7th June 1842
The Cumberland Coal Mines
By Jettinger C. Symons, Esq. on the Employment of Children and Young Persons in the Mines of the Cumberland Coal Field; and on the State, Condition, and Treatment of such Children and Young Persons.
TO HER MAJESTY'S COMMISSIONERS.
London, August 12th, 1841.
Gentlemen
1. The fortnight allotted to me for a rapid investigation of the Cumberland Collieries has enabled me to report merely on the prominent features of the condition of those who are the subjects of our inquiry. I found evidence in some cases difficult to
obtain, owing to the extreme fear of offending great men, on the part of timid or dependent witnesses.
2. The children do not begin to work in the Cumberland Collieries so early as in Yorkshire; for the coal seams are all of a good thickness; in the inland collieries they are at least four or five feet thick. Ten years is a common age for children to
begin to work; and they seldom commence before eight and a half years of age.
3. I can form no correct estimate of the numbers of children who work in the Cumberland Pits. They certainly are not so numerous, even in proportion to the men, as in Yorkshire.
4. This is chiefly owing to the far greater use of horses for conveying the coals from the foreheads (banks) to the shaft. In all Lord Lonsdale's collieries, and in fact, generally on the coast of Cumberland, no lads or children are employed in
trailing, putting, or hurrying. The coal is all worked out on the Newcastle plan, which it is of course needless to describe to you; and this, together with the height of the coal seam, admits of the horses being brought up to the workings, thence
drawing the corves or baskets away.
5. Boys and lads are consequently employed to drive the trams of baskets or corves, of which several are hooked together, along the tramways. These journeys are greatly lengthened owing to many of the large collieries being submarine. In the William Pit
they have 500 acres under the sea, and the distance is two miles and a half from the shaft to the extreme part of the workings. There is a stable also under the sea, in this immense pit, for forty — five horses. The shaft is 110 fathoms.
6. And here I must state that a feature exists in this driving employment I have not hitherto seen, and which constitutes the chief labour of the occupation. To prevent the basket from running down hill and falling on the heels of the horses, it is
customary for the driver to place himself as a post between the foremost basket and the buttock of the horse. He places his left shoulder against the horse, the right foot on the rail of the tram, and the right hand on the top of the basket; the left leg
being generally supported by the trace. When the train of corves is heavily laden, or the descent very steep, a pole is placed through the hind wheels of the trams, and thus it is in a measure dragged. Nevertheless the work is very toilsome, and as will
be seen by the evidence of the surgeon attending Earl Lonsdale's collieries, accidents sometimes occur by the foot slipping off, and getting struck by part of the wheel or axle. The leaning position in which they stand is not in itself, I think,
injurious; but the work itself strikes one as being palpably unnecessary, and as an objectionable preference of the human body for a mere mechanical process; for which shafts might be, and in some of the inland pits are, used instead. It was indeed
stated by one witness, that the use of shafts would be very awkward for the purpose of turning at the foreheads. I believe a very little management would obviate this difficulty. See Evidence of No's. 306, 309, 328.
7. Trappers are employed likewise in nearly all the pits, and their work is somewhat augmented by having occasionally two or more doors to attend to, and by having to alter checks, so that the trains may pass along their proper roads at the dividing
places.
8. The trailers are employed chiefly in the smaller and inland collieries. They seldom, however, trail or hurry further than from the foreheads to use "stake," or terminus of the horse road. Their work is decidedly laborious, but so nearly
resembling the same employment in Yorkshire, that it is needless to repeat the description of the work. In some few pits the men trail themselves exclusively.
9. The children certainly work longer hours in Cumberland than I have found general in Yorkshire. They seem to work 12 hours habitually, and in some of the inland collieries even longer. Owing to the inefficient power of the drawing-engine in one of
these collieries belonging to Mr. Westray, the day's work has been extended to 14 or 15 hours; but this cannot be considered other than an accidental circumstance. It is, however, by no means uncommon for pits to work 13 hours a day without a
change of hands.
10. In most of Lord Lonsdale's extensive collieries they work night and day — the shift who work the twelve day hours one week working the twelve night hours the succeeding week, and so on, alternately. The appearance of the adults in these
collieries was remarkably pallid and emaciated. I should attribute this greatly to the system of night-working; and there is a probability that the change from night to day hours operates more unfavourably on the health than it would do were they to work
altogether at night. In the latter case habit becomes second nature, and sleep as refreshing is obtained by day as by night. Not so when the animal system is subjected to continual change, no habit is formed, and according to the evidence the rest
obtained in the day is very deficient; so much so, as to render the night-work irksome through the inclination for sleep. The wife generally goes to bed by day with her husband, and so do all the family, and the door is often fastened to preserve as much
quiet as possible. In some few pits eight-hour shifts are worked.
11. The wages of both men and children are very good; they vary from 1s to 2s for the drivers and trailers, and from 18s to 25s for the adult colliers.
12. In one colliery (see Evidence 314) I found the wages of the adults amounted to 30s a week, they being at liberty to work as long as they pleased. I took pains to ascertain the effect of these high wages on their comforts and conduct. I found that
they were no better off than those in other places who earned from 20s to 25s. They drink and live more luxuriantly for perhaps two days, and are often ill off for the rest of the week. I need barely add that they are tearfully ignorant; and although,
strange to say, they will take lessons of an itinerant dancing master, numbers feel no sort of shame in being ignorant of their letters, or of bringing up their children without schooling.
13. The accidents in the Whitehaven and Workington collieries were, all within the last eighteen months, most numerous and fearfully fatal. They have arisen chiefly from fire-damp and interruptions of the sea.
14. The accident which occurred in Mr. Curwen's pits near Workington, about two years ago, from an irruption of the sea, was foretold by many. It appears that the seam of coal rose under the sea, so that in working it every step brought the
colliers nearer to the water. They had proceeded a considerable distance with the workings — I believe nearly two miles — in a direct line from the shore. The salt water is said to have oozed through, and some of the men had heard, or said
they had heard, the sound of the sea above them. So great was the apprehension that some of the colliers left their work, and others were only induced to stay by a higher amount of wages. At length the water rushed suddenly in, and though some who were
near enough to the entrance escaped, about forty fell victims, and remain to this hour in the pit. The sea, of course, rapidly filled it, and a black gurgling whirlpool for some time marked the aperture and the entrance of the waters at a considerable
distance from the shore. The rush of air expelled by the water was so violent that it blew the hats off those who stood near. The blame was attached to Coxton, the steward, who then had charge of the work. He was specially and strongly recommended
to Mr. Curwen by Mr. Dunn of Newcastle, and in whom he not unnaturally placed confidence in preference to the reports which reached him from third parties. Coxton would have been torn limb from limb could he have been found by the heart —
rent assemblage of the relatives of the sufferers, who thronged to the spot. There cannot be a stronger instance of the danger of trusting the management of coal pits to subordinate and often-incompetent persons than this inundation at Workington. It is
right to state that the steward was immediately dismissed; and that under the management of the present steward, Mr. Penrice, no accident at any of the pits has occurred worth naming for several months. See evidence of Nos. 317, 322, 331, 332, and
334.
15. Prior, however, to the stewardship of Mr. Penrice, another very fatal accident occurred at John Pit, Harrington, belonging to Mr. Curwen, where 24 or 25 persons were burnt to death. At one of Lord Lonsdale's collieries, the William Pit, a similar
accident, by which an equal number lost their lives, occurred the year before last. On this occasion Mr. Mitchell, the surgeon, accidentally hit upon carbonate ammonia dissolved in hot water as a remedy to be applied to persons burnt. See his
evidence on this point, No. 312.
16. I feel it right to direct attention to the statement of Mr. Mitchell (No. 312), to the effect that the coroner has in no instance required him to make post mortem examinations of persons crushed to death by falls of roofs; without this requirement on
the part of the coroner it cannot be done; and this negligence consequently deprives professional men of the information they might otherwise apply to future cases. I applied to the coroner on this point, as well as for a general statement of the
accidents, which had occurred.
The following is the answer of the coroner: -
"Whitehaven, Carter Lane
5th August, 1841.
Sir.
"I am sorry I cannot furnish the statement of all the fatal accidents which have come under my cognisance, as coroner, arising from coal pits, with the nature of the accident, the verdict, the date, and the number of sufferers during the last three
years. All the inquisitions are sent every Quarter Sessions to the Clerk of the Peace, with whom they will be found, and the cause of death endorsed on each. Post mortem examinations can rarely be of any use in deaths occasioned by accidents in coal
pits, for in most cases the person is killed on the spot, especially when it happens, which is the case in most instances, by the roof of the pit falling on the miner. We have experienced, but not recently, dreadful loss of life by the explosion of
inflammable air, but most frequently no one survives to give any account of how the melancholy event occurred.
"I have, &c,.
(Signed)
P. Hodgson.
To J. C. Symons, Esq
18. That post mortem examinations can rarely be of any use in cases of deaths by accidents in coal pits is an assertion which every medical man can confute; the rareness of these examinations is, on the contrary, a most serious evil; and many cases are
not improbably lost for want of that better insight into the nature of internal injuries, both in cases of burns and contusions, which post mortem examinations can alone supply.
19. A very experienced surgeon in another coal district, in the course of a conversation on burns, attributed the difficulty in curing patients to the necessity of giving stimulants to produce reaction after collapse, when the inflammation has been
internal, and where stimulants will themselves increase the inflammation; whether the carbonate of ammonia may obviate this evil is a question of great importance. Certain it is, that persons apparently but little burnt, and who are able to walk home
from the pits after the accident, above a mile, have subsequently died whilst under medical treatment! Medical science seems to have extended less in this department than any other. From all the evidence I have been able to gather, especially from
persons who had been burnt, I should incline to the belief that the injury was internal, whilst the treatment is chiefly external.
20. Accidents from ropes breaking are almost unheard of in Cumberland; nevertheless the ropes used are no larger than in Yorkshire, the pits are double the depth; and the weight drawn is quite as heavy, and often heavier. This can be alone attributed to
the system of drawing the baskets up bratticed shafts without any conductors at all. There is nothing to catch or jerk the ropes, to which the accidents are chiefly referable, which occur so very frequently to Yorkshire.
21. The Pits are usually well ventilated, and tolerable dry; Lord Lonsdale's are especially so. Mr. W. Peile makes some remarks on the theory of ventilation, and the best mode of affecting it, in which I desire to direct your attentions. See
Evidence, No. 311.
Accidents in the Collieries of Lord Lonsdale, on the Whingill side, out of some hundred men and boys. From June 1st, 1840. to June 1841.
| 1st Jun 1841, Land pits. | Haggers. | Drivers. | Trappers. |
| Crushed by falling of the roof | 5 | | 2 |
| Crushed, causing death | 2 | 1 | |
| Burnt | 11 | | |
| Burnt, causing death | 2 | | |
| Fractures | 1 | 3 | |
| Trifling accidents | 48 | 14 | 2 |
| | 69 | 18 | 4 |
Off work from three to twenty days, and only through cuts or trifling wounds, so long a time as twenty days
22. The children are well treated, except as regards the extreme length of time they are confined to the pits; they are in appearance quite as stunted in growth, and present much the same physical phenomena, as those of Yorkshire — comparing, of
course, those following similar branches of the work. I do not however consider the children, as a body, unhealthy.
23. The morals of the children are very indifferent, and the evidence given is a fair sample of their state of education. They are as ignorant as it is well possible to conceive children to be; not are the lads of from 13 to 18 years old one jot more
informed; but as far as I could ascertain, less so. It is not to be supposed that children confined for 12 hours in a coal pit can have opportunities for any sort of education. There are instances of its being previously acquired and retained, and some
were selected in Lord Lonsdale's colliery; but this is by no means the rule; and the mental and moral destitution in which the great body of the collier children are growing up in Cumberland is fearfully great.
24. The evidence of the child John Holmes (321) is a very fair sample of the general state of education among these benighted children: — "I don't go to a Sunday School, because I don't like, and I'd rather play. I used to read the
Testament. I don't know who Jesus Christ was. I never heard tell of God neither. I am taught to say my prayers, and I say them. I don't know who I pray to. The education of a parrot is precisely similar, and quite as beneficial to the recipient.
25. The employment of females in coal pits is rapidly disappearing under the general odium it excites; but very few remain, and only, as far as I learned, in one old colliery of Lord Lonsdale's.
26. I visited an iron ore mine belonging to Messrs. Tulk and Ley, where the ore lies 25 or 30 feet in thickness, and where the roads are about five feet thick; the men themselves trail, and there are few children employed.
I have the honour to be Gentlemen,.
Your very obedient servant.
J. C. SYMONS
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Coxton, — | | | |
| Curwen, — | | | |
| Dunn, — | | | |
| Hodgson, Peter | | Coroner | |
| Holmes, John | | | |
| Ley, — | | | |
| Lonsdale, Lord | | | |
| Mitchell, — | | | |
| Peile, W. | | | |
| Penrice, — | | | |
| Symons, Jettinger C. | | Commissioner | |
| Tulk, — | | | |
| Westray, — | | | |