|
24th October 1843 Cumberland Quarter SessionsThe General Quarter Sessions of the Peace for this county commenced in the Court House at Cockermouth this day week, before E. W. Hasell, Esq., Chairman, and the following Bench of Magistrates:- T. Irwin, Esq., Calder Abbey; John Watson, Esq., Fitz; Isaac Shaw, Esq., Bootle; W. L. Dickinson, Esq., Workington; Rev. E. Fawcett, Cockermouth; T. A. Hoskins, Esq., The High; Joseph Harris, Esq., Greysouthen; Rev. H. Curwen, Workington; E. S. Curwen, Esq., Workington; Wm. Wybergh, Esq., Isell Hall; W. P. Johnson, Esq., Walton House; J. S. Fisher, Esq., Woodhall; Joseph Pocklington Senhouse, Esq., Nether Hall; Rev. H. Lowther, Distington; G. W. Hartley, Esq., Rose Hall; Rev. A. Scott, Bootle; Rev. John Heysham, Sebergham Hall; Wm. Browne, Esq., Tallentire Hall; Joseph Gilibanke, Esq., Whitefield House; H. D. Maclean, Esq., Carlisle; R. Brisco, Esq., Low Mill House; T. Spedding, Esq., Mirehouse; R. Jefferson, Esq., Springfield; H. Howard, Esq., Greystoke Castle; T. Hartley, Esq., Gillfoot; George Harrison, Esq., Linethwaite; T. H. Graham, Esq., Edmond Castle; W. N. Hodgson, Esq., Carlisle; the Hon. J. H. R. Curson, Derwent Lodge, Keswick; James Stanger, Esq., Dove Cote, Keswick; J. Rartion, Esq., Snittlegarth; F. L. B. Dykes, Esq., Dovenby Hall. W. N. Hodgson, Esq., of Carlisle, took the oaths and qualified as a Magistrate for the county. GRAND JURY Jonathan Wood, of Cockermouth, Foreman; Thomas Barnes, Newton, Abbey Holme; William Bowman, Workington; Joseph Brown, Cockermouth; Ralph Clay, Workington; John Curry, Crosscanonby; Joseph Grave, Cockermouth; John Hewitson, Maryport; John Hodgson, Plumbland; Thomas Jackson, Seaton; Joseph Sanderson, Cockermouth; Joseph Sealby, Maryport; John Senhouse, Papcastle; Daniel Sim, Braithwaite; Wm. Smith, Hensingham; Richard Smith, Cockermouth; Joseph Twentyman, Fitz, Plumbland; John Watson, Mosser; and Thomas Westray, Workington. The Counsel Present were Messrs. Fawcett, Greig, Ramshay, Dykes, Lawrie, Hoskins, and Bell. The usual proclamation against vices and immorality was read; and the Chairman addressed the Grand Jury at some length. In former sessions there had sometimes been as many as 30 prisoners to try, but on the present occasion there were only 13 cases, and none of them likely to present any difficulty to the Jury. PRISONERS. TRIAL OF THE WHITEHAVEN COLLIERS Daniel Garraty, aged 28, and James Doran, aged 24, were charged with violently assaulting and beating Thomas Garraway and David Garraway of Whitehaven, in September last. The solicitors in the case were, for the prosecution Mr. Lumb, for the defence Mr. Roberts, of Newcastle-on-Tyne, the gentleman employed by the Colliers Union. Mr. Ramshay stated the case to the Jury, as it afterwards appeared in evidence. The riot and assault had arisen out of disturbances caused by a strike for wages. The colliers of the town and neighbourhood appeared to have come to a determination not to work for less than a certain amount of wages, and had combined to prevent others working for a less sum than they had fixed upon. He thought it was absolutely necessary that the workingman should be protected in his labour. Every man, in his opinion, ought to be fully at liberty to work on such terms as were satisfactory to himself; at the same time, no one ought to be permitted to say, because I cannot make certain terms, no one else shall work for other wages than those which satisfy me. Wm. Graham — I live in Breeches street, Whitehaven. I am a miner, and keep a public-house. The Union Jack inn. I know the prisoners at the bar. In the early part of September, Garraty came to me in the Market Place, and told me they had a meeting. I asked what it was about; and he said it was to see what was to be done about those men who were at work. He said there were only nine men at the meeting. I said there were twenty-five at work, and nine men were of lile (little) or no use against twenty-five. He said "not much." This was before the assault. By Mr. Greig — I was told to come here by Mr. Lumb. He sent for me about a week ago. I was not told that if I did not come it would be worse for me. No threat was made. I have known Garraway thirty years. He has always been a good character; and never was in trouble for misconduct. Thomas Garraway — I am a miner at Whitehaven. The prisoners are miners also, and I know them particularly well. I was at one time a member of the Miner's Association. The paper produced is a copy of the Rules of the Association. I was not above three or four days a member. I had been a week and three days at work before the attack, and had ceased to be a member during that time. I heard that there were 314 members. I was at two meetings. One of the speakers was Mr. Brophy. He was running down our master (Mr. Peile) very much — calling him a bad man, and the like; and blaming him for not giving his men sufficient wages. Garraty was present at these meetings. I did not see the other. I have not heard them threaten any. I never heard him threaten any one. I can't say I heard him say anything about men working at low wages. He was at both meetings. A copy of the Rules was given to all the members. On the 13th September I had been at work. About 300 men were then off work. We have not regular hours for work; each man leaves when he has done his work. I went into the pit between three and four o'clock, and left about half-past ten. It happened I came away earlier that day than common. I have often been finished with my work in that time. I left work at the Wellington Pit, and got as far as a little Lane, called the Dirty Lane, where I saw the two prisoners, and George Cowan who was standing in the lane. My son was with me, and we pushed on when we saw these men. We went towards the foundry, and looked towards the Castle Row, and saw men running in sixes or sevens together, and they came on until near Preston Street. They came down the steps into a dark entry. We went up Preston Street, which was our shortest way. We had got a little past the warehouse end, when I saw Garraty peeping by; and we ran on. After running a little piece, I looked back and saw a mob following and likely to overtake us. They came from behind the warehouse, where Garraty had been peeping. I said we may as well stop, and we did so, and the mob came within a few feet of us. There were about a score of persons; both the prisoners were amongst them. I had worked side by side with Garraty for a long time. I knew Doran very well. The mob threw a volley of stones at me and my son, and then rushed upon us with sticks and other weapons. They used me very ill. I received three or four cuts on the head — my lip was cut through, and I was badly used on my left side, and my arm bruised with sticks. As many as could get to were at me. Both prisoners struck me. I was almost knocked stupid. I got a great many blows. My son got away. I said to Garraty I'll make thee suffer for this, I know thee. The mob than left me, in a sort of sheepish, cowering way. Garraty struck at me oftener than once with a stick. I saw Doran strike at my son; I cannot say he struck me. By Mr. Greig — The union was for an advance of wages. It had existed about three weeks before my ill usage. The union was formed after Brophy came. Mr. Peile had required the men to sign a pledge — it was a paper. Every man that worked was required to sign the pledge. If they refused to sign they got no more work. I signed that paper. Plenty of the members of the union have signed the paper. I had left the union before I signed the paper. My son was kept off work till he signed the paper. It was a clear moonlight night, when I was assaulted; near eleven o'clock. We went up by the Fish Market and the back streets to avoid the men. The foundry is in New Town, and Preston Street is a continuation of New Town. I am certain the prisoners were amongst the three men whom I first saw. I have always told the same story, and said the prisoners were amongst the three men whom we first saw. I and my son went very quick up Dirty Lane. From the point where I first saw the prisoners to the end of the warehouse where I saw them again, the distance is about 300 yards. Banners were carried by the unionmen in the mornings. I don't know what was upon them. I did not see that the words were that the men did not turn out for higher wages but to be relieved from the test. I never was in prison, nor held to bail. I left the union because I thought I would be better at work. I was not told by any one to say the prisoners were present at the assault — I saw them myself. By Mr. Ramshay — I went the back way to avoid men who were understood to be out at nights dangerous to the men at work. David Garraway — I am the son of the last witness, and was at one time a member of the Union, and have attended some of its meetings; I can't say I have seen Doran there. I left the Union. Doran was at that time out of work. At one of the meetings, I heard Brophy say Mr. Peile was a robber and murderer — I heard nothing particular. The witness then described the assault on the 13th September, upon his father and himself — fully corroborating his father's account of the affair. He added — a brickbat hit me on the forehead. I received a bat on the neck from James Doran. I saw Garraty strike my father. It was a moonlight night, nearly as light as day; and I knew the men well. By Mr. Greig — Brophy called Mr. Peile a robber and a murderer on account of the wages. He said the men had not the money wrought for. He also said that they (the miners) signed a similar paper about twelve years ago, and had been more miserable since than ever they were before. Brophy said the paper was to prevent men working for Lord Lonsdale, who belonged to the union. I was told that I would not be allowed to return to work till I signed the paper. I did sign it. Isaac Mossop — I am a surgeon in Whitehaven, and was called in to see Garraway on the 13th September. His face was streaming with blood, and his head was a complete mass of blood. I discovered three contused wounds on the left side of the head. They must have been caused by very heavy blows. The wounds were distinct. On the external angle of the left eye there was a wound 2½ inches in length; and must have been done by a heavy blow. The under lip was cut through to the teeth. There was a severe bruise on the left arm. All the wounds had been inflicted by sticks or stones. I attended him three weeks. During that time he was not able to work. By Mr. Greig — I have seen process one with placards going about the streets; but did not see what was upon them. Elizabeth Thompson — I live at the Ginns, Whitehaven. On the night of the 13th September last, I was out at my work and about 11 o'clock at night, as we were coming up Preston street with our cart, we saw a number of men on the street. They were striking one another, and knocking them against the wall, as we thought. I heard a shouting of "murder, murder, watch." I then saw David Garraway run past shouting "murder, murder," and "watch." He was running from the crowd. Thomas Garraway came up to us; we held the lanterns to his face, and saw it was streaming with blood. He was clapping his hands, and crying, "Oh, dear, they have killed me." He then called for the watch; but there were none. The crowd was making a great noise. By Mr. Greig — We knew the union was on; but nothing more. I saw no placards upon the walls. The rules of the union were then put in and read. Mr. Greig, in reply, said that no similar case had ever been presented to a Jury; all strikes hitherto had been the attempt of the men to obtain certain objects, but in this they were turned out because they would not do what was against the law of the land. They had a right by statute law to unite for raising the rate of wages, and that law had been admitted by all the judges during the late Special Commission. Labour is a marketable article, and may be kept up by combinations, and these men were deprived of work merely because they refused to give up the right, which the law allowed them. That was the fact of the case, and it was without a parallel. It was the basis of all the difficulties that had recently taken place. The prisoners were prepared to admit they did combine for the purpose of raising their wages, and they were deprived of their work in consequence. The witnesses had been also members of the union, but they deserted their confederates, and gained work — what they lost in credit they gained in pocket. The learned counsel referred to the rules of the union to prove that the object was legitimate, and then contended that the evidence of the identity of the prisoners was insufficient, as it was doubtful if the light of the moon was such as to admit of their being recognised. He also stated that the time when the assault took place was not the time when the prosecutor might have been expected to leave the pit in which he was at work. He noticed also the difference between the statement of Garraway the father and his son, as to the number of men they saw at the end of Dirty Lane; and then eulogised in glowing terms the character of the Earl of Lonsdale, and his conduct in his high and responsible position as the largest land-owner in the county. His lordship was, however, too ill and infirm to visit his estates now as he used to do, and had to entrust them to the management of a minister, who, like her Majesty's rejoiced in the name of Foyle. He it was who had, by insisting when the workmen giving up their right; which they were determined to do, brought about all these disturbances. He concluded by an appeal to the Jury to prevent the workmen from such conduct. The Chairman said that it was an admitted point of law, that the workmen were entitled to meet and combine for the purpose of raising their wages; but then it was perfectly clear, that they had no right to attempt to accomplish their object by intimidating other workmen. Some remark had been made in reference to the coal agent of the Earl of Lonsdale, as if he had done wrong in objecting to employ men who had formed this union; but if the workmen had a right to make their bargain, it was but just that the master should make his bargain also; and it appeared to him that the condition made by Mr. Peile, that no one in his employ should belong to this union, was legitimate and just. Having said so much upon what he considered the law in this particular, the learned chairman carefully went over the evidence, commenting upon its leading points, which appeared to him to bear out the charge of a riotous assault. He then commented upon the proof of the identity of the prisoners; and after reading over the evidence at great length he left the matter to the Jury. The Jury returned a verdict of Guilty of riot and assault. Mr. Ramshay said he wished it to be clearly understood that this indictment was preferred by direction of the magistrates before whom the complaint was heard. Mr. Greig then said he had to move in arrest of judgment. By a recent act, the Court of Quarter Sessions had not power to try cases of conspiracy. The Chairman said, the prisoners were not tried upon the count for the conspiracy; and the Court had full power to try for riot and assault. Application refused. Mr. Greig then applied that the sentence should not be commenced till after the prisoners had an opportunity of taking such steps in arrest of judgement as they might be advised. Application refused. The Court sentenced Garraty to be imprisoned for eighteen months; and Doran for Twelve months with hard labour.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||