Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

5th September 1843

The Coal Miners

The vulgar itinerant Brophy, of whose proceedings in this neighbourhood amongst the coal-miners we have more than once had occasion to speak, has had another week of incessant labour in this town endeavouring to prevail upon the colliers to abandon their work and join the association, but we are glad to state that even the little success he has met with is likely only to be of a temporary nature, for many of the men who were induced, through threats and intimidation, to leave their work, have again gone back to their labour when they found that the magistrates were determined to protect them, as it will be seen they intend to do from an advertisement which appears in another column.

During the early part of last week the work of intimidation was carried to a considerable height. Such of the men as refused to sign the terms submitted to them by the Earl of Lonsdale's agents, which was to the effect that they should renounce the Union, of course left their work, and no sooner did they do so than they immediately began to threaten and intimidate those who were willing to follow their employment, and would not suffer themselves to be led astray and robbed by an itinerant vagabond, of whom not one amongst the whole body of miners, we suspect, has any knowledge whatever. Those who were willing to work peaceably were prevented, and in some cases were ill-used. Brophy, who did his utmost to excite the men, held a meeting on the bulwark on Tuesday evening; when he addressed them in the most intemperate and exciting language, in which he abused the men who were willing to work, and pointed them out as objects of excretion to the excited miners who had left their employment. Thus urged to resentment the turnouts on Tuesday night attacked the houses of several of the miners who were about to proceed to their labour, broke their windows, were clamorous and loud in their denunciations, and discharged fire-arms in front of the dwellings of those who were peaceably inclined, by way of intimidation. This and similar conduct at other collieries led to the publication of the placard by the magistrates to which we have alluded, and it seems to have had a most salutary effect, for the men on finding that they were protected proceeded to their labour, and were joined by many others, who had no doubt been induced to join the turn-outs through fear, and have continued to work peaceably and unmolested ever since.

Thus, we hope, this unpleasant state of things amongst the miners will terminate, though Brophy and his confederates, with their waning influence, have been daily doing their utmost to cherish that base spirit of resentment and bad feeling, which they have all along laboured so hard to propagate.

Brophy, finding we presume that his oratory was not producing the desired effect, issued an address "To the Inhabitants of Cumberland generally, and to the Miners of Great Britain and Ireland," which he palms upon the public as coming from the committee, in which is given such false and grossly exaggerated statements of earnings and hours of labour that there can be no doubt of its having been written by Brophy, inasmuch as it contains statements characterised by that scandalous disregard for truth which has distinguished all his declamatory speeches to the miners. We shall pass over his statements about tyranny and robbery, as they are wholly unworthy of regard, and call attention to the infamous falsehood contained in the statement, that the men labour from 15 to 18 hours for the paltry sum of from 1s 9d to 2s 3d.

The person who published this unfounded statement has an object to serve, and the manner in which he seeks to serve it is worthy of the end he is so anxious to accomplish. We have, however, had access to authentic documents, relative to the Whitehaven Coal Miners, which incontestably prove the falsehood of this statement. From these documents, the accuracy of which is beyond dispute, it appears that some of the colliers are earning upwards of four shillings and six-pence per day, and the majority of them upwards of three shillings per day, whilst none of them have so low a return for their labour as the maximum of earnings stated in the address.

With regard to the equally unfounded statement so frequently put forth by Brophy respecting the robberies practised upon the men by the stewards in stopping their baskets, the documents we have before us are equally explicit; and we feel bound to say that any stoppage of this kind are of so trifling a nature — so unimportant in amount, that there must have been a straining after something to find fault with, otherwise they never would have been mentioned, as they can hardly be considered even a drop in the bucket. Nevertheless, unimportant as these stoppages are they are absolutely necessary, and are only kept at their present low aggregate by the scrupulous care and attention, which it is known are exercised by both the bankmen and pickers. Besides, there is not a hagger in the mines who does not know that if he sends his basket up imperfectly filled, or if he conceal slate or refuse amongst the good coal, that such basket will not be paid for; but take off these restrictions and then let us ask whether the evil would or would not be increased. If we could be assured that they would not, we would in that case at once give in to the doctrine that it would not be worth while making those petty deductions which to answer the base purpose of the itinerant spouter have been magnified tenfold.

Then with respect to the tyranny exercised over the men, we may also state that this accusation is equally false. The Whitehaven Collieries, like all other extensive works, are governed by general rules, which the reciprocal interests of the employer and the employed alike require. When a miner first engages himself to work in these collieries, he is supplied with gear, or working implements, consisting of picks, wedges, hammers, &c., which are exchanged and repaired from time to time at the expense of the proprietor. These implements cost from 3/- to 4/-, which is stopped off the workman's wages at the rate of 1s. per week for a short period, after which the instalment is reduced to 6d. per week. Each miner has to provide himself with riddles, shovels, safety lamps, and pick shafts, all of which are supplied to him at the lowest cost price, which, if properly taken care of only amounts to a very trifling sum per week. When the miner leaves the works, on his delivering up the gear, every article is taken back at its full cost, and the amount paid, with the exemption of the riddles, &c., which are paid for according to what they are then worth. The deductions in the aggregate generally amount to about 1s. 6d. per week, and may be fairly taken as an average of about 3l. per day. On the other hand, however, the pitmen pay no rent for their houses, which are worth from 1s. 6d. to 2s. per week; they are moreover allowed 6d. each per week to purchase coals with, and have the privilege of small coal being laid down at their doors at the merely nominal charge of one penny per cwt. At one time a large cart of small coal was delivered at the door of each family every five or six weeks; but this act of benevolence was so grossly abused that the circumstances led to the present change. The Earl of Lonsdale invariably defrays the expenses of medical attendance in all-cases of accident; but the men are subject to a small deduction for medical attendance in cases of casual sickness to themselves or any member of their families, which amounts to only four pence per month for married men who have families, and two pence per month for single men. In all cases of accident the sum of 5s per week is paid to persons who are injured so long as they are unable to work.

This, then, is a true statement of the case, and this is the system, which Brophy has expended so much idle and profligate breath in denouncing as tyrannical! Would that thousands of British operatives who are and have been out of employment could be permanently employed under similar systems! How many a heart would be gladdened if this wish could be realised! The poor cotton weaver couped up in a damp workshop, and in an unhealthy and impure atmosphere, labours longer hours than the miner, and after all is not able to earn a sum equal to one-fourth part of the miner's wages. We do not consequently wish it to be inferred that the wages of the miner ought to be reduced to a level with those of the cotton weaver. We wish to see all British operatives fairly paid according to the demand for their labour, and they may depend upon it that the price of all labour, of whatever kind it may be, will be invariably regulated by the existing difference in the market between the supply and the demand. That is a fixed principle in political economy which no combinations, either on the part of the employers or the employed will ever subvert. It is wicked, then, on the part of such shallow-pated babblers as Brophy to attempt to persuade poor men who have families depending upon their expertise for a livelihood to throw themselves out of bread, and to cast themselves and their families destitute upon the world in order that he may pick their pockets in his ridiculous attempt to realise the visionary objects of his Utopian project — the National Union.

There is one very favourable feature, however, in the proceedings of the past week, and that is, the men have begun to think for themselves. However dimly the dangers to which they would be exposed by joining the Union may yet be shadowed forth in their minds, they have contemplated dangers sufficient to alarm them, which have produced in them a better state of feeling, and hence the reason why so many have returned to their employment in the very face of the principle advice which has every day been inadvisably given. Those miners who have returned to their work may rely upon it that they have come to a wise resolution for themselves, and a beneficial one for their families; and we have no fear whatever but others will speedily follow their example. See if the miners will only ask by which Brophy is actuated, we will not do them the discredit the slightest apprehension for the result.

Since writing the above, we have been presented with another lengthy handbill in the shape of an address from the miners of this town to the citizens of Dublin, and to the consumers of coal on the north coast of Ireland. This document, which bears the names of 335 miners, is a monstrous collection of falsehoods, exaggerated statements, and wicked inventions on the part of Brophy, by whom it was no doubt penned, and of whose unprincipled mind it bears such striking evidence. The low and vulgar style in which it is written ought to have prevailed upon every printer of character to have rejected such a disgraceful composition as an abuse of the press; but there are unfortunately those in the profession for whom nothing is too low, and the beastly production found its way before the public through the same press that has inundated the town with the indecent and trashy productions of the Socialists. We believe we may state to the credit of the county that there is only one press in it that would have put forth such an infamous production, and that press is to be found in a garret in King Street, from whence the principles of vice and immorality are disseminated by wholesale.

It would really be worse than idle to attempt to refute any one statement, which this handbill contains, because they are so utterly groundless that to attempt to combat them would be equally as absurd as it would be to give battle to a shadow. There is one statement, however, in which we really must call attention, and we seriously submit it to the consideration of every miner, who occupies the relative position in society of either father, husband, or brother, and when he has perused it calmly and deliberately, we ask him — and we ask the public — what they think of the man who could designedly publish so infamous and calumniating a statement as the following: -

"Good God! Irishmen! Lovers of Virtue! think of Mothers and of Daughters having to prostitute themselves to Overmen and Deputies, in order to mitigate or lessen the penalties imposed upon husbands, sons, and brothers, and to secure to either of them an additional day's work. Think of these things! and then say whether or not we are justified in uniting to protect the virtue and property of our children!"

Miners of Whitehaven! Does your very blood not boil in your veins when you see such an infamous charge publicly brought forward against your sisters, wives, and daughters! By the love you bear them, we call upon you to give an open public contradiction to this foul aspersion cast by an iterant calumniating scoundrel, upon those who so justly look to you for protection. Had we not positively seen this statement in print we should not have believed that any villain, more particularly a stranger, and one of very questionable reputation, would have dared to offer you such an insult, as to tell the public that you live not upon labour honestly and fairly procured by yourselves, but obtained, you are told, by the open prostitution of your sisters, wives, and daughters!!! If you tamely sit down under such an accusation as this, you are no longer worthy of being looked upon as men — you will be despised as unworthy fathers, husbands, and brothers — you will looked upon as beings devoid of those feelings and affections which are the common inheritance of our nature — and the very name of a miner will become a mockery and a byword to signify everything that is low and degraded.

The mischievous intentions of the vagabond Brophy in circulating these gross and injurious falsehoods on the other side of the channel is very obvious; it is to create a sympathy in the minds of the Irish people in behalf of their countrymen whom he so falsely represents as the victims of tyranny and oppression, and upon that sympathy, should he succeed in rousing it, he seeks to establish a prejudice against all coals sent to Ireland from Whitehaven! This is the villain's object; but does he not understand, and are the miners so blind as not to see, that the result of Brophy's success would be to deprive the men of their labour, and to bring upon each of their innocent families increased poverty, wretchedness, and ruin! If the men ever bestow one moment's reflection on their positions they cannot but perceive the ruin that must inevitably be their lot if Brophy could carry his intentions into effect. In one word, all the schemes of this base fellow have a tendency to injure the interests of the workmen whom he professes to serve; and it is our sincere convictions that Brophy is quite as much an enemy to the miner as he professes to be to the employer, because the miner is in his power, but the employer is not. The fellow finds that in coming to Whitehaven he has fallen in luck's way, and he seems to know it. There is not any fear of his discontinuing his course of agitation amongst the miners, so long as he is pocketing his collections at their meetings, selling copies of the rules of the Union, and disposing of cards of membership, for which he also has his charge, but we strongly suspect that his vocation is near a close. When Brophy first came to Whitehaven he uttered some pretty strong hints about his poverty, and gave the miners also to understand that he had his expectancies. It is evident that Brophy's expectations have been flattered and more than fulfilled, as he has in all probability netted upwards of twenty pounds in this district during the last three weeks by pocketing the Union entrance fee and disposing of his rules and cards, independent of collections that have been made for him amongst the crowds whom he addressed on the subject of "labours rights and labours remedies"!

The miners in Whitehaven will yet see this fellow's regard for "labours rights and labours remedies" put to the test, which, they may rest assured, will be the moment they stop the supplies. Do the miners imagine that a man in Brophy's condition of life, out of pure zeal for their interests, has come here to spend his time amongst them? We think, on reflection, that they can never be so foolish as to entertain such a thought. Brophy came here a stranger, and he yet remains one, for he takes good care not to lift the veil on any occasion, which he has thrown over his past life. The miners know as little of him as they did on the first day he came amongst them, but he knows much more of them, and had he not found a ready way into their pockets, we opine his acquaintance and theirs would have been marvellously brief, and the mercenary zeal which he has shown for labours rights and remedies would unquestionably have undergone a great abridgement.

We have stated that this mercenary champion of the rights of labour has realized upwards of twenty pounds, which he has drawn from the pockets of the poor miners, for whose poverty he professes so deep a sympathy? We will prove it. According to the seventh rule of the Miners' Association, (a copy of the whole of which we have now before us,) each member has to pay sixpence entrance money — one penny each for a card of membership, and as such a simple article as a card is charged for, it is only reasonable to suppose that each member will be charged a similar sum for a copy of the rules, so that the matter will then stand thus:

 £ s d
Entrance money for 700 members at 6d each 17 10 0
Cards of membership for do. at 1d each 2 18 4
Rules supplied to do. at 1d each 2 18 4
 £23 6 8

And besides this sum, as we have observed, this fellow has pocketed several pounds which were collected for him. We have assumed in our calculations that he has obtained 350 members in Whitehaven, and as a proof that we have not been extravagant in our calculations; one of the placards contains the names of nearly 350 men. It is certainly then but a very moderate calculation to set down other 350 members for the remaining mines in West Cumberland, which makes in the aggregate 700 members, the number on which we have based our calculations. We must, however, impress upon the minds of our readers that we are far within the number, which might have been taken into account in its above statement.

This is really monstrous, and did we not know it to be a fact, it would seem altogether incredible, that men whose situations are represented to be so poverty stricken, should in the short space of three weeks, supply such a sum of money to a person of whom they know so little, and under such circumstances. Why, truly, the fact is enough to impress upon the minds of the employers of the miners that their wages are to high, and that they have too much money to spare, when they lavish such a large sum upon such a lazy worthless vagabond as the creature Brophy. Miners! Look to your pockets! Be wise, and act discreetly, or your conduct will certainly in the end be more injurious to yourselves than it can be to your employers. Discard the viper you have been nursing in your bosom ere he inflicts upon you a fatal injury. The eyes of the public are upon your conduct, and that public views you as victims with an eye of pity, and Brophy as your deceiver with feelings of unmingled contempt. If you are determined to continue the victim of this man, the tide of public feeling will fast set to against you; for we are convinced that there is no class of society in Whitehaven, the members of which are not of opinion that Brophy, for his own selfish ends, is dragging you onward to irretrievable ruin. In consideration, we again conjure you, in pity to your families, in justice to yourselves to free yourselves from the bond of the Union, and discard the worthless and unfeeling vulture who, whilst he has been hypocritically wailing over your poverty, has been mercilessly praying upon the very vitals of your families, and insulting yourselves, your wives, and your daughters by uttering in his speeches, and publishing in his placards, one of the foulest calumnies by which the female character can be assailed, and such as no man worthy of the name of farther, husband, or brother would suffer to be cast on the virtues and character of any female to whom he might stand in any of those pacifies of relationship. As you would protect your own interests, guard also the virtues and integrity of your families, and show the man who dares to assail the characters of your wives and daughters that you are men possessed of courage to defend them, and that the man does not exist who shall assail them with impurity. This line of conduct, miners! is due to yourselves as men — it is due to the public, in the face of whom the chastity of your wives and daughters have been assailed — and the injured females demand it as a right from you on whom they properly hang their hope of protection.

Our Maryport correspondent thus speaks of the issue of the recent turn-out of the miners in that town and neighbourhood, from which it is evident that the iterant vagabond who has caused so much uneasiness in this part of the county has completed his harvest amongst us, as his villainous object is being discovered in all quarters, and the sooner therefore he betakes himself to his heels and is off the better for himself. We shall be much deceived if the fellow does not avail himself of our hint, and leave his dupes to bewail their folly in having for a moment countenance and succoured one of the most foul-mouthed slanderers that ever before preyed on the credulity of any class of her Majesty's subjects. Our correspondent says: -

The misunderstanding which the inflammatory addresses of Brophy caused between the miners and their employers in this district is nearly over — the breach which he effected and on which he exists is now closed, and a perfect reconciliation is daily being brought about by the men in great numbers signing's total renunciation of the Union, and resuming their work.

The deluded men express their sorrow for having leagued themselves with this arch enemy to their interests, and we trust the fleecing he has given his poor victims will be the means of preventing them in future from becoming the dupes of itinerant pseudo-chartist lecturers, whose business it is to create the most fiendish hatred to masters, to minister to the bad passions of the men, and pocket a handsome weekly salary in the shape of toil from their earnings. This is his trade he has no sympathy with the colliers — he is entirely ignorant of their business and their alleged grievances. The men having found this out, and discovered that his violence has done them irreparable injury, the sooner the vagabond leaves this part of the country the better for himself, as he may depend upon it his work of agitation cannot be much longer carried on with gain to himself, even if he be allowed to follow it peaceably which we very much question.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Brophy, —      
Lonsdale, Earl of      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print