Whitehaven Herald
Article from the Whitehaven Herald, 17th November 1838
News
(Extract From the Mining Journal)
We have this week given, in another column, an abstract of the evidence adduced on the coroner's inquest on the bodies of the sufferers by the late melancholy accident at the colliery of Mr. Curwen, accompanying it by a plan, showing the position of the
several pits and works, which we have copied from the Whitehaven Herald. The public must feel indebted to our contemporary for the care with which he has collected the evidence in detail, and the attention he has bestowed on the subject; although we
cannot concur with him in the view he takes, which is conveyed in the observations appended to the report, to which we have also given insertion.
It appears to us that much blame is to be attributed to the agents for the want of care which, we are led to believe from the evidence, was evinced, and from which we have no hesitation in expressing our conviction that the melancholy accident took
place. It is in evidence that the "overman," who formerly held the situation prior to the appointment of Harrson Kay, complained of the air in the "John Pit," and the necessity of it being remedied. He also states most distinctly,
that unreasonable delay took place in furnishing timber or iron where occasion required them, and in many instances idle excuses were made. The brother of the unfortunate man, whose life was sacrificed from his own neglect, admits that a portion of the
workings were "dirty." The "Jane Pit" is stated to have fallen in or choked to within eighteen inches of the top, and yet this accident, which it is natural to suppose would have an effect on the air in the "John Pit," was
neglected, and the work of repairing the damage sustained put off till "the morrow." Yet we do not find that the colliers were also advised to put off their work in like manner.
Throughout the inquiry there has been an evident desire to hide from the jury that which, we think, they saw clearly, as expressed in their verdict, viz.:– "That there was blame attachable to the agents, and that the sacrifice of life arose
from their wanton neglect." Mr. Tate, on whom the management or direction of the colliery devolves, it appears was in the habit of visiting the pit once or twice a fortnight, and in his absence his duties were deputed to a man who, from the
evidence, appears to have been most unfit for the situation he filled. The excuse which Mr. Tate made for the materials required underground not being supplied in proper time, is of so idle a nature, that it cannot for one moment be entertained; indeed,
we think that he must have been fully sensible of the position in which he was placed when the inquiry was being instituted.
Our contemporary has, with a praiseworthy motive, no doubt, and possibly possessing a knowledge of the gentleman to whom we refer, endeavoured to shield him by the observations he has made; but from the evidence given in the preceding columns we are at a
loss to find a justification for the remarks, and which indeed appear to us out of place. For aught we know, Mr. Tate may be a most worthy man, and one whose ability to fill the office in which he is placed beyond all question or matter of doubt
— but, in such case, we need hardly say, the more censurable is he, having undoubted powers, to risk the lives of his workmen by neglect and inattention, as has been proved to have been the case in the present instance. It is to gentlemen filling
the onerous offices of viewers or agents that are committed the safety of lives, as well as property — they are, we believe, in all cases well paid for the laborious and responsible duties attached to their office — they are, generally
speaking (although in some instances practical men, who have "worked" their way upwards), men of enlarged minds, and possessing the advantages of education. If they are sensible of the dangers attendant on the working of collieries, and the
importance of having a free current of air (as we take for granted they necessarily must be), how highly censurable is it, that when danger is known to exist — which we contend there was in this case — they should have allowed the works
to be in such a state, that one of the witnesses (evidently with a leaning towards the agents) admitted that in passing through the main drift, "he closed two doors, but the third was in so bad a state that it was useless to close it." Here,
then, at once is an admission of the state of the works; and when it is considered that any neglect of the air-course, arising from obstruction or want of proper checks, may in all probability be the cause of so frightful a sacrifice of life as that
which it is our painful duty to record, no language can be too strong in condemnation of that negligence which we must repeat, appears to us to have been manifested on this melancholy occasion.
Human life is too often, we regret to say, wantonly sported with by those on whom devolve the exercise of those powers which should at once be its protection. We had last week occasion to revert to the loss of the Northern Yacht, a subject now brought
under the consideration of Government by ourselves, and when we reflect upon the awful loss of life which, during our short pilgrimage, it has fallen upon us to record in the Mining Journal, arsing from colliery accidents, it is, indeed, a source of
lamentation that more caution should not be observed in the appointment of the parties to whom the management of the works is committed.
If there be another topic to which we may direct the attention of the public, it is the absence of any fund from which the families of the sufferers may receive relief. We cannot doubt but that the proprietors of collieries, the coal trade, and those
who are dependant upon it for support, would readily subscribe to such a fund, if once established. It is not a local, but a national question, when we consider the risks and hardships that the collier undergoes in digging from the bowels of the earth
those treasures to which we are mainly indebted for the high position in which England so proudly stands. The subject shall have our best attention, and in the interim we have to announce our subscription of Five Guineas, towards any fund which may be
raised for the relief of the families of the forty sufferers by the fatal accident. We trust some of our liberal friends and subscribers, possessing the means more amply than ourselves, will add to the list, which we shall be happy to receive, and
weekly to report in the columns of our Journal.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Curwen, H. | | Mine Owner | |
| Kay, Harrison | | Overman | |
| Tate, — | | Manager | |