3rd October 1843
Termination of the Strike
We have much pleasure in announcing to our readers that the colliers of this district have so far sobered down to a common-sense state as to have returned to their labour and signed the test required by their employer, with a view of preventing them from
again submitting themselves to be duped and pilfered and have their energies ground down by such unprincipled vagabonds as Brophy and his wicked coadjutors.
We have always viewed with feelings of pain the strike amongst the workmen, well knowing, as we all along told them, that the attempt to force on their employer the tyranny of an union must signally fail, and that the deluded men and their families would
be the only sufferers by their hardihood and blindness in persevering in an useless attempt at dictation; and which, if even they had succeeded in carrying their point, could never have recompensed them for the sufferings and deprivations they have
undergone by even a temporary suspension of labour. However, as the "strike" is at an end, and the union has passed away along with it, we will not again enter upon a review of the ill policy of the workmen joining a society which would at all
events have raised dictators and tyrants over them, whose beck and call they must have complied with whatever might have been the baneful and pernicious consequences to themselves and their families in thus obeying the commands of a tyrannical and
expensive association. At the same time we should not be acting the part of a friend to the workmen if we omitted to call their attention to the loss they have sustained by the strike, in addition to the great personal suffering and privation which they
and their families have endured by the suspension of labour in consequence thereof. The condition and comforts of all operatives depend on the constant employment of their labour, it being the only source from which they can derive the required funds to
purchase and supply themselves with the common necessaries of life, indeed the only means they have of existing at all. The consequence, therefore, of a suspension of work, from any cause, for ever so short a time, is an irreparable injury and loss to
the workman, inasmuch as his supplies are stopped though his demands become more urgent by the pressure of hunger and want. The loss sustained in consequence of the turn-out in this district cannot have been less than £10,000, and as the
opportunity of applying the labour which would have produced this large sum of money, is like time passes away, irredeemable, we cannot but regret the loss, especially as it has been occasioned by the misguided and foolhardy act of the miners in so
readily and inconsiderately lending themselves to that designing and worthless miscreant, Brophy, whose only object was self-aggrandisement at the expense of his deluded followers.
We have stated the pecuniary loss to the turn-outs at £10,000, and in doing so we are satisfied that we are under rather than above the mark of the actual sum thus kept out of circulation, yet as we do not wish to exaggerate the amount of loss
sustained by the reckless step that has been adopted, we will take it at that sum. The strike, then, has been the means of preventing this large amount of money from coming into the pockets of the turn-outs, the control and expenditure of which would
have rested entirely with themselves, and would have secured to them, their wives and families, a comfortable and independent subsistence; but in consequence of the absence of these funds they have been driven almost to starvation and destitution, and in
order to sustain life at all have had to crave as a favour what little they have had to subsist upon during the strike. On the other hand, if the strike had never existed labour would have been constantly employed, and the men in the receipt of an
adequate remuneration for the same; the tradesmen supplying the miners with the necessaries of life would have considered themselves in some degree the parties favoured, which would have been a happy contrast to the case of the turn-outs, who were driven
to ask a favour the granting or selling of these commodities to meet the pressing exigencies of their starving wives and children! We should like to know how the turn-outs can ever make up the loss sustained by any exertion or effort on their parts, the
suspension of work, as we have already observed, alone being a direct and irreparable loss, because no subsequent period can afford the same or like opportunity of applying the labour which has been suspended. They might, it may be urged, in a manner
approximate to it, by a larger outlay of labour than is necessary to meet their ordinary expenses; but this of itself is an evil that ought to be avoided, and which never could have existed had it not been for the desolating strike, of the bitter fruits
of which so many have partaken.
This, however, would neither be making up nor recovering the time and money lost, but merely obtaining a recompense for their extraordinary exertions, which, if their physical powers are equal to endure, would have been open to them though they had
received the large sum of money which we have shown they have lost by their suspension of work, without the heavy drawback of its being anticipated as made; but what advantage would it be to them when it is anticipated and taken from them as it is
earned? We are sorry for the men's sakes, but it is manifest that the loss cannot be obviated.
The evils and injuries we have just pointed out are not the only sufferings the turn-outs have entailed upon themselves by their unwise and rash steps in leaguing themselves with Brophy and his clique of selfish agitators. The pressure of want has in
many instances been so severe and urgent that many of them have stripped their houses of what little furniture and apparel they contained, to sell or otherwise dispose of at a ruinous sacrifice, to raise money to meet their craving and hungry wants; thus
homes which before the strike were neat and comfortable have been reduced to a state of desolation, without even the commonest and most necessary articles of household furniture for the use and comfort of their families. Besides this sacrifice many have
run largely and deeply into debt with their provision dealers and other shop-keepers, who in self defence will be compelled to resort to the stringent and stern hand of the law for a compulsory recovery of his debt, increased as it will be by the law
costs, unless the amount be liquidated speedier than we are afraid the turn-outs will be in a position to effect. This is no doubt much to be regretted, and we are grieved to think that the poor miner's best energies should be so shackled, and the fruits
of his future labour anticipated before they are yielded, to discharge a debt incurred while, lending himself to further the purposes and ends of the worthless demagogue, who all along has been looking at the evil consequences which must fall upon his
defrauded and deluded followers with a satanical and demon-like pleasure, well knowing that he would not only escape scathless and unharmed, but with better lined pockets than when he first made his appearance in this part of the country. As friends of
the workmen we have week after week pointed out to them the certainty that they would in the end be the only parties who would suffer by the strike, and we sincerely regret that they did not before now perceive the evil and ruinous consequences of
pursuing and persevering in the fool-hardy and unwise step which they had made, and retraced it before; but no evil was ever yet inflicted on man from which he might not learn a good lesson, if he looked at it in a proper light, we therefore hope that
the colliers of this district will be benefited by the painful experience they have gained from this unfortunate strike, and keep the evils and deprivations they have suffered constantly before their eyes as a beacon to warn them against lending
themselves hereafter to such a worthless character as Brophy. Let them always bear in mind that the suspensions of labour, let the period be ever so short, is a loss which they can never redeem.
The colliers have now been off work six weeks, and it is worth while to contrast with their condition during that period, the state of those who remained at work instead of joining the union. Those men who continued their labour were contented in their
minds — comfortable with their families at their respective homes — and constantly making unusually great wages, in consequence of their being allowed to work as long as they liked; whilst, on the other hand, the turn-outs, during the same
period, have been making nothing — have suffered the pangs of hunger — have felt all the horrors of destitution — have been discontented and unhappy at seeing the evils they have brought upon themselves — the ruin they have
inflicted on their families and their homes — and the vagabond life they have been leading, whilst they might have been supporting themselves and their families with credit and independence. Look colliers, "on this picture and on that,"
and ask yourselves as reasoning men ought to ask such a question, if you do not think that you have victimised yourselves by attending to the counselling's of the villain Brophy, against whose wiles we so often warned you, and who feels no sympathy
whatever for the humiliating position in which he has placed you.
BROPHY'S PLIGHT
Since writing the above we have learnt that the heartless and foul-mouthed scoundrel Brophy left this place yesterday evening by the Belfast steamer. We trust that the workmen in other places where he may attempt to agitate in favour of the Union, will
take a warning from the dupes and victims which he left behind him in this town. Brophy remained long enough in Whitehaven to see the melancholy consequences of his pernicious advice to the miners, and he did not leave the town until, like the Trogan
dame, he had become
"A sad spectator of the ills he'd caused."
We all along prognosticated that this cowardly miscreant would cut and run as soon as he saw that he had fairly entrapped a sufficient number of his victims. It has been so, and the termination of his career has been worthy of the manner in which it was
continued.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Brophy, — | | | |