|
Gateshead ObserverArticle from the Gateshead Observer, 6th July 1839 The Colliery CatastropheExplosion at St. Hilda's Pit, South Shields, and Loss of Fifty-Two Lives.We had last week the mournful duty to discharge, of collecting and publishing the details of an explosion of "fire-damp" at St. Hilda's (or the Church) Pit, in South Shields, the property of Messrs. W. and J. Brandling, which occurred on the morning of Friday, the 28th ult., and by which fifty-two human lives were sacrificed. We gave, on the 29th ult., as correct a list of the sufferers as it was then in our power to procure. On Saturday evening, at the Crown and Anchor inn, a jury was impanelled by Michael Hall, Esq., coroner, that an inquest might he held. One case only was taken, viz. that of George Walker ; and after the jury had viewed the body, the inquiry was adjourned to Monday. On Sunday, the bodies of the sufferers were buried — 26 at St. Hilda's, 15 at Trinity church, and the remainder at Jarrow and North Shields. The affecting ceremony was witnessed by large crowds of inhabitants. On Monday last, at mid day, a public meeting of the inhabitants, convened by requisition, was held in the town hall, South Shields, (the Rev. James Carr in the chair,) to promote a subscription for the relief of the families of the sufferers, and to take such other steps as the calamity might seem to demand. The Rev. Chairman opened the meeting with an appropriate and touching appeal to the hearts of his fellow townsmen — an appeal to which it was evident, from the deep interest manifested in every countenance, that the numerous and respectable assembly warmly responded. The event which brought us together (he said) is the most melancholy that has occurred amongst us in my experience. We have had our shipwrecks, but some them as extensively calamitous. We have had our pestilences, but it was not as appalling as this catastrophe. We have had no previous affliction by which so many of our fellow creatures were at once swept out of existence. Upwards of fifty of our neighbours have perished by this visitation at one stroke. 44 children have been deprived of support, and a much larger number have been rendered fatherless, for I include not those who are labouring for their own maintenance. 19 wives have been widowed — and some of them will shortly increase the number of children left helpless. It is an occurrence which demands our warmest sympathies and our most active and liberal succour, and I am sure that it will not appeal to your humanity in vain. (Applause.) Dr. Winterbottom, the oldest inhabitant present at the meeting, was called upon by the Chairman to move the first resolution, and spoke of the affecting sight which they had witnessed on the previous day, when 28 of their fellow creatures, so recently in the flesh of life and health, were ranged side by side in the parish church, for internment. No sorrowful a scene he had never before beheld in South Shields, in the whole course of the long life which he had spent in the town. Dr. Winterbottom proceeded to touch upon the great improvement which had taken place in the manners of the pitmen since his younger days, owing to the influence of religion. He regretted that there was no institution existing amongst them to provide against such visitations as the present, and referred to the inadequacy of parochial aid. Many of the pitmen (he said) had placed a portion of their earnings in the savings bank, but some miscreants had falsely assured them that the institution was unsafe, and had induced them to withdraw their little hoards — and their savings had been spent. Dr. W. concluded by moving a resolution, to the effect that a subscription be commenced forthwith. Mr. Robert Anderson seconded the motion, and eulogised the heroism of the gallant men — one of whom he saw present — who had risked their lives in the cause of humanity, and who, in some cases, were happily successful in rescuing their fellow creatures from death. (Applause.) The Chairman, before putting the motion, said, that one of the brave pitmen saved his own son, and himself perished in the mine. He (Mr. Carr) had since seen the son weeping over the coffin of his gallant father. (Here, the Rev. Chairman was affected to tears at the recollection of the scene, and was for some time unable to proceed.) The resolution having been carried unanimously. Mr. Bainbridge moved the appointment of a committee, consisting of the following gentlemen :—
He could not resume his seat without expressing his high admiration of the conduct of Mr. Mather (loud applause), and Mr. Anderson, and the medical gentlemen of the town, and the pitmen and others, who so freely periled their lives in the attempt to be of service to the sufferers. (Applause.) Mr. J. Hargreaves seconded the resolution. He could not avoid expressing his opinion that the families of the sufferers had a strong claim on the owners of the colliery. Not that he had the slightest doubt of their disposition to repudiate this claim ; he had the utmost confidence that they would come forward in the most liberal and handsome manner. The Dean and Chapter, too, (hear, hear,) would feel bound to be peculiarly bountiful in their subscription, inasmuch as they had been greatly benefited by the labour of the men whose lives were sacrificed in the mine. The Chairman said, that he had seen Mr. Anderson, the viewer of the colliery, to ascertain if there were any fund in the establishment to meet such causes as the present. Mr. Anderson replied in the negative, but said that he had no doubt the owners would be disposed to act very liberally. (Applause.) They had already undertaken some expenses arising out of the event, and he (the Chairman) believed it was the custom of coal owners to allow the widows in such cases to occupy their houses rent free for life, and to supply them with coal free from charge. (Applause.) The Dean and Chapter had been mentioned, and he was confident that they also would act with becoming liberality. But the public would not be so unreasonable as to expect the owners of the colliery or the Dean and Chapter to bear more than their fair share of the burden. If a workman were to suffer some severe injury, or to meet with his death, in the service of a tradesman — say a printer — it would not be just to expect that the employer should bear all the burden of the distress occasioned by the accident. A good principle must not be pushed too far. The owners of a colliery, if they received large benefits from their work, were also conferring large benefits, by providing employment for the inhabitants, and in many other ways. The people of the district generally were benefited ; and as they sat over their glowing and comfortable fires in the winter months, they should think with gratitude of the men who periled their lives in working the coal. (Applause.) In a case like the present, it was the duty of all to come forward. Coal owners were at great expense, and ran great risks, and ought not to be too heavily laid on, in such an emergency as had now occurred. Still, it became them to set a good example, and he had no doubt that the owners of St. Hilda's colliery would not be found wanting. (Applause.) The resolution was unanimously carried, and The Rev. Mr. Dixon then moved :— "That the thanks of the meeting be given to the medical gentlemen, who gave their valuable and disinterested services on the occasion, and also to Mr. James Mather, for his many exertions, and useful attentions to the sufferers, in the mine itself, whereby speedy relief was, in many cases, advantageously afforded ; likewise to many of the miners themselves, for their courageous exertions in behalf of their fellow workmen, and to other meritorious individuals. Mr. Dixon spoke warmly of the support which the mourners derived from the consolations of religion. Mr. James Edwards seconded the resolution, and it was carried by acclamation. Mr. Hargreaves suggested the propriety of a permanent colliery fund, as a provision against accidents, to be maintained by the contributions of the workmen, the coal owners, and other persons. The special fund now to be subscribed would, he trusted, be on so liberal a scale, as to convince the working classes, that those who were, step by step, raised above them in worldly circumstances, sympathised in their distress, and were ready to aid them in the hour of need. (Applause.) The Rev. Mr. Dickinson supported the views of Mr. Hargreaves. Mr. Mather then came forward, and with graceful modesty acknowledged the resolution of the meeting. Next (said Mr. M.) to the approbation of a man's conscience, which he took to be a reflection of the divinity itself, was the approbation of his fellow countrymen. The meeting had been pleased to make especial mention of his name — he was happy to say, however, he was but one of many. The medical men made the most self denying exertions, not only at the pit mouth, but in the pit itself. No means of succour that could be tried were left untried. Then, too, the heroic exertions of the pitmen. Their whole faculties were absorbed in efforts to rescue their brethren from death. The most splendid exertions were made by these noble men that it was ever his lot to behold. They came from the midst of the atmospheric poison, and well nigh dead, only to rush back, recruited, to save, if it were possible, their perishing friends. Their first words when reviving from a state of apparent death, were not for themselves, but for permission to return to the foul recesses in which already their lives had been nearly sacrificed in the cause of humanity. There were scenes occurred in that gloomy mine, which, had they been performed in the light of day, and before an assembled world, would have immortalized the names of those humble, but heroic men. (Applause.) The deeds of those brave hearted pitmen showed that human nature, in spite of all its defects, was not so bas as some would make it. (Hear, hear.) He trusted that the present awful calamity would not be without its uses, but would suggest and compel an inquiry into the cause of these extraordinary explosions. The science of the age, he was persuaded, was competent to meet and to overcome the evil. Davy had done much, but more remained to be done. He could not think that such accidents were generally the result of carelessness in the workmen. There were other agents at work, and these must be sought after. If so, they would be undoubtedly be detected, and the remedy also would be discovered. It was just fifty years since South Shields immortalized itself by an invention for the preservation of the shipwrecked sailor. It was previously thought that our mariner, when wrecked in certain situations on the coast, were past all hope of escape from death. But a committee was formed in South Shields fifty years ago — (Dr. Winterbottom: True, true! I recollect it!) — and in a few months a means was found of contending with the storm, and saving human life. Why should South Shields not take such another decisive step! Let a committee be formed at once, that the cause of these colliery explosions, and the means of prevention, might be discovered with the least possible delay. (Applause.) The Chairman said, in reference to the suggestion of Mr. Hargreaves, that an experiment had been made and failed ; it was found impossible to form a permanent fund. Mr. Hargreaves replied, that the plan had answered in the Earl of Durham's collieries, and why not elsewhere. Mr. Robert Anderson said, that, some years ago, on the occasion of an extensive loss of life in the Greenland fishery, a subscription was raised for the families of the sufferers. The contributions were so liberal, that a larger sum was subscribed than could prudently be applied to the special purpose for which it was raised. A surplus therefore remained, and an excellent and very energetic man, Mr. George Straker, suggested that it should be the nucleus of a permanent fund for the relief of the families of shipwrecked seamen. The suggestion was acted upon, and a society was formed which had done great good. To this society seamen did not contribute ; it was supported solely by other classes of the community ; and any attempt to form a similar society in connection with the collieries of the district, he was very much afraid, would altogether fail, if they trusted to contributions from the hard earnings of the pitmen. He hoped that the subscription to be this day opened would be so abundantly liberal, that a surplus would remain as the nucleus of a society on the same principle as that for the relief of the widows and orphans of shipwrecked seamen. (Applause.) The Rev. Mr. Green observed, that the plan agreed by Mr. Hargreaves had probably failed in individual collieries, in consequence of the migratory habits of the pitmen. But the plan would perhaps succeed if it included the whole of the coal district of the north. Mr. Marrace said, that a fund against the hour of need had been formed, through the instrumentality of the Earl of Durham, in his lordship's extensive collieries, and had been the means of great good. His lordship was a bountiful contributor, and the men most willingly assisted in maintaining the fund. The Stanhope and Tyne Company contemplated a similar institution, and though there were difficulties, arising out of the circumstance that they had many different classes of workmen in their service, there were non as regarded the disposition of the men — they were all ready and willing to subscribe. (Applause.) The company, in imitation of Lord Durham, would contribute liberally to the fund, and there was no doubt that the institution would be formed, and would succeed. He hoped therefore, that the experiment would be tried in the collieries of this district, on the principle laid down by Mr. Hargreaves ; and he (Mr. M.) would do all that lay in his power to promote such a project. (Applause.) Mr. Marrace's name was here added to the committee ; and when Mr. Anderson had expressed his pleasure at that gentleman's statement. The Chairman said, that he had just heard, and had much pleasure in stating, that the working men of the town were at that moment holding a meeting, to promote the same objects which had brought together the gentlemen assembled in the town hall. (Applause.) Mr. Salmon, the hon. secretary of the meeting, in compliance with a general wish, drew up an addition to the second resolution, embodying the suggestion of Mr. Hargreaves and Mr. Mather. It was as follows :— "That it be an instruction to the committee, to effect, if possible, the establishment of a fund, having for its object the relief of those who may happen in future to be left destitute by accidents of this kind ; and also that the attention of the committee be at the same time called to the frequent occurrence of those melancholy events, with a view to inquiry, if any, and what means can be derived for their future prevention." The Rev. Mr. Dixon stated, that on his return from church on Sunday, after the funeral, he found a letter awaiting him from Mr. Ingham, requesting that his name might be put down to the subscription for £30. (Applause.) Mr. Bainbridge moved a vote of thanks to the clergy, churchwardens, and others, for their kind and attentive conduct on the occasion of the funeral. Mr. W. Swinburn seconded the meeting, and it was unanimously adopted by the meeting. The Chairman said that such a resolution was perfectly unnecessary. The clergy and churchwardens had discharged a mere duty, and would have been the basest of wretches if they had omitted to perform it with proper decorum. Thanks, therefore, were not required ; but as they had been tendered, he acknowledged them on behalf of himself and his brother clergymen. Mr. Salmon returned thanks for the churchwardens, and a conversation ensued as the best means of promoting the subscription, in which Dr. Leitch, Mr. Glover, and other gentlemen took part, and Dr. Leitch's name was added to the committee. Thanks were voted to the chairman, and the meeting separated, but not until upwards of £200 had been subscribed. The inquest was resumed at two o'clock, having been delayed till that hour to meet the wishes of the gentlemen who convened the public meeting. The Jury consisted of the following gentlemen :—
John Heppell, of South Shields, pitman, deposed that he had worked in St. Hilda's pit many years ; observed nothing prior to the explosion of Friday which led him to expect any accident ; was working about 400 yards from the place where the explosion took place. By the Foreman: Davy lamps were not used in the part where the accident occurred, except by the persons who inspected the pit, to see if it was safe. Henry Dinning, of Templetown, South Shields, pitman, (brother of John Dinning, one of the sufferers,) was down the pit when it exploded ; witness and his brother, when they perceived that there had been an explosion, ran towards the pit mouth, and in their progress saw the fire coming off at the distance of 40 yards ; witness had to be carried out of the pit ; never used a Davy ; did not think it necessary to do so ; the pit, so far as he could tell, was properly worked. T. J. Taylor, of Earsdon, colliery viewer, explained from a plan the workings of the pit, and especially in the district where the accident took place, which was at one of the extremities of the mine. The explosion (said Mr. T.) had done hardly any damage to the pit. Few of the men had been killed by the fire damp ; but when the explosion occurred, and they rushed from the place, many of them had taken a road which was choked by a fall, and had perished from the after damp. There were two roads leading to this part of the mine. One was the rolleyway, which it was not safe for the men to traverse ; and Mr. Anderson, the viewer, had therefore very properly got another road made for them. When the explosion took place, many of the men took the first turning in the direction of the pit mouth, vis. the rolleyway, and were killed by the after damp. Those who proceeded further, and took the proper road, escaped. In his opinion, the pit was very judiciously laid out. Where candles were considered safe, the Davy lamp was not used. Both masters and men objected to the lamp, when candles could be used. Bryan Reah, overman, on Friday morning, at 4 o'clock, was in the pit, at that part where the explosion took place. All was right at that time ; there was a proper current of air, and the pit was in a good working state. The cause of the accident he could not state. In the part of the mine that he had to do with — the west part, where the explosion took place — no Davy lamps were used. At the time of the explosion, witness was 700 yards distant. The Davy lamp, he thought, would not have prevented it. Once before, about twelve months since, there was a bit small fire in the pit — not where the present accident happened. After a close examination by the foreman, the witness admitted that the accident would not have happened, if the whole of the men had used the Davy lamp. John Hardy, of Templetown, wasteman, had worked in the pit from its commencement ; it was his duty to see that it was in a working state. Between 10 and 11 o'clock on Wednesday morning, when he examined the west part of the pit, it was in good condition, and free from danger. When the explosion took place, he was in a different part of the pit, but there was a stagnation of the air, which told him there was a blast, and he and others made for the pit mouth. He saw several men coming from the west part, bringing with them some of their fellow workmen, who were not dead. When he found where the pit had fired, he was greatly surprised, having no idea that an explosion could occur in that part, it was considered so safe. Candles were used in the whole of the pit, except "the broken," it was witness's duty to keep the air courses open, and when engaged in inspecting the pit, he generally used a Davy lamp. The men found their own candles ; lamps were found by the masters. Twopence per score was allowed to the men, for candles, and when there was no apprehension of danger, there was no such thing as getting the men to use the Davy lamps. By the Foreman: If lamps had been used, the men would have had warning, and saved themselves, but they would not use lamps. It was more profitable for the men to use candles. James Walker, of South Shields, pitman, father of the deceased George Walker, deposed, that in his opinion the pit was properly worked. His son was one of the sufferers by the explosion. William Hardy, of South Shields, deputy overman, had worked many years in the pit. It was his duty to go round the pit, and see that all was all right. The mine was in a perfect working state the week before the accident. Witness worked in the south part. By the Foreman: Candles were generally used. Two months or six weeks ago, there was a little foul air in the place where the accident occurred. Where candles were used, the coal was blasted by means of gunpowder. This mode of working was the most profitable for masters and men. Edward Hardy, of South Shields, deputy overman, had worked seven years in the pit, and it was always conducted with great care. At a quarter past 6 o'clock on Thursday night, witness was in the part where the explosion took place, and never saw the pit in a better working state. On hearing of the accident, he immediately went down the pit, and found his own boy dead. There was no person to blame, to his knowledge. By the Jury: Previous to the accident, a man had been taken from "the tenth board," and placed in the ninth. Witness, therefore, did not examine the tenth board on Thursday night, as no person worked in it, a "trouble" having been met with there. It was about 16 yards from the ninth board. Witness examined the pit with a candle. In the mornings, a lamp was used for inspection, lest anything should have occurred during the night. If lamps had been used by the men, it is likely this explosion would not have occurred. Matthew Liddell, of Kenton, colliery viewer, went down the pit on Friday afternoon, between 3 and 4 o'clock, and saw traces of the explosion. The cause he was not able to state. In the tenth board, or between the ninth and tenth, a man was found, where none of the men ought to have been. It was supposed that he had gone into the tenth board for a shovel, which had been left there with other gear, when the board was worked. The pit seemed to have been conducted in a work-manlike manner. St. Hilda's, and many other collieries, could not be worked with profit, without blasting, owing to the stiffness of the coal ; and where gunpowder was used for blasting, it was useless to resort to the Davy lamp. If candles were discarded, one half of the collieries of the north might be shut up. He doubted, indeed, whether there was not less liability to accident with candles than with lamps. With the former, greater precaution was used ; and when there was a little puff, it fired, and the pitmen had warning, and left the place. W. Anderson, of South Shields, viewer of St. Hilda's colliery, was down the pit on Monday before the explosion, and found all right in the part which he inspected. He considered that if one part of the pit was safer than the other, it was that in which the explosion occurred. Shortly after the explosion, witness went down the pit, and went with a lighted candle nearly to the spot where the bodies were found, but did not make much examination, being engaged in attending to the sufferers. This day, he had again been down. The tenth board, which he had thought right to stop three weeks ago, was so foul that he could not enter it. The ninth board was a little foul. One of the men, he thought, had gone into the tenth board, with a lighted candle, for some gear. A pitman named Hill was found near this board, much burnt. The fire had not been large. The greater number of the men had been killed by the after-damp. — By the Foreman: The mine could not be used with lamps. The coal was so course and hard, that it must be worked by blasting. The expense by any other means would be double, and the coal would be raised 20 per cent. In price. The pit must be worked with candles, or not at all — gunpowder must be used. Where the accident occurred, it was like a new pit ; and any one acquainted with such matters would have said that it was quite safe. The place at which the explosion occurred was 1,058 yards from the shaft, and immediately under Mr. Groocock's house, near the Brandling Junction Railway. The pit was well ventilated. Arthur Dixon, wasteman, was through the pit on Wednesday, in that part where the accident occurred. Witness was in the tenth board, which had been "nipped," so that they men could not work in it. The board was "holed." It was free from foul air, when witness tried it with his lamp. T. W. Jobling, of Jarrow, viewer, went down the St. Hilda pit on Friday afternoon, about 2 o'clock. The air-courses were deranged from the explosion. There were two passages to the part which had exploded. Witness got nearly to the extremity of the workings. One of the air-passages was choked, from a fall, which must have occurred within 48 hours of the accident. The air had passed down the road which remained open, while the other remained partially still. Foulness had accumulated, and, as he supposed, one of the men had gone into the innermost or tenth board, with a candle, to procure a shovel, which was found there after the accident ; and owing to the foulness, an explosion took place. The pit most decidedly was worked in a proper manner, and the air-courses carried with great judgement, so that no blame could arise out of the mode in which the pit was worked. By the Foreman: Had the Davy lamp been used, it was probable there would have been no explosion, but it could not be used, for the mine must be worked with gunpowder. He knew no authenticated case of an explosion with the Davy lamp. No other witnesses were examined. — The Coroner addressed the jury, expressing his opinion that they could bring in no other verdict than "Accidental death." Mr. T. Horn, of Newcastle, in an address which he was permitted by the Coroner to make, put it to the jury whether they should not find a verdict of "Manslaughter." The jury, after an absence of about half an hour, returned with the following verdict :— "We find that the death of George Walker was accident, but we accompany our verdict with a special recommendation that the practice of working coal mines with candles be abandoned, and that lamps be adopted in their stead, as from the evidence taken at this inquest, it plainly appears that the explosion had been caused by the incaution of one of the men, in going with a lighted candle into what is termed the tenth board of the mine, which had been foul."
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||