|
26th February 1839 Coroner's Inquest On The Suffers At William PitOn Tuesday last an inquest was held on view of the bodies of the unfortunate sufferers in the recent explosion at William Pit, before Peter Hodgson, Esq , and the following jury:— Wm. Atkinson, (foreman), John Jones, Daniel O'Pray, John Smith, John Ward, John Hylan, William Banks, William Nicholson, Jonathan Bowman, William Caddy, Peter Christy, and James Armstrong. The jury were summoned to meet at 10 o'clock in the morning, at the Public Office, and were punctual in their attendance with respect to time. As soon as the jury had been sworn on all the cases, the Coroner addressed them follows :— He said the court had been assembled to inquire into the cause of this awful calamity. The dispensations of Providence are unaccountable, but the object of their enquiry, in this case, would be to learn if all due precaution had been taken, — that the accident had not been the result neglect-and that there had been no bad intention on the part of those with whom it originated. In the course of their proceedings witnesses would be called before them, to whose testimony they would pay attention, and dismiss from their minds all that they might have heard respecting the melancholy event out of doors. Reports ought to have no influence over their minds — their verdict, whatever it might be, should be governed entirely by the evidence laid before the, and they ought not in any respect be influenced by hearsay. All the evidence that could be produced in this calamitous case would be laid before them; and he had no doubt but they would discharge their duty conscientiously both to themselves and to their country. The coroner then suggested that the jury should proceed along with him to all the houses where the different bodies were lying, in order in see them, with a view of facilitating the enquiry. We attended the jury to each "house of mourning" many of which were truly the abodes of wretchedness, whilst those of others presented a comfortable appearance, which evinced the habits and orderly disposition of the owners. The first house visited was that in which two brothers were lying, named James and Robert Tear, the former 18 years of age, and the latter 12. They had the appearance of being in a state of sound repose — their countenances were a little florid, which gave them a fresh and life like appearance. Their features were as calm and undisturbed, as they had ever been in the happiest moments of life, which indicated that their transition from life to death had been instantaneous — the work of a moment, — and that they had passed away with either a struggle or a sigh. After viewing the bodies of the two Tears, the jury adjourned to the Golden Lion Inn, where an examination of the witnesses commenced. William Thornton examined. — The Tears were brothers, and lived in Nicholson Alley. I did not see all the bodies as they came up, but I saw the Tears, and they were a little burned. The men were mostly killed by suffocation. But some of them were slightly burned. I am an overman at William Pit and my duly is to see that the ventilation is kept good, and that everything is in proper order. I examined the pit the last time on Saturday morning — I went through it all, and found it quite right. I found the ventilation was good at that time, and that it was in a capital state of safety. I saw some of the work people. I went into the pit at half-past two o'clock in the morning of Saturday and remained in it till seven o'clock. I was not in the pit afterwards, till after the explosion had taken place on Monday morning. Robert Tear was in the pit, he was employed there. I first heard of the explosion about a quarter past three o'clock on Monday morning. I immediately dressed myself, and went down into the pit. I saw nothing particular at the bottom of the shaft, and proceeded to examine the workings. I proceeded about a mile, and found every thing correct at that distance. The air was good at the distance of a mile, but I found here that some doors were blown away, which we got closed up as soon as possible, for the purpose carrying the air forward. I then proceeded about a mile further and found four or five doors blown away. I got temporary doors fixed, and by this means we go a supply of good air. I proceeded five or six hundred yards further, and found several stoppings of doors blown out, which we replaced with wood. We then went on to two doors which were standing: we opened them and proceeded about sixty yards further, and found another slopping blown out. We here found the corpse of a boy named Levi Hoskins, lying on the pavement on his face. The boy was not burned that I could discover. I proceeded on still, and found the, bodies of another three boys. Richardson Shields, William Atkinson, and, I believe John Ross. I went on further and found a horse lying dead, I proceeded and found another three bodies lying, Christopher Pearson, William Doran, and John Donald, who were suffocated. In going forward I found a horse dying. I went on still further, and found a man alive. — John Develyn, who was lying on the pavement, with his safety-lamp burning by his side. Felix McGinnis was laying beside him. I went further on, and found Richard Harrison, John Tordiff, John Firth, and a boy I did not know. I proceed a little further and found Hugh Roney, William Smith, Barney Cairn, and William Davidson — all dead. I saw no more corpses in the pit. I went further, and saw three others nearly suffocated — they were John Develyn, Joseph Topping, and Thomas Kennedy. I got them all to the bottom of the shaft, and had them drawn up, and, for anything I know to the contrary, they are all living yet. The circumstance of the doors being blown away was indicative of a blast. I had much difficulty in breathing, and the air was bad, when I was at the furthermost point from the shaft. One of the Tears seemed slightly burned, but not sufficient, as I thought, to cause death. John Watson sworn. — I live at Whitehaven; I am an overman, and was in the pit at the time of the expiation on Monday morning last. I went in on Sunday night at nine o'clock. When we heard the explosion it was about three o'clock in the morning: the first time we heard it, we made for the shaft. Three men came to us, who though the explosion was with them, and they delayed and heard it again. We put on our clothes, and came on five or six hundred yards. Here we met the stife, and had great difficulty in breathing and getting through it. At length we got fresh air, where we stopped, and saw that some doors had been blown away. We put up some temporary doors; and finally reached the shaft and came up. Alexander Galloway sworn. — I went down into the pit after the accident to see if I could assist. We met Topping and some others, and saw a boy whom we brought to the shaft. Topping did not say how the accident had happened. (The remainder of Galloway's evidence was an entire repetition of of that of the preceding witnesses, as far as it went) After these witnesses had been examined, the coroner and jury left the Golden Lion Inn, and proceeded to visit the dwellings of the suffers generally, after which (it being nearly twelve o'clock) the jury were bound were to make their appearance at the Public Offices at two o'clock precisely. In viewing the various sufferers whose death had been cause by choke-damp, we may state that their appearance, generally, was similar to that of the two Tears. In some of them, indeed, so little was the appearance of the countenance changed that it required a knowledge of their dreadful fate to carry conviction to the mind of the reality of their death. Some of the faces and breasts of the unfortunate miners were scorched and burned; consequently their appearance was very different from that of those whom we have been describing. Some of them indeed had suffered much, and their aspects were awful in the extreme, — particularly those of George Stott, aged 60, and a boy 13 years of age, named Michael Wheatley, both of whom were lying in one bed. These two persons had evidently been exposed to all the fury of the blast, and those who have ever witnessed the effect of such dreadful explosions upon the human face, will be better able to conceive than we are to describe the appearance of these two unfortunate sufferers. — suffice it to say, that in their countenances every aspect of humanity was obliterated, and replaced by the most awful and horrid appearance of which the human mind can form any conception. The coroner and jurymen assembled at two o'clock with considerable punctuality. The coroner observed, that if Topping were able to give evidence it was, in the first place, their duty to take it; if he were not able he thought they had better adjourn the inquest until they could obtain his examination. There were no witnesses present, and ho thought they had better proceed to his residence and examine Topping, who was the only person, at present, capable of giving in account of the blast. The coroner and Jury then proceeded to Joseph Topping's house, near William pit; they found him in a weak and dangerous state, but perfectly sensible, and willing to be examined. — He was then sworn and deposed as follows to questions put to him by the coroner :— I am a miner, and was in William pit on the morning of the accident; a boy named Kennedy went with me; we went about two miles from the bottom of the pit, where the accident happened. The boy had a patent lamp and a common lantern in his hand — there was an oil light in the lantern which was open. I considered the place perfectly safe, between half-past two and three o'clock, the inflammable air became ignited. If I had suspected any danger I would not have gone in. After an explosion of fire-damp, unless persons working at the place makes his escape, he cannot live. Immediately after an explosion or blast, air is produced in which we cannot live. I am satisfied that from the effects of the ignition of the inflammable air, and the blasts consequent thereupon, the individuals who lost their lives in William pit, yesterday, were killed by the ignition of inflammable air, or by the choke damp consequent upon the explosion, by which they were suffocated and that the whole catastrophe was accidental and not occasioned by any negligence or want of skill whatever. After the examination of Topping, the jury returned in the Public Office, where the Coroner thus addressed them :— He said they had now received all the evidence to be attained. It appeared from the examination of the overman, Mr. Thornton, that everything in the pit was right when he examined it on Saturday and that, no one was in it on the Sunday. The first intelligence of the explosion was conveyed to Mr. Thornton at 3 o'clock on Monday morning; he immediately dressed himself, went to the pit and did everything that an honest, industrious an honest person should have done. The explosion took place, notwithstanding every precaution to guard against it, and, as was always the case, choke-damp succeeded, in which no man could live. It was, in fact, one of those calamities which no human foresight could prevent. They came now to the important question — how had the accident happened. They had heard Joseph Topping's evidence, that he had gone into the pit along with a boy, who had an oil lamp, as well as a Davy-lamp, in his hand: the oil-lamp, it appeared, was broke, and set fire to the inflammable air, and choke-damp immediately ensued. It was their duty to enquire whether death-had resulted from explosion or from choke-damp. — It certainly appeared from the evidence they had been enabled to obtain that only two of the unfortunate sufferers had met their death in consequence of being burned — the others had all died from suffocation, in consequence of the choke-damp. That question, however, it was their province to decide. The coroner then entered into the evidence, and said he thought that the lamentable loss of life was clearly owing to suffocation, generally, as it did not appear, that more than two of the suffers had met their deaths from burning. If the Jury differed from him, he hoped they would communicate their differences to him; if they did not differ from him they would agree amongst themselves and deliver in their verdict. They could also state in their verdict if they thought Topping had used ordinary caution. The jury, after a short consultation, returned a verdict of accidental death in all the cases. They found that George Stott and Michael Wheatley were burnt to death, and that all the others died from suffocation. The jury also thought proper to accompany their verdict with the following recommendation :— "That in future no person be allowed to use a lamp, the flame whereof shall be exposed so as to come in contact with the air, and they advise that in future, greater caution shall be observed in this respect." From the evidence laid before the jury, and no pains are spared to obtain information to the fullest extend, they came to a very correct and proper conclusion, and one which, we are happy to say coincides generally with public opinion. And now for the "last sad scene of all" — the funerals of the deceased miners, some of them were in such a state that they were interred as soon as the jury had viewed them, but the principal number of the funeral took place on the following day, on which occasions the remains of the unfortunate miners were separately attended to their graves by the members of the Miners' Society, each of whom wore a white hat-band on the occasion, the whole of which, as well as the expenses of the families were generally provided at the expense of the Earl of Lonsdale. The right of so many human beings, some of them in the prime of life, but the greatest number of whom were youths, who had not arrived at man's estate, thus passing to an early and unexpected grave, presented an imposing and melancholy spectacle; and when we called to recollection that but a few short days before most of them were traversing those very streets through which the dead bodies where them borne along, the scene was well calculated to arouse a train of thoughts and reflections, the whole of which terminated in the melancholy conviction — "that even in the midst of life we are in death!" The poor in their ordinary circumstances and situation in life are "the pilgrims of many a care untold;" but when such terrible calamities as that which we bare been describing occurs, they not only harrow up feelings, however otherwise injured to distress, but they leave unprotected widows with families of children in a state of destitution little differing from that of orphans. We rejoice, however, that such will not be the case in this instance. The Earl of Lonsdale, with the kind and benevolent feeling, by which his whole life has been distinguished, has given instructions to provide the widows and families of all the deceased miners with cottages, rent-free, gratuitous firing, and an allowance of two shillings per week.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||