Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

Whitehaven Herald

Article from the Whitehaven Herald, 21st October 1843


Charge Of Riotous Assault

The Colliers' Strike

Daniel Garraty — aged 28, neither reads nor writes — and James Doran — aged 25, reads and writes imperfectly were charged with violently assaulting and beating Thomas Garraway and David Garraway of Whitehaven.

Mr. Ramshay and Mr. Bell appeared for the prosecution; Mr. Greig, with whom was Mr. Lawrie, defended the prisoners.

Mr. Roberts, of Newcastle, was solicitor for the defendants; Mr. Lumb of Whitehaven for the prosecution.

Mr. Ramshay stated the case to the jury. He said — The charge against the prisoners Garraty and Doran was that they assaulted Thomas Garraway in pursuance of a combination among themselves to raise their wages. Another count stated that the assault was attended by riotous circumstances; and a third laid the offence in a lower form. The prosecutor was a miner in Whitehaven; the prisoners were persons who at the time of the transaction or recently before were also miners. [At the request of Mr. Greig all the witnesses in the case were ordered out of court.] At the time in question, it would appear in evidence there had been at Whitehaven, among the colliers, a considerable state of excitement. They seemed to have entered into an agreement that wages should be kept up, and that any collier should be attacked that should work for less than the amount agreed upon. In pursuance of that understanding there were serious disturbances. Miners were attacked in returning from their work, and endeavoured to be intimidated by those who were standing out. The prosecutor, Garraway, had been himself once a member of the Union, but having discovered the folly of it had returned to his work on fair and proper terms. On the night in question he was returning from his work between eleven and twelve o'clock with his son. He should show that a body of men consisting of about a score waited for their return from the pit and attacked them in a very violent manner. Thomas Garraway, they would find, was severely beaten with sticks and stones, and was so seriously injured as to be unable to go to his work. That was by no means a trifling thing. It was a serious charge against the prisoners, and the jury would he felt assured; give it their most serious consideration. It was not to be tolerated that in this or any other country the working classes should be wanting in that protection which the law threw around them. Every man ought to have the fullest control over the price of his labour — if he did not think it high enough he had a right to refuse to work on the terms offered; but not under any pretence whatever had he a right to dictate to and tyrannize over his fellow workmen by violence or intimidation; for the law conceded to every man the right to work on what terms he thought fit. The learned counsel then called the following witnesses: -

William Graham (examined by Mr. Bell) — I reside in Breeches street, Whitehaven. I am a miner, nothing else; but I keep a public house in Whitehaven — the "Union Jack" inn. I know the prisoners at the bar. In the early part of September Garraty came to me in the market place. I asked him how he came on; he said finely. He said they had had a meeting; I asked him what about. He said it was to see what was to be done with these men who were at work. He said there were only nine men at the meeting. I said there were five and twenty at work, and nine were of no use to five and twenty. He said no, he thought not. That is all I know about it.

Mr. Bell — Did he or did he not say -

Mr. Greig — I object to that. Let him say what else was said.

The Chairman — Try to recollect.

Witness — He said it was their intention to do an injury to the men coming from their work. This was before the assault took place.

By Mr. Greig — Mr. Lumb told me to come here to day. He sent for me. I can't say to a day how long ago it is since he sent; may be a week ago. I was not told it would be worse for me if I did not come. There was no threat; I come here as a willing witness. I have known Garraway thirty years. I never heard of him being in trouble for anything.

Thomas Garraway — I am the prosecutor. I am a miner at Whitehaven. The prisoners are miners also. I know them both particularly well. I was once a member of the Miners Association. This paper produced is a copy of the rules of it. I was not above three or four days a member. I had been a week and three days at work before the attack. I attended two meetings whilst I was a member. I think there were three hundred and fourteen cards for members. At the meetings I attended a man called Brophy spoke. A great deal of it was coarse, blaming Mr. Peile. He run down our master very often, for being a bad man, for not giving our men sufficient wages for their work.

By Mr. Greig — Garraty was present at these meetings.

Examination continued. The workingmen were not threatened, that I heard at these meetings. I never heard Garraty threaten any. I can't say I heard him say any thing about them working. The rules were, I understand given to all the members. On the 13th of September I had been at work. There were a good many in the same pit that night. A good many — about 300 — were off their work. We have not regular hours of working; every man leaves off when he is done. When a man goes in it is not known particularly when he will come out. I went in about three o'clock in the afternoon. When a man goes at that time it is expected he will leave about one or two next morning. I left at half-past eleven. I had often got done at the same time. I rode up Wellington Pit, came along the quay, and got to Rosemary Lane. I came to a little lane that goes by the name of Dirty Lane, and saw Daniel Garraty, James Doran and James Cowan. I was with my own son, and on seeing them we pushed on. I looked over my shoulder, and saw nobody. We went on towards the foundry, and looked towards the Castle row. We saw men running in sixes and sevens together, and they came on until they were near the steps in Castle row. They then came down into a dark entry. We pushed on up Preston Street, which was the shortest way. We had got a very little past the warehouse end when I saw Daniel Garraty, and we set off running. Garraty was then peeping by the warehouse end. We run on a little piece, and saw a mob was going to overtake us; it had come out from the warehouse end where he had been peeping. I saw they were going to overtake us and said we might as well stop. They came to within six or seven feet of us. There were upwards of a score, or more. I saw both the prisoners amongst them. I had worked a long time with Garraty, and knew the other one because he was brought up in the same place. They flung a volley of stones at me and my son. I was in my working dress. They then rained upon us with sticks and other weapons, and abused me very ill. I had three or four cuts on my head; my lip was cut through and I was badly used on my left side, which was bruised with sticks while I held up my arm to protect myself. As many as could get to me were at me. Doran and Garraty came up and struck me. I was almost knocked stupid. I can't tell how many blows I got — a great many. My son ran away. I said when they were leaving, "Garraty, I know thee, I'll make thee suffer for that." With that they left me in a kind of sheepish way, cowering down. Garraty struck me oftener than once with a stick. I can't say Doran struck me, but he struck my son.

Mr. Greig — The Union was for the advance of wages and reduction of hours. It existed, perhaps, three weeks before my ill usage. I don't know what was the cause of its formation. It had nothing to do with what Mr. Peile required that I know. Every man had to sign a paper before they went to work. All who wrought had to sign it. If a man refused he got no more work. I signed the paper.

Cross-examination continued — I left the Union when I signed the paper. I was never turned off. I was kept off work till I signed it. My son was too. The 13th of September was a clear moonlight night; the moon was nearly whole. It was near eleven o' clock when I was hurt. I came up the back way on purpose to escape any thing that should come in the way. Men at work were frightened to go home. The foundry is in the New Town, of which Preston Street is in connexion. Dirty Lane is about twenty yards long; from the point where I first saw the three men round by Guineas Warehouse and Jefferson's warehouse to the foundry, may be sixty yards. I cant say positively. I never measured the ground; it is guess work. I did not mention the prisoners at first, when I saw them at the point. I always said the prisoners were two of them. We were going at a rate workmen always go at, and went faster when we saw them. We went up Dirty Lane, and left them behind us. We were going very quick. I might walk three hundred yards between the time of first seeing the prisoners and meeting them the second time. Placards were carried about twice in the mornings. I was not near enough to see what was on them. I don't know whether they had on that the men did not seek higher wages, but only the situation of the text. I was never in gaol — never committed — never taken up to the officer. I was once held to bail for fighting. I left the Union because I thought I would be better at work. I had no conversation with Mr. Peile about this. No body ever told me to say that the two prisoners were among the men who attacked me

By Mr. Ramshay — The men in the union were considered dangerous to those at work.

David Garraway — I am a collier and the son of the last witness. I was a member of the union. I went and got a card and got my name set down. I attended a meeting of the union coal miners belong to it. I have seen Garraty, but I cant say I have seen Doran at the meetings. When I left the union Doran was out of work. I heard Mr. Brophy say Mr. Peile was a robber and a murder. I remember Wednesday night the 13th September. (The witness recapitulated the facts stated by the preceding witness.) A brick bat hit me on the forehead. Then they rushed in with sticks. I received a blow from James Doran. I saw Garraty strike my father. One man was standing near me. I got a bat at him with my stick and got away. It was a moon light night — about as light as day, and I had no difficulty in distinguishing men's faces. Daniel Garraty had a blue coat on when he came up; he usually wears a jacket. Doran had a Scotch cap on; he usually wears a hat.

Cross-examined by Mr. Greig — Mr. Brophy called Mr. Peile a rogue and a murder — about the men's wages. He said the men did not get what they worked for — they should have more wages for less work. He said they signed a paper, like the one they had to sign then, about twelve years since, and had been more miserable than ever they were. The paper required them to keep off the Union while in Lord Lonsdale's employment. The work was taken from several men till they signed Mr. Peile's paper. I signed it. I had got orders I had not to go to work till I did sign it.

Isaac Mossop — I am a surgeon in Whitehaven. I remember being called to see Garraway on the 13th Sept. I found his face streaming with blood, and his head a complete mass of blood. I first cut off the hair and washed the blood off. I discovered three contused wounds, rather on the left side of the head, varying in length from one inch to two and a half. They were not very deep. They were very severe, and must have been produced by heavy blows from some blunt instrument. There was a wound at the outer angle of the left eye, about two inches and a half in extent. There was one on the lip, which was cut through to the teeth. He had a very severe bruise on the left arm. I attended him the greatest part of three weeks, during which time he was unable to work.

By Mr. Greig — I have seen processions with placards, going about the town. I did not read them.

Elizabeth Thompson — I live at Gins, at Whitehaven. I remember the night of the 13th September last. About eleven o'clock when I and my partner were coming up Preston street with our cart. We heard a great noise, and when we looked round I saw a great number of men striking one another and knocking them against the wall as we thought. We heard a shout of "murder! watch!" I saw David Garraway and his son was running and was shouting. Thomas came up from the crowd, after his son. We held up a lantern, and saw his face streaming with blood. He clasped his hands, called for the watch, and said "oh! dear they've killed me." We could not count the crowd, but there were a great many knocking these men about.

By Mr. Greig — We knew that the Union was on, but no more. I saw no banners, or no placards on the walls.

Mr. Ramshay here handed in the rules and regulations of the Miners' Association of Great Britain and Ireland, the first of which was read by the Clerk of the Peace.

This was the case for the prosecution.

Mr. Greig said it now became his duty to address the jury on behalf of the prisoners. The case which had been presented to them was unlike any with which he was acquainted; it was one of the most remarkable which had occurred in the history of strikes. Hitherto all strikes, or a vast majority of them, had been the acts of men who had turned out to attain certain objects, which they had in view. In this case the men were turned out by their master, because they did not choose to enter into an agreement with him which was against the law of the land. Workmen had the power of uniting for the purpose of raising their wages; the power was acknowledged by the statute law, and had been admitted and expatiated upon by every judge before whom the question of a strike had been tried. In all the recent special commission cases the judges declared that men had a right to combine to increase the rate of wages, and it had been acted on throughout the kingdom. It was, undoubtedly, a legal and sound principle. Labour was a marketable commodity, as much as wheat, or oats, or as a horse. If I bring my horse to market I have a right to obtain the highest possible price for it. If I meet with a friend, in going to market, having the same object in view — the sale of his horse — I have a right to enter into a compact with him not to dispose of our horses except at a certain price. In this way prices were legally and legitimately kept up. And it was in consequence of refusing to give up this right that the prisoners had been thrown out of employment, deprived of their wages, and reduced to misery. It was a thing unheard of before. The manager of a coal mine thought fit to compel men to enter into a condition, which they had no right to impose. The poor colliers had been turned out, not because they had misconducted themselves, or worked badly, or were guilty of any impropriety, but solely because they did not choose to give up their right of combination. That had been the cause of all the painful circumstances, which had come before them. The first and best of workmen had been deprived of employment simply because they had refused to resign their rights as British subjects. He should now proceed to the case. The prisoners had desired him to say, in their behalf, that they did combine for the purpose of raising their wages, and that they were turned off because they did not choose to take the pledge to which reference had been made. The Garraties, as soon as they signed it, were re-admitted to their work. What were the contents of the pledge? It required them not to belong to any Union, of any kind whatever, so long as they were in the service of Lord Lonsdale. The Garraways, in consequence of becoming renegades, and deserting their friends, got work. That was the reward of their tergiversation. What they lost in character, they gained in pocket. Happy men! (The learned counsel here read two of the rules of the Miners' Association of Great Britain and Ireland, which deprecate the braking of bonds existing between workmen and master, and discountenance all violation of the laws of the country.) The object of the Association, therefore, was a legitimate one. Could there be a ground of objection against it so long as they kept within the pale of the law — which they showed, by their rules it was their intention to do? It was for becoming members of this association that the prisoners had been thrown out of employment. With regard to their being the parties guilty of the assault with which they were charged, he submitted that there had not been sufficient proof of their identity. True, the Garraway's had sworn that it was moonlight, but this was not so, if the almanac was to be believed, which did not denote that it would be moonlight at the time the assault was committed. They had it from Garraway himself that, going to work at three o'clock in the afternoon; his usual time of returning was two or three the next morning. Was it likely, then, that the prisoners would be on the look out for him several hours before they knew it was probable he would return? Returning to the question of the strike, the learned counsel remarked that a heavy responsibility lay on every one who wielded great power. He was responsible for the use of it; and in this county no one was more responsible than Lord Lonsdale. His enormous possessions above and below ground rendered him a trustee of a very serious and responsible kind; and he (the learned counsel) must say, well and honourably did he discharge that trust. Few men exerted themselves more honourably than his lordship did for the benefit of those by whom he was surrounded. He was well known in the county, and great was his regret that age and infirmity prevented him visiting his estates, as it was his wont to do. In consequence of not being able to do this he was obliged to entrust the superintendence of them to others, and in common with our gracious Queen had got a Prime Minister who rejoiced in the name of Peile — and who, he might truly say, was not generally more appreciated and admired than the political prime minister. The steps, which had been taken by this person, were taken, he was convinced, without the knowledge of Lord Lonsdale, for his lordship would be the last man to deprive a British subject of his rights. Mr. Peile, he (the learned counsel) had no doubt, had been acting conscientiously — had done what he considered would be for his lordship's benefit, — but he had adopted a course which was unsupported by law, principle, or authority. Were men's interests not to be considered, because they happened to be pitmen — because the curse of Cain had doubly descended upon them — because they were compelled to earn a scanty subsistence under ground, in the damp recesses of mines into which the light of the sun never entered? He called upon the jury to protect these men, and to show by their verdict that they thought it better for men to maintain their birthrights than to turn renegades in order to gain a miserable pittance. He begged of them carefully to weigh the evidence and the arguments, which had been adduced. If he thought they were sufficient to establish the guilt of the prisoners, it would be their duty to convict them; but if they saw any reasonable doubt as to their identity then it was their duty to give them the benefit of the doubt.

The Chairman summed up. It was his duty to disabuse their minds of any wrong impression that might have been left by the speech of the learned counsel. If it was clear, on the one hand, that workmen had a right to make what bargain they pleased for their labour, it was equally clear, on the other, that their masters had the right to employ workmen on their own terms. If they found persons coming from a distance to stir up their workmen to unite, and pursuing a course calculated to lead to dangerous consequences, they had a right to require that those in their employment should abstain from entering any union from which serious results were likely to flow. The question was were the jury satisfied that the prisoners were the persons who had committed the assault upon Garraway? That man's evidence was clear and straightforward; the attempt to shake his character had utterly failed; and he should be glad to think that miners generally resembled him in point of respectability and intelligence. The Chairman then carefully read over the evidence, showing its bearings on the charge against the prisoners.

The Jury after consulting a few minutes returned a verdict of "Guilty of riot and Assault" against both prisoners.

Mr. Greig applied for arrest of judgment. By a late act of parliament charges of conspiracy were withdrawn from sessions, and on the ground that the indictment on which the prisoners had been tried contained a charge of that kind he applied for arrest of judgment.

Mr. Ramshay said the charge of conspiracy was merely a variation of the charge of assault.

The Chairman said no sufficient grounds had been shown for arrest of judgment, and he should refuse the application.

In passing sentence upon the prisoners the Chairman said they had been convicted by an intelligent jury of a very serious offence, which endangered the public peace, and which it was the duty of magistrates, acting with due regard to the welfare of the country, severely to punish. True it was that workmen had a legal right to combine to raise their wages; that was no offence; it was not for that that the prisoners had been tried; they had been tried for a riot in the streets of Whitehaven which was caused and brought on by themselves, because they were not satisfied to settle their own wages, but wished to compel others by barbarous and savage treatment, to leave their work. Garraty had been the worse of the two; he had shown neither contrition, sorrow, nor repentance; and the sentence of the court was that he should be IMPRISONED WITH HARD LABOUR EIGHTEEN MONTHS. Doran, being an offender less in degree, the magistrates hoped a milder sentence would have due effect; and the sentence upon him was that he should be IMPRISONED WITH HARD LABOUR TWELVE MONTHS.

Mr. Ramshay said he might be allowed to state that the prosecution had been undertaken solely at the request of the magistrates before whom the prisoners were examined.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bell, —    Solicitor  
Brophy, —      
Cowan, James      
Doran, James   25   
Garraty, Daniel   28   
Garraway, David      
Garraway, Thomas      
Graham, William    Miner  
Greig, —    Solicitor  
Lawrie, —    Solicitor  
Lumb, —    Solicitor  
Mossop, Isaac      
Peile, —      
Ramshay, —    Solicitor  
Roberts, W. P.    Solicitor  Whos Who Page
Thompson, Elizabeth      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print