18th September 1843
The Colliers and Their Strike
We certainly did hope that we should have been in a position this week to have announced to our distant readers that the strike amongst the collieries in this town and neighbourhood had caused, and that they were again at their wonted occupation, instead
of being seen loitering about in indolence, and subjecting themselves and their families to famine and destitution. We do, however, most deeply regret, for the sake of both the men and their families, to state that the case is otherwise, and that we are
compelled to convoy to the public the tidings that they have not as yet abstained from inflicting punishment on themselves! The colliers still, to a considerable extent, and with the mistaken guidance of enthusiast, continue to bow down and worship the
tyrant Brophy, who is trampling them and their energies under his feet, for the sole purpose, as we have repeatedly remarked, of advancing his own private and individual interest, without a moments thought or, remorse for the culpability and wickedness
of his conduct, or for the misery which must inevitably result therefrom. However we can at the same time assure the public that the strike is on the wane, and the events of the past week, much as we regret our being obliged to record such facts against
any of the miners of this district, must necessarily hasten the extinction and suppression of the strike. It is a strange anomaly in the conduct of the colliers that they should attempt to coerce any potion of their fellow-labours who may think proper to
exercise their industry upon terms different from themselves. Who could have thought that any body of English operatives could have been found so ignorant as thus to violate the rights of labour? The damages, Brophy, whom we look upon as the arch enemy
of the working classes, has urged the thoughtless amongst them to this excess, and we trust we shall yet see punishment fall upon the right head. No effort was ever made by Brophy to discourage these disgraceful proceedings, and the Union has never
discountenanced them, and therefore no reflecting or sober-minded man need be any longer at a loss to know the abominable nature of the materials of which the union is composed. The two unfortunate men who were sent to prison on Saturday last, of which
we have given an account elsewhere, can be viewed in no other light than as Brophy's victims, whilst this villain himself bids fair at present to terminate his career in a similar place of confinement.
We have repeatedly pointed out to the workmen that they were wrong in leaguing themselves with Brophy, and in following out his advice, and we have also before told them, as we do now, the dangerous consequences of their doing so — that the result
would be pregnant with future evils to themselves, and that they would ultimately be the greatest sufferers, whilst he the investigator of all the mischief, would escape and preserve himself from harm. We appeal again to the events of the past week in
support of these prognostications, the verification of which, as already witnessed, proves the hollowness of Brophy, the utter worthlessness of his cause, as well as the insufficiency of the forthcoming aid in the shape of pecuniary assistance, which
they were led to expect would be obtained from the Miners Association.
We last week presumed to question the adequacy of any remittance which could be made by the Miners Association to the pressing necessities and emergencies of the unionists and their starving families, whom Brophy had all along deluded with a promise that
the remittance should arrive and, forsooth, be equal to their wants! By this and other similar and previous falsehoods, Brophy succeeded in beguiling his poor deluded followers into a fond hope of realizing whatever extravagant wish he might chose to
stir up in their breasts; and how true have our observations turned out when we said that the remittance, if any ever came, would be but as a drop of water in the bucket when it became divided amongst the numerous unionists in this quarter. The small
miserable, and insulting amount sent by the Miners Association to Brophy and the turn-outs on Wednesday last, tends distinctly to show the difference between the amount of promise and the amount of realization; and the miners must indeed be blind to
their own interests if they do not open their eyes to the truth on beholding this glaring fact, for it is possibility one of the most barefaced impositions ever practiced upon any body of working men, and if the miners do not make their stand against the
impostor Brophy after this, they must never hence forth claim to be ranked amongst intelligent and discerning men. The instance of mockery and insult on the part of Brophy is only exceeded by the wickedness of his design, when, as report says, he
attempted to escape with the whole of the booty, and would have succeeded in his villainy had it not been for, the activity, and vigilance displayed by some of his deluded followers, who, having a want of confidence in him, choose to keep a very sharp
and prudent look-out, and by that means, it is said, disappointed him of carrying his nefarious design into effect. After this disappointment, Brophy with much pomp, proceeded on Wednesday evening to divide the miserable and insufficient remittance,
amongst the men, when the heads of families were insulted by being offered for the past and future maintenance of themselves, their wives and their children the magnificent sum of 2s. 1½... each.!!! O miners! if ye maintain in your minds one
particle of the spirit and independence of free-born men, resent this mockery of support, and never submit to cringe to others, like the creature Brophy, for a beggarly pittance like this, whilst you can proudly and honestly maintain yourselves and your
families by this free and independent exercise of your own industry! Such conduct is unworthy of the character of the British Labourer, even in the very lowest ranks of life, and calculated only to degrade you in the eyes of your countrymen. It possesses
an aspect too humiliating for any class of Englishmen to endure. If Brophy be still determined that you should hold out till you accomplish the objects of the Union, or rather until you realise his private and selfish views, we can only tell you that the
case is hopeless, and that you are actually further removed from their accomplishment that you were at the beginning of the strike.
This remittance, accompanied as it was with the intimidation we have mentioned, no doubt astonished and confounded the followers of Brophy, yet the assurance and hardihood of the fellow is so great, that although he knew that presenting the heads of
families with 2s. 1½ d, each was a mockery and so insult to the miners in their starving and destitute conditions, in consequence of joining the Union, he contrived to turn the indignation and frenzy with which the breasts of his daped followers
were charged in consequence of the gross and cruel mockery which he and his elique of agitaters had cast upon them against their fellow workmen. Hence we find him in inveighing in the most disgraceful and violent language against the industrious miners,
whom he could not induce to leave their work, pointing them out to his followers as the cause of their being out of employ, and in their present destilum and starving state, though he knows right well that he himself in the sole cause of having reduced
his deluded followers to their present pitiful condition. He told them that this obstacle would have been removed ere they could carry their point and gain the advantages laid out by the Union, and thus succeeded in shielding himself by directing the
vengeance of his followers against their fellow workmen — a manoeuvre which succeeded but too well in betraying some of the more thoughtless of the turn-outs into acts of violence, for which they have already been consigned to prison, and will
shortly be brought to the bar of justice to answer for the offence, whilst the guilty scoundrel who urged them to the deed, skulks in the background and escapes the punishment he so richly deserves.
Indeed when we consider the extreme violence of Brophy's language, addressed to men, many of whom stand low in the scale of intelligence. Indeed when we consider the extreme violence of Brophy's language, addressed to men many of whom stand low in the
scale of intelligence, and those minds he had previous poisoned, the brutal attack committed by Brophy's followers on their fellow workmen on Wednesday night last, is by no means to be wondered at, more particularly when we find the unionists excited by
rage and disappointment at the smallness of the remittance which had been sent for their support, and with which they were told to maintain themselves and families in comfort! Through rage and vexation these men urged by Brophy, attempted to act the part
of assassin against them, unarmed and unoffending fellow-workmen who had been peacefully pursing their daily labour in the mines, whom they beat with sticks and stones in the most savage manner, and had nearly accomplished the murder of one of their
victims. This disgraceful and brutal act has been the means of raising the universal feeling of horror and disgust in the public mind against Brophy and his savage followers. The fate of the unionists be it what it may, will now gain them no sympathy
from the public, who speak of their conduct everywhere in terms of general condemnation. But much as this brutal conduct on the part of the turnouts is to be regretted, it has at least had this beneficial effect, it has afforded the masters and the
magistracy an opportunity of promptly, adopting precautionary measures for the protection of those man who are willing to work, thus proving to Brophy and his barbarous followers that they will not be permitted to violate the rights of labour with
impunity. Mr. Peile, Lord Lonsdale's agent seeing that those miners who were willing to work were instructed by the Unionists, lost not a moment is supplying to the magistrates for protection, and as the magistrates had previously published
a placard stating their intention to protect the industrious miners who were disposed to follow their labour, it is scarcely necessary to say that Mr. Peile's request was immediately complied with. Almost at the same time, the tradesmen of the town took
up the subject with considerable warmth and signed a requisition to the magistrates for calling in the aid of the military. Accordingly on Friday evening a company of the 93rd Highlanders, under the command of Captain Banner arrived from Carlisle,
and took up their station at the Castle, where they yet remain. On Thursday night the relays of miners as they proceeded to and from the pits, were guarded by special constables: but they now go and return alone without the least molestation, the
turn-outs being pretty well convinced by this times that they will not be permitted to obstruct the free exercise of industry with impunity.
This promptness on the part of the magistrates, seconded by the unanimous feelings of the inhabitants, has struck the tyrannical demagogue Brophy with dismay, and is rapidly diminishing the ranks of his followers, who are now beginning to see the
determination with which they will be resisted if they again attempt to interfere with the rights of the more industrious portion of the miners to pursue their labours as they please. As in most other strikes so in this, the men who refuse to work will
be the victors, and with regard to their unprincipled agitator his occupation may now be looked open as gone. We repeat that it is the men and not the masters by whom the misery and inconvenience of the strike will be felt. With the present stock of
coals at the bank, and the aid of the hands who are now at work, a sufficient supply can be kept up to meet the demands of the market, and nothing further is wanted; so that the turn-outs, by following the advice of Brophy, have inflicted a grievous
injury on themselves.
In conclusion, we cannot refrain from complimenting the Bench on the propriety of its abstaining from a summary conviction of the prisoners on Saturday last, which would only have visited the prisoners with the infliction of a small fine — a very
inadequate punishment, it must be confessed, to the grave nature of the offence with which they stood charged, for on the elder of the Garraway's being asked if he was put in bodily fear of his life, the wounded men replied in the affirmative,
observing that the many dangerous contusions which were infected upon him, and particularly on his head, fully justified his fears. We believe that the poor man's remark found an echo to every breast, for his head and face was literally covered with
wounds.
If Brophy was a men possessed of a properly cultivated mind, no one could envy him of his feelings; but the vulgarity of the fellow's conduct, and the brutality of his language prove him to be totally insensible to the misery that he is spreading around
him; he has a head capable of glaning mischief, but he has not a heart to feel for its consequences, otherwise he could not but have felt a considerable share of compunction for the distress into which two innocent families were plunged on Saturday last,
by the heads of those families following the evil advice which he has so industriously given. We are not, however, without the hope, and we know that we are joined in our expectations by hundreds, of seeing this worthless and selfish vagabond meet with
the just reward of his cruel and infamous conduct. He has carried misery and destination into the home of many a poor miner, and it will be no more than an act of retributive justice if the chalice, which he has presented to the lips of others, should in
the transpiring of events pass from other hands into his own
HAVE STRIKES EVER DONE ANY GOOD TO THE LABOURING MAN
"Every man in Great Britain has a right to the use of the law and the means of enforcing that law for the protection of that which is his own"
All things, which we see around us, belong to somebody, and all these things have been produced by labour, consequently they are the production of the labouring man. This is a view which working men seldom loss slight of, they always consider, and truly,
that everything is proceeded by labour; but they consider, as a consequence, that it ought to belong those who produced it: they seldom reflect, that although the present owner did not produce it by his own labour, that either he or his ancestors
produced something by labourer which was so valuable that it enabled them to purchase the labour of some other man, and this purchase would be in the shape of wages. When there was not much labour in the market for sale, the labour would demand and
obtain a large amount of wages; but when labour became more plentiful in proportion to the demand, the price would be reduced as labour is not an article which can be kept out of the market without a loss to the labourer, for every day he refuses to sell
his labour he is a loser to the amount of the price offered for that labour. The man who wishes to purchase labour considers the quantity of the article in the market, and the number of persons wishing to purchase the article, and these considerations
bring him to a just conclusion of what value labour is.
It has been laid down as a rule, that the rate of wages depends on the amount of that portion of the capital, which is appropriated to the payments of wages, compared with the number of labourers. Thus wages may be affected by various contingencies: they
may decline in consequence of the capital being diminished, while labourers remain equally numerous, or by the number of labourers increasing, while the capital has remained the same; or by the capital decreasing, and the number of labourers increasing
simultaneously; or they may rise in consequence of these circumstances being reversed. Thus every system of things for improving the wages of the labourer, which is not based on some scheme for the improvement of the capital appropriated to the payments
of wages, must end in disappointment to those engaged there in.
We have found that all things which we see around us, has a right to be protected by the law, on account of it be the property of some person or persons. Now the property of the working man is his labour, and this property the law protects in a variety
of ways: it protects the labouring man while making a sale of the commodity, and if the purchaser makes any objections to pay the full amount agreed upon the law is ready at all times to enforce a just payment: it is also ready at all times to protect
any person who may have sold his labour from being insulted and abused whilst delivering that which he has sold. These are a few instances in which the law protects labour. The law also recognises the right of labourers to meet together to consider what
is the highest amount of wages they can obtain for their labour, and it also recognises their rights to form themselves into a society for the purpose of obtaining the said wages, and of refraining from work till that amount of wages be paid: for the
labour (which is their property) is their own — they may sell it or keep it to themselves as they choose; but if their masters be able to purchase labour of some other men at a cheaper rate, it protects these labourers from being insulted and
abused by those who are desiring the higher amount of wages; but it is possible for men to unite and all insist on being paid the amount of wages agreed upon by themselves, and refrain from work till such wages be paid; and the masters during such time
may not be able to purchase any labour at the price which they are willing to pay, the consequences is, what is called a general strike; and allow me to instance one or two such strikes to see whether they benefit the labouring man or not.
I will first notice the strike, which took place at Preston, in the winter of 1836-7, among the cotton spinners of that place. The spinners amounting to 660 struck for an advance of wages, and in, consequences of their leaving their work, 1320 children
employed by them were thrown out of work, 6100 card loom hands, reelers and power-loom weavers, 420 over-lookers, packers, and engineers, making a total of 8500 persons, and out of this number the 660 spinners were all who voluntarily left their work,
and the remaining 7840 were thereby thrown out of employment. The strike continued three months during which time their wages would have amounted to £52,513 and the loss sustained by clerks, waggoner's, carters, &c., amounted to £17,500,
making a total of £70,013; but during these three months they received from the funds of the Union £4,290, from private charity and parish relief £2,500, relief given by the masters £1,000, received from various sources
£5,013 — total £12,803; thus leaving a clear loss of £57,210 to the labouring classes engaged in the strike, but the loss sustained by the town of Preston is estimated at £107,196, and at the end of the strike the working
classes were obliged to go to work on conditions proposed by the masters, who wisely refused to give employment to 200 of the spinners who had been most active in the turn-out, and they were thus obliged to leave the place they had brought to desolation.
If those spinners had at the end of the three months gained what they struck for it would have taken between 8 and 9 years to make up the money which they and their fellow labourers lost by the strike, and between 16 to 17 years to make up the loss which
they caused to the town of Preston. In the summer of 1837 came the strike amongst the Glasgow cotton spinners, which lasted upwards of 4 months, and caused a loss to the operatives of £47,600, independent of the loss of the masters, merchants,
tradesmen, and others; and during the latter two months of the time there were upwards of 60 prisoners committed for trail, more than the usual number. Mr. Sheriff Allinson speaking of the strike says "that in those 4 months £200,000
was lost to the city of Glasgow, without a single shilling being gained by any human being, by the strike of this trade alone!! The total loss sustained by Lanarkshire between the strikes of the colliers, the iron moulders, sawyers, and spinners last
year was at least £500,000. Society cannot long go on under a repetition of such shocks: capital will migrate from this country where it is subject to such calamities." There might also be mentioned the various strikes which have taken place
in Manchester among the cotton spinners, till the masters, being wearied out and afraid of losing their trade altogether, desired the Messrs. Sharp and Co., of Manchester, to direct the inventive talents of their partner, Mr. Roberts, to construct
a machine whereby they might dispense with the services of the spinners, and the result was the invention of the self-acting mule which does the work so much better then the spinners as to leave them no chance against it.
The workmen employed in making gun barrels, the calico printers, the flax dressers, the croppers of the West Riding of Yorkshire, the silk weavers of Macclesfield, &c. "could a tale unfold on the subject of strikes." "We cannot do
these things in Dublin said an Irish cabinet maker," or if we could we would not for the men are so combining to keep up prices that most work of this description is now executed in England or Scotland." A correspondent of a most popular work
relates a conversation he had with a gentleman from Dublin about the trade of printing. The Dublin gentleman, says that the publishing trade is now less there than formerly, and that a number of works which are published there, are printed in England or
Scotland. He instanced two works, which were thus executed in Great Britain; the Dublin Review, which is printed in London and a Roman Catholic Bible, which is printed in Glasgow. "True," he says, "we can print as well: we have as good
machinery an as good paper; we have also few or no taxes; every thing is cheap; but all these advantages are fruitless, in consequence of the combination of the workmen. In short things have come to such a pass that there is no temptation to produce
books in Dublin, and there is every prospect of the printing trade becoming extinct in that city, except for newspapers and other things which must be printed on the spot."
Hear Mr. O'Connell, too, on the effects of combination, (a gentleman that whom none would report more favourably of Irish society): he says "the business of calico printing, which had long been carried on in Belfast, was taken from it in
consequence of the combination of the new engaged in it. The party who had embarked his capital in the trade sold off materials, and the result was that one hundred and seven families were thrown out of board. The town of Bandee by the same means lost a
yearly outlay of £11,000 or £12,000 in wages. And with respect to the city of Dublin I do not overstate the matter when I say that wages to the amount of five hundred thousand pounds a year were withdrawn from it in almost every article of
combination in the foundry trade alone not less than £10,000 a year was lost out of Dublin which would have been retained if the system of combination did not exist." Do men expect, by combination and wishes permanently to secure both higher
wages for their labour than circumstances will allow, and also a durable rent for their produce! Will not the market for our industry be lost if such as effect continued! Will not Prussia and Russia, and France receive it with open arms and readily give
it that protection which it has ceased to find in the British Isles, and will not our town be reduced to ruins, and the land of Watt and Arkwright be stripped of its fabrics, and despotisms, in the end, reap those fruits which the arms of freedom have
sown. Around us, on all sides, the manufacture of these strikes upon the interests of industry are spreading. They tell us in a voice of thunder, that the worst enemy of the poor is a combination.
September, 1843. X.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Allinson, — | | Sheriff | |
| Banner, —, Captain | | | |
| Garraway, — | | | |
| Lonsdale, Lord | | Mine Owner | |
| O'Connell, — | | | |
| Peile, — | | Colliery Agent | |
| Roberts, — | | | |