Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

Gateshead Observer

Article from the Gateshead Observer, 24th April 1841


Colliery explosion at Willington

Another of those no less frequent than unavoidable calamities which desolate the homes of our mining population, by suddenly sweeping into eternity numbers of their relations and friends, on whose labour they depend for the means of subsidence, took place on Monday last, at one of the collieries at Willington, called the "Big Pit," (Matthew Bell, Esq., M.P., Dixon Brown, Esq., and George Johnson, Esq., owners) This colliery had been laid off for a number of years, in consequence of the seam of coal having been wrought out. It was commenced again a months ago by the opening out of a new seam, called the "Bensham seam," about 30 fathoms lower down, which is the seam now working at Wallsend colliery.

The explosion took place at about twenty minutes past one o'clock on Monday afternoon, and was made known to those at the bank by a very load report, and a dense volume of smoke suddenly issuing from the mouth of the shaft. Nothing had occurred from which such a catastrophe could have been anticipated ; and at eleven in the forenoon, when a portion of the men left off work, the workings were in their usual condition. In this as in almost every other case of a like nature, the cause of the accident is involved in obscurity, from the fact that those who alone could have furnished a clue to it, shared in the general destruction. There were in the pit at the time, 35 men and boys, 32 of whom perished.

The three persons who were preserved alive, and almost unhurt were :— Michael Ranson, Henry Dunn, and George Charlton, a boy. They were sinkers, and employed in another part of the mine, about half a mile distant from where it took fire, and near the workings of the "Edward" pit. Both the fire and the "after damp" had consequently become exhausted before they could reach the spot. The situation of these men was, however, not withstanding, one of considerable peril, from the quantity of dust which was violently blown about them, and with which they were like to have been suffocated. They were splendidly extricated, the viewers and a party of workmen having descended as soon as possible after the explosion.

There were four bodies brought up the same afternoon. The men worked the whole of Tuesday and Tuesday night ; and at six o'clock yesterday morning, all the bodies had been found except four. These were George Campbell, John Campbell, John Brown, and John Hall ; about 12 o'clock, the body of George Campbell was brought up, much mutilated, having been buried under a heap of fallen material, from which it took three hours to extricate him, after he was discovered. Up to four o'clock there were no more bodies found ; one of the workmen said that they did not know where to look for the rest. The fire was still not quite extinguished, though water had been constantly conveyed down from Monday afternoon.

It is a circumstance worthy of particular notice that a pony also survived the dreadful catastrophe. This animal was both lame and blind, and had been in the pit for a great number of years : indeed, for a period beyond the recollection of the oldest workman, one of whom said he remembered it even when he was a boy. It had become a special favourite ; and its preservation seems to have been almost miraculous, as it was in the mine for twenty six hours after the explosion, without either water or food.

It would be useless to attempt to paint the scene at the Bank, as the mouth of the mine is technically termed. As a measure of precaution, the women and parties who could be of no avail, were kept at a distance from the spot, which exhibited a most melancholy aspect, the vicinity of the Bank being occupied with coffins ready to receive the wretched remains of the deceased as they were brought to light.

Some of the bodies were much disfigured ; others were little injured, having, as it was supposed, survived the fire, and been suffocated by what is called the "after-damp," or accumulation of noxious gas which is left after the fire subsides. This colliery was always consider safe. It was visited, about a month ago, by a party of ladies, who were much entertained with the appearance of order and caution in the works, the stables and other erections being all whitewashed.

At half past two o'clock on Wednesday, the coroner, Stephen Reed, Esq., and a respectable jury, met at the house of Mr. Henry Wardale, sign of the Engine, Willington. After the jury had been sworn, having previously viewed a number of the bodies, the coroner briefly addressed them on the nature of their duties, and said that as there were yet three bodies in the pit, and other circumstances which would prevent them from entering properly into the investigation that day, he would not trouble them further, but adjourn the inquest until Thursday, as 12 o'clock ; and in the mean time made out orders of burial for those who wished to have their friends interred immediately. — Northern Advertiser.

[FROM THE COURANT]

The workings are, comparatively, most extensive, the eats headway running 280?? yards, and the west headway 280?? yards, while that to the north is even much shorter. The shaft is sunk to the depth of 149 fathoms, the High Main Seam being passed through, and the working of the Bensham Seam fairly carried on.

There were employed in the pit at the time of the explosion 35 men and boys, and the first intimation which those at the bank received of their fellows' danger, was the tremendous report, accompanied by a dense volume of smoke. The effect upon the earth for a considerable distance round, is said, in some degree, to have resembled that produced by the shock of an earthquake, the whole surface appearing, as it were, to quiver. The noise was heard far in every direction, more especially eastward, the wind at the time blowing strong towards that quarter : and the melancholy tidings were thus proclaimed throughout the whole neighbourhood by the very agency which wrought the mischief. Relatives, and all in any way connected or sympathising with those engaged in the work, were drawn to the spot, manifesting in every look and action the dismay anxiety, the gloomy foreboding, or the intense sorrow, with which the occurrence had overwhelmed them. Two men — Michael Ransom and Henry Dunn — and George Charlton, a boy, all sinkers, were employed at some distance in the east headway, and were made sensible of their danger by the dust and wind which came upon them. Fortunately, the after-damp was spent, and they reached the shaft without being injured ; there they found that stones and woodwork at the bottom were torn from their places and had fastened the "cage;" but, after much labour, they were rescued from their perilous position and conveyed to the top in safety, Without loss of time, and with a readiness which, while it bespoke their feeling, displayed their courage, a body of workmen descended and forthwith commenced their melancholy work. The labour, exhausting though it was, was continued unremittingly, until the bodies of the thirty-two sufferers were recovered. Amongst the number obtained in the earlier part of the search, were three, who, though much mangled, were yet alive : they were immediately conveyed to where the most judicious assistance could be afforded, but they shortly afterwards died in excruciating agony. In another part of the west headway lay three more, completely dead, one of whom was dresses, and had his night-cap stuffed in his mouth ; the others had a part of their clothes on ; and it is accordingly presumed that these unfortunate men, aware of the peril they were in, had ventured on an attempt to escape. Twenty nine bodies had been obtained on Wednesday, and in the course of Thursday the remaining three were found.

Many of the bodies were in a sound state, indicating that their death had been the result of suffocation. In the majority of cases they were mutilated, and presenting a sight truly appalling ; in others, the falling of the stone and props, which were wrenched from their places by the one devouring power, had so completely unhumanised them — so broken very bone and muscle — that the coffins had to be sent down, to prevent limb falling from limb, while being conveyed up the shaft.

How or where the calamity originated must ever remain matter of speculation. The seam which was being worked, was the same as that in which the accident at Wallsend happened, and is generally spoken of as being attended with greater risk than other seams. Those about the pit, and who, though interested, may be considered the most competent judges in the matter, positively state that no apprehension of danger existed in the mind of any one — that, on the contrary, perfect confidence prevailed, and was justified by the care and labour which had everywhere been bestowed. The solution put forward as the most probable, and is supported by concurrent testimony, is that the whole is attributable to the neglect of a boy, "a trapper," who left the trap door in the north headway, to which it was his duty to attend, to play with two other boys close by, It is essential that these doors be shut, except at the very moment when the "putter" is passing ; and in the present instance, it is supposed the boy propped open his door — that it remained thus for some time — and that the necessary ventilation was thereby prevented.

[FROM OUR REPORTERS]

Previous to reporting the proceedings of the adjourned inquest, held on Thursday last, we give a correct list of the sufferers by this impressive calamity :—

Thomas Wood, 39, wood-leader, has left a wife and six children. Michael Martin, 38, hewer, has left a wife and four children. William Martin, 10, trapper, son of the above. John Campbell, 34, hewer, unmarried. George Campbell, 18, putter, nephew of the above. [The last four were all united by near ties of relationship. George Campbell's mother was Michael Martin's sister.] Thomas Dodgson, 27, hewer, recently married. William Dodgson, 25, hewer, brother of the above. Jonathan Crosier, 20, putter, unmarried. John Joyce, 23, putter, unmarried. William Howey, 24, putter, has left a wife and two children. Robert Brown, 19, putter, unmarried. George Martin, 17, putter. — [The family of this young man has suffered severely from coal pit accidents. He had a brother killed about fourteen months ago by a fall of a portion of the roofing in Bell and Brown's Wallsend pit ; his father, some years ago, met his death by a rush of water ; and, at a later period, his grandfather, by an explosion — both at the same colliery.] William Coxon, 36, hewer, a widower, has left one child. Joseph Johnson, 27, hewer, unmarried. Thomas Bainbridge, 18, putter. William Bainbridge, 11, trapper, brother of the above. Simpson Mason, 10, trapper. Thomas Bolton, 9, trapper. James Liddell, 14, putter. Thomas Pearson, 15, driver. Robert Pearson, 9, trapper, brother of the above. James Pearson, 18, putter. John Reed, 28, deputy, unmarried. Robert Black, 15, driver. John Crawford, 22, onsetter, unmarried. Richard Cooper, 9, trapper, [supposed to have been the cause of the explosion, by leaving his trap-door open, and going to play with some of the other trappers.] Matthew Ranson, 15, onsetter. John Hall, 16, driver. John Brown, 13, trapper. Robert Campbell, 14, driver. Joseph Crosby, 17, craneman. George Scott, 9, trapper. — John Crawford, Robert Black, and James Pearson, were alive when taken out of the pit, but expired very shortly after.

The first witness called on the inquest was —

Thomas Campbell (a deputy, and the father of one of the sufferers). Is a pitman and has been three months employed in this pit, which is the Bigge Pit. Went down into the pit every day, and remained there seven hours. His duty was, to examine it, and see the men, and what was going on ; and particularly to the ventilation of the pit. The air in general was very good ; on the morning of the accident was quite cool — so much so, that the men complained of being cold. When the air is cool, it is an indication of being pure — when hot and oppressive, of its impurity. No "blowers" of gas had ever been known in this pit — the little gas generated being always carried off by the current of fresh air circulating throughout the workings : this current was caused by the furnace at the upcast of the pit.

[A plan of Willington Colliery was here shown by Mr. Johnson, one of the proprietors, from which it appeared that the workings were as yet but little extended. In his (Mr. J's) opinion, the ventilation has perfect. He had been down into the pit that morning to examine it ; and from that examination, he was inclined to think that the explosion had been caused by one of the boys leaving his "trapdoor" to go and play with some of the other lads : and he was strengthened in his opinion by the fact, that the body of this lad (Cooper) was found in a very different position from that in which it would have been had he been at his door. The door being thus neglected, he thought the gas had escaped from the workings ; and one of the men coming with a candle, the gas had exploded, and thus caused this dreadful loss of life.]

Thomas Campbell (resumed):— The pitmen used candles, not Davy lamps, the pit being considered so safe as not to require the latter. He had himself been down the pit with a candle since the accident ; was there when his son's body was found. There were four boys who had charge of these trap-doors. Their duty was to open and shut them as the men passed through with coals. His son was a "putter." From his examination of the pit, he thought Mr. Johnson correct in his opinion as to the cause of the explosion. His son was 18 years of age.

The Coroner :— Should not the door (being, as you say, constructed so as to close with the force of the current of air circulating in the workings,) have shut of itself when left? unless, indeed, it had been propped open by the boy in charge, when he went away.

Mr. Johnson and the witness Campbell answered in the affirmative to this interrogative of the Coroner : and the latter also stated that all employed in the pit had been warned of the danger of leaving the doors open ; so that if his son — who had to come through this (as he supposed) neglected door to "put" the coals from the "board" where the explosion took place — found it open, he would conclude it had just been opened, and that the "trapper" was close at hand to shut it.

The Coroner :— Did the "putters" carry candles on their tubs? Yes, to give light while filling their coals, and putting them into the tubs on the inclined plane — from whence they are taken on the railway, and afterwards to bank. He (Campbell) did not think his son (finding the "trapper" absent) could have propped the door open, to save himself trouble, he was always so steady. Mr. Johnson also stated that there would have been no time, had such been the case, for the accumulation of a sufficient quantity of gas to cause the explosion — since not more than two or three minutes could elapse between his going and returning. Campbell said he considered this pit as safe as any. (The age of the boys having charge of these trap doors was found upon inquiry to vary from nine to thirteen years.)

The Coroner then asked Campbell several questions respecting the state of the atmosphere on the day of the explosion, he having heard, he said, that the state of the external atmosphere (particularly when the wind was from the south) had a great affect upon the atmosphere in the pit ; to which Campbell replied that that was the case — but on that Monday, the wind was from the north west, a quarter which made no difference to the air in the pit. The diameter of the shaft (which is circular, and has no division) is 9 feet 4 inches ; and so far from the "cages" filling up the passage in going up and down, there is an area of five feet between them ; or taking every side (it was stated by one of the jury), 20 feet. The time of passing, too, was so momentary, that no interruption could take place — as was proved by the rate of the current (never less than 4 feet to 5 feet per second) of air in the shaft.

William Hornsby (a pitman) was then examined — Was in the Bigge Pit on Monday last — left at none o'clock, when the other men came down. The pit was perfectly well ventilated when he was there — considers it quite safe. Cannot state anything certain as to the cause of the explosion. The deputy had been in his "board" at half pas eight. Never knew the ventilation better than on Monday. The trap-doors were all right when he left. Has often heard the deputy charge the "trappers" to look well after the doors. Works with a candle, and is not afraid to do so, thinking it quite safe. Can think of no other cause of explosion than neglect on some of the "trappers" parts.

Mr. Johnson wished every inquiry to be made ; but the Coroner and Jury both thought there was no necessity to examine all the witnesses : only two more witnesses were therefore called — the first of whom,

Michael Ranson, stated he was down in the eastern extremity of the pit when the explosion occurred, about 500 yards from the shaft : the explosion occurred nearly 700 yards from where he was. Knew something had happened by the sudden rush of wind, and the dust brought along by it : their candles were blown out. He and his two companions made the best of their way towards the foot of the shaft, on reaching which they found the stone-work fallen, and the timber gearing supporting it lying about ; they found the "cage" at the bottom fastened, but they loosed the hook, and were drawn up by the other tub, which was sent down for them.

Robert Wilkinson (a hewer) was in the "shift" that was down just before that in which the men were lost. He worked in the middle board. The air was very good where he was when he left, which was about nine o'clock in the morning. The boy Cooper kept the trap-door of the board where he worked, and was, so far as he had seen of him, a steady lad ; he had never known him neglect his door. He believed the trap-doors were in a sound condition. The youth Campbell "put" for him. When the pitmen have hewn their quantity of coals, they leave the pit — the putters and trappers remaining behind, till the putters had got all the coal taken to the top of the inclined plane. These boys are sometimes four or five hours in the pit after the hewers — but always under the superintendence of the deputies and other overlookers, who continue in the pit all the time the others are there. — [While this witness was under examination, work was brought that the missing corpse has just been found.] — There was quite sufficient supply of air to render the use of candles safe.

Mr. Johnson then explained to the Coroner and Jury that the "back-deputy," who succeeded Campbell (the first witness) in the pit, has the control of all the men and boys — that he sees the doors are kept in order, that the ventilation is preserved, that all in the "workings" leave before him, and that all the lights are extinguished before he leaves.

The Coroner then addressed the Jury, saying, that after hearing the evidence of the witnesses already examined — and after the perspicuous explanations given by Mr. Johnson of the construction of the colliery — he conceived there could be no necessity for calling more witnesses, as they could only state surmises. It appeared to him most probable, that the accident had originated in the neglect of some of the "trappers," as before mentioned — they could arrive at no certainty. There could be no hesitation, in his opinion, as to the verdict which they must return — "Accidental death" — but it was for them to decide. Every attention appeared to have been paid, both by the proprietors and superintendents, to the proper ventilation of the colliery. — The Jury, without retiring, immediately returned a verdict of "Accidental Death, resulting from the Explosion of Hydrogen Gas."

[We cannot conclude this notice of this melancholy event without stating, that every requisite explanation with respect to the working of the colliery, and the situation of the different passages, was most readily afforded by Mr. Johnson and his nephew, who both seemed deeply concerned at the loss of life occasioned by it.

That this sad catastrophe was the result of mere accident, there can, we think, be no doubt — the result very probably, of the cause suggested by Mr. Johnson, viz., the boy Cooper leaving his trap-door, to play with some of the other lads. That the pit, too, was considered perfectly safe, as stated by the witnesses (one of whom lost a son — and all, friends or relatives,) we have little doubt. But we put it to all who have the management of similar concerns, whether it is at any time wise, or even right, where there are so many lives at stake, to risk them, by dispensing with the use of the safety lamp! True, there may be cases where the use of candles would never endanger the lives of the workmen ; but who can take upon himself to say that such shall be the case? And how often does it not happen, that such accidents occur when least expected, and most carefully guarded against, both by proper ventilation and other means, except the use of the safety lamp ; and then, as in this instance a number of our fellow creatures are at once hurried into eternity, leaving the young and helpless, or the old and infirm, to lament their loss — a loss never to be made up by any kindness!]


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bainbridge, Thomas      
Bainbridge, William      
Bell, Matthew      
Black, Robert      
Bolton, Thomas      
Brown, Dixon      
Brown, John      
Brown, Robert      
Campbell, George      
Campbell, John      
Campbell, Robert      
Campbell, Thomas      
Charlton, George      
Cooper, Richard      
Coxon, William      
Crawford, John      
Crosby, Joseph      
Crosier, Jonathan      
Dodgson, Thomas      
Dodgson, William      
Dunn, Henry      
Hall, John      
Hornsby, William      
Howey, William      
Johnson, George      
Johnson, Joseph      
Joyce, John      
Liddell, James      
Martin, George      
Martin, Michael      
Martin, William      
Mason, Simpson      
Pearson, James      
Pearson, Robert      
Pearson, Thomas      
Ranson, Matthew      
Ranson, Michael      
Reed, John      
Reed, Stephen    Coroner  Whos Who Page
Scott, George      
Wardale, Henry      
Wilkinson, Robert      
Wood, Thomas      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Bigge Pit  Bigge Pit



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
23 Apr 1841  Dreadful Explosion at Willington Pit, Thirty-One Lives Lost (The Times)
24 Apr 1841  Colliery explosion at Willington (Gateshead Observer)
24 Apr 1841  Dreadful Explosion At Willington Pit, Thirty-One Lives Lost (Berkshire Chronicle)
27 Apr 1841  The Colliery Explosion at Willington (The Times)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Willington, Bigge's Pit
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print