|
Whitehaven HeraldArticle from the Whitehaven Herald, 13th January 1844 Distressing Coal Pit AccidentTwo Lives LostA melancholy accident occurred at Croft Pit, the property of Lord Lonsdale, on Thursday night last, by which two young men were killed. At six o'clock ten young men entered the basket by which they are let down the shaft by an engine. Three of them, John McGuire, Christopher Kitchen, aged 16, and Daniel Lennon aged 21 stood up, on the side of the basket; the rest were inside. The signal having been given, the basket was lowered and when it had descended about 30 feet, by a sudden jerk of the rope, which is described below, in the evidence before the coroner, Lennon and Kitchen lost their hold, and were precipitated to the bottom of the pit and almost literally dashed to atoms. McGuire and the rest of the men retained their hold and lowered to the bottom of the pit without sustaining any injury. Mr. Lumb, the coroner, summoned a jury at three o'clock on the following day, at the Dog Inn, Preston Street. Having been sworn in the usual way they proceeded to the New Town to view the unfortunate men, after which they returned to the inn and — The coroner opened the inquiry by remarking that complaints had reached him respecting the exclusion of colliers from the jury. He must say he totally disagreed from those who thought the object of the enquiry would be further by summoning them on the inquest. If he had taken that course an application might have been made by the agent of Lord Lonsdale, to be included also; but as he did not see that any good object could be answered by it, he had determined to exclude them, and to collect a jury from amongst the townsmen of Whitehaven, whose intelligence rendered them fully competent to enter into the investigation and do justice to all parties. It was his wish, however, that every person should be brought forward as a witness who could throw the least light upon the circumstances attending the melancholy accident which had brought them together. John McGuire was then sworn. He said — I live in Back Row, New Houses. I have been a collier for thirteen years, and was working at Croft Pit yesterday. I have been working for there seven weeks. I knew Christopher Kitchen and Daniel Lennon; they were young lads employed in driving. I went with them to the pit on Tuesday night. Lennon went with me from my own house, and we met Kitchen waiting at the top of the pit to go down. We got there at the usual time, six o'clock. We got into the basket; there were ten of us. Ten is a large number; I never saw more than seven or eight before; I never descended with ten before Friday night. Four lads sat down in the bottom of the basket; three stood up, and I with Lennon and Kitchen stood up on the edge of the basket. We began to ride down, and I told them to "grip hold" when I found we were going faster than common. We were all right in the basket when we started; the banksman told the engine man to lower and he did; and we had just lost sight of him when we began to descend faster; we had lights with us, but the wind put them out. When we had been let down about ten yards the basket stopped and then give a sudden jerk up the pit. I lost my feet, but I kept my hold and they afterwards beat on the basket again as we were going down. I asked for Lennon, and someone asked for Kitchen, but they did not speak; all the rest answered; but we did not see they were not on the basket till we stopped at the bottom of the pit. Neil Henderson came down to us before any one came up. We found the bodies, but I did not look at them. We were all pulled up afterwards, one at a time, by hand. I never had any occasion to complain of the engine man; he is steady, and fit for his work. I should have no fear to go down again. I have told you all I know about the accident. By the Foreman — I did not know whether all the slack of the rope was taken up before I entered the basket. By the Juror — When I asked for Lennon I thought the rope had broken and had made us go quicker. I think Lennon fell in consequence of the jerk. By the Coroner — It appeared at the time as if neither the engine or the rope had any control over the basket. All who were in it were saved. I have heard the deceased men cautioned by the banksman not to ride on the edge of the basket. They had done it before. I have done it often myself. We put little lads in the basket for safety. We did not go down the pit afterwards. Edward Henderson — I live at the top of Croft Pit, and am an engine attender. I do nothing else. My son who was 19 years old, assists me. He has been with me ever since he was fit to handle an engine — about four years. I had charge of the engine last night. My son and I relieve each other. The engine was in his care at the time of accident. One man is sufficient to manage it. I did not see the men come to the pit top, nor go down. I saw nothing about it till the banker shouted out. The engine is in very fair condition for her work. I heard the last witness's evidence. I never knew an accident happen in the same way before. My son is not here. I was standing beside him when the accident occurred. He had hold of the handles. You must always have hold of them when the engine is riding. The engine was started just as I entered. She had lowered about 15 feet when the rope jerked. We can tell in the engine-house by the stroke how far the basket has descended. A surge came on the rope; it slipped down the pit from the rope barrel, and gave a shake more than common. The rope is guarded between two arms and a rim on each side. The rope was running through this when it slipped over the edge of the wheel and dropped down upon the main axletree. The axletree would be between six and eight feet between the rim, over which the rope fell. The engine had no control over the rope until it got right again. I don't know how it had slipped; I have known it to fly out, but never when any persons were riding. We take more care when men are in the basket than coals. We get a sign from the bottom to know what the baskets are laden with. We see the rope always as it goes round; we can see it setting. All was right yesterday. It is a flat one we use. By a juror — Is the wheel perfect? Witness — yes; the guards were just as usual. The wind had effect on the rope last night. It was very stormy, and wind always causes it to move from side to side. Croft pit is much exposed. When the rope comes up with an empty basket it lies lighter on the barrel, and the coils do not lie so close. An empty basket had come up to take these men down. The ten men might as easily have been killed as the two. I don't know how anything done on our part could have prevented the accident. By the Coroner — I should have cautioned your son if he had been here, before hearing this evidence, because he had charge of the engine. You having been present, are a competent witness and there is not the necessity for it, but if he had been here I should have cautioned him so that he might have answered any questions or not. McGuire have you any charge to make or questions to make or questions to ask? McGuire — No sir. E. Henderson re-examined — I was let down the pit when the engine stopped. The men asked if they could get up safe. I said if they would hold their tongues they would all get up safe. After I got them all up one by one I went down to get the bodies of Lennon and Kitchen who were missing. Four or five men were working but did not know what had happened. The deceased men were lying beside each other, both in the same direction. Kitchen's arms were by his side and his head, which was knocked off, was a little below his feet. I picked it up. There was a great deal of blood. We put him into a sack and got him up. Some of his bones were broken. He seemed to be badly mashed up. He had fallen about 230 or 240 yards. The pit is 250 yards deep. Lennon was lying on his back. I and some others went to lift him, but he was knocked to pieces and in such a state that we could not lift him altogether. I have seen different barrels from those who used at Croft Pit. They are made according to the depth of the pit. When all the rope is round, it would be two inches from the top of the rim. I have seen more, and think it safer to have more. I would say Mr. Jackson and Mr. Peile were very careful in preventing accidents. I am as careful in letting colliers down the pit, as in letting down strangers. A collier named Joseph Fee put the following question through the coroner: — "Is this rope barrel sufficient for the men riding up and down the pit?" Witness — The men never objected it. I would have no hesitation in riding down with it if the engineman was careful in lowering. It is not as safe a barrel as some are. Croft Pit barrel is not made on the improved plan. It has been up for 19 years, and has been repaired a few times. At the suggestion of Joseph Fee, the coroner asked if any accident happened to the barrel on Monday night? Witness — The rope barrel gave way on Monday night and the men could not go down. The arms, which guarded the rope, were broken. They were repaired that night. They had been broken before. The Coroner (to Fee) — Are you one of the men who wanted to be on the jury? Witness — No, I am not; but the men say the rope barrel is not sufficient to ride. Coroner — Now I will swear you, for what you have said is no evidence unless it is given upon oath. Joseph Fee — I have told you all I know. The witness said it did not act the same way before; now it did on Monday night, and I was prevented going to my work. The Coroner — Now, answer this man, Henderson; do you consider this barrel safe? Witness — I should, if the person was to qualify to manage the engine, but not otherwise. No two engines work so exactly alike. The stroke is too long for the beam and causes a jerk in consequence; but the jerking is not so much felt by working the engine steadily. The rope might have slipped over the edge with the best engine. The Coroner (to Fee) — Now I shall swear you. Fee again objected. The Coroner — I wish to be gentle, but if you do persist in refusing I shall commit you to Carlisle Gaol. Do you mean to be sworn? Fee — What Concerning? The Coroner — The death of these men. Fee — I can't tell you any more. I know nothing about machinery. Coroner — Were you one of the Union Men Fee — Yes I was. The Coroner — Now, I shall be obliged to you if you will be sworn, and it will prevent you and me quarrelling. Fee then, after some little hesitation, consented, and was sworn. He said, I have been accustomed to ride up and down Croft Pit since 1818. I have no ground of complaint with it. I don't know the barrel used. I never examined it. I never complained to any body that is was not safe. My reason for asking the engineman if it was, to day, is that there is a rumour among the men that it is not. McAllister is one of the men; he wanted to be on the jury. The barrel was broken on Monday and we were prevented from going down to our work. I had gone down to the pit yesterday. By a juror — I would ride down by the same barrel. I came up it last night after the accident happened. Another collier, named Isaac Robinson was here called at the suggestion of Fee, but refused to be sworn. The Coroner — Have you any scrupulous objection to taking an oath? Robinson — No The Coroner — Then you must be sworn. Robinson hesitated for several minutes. A Juryman — Are you afraid of loosing your employment if you take an oath? Robinson — No, but everyman knows that barrel is not good and a new one has been wanted three years. The Coroner — Now I will swear you. Robinson reluctantly took the book and was sworn. He said — I live at Sandwith. I have worked as a hagger for nine years, and ridden up and down generally every day. I never complained of the state of the barrel. Those about the engineman have been complaining. There is no more danger now, when, a thing of this sort happens it is the time when it gets mended. The men have been objecting to the barrel two or three times. It's a bad concern. On Monday night four of us were ready to get in the basket and it broke. I think it is too bad to get repaired. I never examined it, but I know men who have. Hetherington knows it is not safe. The ropes and chains are good or else there would have been a deal more mischief. The jury have a right to see the barrel; they can't judge of it without. Mr. Lumb — Were you a Union Man? Witness — Ay; but I'm nee waur of that. Coroner — Certainly not. Witness — I consider this quite an accident, and might have happened with the best of barrels and engines whatever. The Foreman — I think Mr. Henderson should not have been shown so much hesitation in answering questions put to him. The Coroner (to Henderson) — Were you present on Monday night when the barrel went wrong? Witness — No I was in bed, but was called up. One of the arms was broken. The Coroner — Do you think this is a completely unfit barrel? Witness — No, I would not. The men never complained to me about it. The Coroner — Could an improvement be made upon it? Witness — Certainly. If the barrel was a little larger it would be better. The barrel has contained the rope for 19 years, and there was never an accident before. I would not say it was safe or that it was unsafe. We go by the engineer's orders. When he thinks it is sufficient to work we have nothing to say. Mr. Peile and Mr. Jackson have both gone down with the same barrel. Robinson re-examined — A new barrel is wanted. The Coroner (to Henderson) — Do you think this barrel is unsafe. Henderson — I won't say it's unsafe, or I won't condemn it. The Coroner — I don't understand this. It is not using either me or the jury fairly. Who is the engineer? Henderson — Samuel Shepherd. William Graham was then sworn — I am a pitman in Croft Pit. I have three years in it, and have been in the habit of riding up and down. The barrel was broken sometime last spring, and it has never been considered sufficient since. It has been mended till it can be mended no more. I don't think it safe. As to blame to either engineman or overman, I think there is none at all. I would go down by the same barrel to-morrow. Repairs have always been attended to. I have no hesitation in saying everything is done for the safety of the men. If the men had not been on the basket edge they would not have been killed. I have not doubt the surge caused them to lose their hold. I think ten is too many to go down. We consider four men a fair basketful. If the rope had been bad last night there is no doubt all would have been killed. Henry Burns — I am a banksman at Croft Pit. I put the men and the boys in the basket. I would have no hesitation in descending the pit myself. I have ridden down the shaft with this barrel. I never heard the men complain of it. I told Kitchen when he got on he was not safe there, but he would not get off. A collier named Rudd was next sworn, but his evidence was immaterial. The Foreman, in answer to a question from the Coroner, said he did not consider it necessary for the enquiry that Shepherd, the engineer, should be called. The Coroner then summed up the evidence. The question, which the jury would have to consider, would be, whether the rope accidentally came off the barrel, or came off in consequence of the barrel not being a proper state for the purpose to which it is applied. He should have liked that Henderson had given his evidence in a more straightforward manner; but they had it from the men themselves who had insinuated the insufficiency of the barrel, that the rope might have slipped off the wheel with any barrel. It would be for them to consider what weight to attach to the testimony they had heard, and to decide accordingly. If they thought it was not sufficient to enable them to come to a proper conclusion, he would adjourn the court that further evidence might, if possible, be procured. The Jury after a few minuets consultation returned a verdict of " Accidental Death", in both cases. The Coroner — Do you impose any deodand? The Foreman — No sir; we do not consider it necessary. We have had nothing before us to warrant us in concluding that there was any neglect on part of the engineman or banksman. The enquiry lasted about three hours.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||