12th September 1843
The Colliers and their Strike
Whitehaven,
Tuesday Morning, Sept. 12 1843,
The strike amongst the colliers of this district still continues to some extent, but the number of adherents is daily decreasing, and so rapidly, that the worthless demagogue, Brophy, has been striving to amuse and alter the few still following in
his train by some most discreditable exhibitions, such as are invariably the last resort of a failing demagogue to keep up a waning agitation and to sustain a corrupt, mercenary, and disreputable cause. Indeed we are of opinion, notwithstanding the
exhibitions Brophy has resorted to, in order to keep up the number of his injured and deluded followers, that they are not so much kept up to their present number by any thing proceeding from him, as from several of the most forward and hitherto
pertinacious member of the strike amongst the colliers themselves, who having nothing better to do, naturally follow Brophy as a matter of amusement.
One of Brophy's vulgar and silly exhibitions during the week consisted in burning a number of the Pacquet, of Tuesday last, in the presence of his deluded and senseless followers on the Bulwark, in which it will be remembered we fairly and calmly
discussed the point of difference between the workmen and their employer, embracing at the same time the opportunity it afforded of pointing out to the miners the source and spring of action of the alleged disinterested and certainly gratuitous
indifference of Brophy on their behalf, and in which we succeeded in showing to them but too clearly, and in convincing the majority, that they had no legitimate grounds of complaint against their employer or his agent, and that Brophy's
object in throwing the apple of discord amongst them was to line his pockets, and to render the poor miners subservient to him and his clique of agitators. This was the head and front of our offending. It was for this that the mercenary wretch,
Brophy and the duped followers committed to the fames as Tuesday last a copy of our last week's publication, which was consumed amid yells as savage and as senseless as those which characterized the untutored Indian's "Warwhoop." Who
does not see that the same savage spirit that consigned one paper to the flames, if uncontrolled by the arm of the law, would have doomed the writer of the obnoxious article to perish at the stake? Such in the way this coarse and vulgar biped meets the
arguments of these who may happen to differ with him. From the pernicious influence of such leaders as Brophy, whose conduct in positively a disgrace to the intelligence of the age, may the British press, whatever may be its politics, always stand
forth to defend the humblest of our operatives! We rejoice that we have laboured with effect — that we have opened the eyes of many of the miners to Brophy's stupidity. The fellow knows that we put his craft in danger — that we have
exposed his intrigues, his frauds, and his deception, and hence the bitterness of his resentment. We shall steadily pursue our coarse, being convinced that we are alike upholding the interests of the employer and the employed, and that the only interest
which our course is likely to injure is that of the unprincipled vagabond who has for several weeks been fattening upon the poor men's pittance, being himself too lazy to work for an honest livelihood. We dare state our existence on the fact, that those
men who have, takes our advice and have returned to work, will find in the future that they have acted wisely, and that those who have followed the selfish and ridiculous counselling of Brophy will soon discover to their cost that they have
brought upon themselves and their families poverty, destitution and ruin. Let the deluded miners hear those words in remembrance, fed in the lapse of but a short period of time they will live to witness in sorrow their sternest realisation.
Had Brophy and his followers, instead of burning the Pacquet, answered the arguments it contained, they would have had the triumph of men, had they done so successfully; but finding themselves unable to execute the task they burned the paper which
contained them, and thus consented themselves with the revenge of savages! Every argument which the offending article contained remains unanswered to this hour, because they have been found to be unanswerable, and hence the effect that has been produced
by their remaining in full influence, for though Brophy may be able to throw dust into the eyes of the more illiterate portion of his followers, he cannot thus delude an intelligent public who think and judge for themselves, and who do not exactly
see in the burning of a newspaper any thing in the shape of either reason or argument, but, on the contrary are apt to infer that such an ignorant and savage way of meeting an opponent denotes a lamentable want of both.
Colliers! This burning exhibition of your enlightened leader is the only answer that Brophy has been able to give to our remarks of last week; but we would be sorry to think that even the least intelligent amongst you could seriously put it forth
as an answer, whilst we would take hope that every intelligent man to your ranks felt his cheeks mantling with shame when he behold the disgraceful exhibition. We look upon the deed as his, not as yours; it is unworthy of you, but it is characteristic
enough of him. What was the object of this man in adopting such a course! Was it not an attempt to blind your eyes by the flame which played before you to the weakness of his position, and to his liability to fairly meet and deal with our observations
and further, by the excitement produced, to prevent you from coolly reflecting and judging for yourselves respecting his weakness and incapacity. We never object to any man fairly meeting or refuting our arguments if he can; but we do object to, and
strongly detest, such gross deception as Brophy has practised on his followers, which is, however, an invariable characteristic of all itinerant demagogues, when they find themselves unable, even with their weak, wordy, rambling statements, to
meet an opponent. With all his sophistry, however, and with all his claptrap exhibitions and burnings, this fellow's career of deception and bumbling is fast drawing to a close; for the time has arrived when the miners are beginning not only to suspect,
but to behold the hollowness of his pretensions. Though his persuasion and their own folly they have lost the means of supporting themselves and their families, and they are beginning to suspect that the promised pecuniary aid from Newcastle is about of
the same visionary nature as all the other promises which Brophy has made in furtherance of his purpose to delusion. In this respect, we flatter ourselves that we have done the miners some service, as we are convinced that our previous cautions
have prevented many of them from becoming the demagogue's victims.
Let us take a glance at what are likely to be the consequences of your joining this union, on the altar of which so many victims are to be sacrificed. In the first place, it appears, you would not be free agents in the disposal of your labour and
privileges, which constitutes the pride, and glory of the British operative. In making your contracts with employers you would not even be a principle to the bargain — you would have no will of your own, but would be compelled to work for what
wages and during what hour a board of strangers, sitting at a distance, might in the exercise of their wisdom caprice think proper to name! Again, if this board thought fit that you should desist from work, even though you were amply remunerated for your
labour, and your wives and families happy contented, you would have to comply with this unreasonable mandate, and entail upon yourselves and families future want and misery, for the mere purpose of advancing the mistaken views and ends of more who would
be entire strangers to you, without even having so much as a voice or a opinion in the matter; and in addition to all this, you would have to submit to your wages being taxed in order to support in affluence and in indolence a set of men wholly unknown
to you either in person or in character! What would the calumniator Brophy have said of your employers had they ever demanded from you anything so derogatory as this! If the miners have their union they will have it to support; for no trades union
was ever yet carried on without its hired staff, consisting always of such men as Brophy, too lazy to earn a living by honest labour, and yet mean enough to wring it out of the hard-earned pittance of his fellow men. In proof of this we need only
enumerate one instance in order to show how the poor dupes who join the union will be taxed. The directors of the union have engaged the professional services of a briefed barrister of no reputation, of the name of Roberts, who is to receive a thousand
pounds for the first year, and five hundred pounds a year afterwards. Besides this enormous cost, there is the express of the Brophys and other hangers on, who will never work so long as they can find dupes to maintain them.
Colliers! Think of this! Look to yourselves and reject the ruinous union for the sake of your wives and children. If they continue without their union they will be freed from the cost of maintaining it, and have their entire earnings for their own
personal comfort and support, and that of their families. Many colliers have at different times left this district to work in places where unions existed, conceiving that they would enjoy many and decided advantages there from. These promised advantages
however, they never possessed, and they have almost invariably returned in the coarse of time denouncing the union as costly, without any remunerating advantages being derived from them, had their supporters as hollow and unsound at the heart, as the
deluded men in this district will ultimately find their worthless and merciless leader.
We are told that the legislature of the country has by its united acts recognized unions, and admitted the policy of them. Certainly the legislature has tolerated union by revoking acts of Parliament interdicting trades and unions, but by the very same
act by which it tolerates unions, the legislature sanctions, protects and supports the masters and men who disapprove of unions, or do not choose to join them, by inflicting severe punishment on any unionist presuming to intimidate either the one or the
other — the master or the men. We ask the colliers in a body — because we know that there are men of judgment amongst them — whether any combination which drives trade from a district by suspending it even for a time can possibly do
them any good? We say the trades unions do this, and more than this, and appeal to the Staffordshire district as a proof, where the unions have succeeded most effectually in pauperising the artisan and collier, and driven the trade to distant lands,
whilst, at the same time, the workmen, as a body, have been made the dupes and scape goats of political quacks and lecturers of Brophy's grade. Brophy has himself already launched somewhat into politics, about which he just knows as much as
he does of the disastrous effect of unions upon the conditions of the workmen, and we warn the colliers of this district, least, like those in Staffordshire, they should be made political scape goats of by individual so utterly worthless and contemptible
as the creature who is leading them on headlong to ruin.
We certainly do not consider Brophy, either honest or sincere, when he says that he merely came here to establish the right (which has never been questioned) of the miners to unite and protect their labour, whilst in the same breath he launches
into the wide and pernicious field of universal suffrage, were by ballot, and Chartism generally. What the object or purpose of this fellow is, beyond that of putting money in his purse, it is very hard to say, for we one night heard him declare that he
would stay in the town till he established the union, even if his pecuniary resources were so reduced as to compel him to lecture in the public circuits for a lodging, and take all water for his drink. Next, he said, he would go into Ireland and agitate
there on behalf of the miners; and lastly, that he would remain in the town, and keep a school education to the miners children. This latter proposition is certainly a very praiseworthy one, and might have a good effect if such a school were conducted by
a strictly moral and intellectual character; but the result might be just as perilous on the other hand, and, partially speaking, quite as bad in its effects, were it conducted by an ignorant, dissolute, and unprincipled demagogue like Brophy.
Where in the miner, we would ask, who would allow his child to be educated by the man who has driven many of the colliers to proclaim the wives and daughters of their fellow labourers as prostitutes to the world, and to point out their husbands and
brothers as conceiving partners in these scenes of degrading vice and wickedness? We do not believe that there is any grounds whatever for this abominable charge. We do not believe that there is even the shadow of a suspicion to warrant this scoundrel in
putting forth so scandalous an accusation; and we confess that we are not a little surprised at the conduct of the miners in allowing him to bring so foul a charge against their wives and daughters with impunity; they must be either more or less than men
to endure it, and more particularly has he has since publicly reiterated the charge, and has even threatened to publish the names of the guilty parties! Upon the strength of our opinion on this subject, we dare him to do so. Now, let the public mark how
the cowardly calumniator will shriek from the task! He a trainer of childhood! Where is the man with the footing on a parent who would suffer the mind of youthful innocence to be poisoned by the unhallowed principles of socialism — who would permit
the young idea to have engulfed upon it the loose and unprincipled doctrines of the chartist — or who would sanction a child receiving its first moral impressions from a man whose language would disgrace a brothel; and whose conduct shows him to be
unworthy of leading even the poor duped whom he has succeeded in inducing to listen to his counsel. The very idea of this fellow setting himself up as a teacher is as absurd as it is ridiculous, and, for the present, we take our leave of him with the
same feelings with which we have ever viewed his language and conduct, namely, those of ineffable contempt.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Brophy, — | | | |