolly-way," about 30 yards, leading into the "Little Pit." I tried the air with a candle and found it good. I then get a safety lamp, and went along further, and I found the air good all the way to the mouth of the stone-drift. At this point I found a great deficiency in the quality of air, and the current was not in the right direction. On proceeding along the stone-drift the two man-hole drifts at the end were blown down ; also the air-crossings beside them. The fresh air which ought to have gone along the main line was escaping at these two places. Along the main-way from the mouth of the stone-drift I came to a set of "rollies" with empty tubs on them. The horse at the end of the "rollies" was dead, and its driver, a boy. I proceeded on with the overman, John Miller, whom I met, about 60 yards, and came to a set of "rollies" in a siding, laden with tubs. The horse at the out-bye end of the "rollies" was dead, and also the driver. We went forward another fifty yards, and at the Meadows Way-end we found another body dead. For the want of air at that point we were obliged to return. We went back about 300 yards, where there was more air, and we considered the best thing we could do was to get bin the stoppings, to carry the air forward. From what I saw I was quite convinced that all the men in the pit when the explosion took place were dead. Left Miller there to forward these operations, and went myself to the Meadows Way-end, and persevered up to the Meadows flat, where I found two men and a horse dead. The air was again so bad I was obliged to return to the Meadows Way-end ; when I got there Mr. Brown, the first witness, came up. We stood a while, and then returned to the flat, and got about 100 yards further up than before, when we found it necessary to return to the Meadows Way-end again. We then determined to get all the air-stoppings in as soon as possible, to clear the whole pit of after-damp. Mr. Brown went with some men into the first stopping of the "Brockly-whins" flat, and I went on into the stone drift, where the other men were putting on stoppings. I then went to the Meadows flat again, and got 50 yards further than I did previously, when I was forced again to return. Went to the men at the stoppings, and an hour after with Mr. Brydon and others went into the broken Mothergate flat, and up four pillars, where 18 or 19 men were found. The remainder of my time was spent in getting out the dead bodies. The stoppings were put in, and the air was improved, so that I could not then in the second and third headway courses perceive the slightest indication of gas. In the Mothergate flat the gas was bad. Cross-examined by Mr. Roberts. — Went down the pit at 7 in the morning. The air was then good. Deputies examine the pit at different times, and when they observe danger they inform the inspector, but I do not know in this case whether any information was given. I do not think the stoppings could have been made so strong as not to have been blown down by the blast. About noon on Sunday a lamp was found about four yards from the edge of the fall of the stones at the "jud." The lamp was entire, except that it wanted the plug at the bottom where the oil was put in, which was out. The lamp was standing against a prop, and there was a little oil in it. The wick was loose in the pipe. If the explosion had been caused by the plug being out, the gas would have had to ascend the tube containing the wick, but that, though possible, is probable. The explosion must have taken place from a defective or injured lamp. Afterwards two other lamps were found by John Miller ; one was perfect, the other had the gauze much twisted, just above the lamp, having the appearance of being crushed. I think the crushing of the gauze had caused the explosion, by the flame coming through the gauze. Cross-examined by Mr. M. Jude. — Two pillars generally intervene between the "whole coal" and the working. The men in the "whole coal" work with candles, and never object to doing so. They have often complained of too much air, though the greater quantity of air the greater the safety. There was no "whole coal" being worked at the "jud," and therefore there were no candles there, but lamps, as they always use lamps in the broken. The nearest candle would be 996 yards distant from the "jud." I never in my experience knew the current of air, in moving a lamp from one place to another, to force the flame through the gauze. Have seen dams put in, and do not think if they had been put in they would have stopped the explosion. Was never asked by the men to put dams in. Did not consider it necessary to have the stoppings stronger than they were. It is not allowed to remove the oil from one lamp to another. The men are not allowed to do anything to the lamps except in the presence of an officer at the proper place. By pouring the oil from one lamp to another, the flame would be forced to an angle on the gauze, and might come through. Know no reason why the plug was not in the lamp. Dams can be made stronger than the ordinary stoppings. Neither the master, mason, nor the wastemen, were there at the time of the explosion. The choke-damp was about three hours and a half in the pit after the accident happened. Did not think there had been a large accumulation of gas. A similar accident might happen, and knock the stopping down. If the stoppings had not been knocked down, the after-damp might still have got the men. Cross-examined by Mr. Marshall. — Dams are only used in collieries to confine the water. If a "Geordy lamp" had been used, I think it would not have resisted the force this lamp is proved to have received. There is a glass tube within the gauze of the Geordy lamp, and none in the common Davy lamp. The injury to the Davy lamp might have happened after the accident. If the Geordy lamp had been injured by the breaking of the glass, it would still have been equal to a Davy in safety, but the breaking of the glass would have cut the gauze. I think the stone fell when the "jud" was removed. I travel the waste once a week or fortnight, and never knew any accumulation of gas in the waste, and no complaint was ever made to me. The master wasteman reports daily the state of the waste and nature of the works. Cross-examined by Mr. Roberts. — I am sure the stone fell before the explosion, because the props, about 14 in number, had been withdrawn, and placed on a tram. The fall was 6 yards by 3 yards. In this pit there are two shafts, the air going down one and up the other ; the air travels about a mile and a half, and 40,000 cubic feet pass a minute. Joseph Fairless, inspector of Haswell Pit. — As soon as I heard of the accident I went down the pit ; it was a little after 7 o'clock on Saturday evening. I examined every part of the mine between that time and Sunday morning, particularly that part where the dead bodies were found. From the examination I made I think the accident happened in the ninth headway, in the Meadows flat. The deputy had been drawing a "jud" there. I know that, because his axe was standing close by where the stone had fallen, at the place the props were taken away. Some of the props were lying on the "horned" tram, which was standing about 6 or 8 yards from where the stone had fallen. I found three bodies there. They appeared to be burnt, but I cannot say whether they died from the burns or the after-damp. There were no indications in any other part of the mine of an explosion having taken place. Found nothing there but the bodies. I am of opinion the stone had fallen before the explosion took place. My reason for thinking so is that the props had been taken out, and the men were away from it a little. I have been inspector of that pit about two years and four months, and during that time it was considered a safe pit. If the men thought there was any danger, it was their duty to report it to me ; they had orders from the masters to do so. Never received any notice during the time I have been there of there being danger. Never knew of an accumulation of gas in the waste. I had inspected the pit between 2 and 3 o'clock in the morning of Saturday, before the men went to work. I never saw her in better trim than she was in at that time. The current of fresh air was strong ; there was no indication of gas. I considered it then to be perfectly safe. We consider it safe to work the "whole coal" with candle, but the "broken" is worked with Davy lamps, as a precaution against danger from gas coming off by accident. Cross-examined by Mr. Roberts. — It is not prudent to work the "broken" with candles, and I do not know of any of the men having done so. Do not work the waste with candle. It is always dangerous to draw a "jud," but sometimes the danger is greater than at other times. Cannot say whether the accident arose from a small or large quantity of gas. Cannot form an opinion from the choke-damp, or the ground it extended over. Cannot say whether or not there was an accumulation of gas where the accident occurred. On the 21st, and on the 28th of the month, I examined the place very closely, but could discover no accumulation of gas. There is no connexion between the waste and the place where candles are used. There are no "whole boards" going at the Meadows flat. The Meadows flat is about 150 yards from the "waste" going through the groove. There is a distinct return drift, independent of the groove. The size of the drift is 6 feet by 5½. Cross-examined by Mr. Jude. — The lamp found by Mr. Scott was without a plug. I was present when it was found; it was near the "jud." I cannot account for the plug being wanting. It was about 300 or 400 yards from the place where the accident is supposed to have occurred to the nearest naked light. I am appointed inspector of the mine by the masters ; it is not usual for the men to have inspectors on their part. I think from the appearance it was impossible the fall could have been caused by the explosion. The timber had been taken out. There was timber knocked out in other parts of the mine. That was caused by the explosion, and at some of those places the stone had fallen. The timber where the explosion took place was drawn and laid on the "horned tram," which must have been done by the men before the explosion. I examined the mine every day. There were two other lamps found, but I was not present. Cross-examined by Mr. Marshall. — The danger of drawing a "jud" arises not from gas, but the falling of the roof. I arrived at bank between 8 and 9 o'clock on Saturday morning. Cross-examined by Mr. Cleugh, a pitman from Thornley. — If the pit had been working seven years in the "whole coal," and four in the "broken," which being dried was there not danger to be expected, on the drawing of a "jud," that a quantity of gas would come sufficient to destroy all the men in the pit ? — No. Did you ever know gas come from drawing a "jud" before ? — No. Was it your opinion any considerable quantity of gas would probably have come from drawing a "jud?" — No. Was there any probability of the gas coming from any other point to cause the explosion ? — No, and I think the gas in this instance came from the fall. The air current runs at 18 miles an hour. The current is split six times in the "whole" between its entering the workings and coming out of them. Splitting the air increases its efficiency, in my opinion, for the purposes of ventilation. The in-letting course could not be less than 50 square feet, in the least part, but I have not measured it. I have never seen so large airways in any other colliery. The in-letting course is at the bottom of the shaft. There are no pumps in the down-cast shaft. I am not prepared to say what space is left in the shaft for the air to pass down, but there is quite sufficient, in my opinion, for the ventilation of the mine. In examining the pit to see whether the air is good or bad, I ascertain that fact by using a candle. When the foul air is present there is a blue tinge at the flame, which tapers up to a point. Never saw candles that would exhibit that appearance when there was no gas. Have seen a difference in candles ; but never saw one show a blue tinge without gas ; it was a gray tinge ; and it arises from the grease of the candles. If the air be mixed with stithe the candle will carry a large flame, but no blue tint. There is no danger of an explosion when the blue tint is absent. When the gray tint approaches to a white one there is no danger of an explosion. There was no blue appearance in the candle when I went round the pit on the morning before the explosion took place ; the candle presented an ordinary appearance, and gave not the least indication of gas being present. I have tried "the broken" with a lamp, after a fall had taken place, on previous occasions, but never observed any appearance of gas. John Miller, one of the overmen at Haswell Colliery, examined. — I have charge of the whole of the "Little Pit" where the accident occurred. I went down immediately after the explosion took place, and I have since examined every part of the pit minutely. I am of the opinion the explosion took place in the nine head-ways on the Meadows flat, where the "jud" was taken down. The "jud" had been drawn, and I think a "blower" had come off, or an accident might have happened to the lamp. I produced a Davy lamp much crushed, which had been found by David Wardle ; it was lying with a piece of timber over it, and there was some stone on the timber. My opinion is, the stone had fallen before the explosion took place, as part of the timber had been taken out and piled on the "horned tram." I think the taking away of the timber had caused the stone to fall, and foul air had come away, which might have come in contact with a lamp previously injured by the fall. Three lamps were found there all damaged. The oil plug was out of one of them. If the lamp had a small wick I think it possible the gas would go through the plug-hole, and so communicate with the flame, especially if the lamp was lying on the slant, as I found it. Did not examine the wick. If the gauze of the lamp were perfect, I think the blow which crushed it would not force the flame through, so as to ignite the gas outside, notwithstanding the injury it received. There is no indication in any other part of the mine to show where the explosion took place. I have been overman of the pit turned nine years. Never considered there had previously been any danger from the accumulation of gas. Never had any complaints from the men concerning the gas. Was twice through the pit on Saturday, and examined it carefully. The last time I was down I went a little after 5 o'clock in the morning, and came out before 7. There was no appearance of danger then. Cross-examined by Mr. Roberts. — 15 of the men had safety-lamps in that district at the time of the explosion. I cannot say whether they have all been found or not. I found six of them myself. They were all perfect except the one I produce broken, and the other wanting the oil-plug. The remainder are down the pit, and may be produced. I cannot identify the lamps I found, except the two I have produced. I examined the others I found, and am sure none of them were defective. All the men in the workings were killed, but three men and a boy, named William Hindmarch, William Raine, William Harrison, and John Thompson, who were at the bottom of the shaft, escaped. The pit is not at work now, but I am not prepared to say whether or not it would be an inconvenience to the owners to have the pit examined. Cross-examined by Mr. Cleugh. — Cannot say whether or not the lamp found crushed had been hanging on the prop before the fall. Williamson was much burnt in one of his arms. Never travelled the waste, so that I cannot say whether there is any accumulation of gas in it or not. Mr. Marshall declined putting any questions to this witness. Cross-examined by the Coroner. — There is no communication between the part of the pit where the candles are used and the "jud." The broken might be safely worked with candle, but, to be more safe, the Davy lamp is used. I always considered the pit to be a safe one. Never observed gas blow off when falls have taken place in this pit on previous occasions, but have seen it come off at other places, and judge that it may have been so here on this occasion. There is no doubt that gas is thrown off when falls occur in the Haswell pit, but where we stand we have not an opportunity of seeing it, for it is carried away by the current without coming near us. Mr. Roberts, addressing the Coroner, urged upon him and the jury the necessity of examining the mine by some disinterested party, who should report on the matter to the jury ; and also that the remainder of the lamps should be produced. The Coroner said, the owners had no objection to produce the lamps ; and, as to the examination of the mine, he thought the owners, on a proper representation being made to them, would allow it to be made. Mr. Roberts said, he wished Mr. Jude, Mr. Mather, and some of the workmen should examine the mine. The Coroner said, if any examination was made, it should be by some competent party, neither connected with the masters on the one hand, nor the workmen on the other. Mr. Marshall said, on behalf of the owners, that they had no objection to proper professional men being appointed to examine the mine, but he considered the persons named were biased against the owners, which was a similar course to that taken by Mr. Roberts respecting the witnesses already examined. Mr. Roberts proposed Mr. Mathias Dunn, a practical viewer, to assist Mr. Mather, who he considered was an indifferent person. Mr. Marshall said, he thought they could not fix upon the persons to examine the mine to-night. To-morrow the workmen employed in the colliery would be examined, and then the jury might decide whether an examination was or was not necessary. He objected to both the parties named. Mr. Roberts considered he had a right to bring forward any gentleman as a witness, and he would ask that he be allowed to examine the pit. The Coroner said, if a party was possessed of information he could summon him to attend and give evidence, but if he had no information on the subject he had not power to compel his attendance or to cause the owners of the colliery to allow him to examine the mine. Mr. Roberts. — Then, Sir, on behalf of the relatives and friends of the sufferers, I apply now to the owners of the colliery to allow Mr. Mathias Dunn, Mr. James Mather, Mr. Martin Jude, and some of the workmen employed in the pit, to examine the mine, with the view of giving evidence at this inquest. Mr. Marshall, for the owners, replied, — We have a personal objection to Mr. Dunn, and Mr. Mather is not a practical man. The owners have no objection to the pit being viewed by two persons, one being chosen by the owners, and the other on behalf of the men ; and in that case the owners have no objection to Mr. Mather accompanying them, attended by three or four workmen employed in the colliery. Mr. Roberts said he proposed Mr. Dunn, and he knew of no other viewer in whom the pitmen had confidence. In case he refused, he applied to the coroner to adjourn the inquest for time to allow an application to be made to the Secretary of State upon the subject, which he pledged himself to make. After some warm expressions of disapprobation from Mr. Roberts, Mr. Marshall intimated to the coroner that the men upon the colliery had applied to Mr. Heckles to attend and examine the mine on behalf of the workmen. Mr. Heckles said he had been applied to by Mr. Cleugh on behalf of the men. A voice — "Mr. Cleugh does not work at the colliery." The coroner then ordered the Court to be cleared ; which being done, the Court was adjourned till 10 o'clock to-morrow morning.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||