Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

Whitehaven Herald

Article from the Whitehaven Herald, 3rd November 1838


The Dreadful Explosion at John Pit

The brief account we gave in the last week's Herald of this melancholy and most awful calamity has turned out too true in almost every important particular; but as the public anxiety to learn the most minute details of an accident unexampled in the loss of human life in this district is still very great, we deem it our duty to lay before our readers a copious report of the proceedings on the coroner's inquest, and for the readier explanation of the statements of the witnesses we insert a sketch of the scene of the direful catastrophe :—

The Coroner's Inquest

We stated in our last that on Friday, William Bragg Esq., coroner for the liberty of the Lordship of Egremont, had that afternoon commenced holding an inquest on the bodies of the unfortunate men recovered from John Pit. In pursuance of Mr. Bragg's precept the jurors had been selected from Harrington exclusively, and the gentlemen summoned met the coroner by appointment at Distington at one o'clock in the afternoon, but it there being informed to him that some dissatisfaction existed in consequence of his inquest being entirely taken from Harrington it was further arranged that a portion of the jury should be taken from Distington. After a short delay the following gentlemen were sworn upon the jury on this solemn occasion :—

1. Henry Piper, Harrington, gentleman.
2. John Gibson, Harrington Harbour, master mariner
3. Shadrach Moordaff, do. gentleman.
4. George Warren Gilpin, Harrington, gentleman.
5. Matthew Sanley, Harrington Harbour, master mariner
6. John Pearce, Rose Hill, Harrington, gentleman.
7. Thomas Wilson, do. gentleman.
8. John Carr, Harrington Harbour, master mariner
9. John Robson, Harrington, shopkeeper.
10. Rownson Ewart, Harrington, farmer.
11. Isacc Kitchen, Distington, farmer.
12. Henry Stalker, do. gentleman.
13. George Jackson, do. farmer.
14. William Meals, do. innkeeper.

On the jury being impannelled, the Coroner proceeded to explain to them the nature of their duties. In the first place, he requested that they would discard from their minds whatever reports they might have heard connected with the melancholy accident which had called them together, and confine their attention solely to the facts that might be stated in evidence. Their first duty would be to inquire into the cause of the accident, which he was led to believe, would be shown to have occurred from an explosion of inflammable gas. They would next inquire whether such explosion had taken place through the negligence or inadvertence of any one; and if so, then was that negligence so gross and criminal as to justify a verdict of manslaughter. Thirdly, it would be their duty to inquire if the pit was in a fit state to work, or so supplied with air as to ensure the safety of the workmen — for the proper ventilation of the mine was a highly important part of all such inquiries as the present. In the fourth place supposing that danger existed in the state of the pit, then came the inquiry were the workmen forewarned of the danger? They might also extend their investigation into the general condition and regulations of the pit, and ascertain whether the workmen used lamps or candles; and if they found that the explosion occurred through the criminal ignorance or negligence of any one, on that person must they rest the blame of this unfortunate event.

After one or two observations of a general nature, the Coroner and jury proceeded to view the bodies of the sufferers, visiting first those who lay at Distington, thence proceeding to Lowca, calling at Pica House, returning to Distington to view the body of Harrison Kay which had in the meantime been brought up from the pit, from thence to Workington, concluding their painful route at Harrington. Before this most distressing part of their duties were concluded, it was nearly ten o'clock at night, at which hour the proceedings were adjourned until next morning.

At nine o'clock on Saturday morning the coroner and jury assembled at the house of Mr. Carr, innkeeper, in Harrington, from whence they adjourned to the School House to hear the evidence.

The first witness called was

James Cooper, one of the boys who had a miraculous escape and who appeared lame. On being sworn, and duly warned by the coroner to speak the truth without favour or prejudice, (as were all the other witnesses on taking the oath,) the witness said — On Wednesday morning last, about five o' clock, I was at John Pit, along with John Gill, John Nutter, and James Wynn. I was a trailer in the pit. We all got into a basket, and when going down I heard a great noise like a crack out of a gun. We were thrown out of the pit, and I fell into a basket on the striking board. Wynn tumbled down the pit again; but the other two were saved. I was not sensible for some time, but I did not know the cause except from report. I did not hear before from any of the men whether there was any danger or not. I was ready to go down that morning as usual, and I never heard any of the men say that the pit was in a bad state.

Jonathan Ellwood sworn. — I was back overman at John Pit. I was there on Tuesday last. I went down at eight o'clock in the morning, and came up in the evening when the pit was done working. My duty was to see that the air went right after the overmen had been their rounds in the morning. When I came down on Tuesday evening the hooker-on told me to go to Jane Pit eye to see if the air sufficient. I did so, and there found a fall in the main air course; the size of the air course was then eighteen inches high, and two yards broad. Could not tell what the size of the air course was before the fall, but before I left it, I made it larger than I found it, and then thought it sufficient. I then went and reported the circumstance to Mr. Tate, the agent. I don't know whether Mr. Tate did any thing or not in consequence of what I told him. Mr. Tate went down the pit twice a week. I did not shut any doors in the pit on the night before the accident. I never did so except when the air was bad, and to the best of my knowledge it was all right on Tuesday evening. Mr. Tate was down in the pit on Monday last. When I went to report to Mr. Tate on Tuesday night, he asked me if I thought the air-course was sufficient? And I said it was. After I heard on Wednesday morning that John Pit had blasted, I went again in search of Mr. Tate, and found him on the pit top. That might be about six o'clock. Mr. Tate and I went down at that time to within about five fathoms of the bottom, but we could then get no further. We found the pit in a ragged state from the blast. We then came up, and afterwards every means were used to get at the men. In about half an hour after, I went down again with James Rankin (one of the Parton pitmen), and got up James Wynn. I went down several times afterwards, and assisted in bringing up other men, and continued so employed until six o'clock this morning. All the men brought up were quite dead, having been either suffocated or burned. I never heard since Harrison Kay was engaged as overman at John Pit that there was any want of ventilation, or any want of materials. I never heard that John Pit was an unsafe pit, and it has been a much better air pit since Jane Pit was put on. Jane Pit was made the upcast pit after John Sharp left John Pit, (where he was overman). We found the principal part of the bodies in the steer. The overmen always took lamps with them. The air of John Pit was always good, so much so that the men worked with candles and not with lamps. Whenever there was any deficiency of air I went and examined the air course. Harrison Kay was found far in the workings, with all his clothes off. I have found bad air sometimes before in John Pit, but never knew of such a thing as a man being burned there. There never was a hagger worked in it with a lamp since I knew it.

In reply to questions by different jurors, Ellwood said I thought that I had done my duty when I told Mr. Tate of the fall on Tuesday evening. I never found any deficiency of wood about the pit to carry on air. The air courses were not watched, but when the air was in a bad state then we went to examine them. My duty was not to make the air better, but to report when it was bad. I remember that there were falls before from the Jane pit shaft; the falls were from the sides. I am not aware that any means were taken to prevent the recurrence of them, but alterations may have been made in the shaft without my knowing it. The rubbish fell at the mouth of the shaft. The falls were all at the same place. I cannot tell whether it would have taken much trouble to have prevented the falls, but I did not consider the pit quite safe as it was without constant watching. Harrison Kay was the principal overman in John pit, and it was his duty to look after the air shaft.

George Vitch deposed — I belong to Workington, and was sent for to assist in getting the unfortunate men out of John pit on Thursday morning, I went down with assistants. I cannot exactly say what number of bodies I found, but I think 17. I found them on the Steer. I saw four more bodies at the time, but I was so much exhausted that I could not stay to get them. The whole of the bodies lay as if they had been blown where I found them by the blast. All the 21 bodies were laying within five yards of each other. They were blown all up in a heap across the Steer to the north working. They were not very far from the Steer, where I suppose they would be sitting until the overmen returned from their examination of the pit. The blast had come from Harrison Kay's (the south) side of the pit. The picks of many of the men were stuck into their bodies, and they, with their lanterns, bottles, and other things, were all mixed up in a mass. I think the men had not been set to work that morning.

John Darling (an old man) said — I attended the air furnaces at the top of Jane pit on the night of Tuesday last. My duty was to be there each alternate day and night. On the night previous to the accident I was on duty at the furnace, and about midnight I heard a fall down the shaft of the Jane pit. The fall was a great one — a terrible deal of stuff fell. I thought all was going down together, the fall was great. It forced the fire out of the furnace, and drove me from where I was standing, and out of the door. The fall might last five minutes. After that the fire wouldn't burn, and the arch (basis of the air tube) was so clear that I could see to the top of the pit. When there was no stoppage we could not see, because all the foulness used to come steaming up there. I concluded that the air course was stopped up altogether, and that the foulness couldn't then come. When I say that I was forced from the furnace I do not mean that I was driven by the force of the blast, but that I was compelled to retire to the door for fear of being burned or suffocated. I went out many times after that to look for the men coming, but none came for a long time. At last, at day-break, Harrison Kay came to me to see if the air was good at the shaft. I told him the air was not good, and I told him also what had happened plain enough. I told him that I had heard a great fall. He found by trying a candle at the shaft that the air was stopped. I said he had better go and tell Mr. Tate, but he didn't say whether he would go or not. I believe he did not go, but I cannot positively speak to that. All that he said when he left me was — "D-n the pit!" I can't say what he did after that. In about half an hour after the explosion took place. The report was enough to frighten anybody. I was close to it.

In answer to questions by jurors this witness said — Sometimes the air in the Jane pit shaft would blow a candle out, but on Tuesday morning it had no effect. I once before heard a fall as big as Tuesday's, it was cleared away. I can't say who was the overman below then. The place was often dropping a little. The great fall I speak of took place two or three weeks ago, and as the furnace burned well enough after that I think the rubbish must have been cleared away. There was I believe a fall on Tuesday afternoon, but that was cleared away. The air course was I think, choked up by the last fall.

Mr. Bragg here observed, that presuming that no blame attached to others, it was already clear that great culpability attached to Harrison Kay, for his duty it was to go down and take care that all was safe, and the others ought not to have gone down until his return.

Juror to witness — Do you think that the shaft could not have been made safe by Mr. Tate? — Witness: I can't say.

Coroner — No; of course; it is not likely he can speak to that.

Mr. Stanley (principal agent to Mr. Curwen) said they would call a witness to speak to Mr. Tate's conduct if the Coroner desired.

Mr. Bragg said at present they had nothing to do with Mr. Tate. There was nothing in evidence that impugned his conduct, and he did not sit there to attend to what idle stories might be told out of Court.

Joseph Furness was next examined. He stated — On Wednesday morning last I was sitting at John pit top when the explosion took place. Me and others ran over the Bankstead and away into the fields. We continued to run until the pit settled. When the fire had subsided, and the pit top was quiet, we went back. The first thing on our return that I saw was the boy Cooper in a basket, which had been blown up the pit on to the striking board, just as if it had been lifted there. Another boy (Nutter) was sitting on the side of the shaft, with his feet hanging down the pit. The first thing that made us know he was there was his saying "Please men lend me your hands out of this." Saw John Gill, who had also been blown up the pit, but he was found by some other men. I have worked at John pit since the accident at Workington (14 months ago), all but three weeks which I worked at Ellenborough, and three weeks at Parton at the time when John Sharp left.

Coroner — Was John Pit a good air pit? — Witness — When the Jane pit shaft is kept clear and right John pit is as good an air pit as any in England.

Did you ever know the Jane pit shaft wrong? — Ellwood told me the night before that it was choked up within 18 inches of the top, and that he had told Mr. Tate so.

Yes, but of your own knowledge, did you ever know the air bad in John Pit? — No I can't say I ever did. It was good the night before the accident, and had been so ever since I came to it from Parton. When I left John pit, and went to Parton, it was not because the air was bad.

Ellwood told me that when he went to Mr. Tate to tell him about the shaft being choked up to within 18 inches of the top, Mr. Tate said he would send men in the morning to clear it out; and on Wednesday morning John Kay and Thos. Crennell told me that they had received orders to clear it out that day. John and Harrison Kay were brothers. I have heard Harrison Kay say that he could not get wood from Moorhouse (Mr. Tate's) to keep the pit clear of dirt (foul air). Robert. Wynn who is dead and gone, was complaining to Harrison Kay that his place was dirty, when Kay said he had best be cautious, as she would always be dirty until he got slides to carry air into her.

Yet Wynn continued to work with a candle. His place used to get clear in the day, but at night it became foul, and he had to dash the dirt out in the morning with his shirt. He used to leave his candle out in the main working until he dashed his place clear; it was about 30 feet in, and by working in it during the day it got clear. My working was a few yards from Wynn's, but I never had to complain of the air, nor did I ever hear any one on the same side complain. Wynn had the air before us, but we were in the blob of it — it bosomed in just where we were.

In answer to jurymen — I did not leave John Pit on account of bad air, and had the accident not happened on Wednesday morning we all should have been down in half an hour. We had no fear of her being foul, but it seems there could have been no good air in her, as she was so full of fire. Mr. Tate was in the habit of coming down into the pit once or twice a fortnight; he might be down oftener; and me not see him.

Juror — Do you think Harrison Kay was a fit man to be appointed overman? — Witness — I wont say; every man must judge for himself about that; I think it has shown for itself whether he was or not. I should have been down the pit that morning had I not once been nearly snapt myself at Workington; I have been cautious about going soon down ever since.

John Douglas — I have been at John Pit about 18 months — ever since the time the water was in her. I was the first man who went down after that. I was at home on the morning of the explosion, and on being told of it I went first for the doctor, and then to the pit to assist what I could. I went down with others on Thursday about three o'clock in the afternoon, when we found about a dozen bodies. They were on both sides of the Steer; four on the south side were all in a heap; the others were straggled about. They seemed where I think they would be waiting for the return of the overmen; the Steer was the spot where they usually waited. I think they had been driven by the blast from the south side, because that end was clear and the north end was choked up. The air was very decent in John Pit when the Jane Pit shaft was kept right. I have heard complaints of the shaft falling down, but none of the air. I have heard William Hetherington say that he could not get stuff (wood, plates, nails, &c.) to make the men comfortable. I never complained, but I have asked William Hetherington for wood and iron to mend the trailing road, but I never got any. I never knew any explosion in John Pit before, except about 12 months ago, when Robert Jackson was badly burnt; but that was owing to his own neglect, in going where he had no business. I never knew any man refuse to go down this pit in consequence of foul air or insecurity, but when John Sharp left the workmen objected to the overman appointed in his stead. The Jane Pit was opened after Sharp left, since which time there has been no complaints. I have two brothers who left John Pit for foul air, but that was caused by the shaft of the Jane Pit falling in; but on the shaft being repaired they came back and have worked there ever since. I have known the workings a little dirty in the mornings sometimes, but then we used to bat them with our shirts and work in them with a candle.

John Sharp sworn and examined — For about nine or ten years I was overman at John Pit. I left it ten weeks ago.

For what reason did you leave John Pit? — I left because I could not make her so safe as I wanted to make her.

How was that? — I left for three reasons. Firstly, because I could not get a sufficient quantity of air into the pit to carry her on with safety. Secondly, I could not get materials when I wanted them to get on with my work in time. When I wanted a thing in a few days, I could not get it for weeks. In short, I never could get things when I required them. Thirdly, I could not get assistance from Mr. Tate when such was needed. The pit was not sufficiently ventilated when I left it. The reason was that the upcast pit at the time (Hodgson Pit) did not draw regularly. The air was always laden — the shaft did not draw it up. I repeatedly told Mr. Tate about this. After I left they carried the air to Jane pit. The doing of that was commenced, but not completed, when I left. I cannot say what state John pit was in before the accident, nor since the Jane Pit became the upcast pit. I have heard many accounts, but I can state nothing to be relied on as to that. I never had anything to do with Jane pit, and cannot say whether opening her has answered the purpose intended or not. I went down John pit on Wednesday morning but not to the bottom at that time, as it was not safe. I have been there, less or more, ever since. I was down at the time Nichol and Addison were found on the scaffold at the pit bottom. They were the first found after the man who had fallen down the shaft. When I went down again, I found three more, a few yards from the pit foot. On Thursday when I went I discovered a great number — can't say how many. They were principally across the Steer, on the north side. Two bodies were got 40 or 50 yards further up the Steer. They were the last found on Thursday — making in all 38 bodies got out up to that time. The heap which we discovered were all jammed close together, mixed up with broken corves and other things, from the appearance my opinion is that the body of fire came from the south side. I was not present when Harrison Kay was found. Before the opening of Jane pit, Mr. Tate and I consulted together about it, and agreed that it would be advisable to make her the upcast pit.

As his witness's examination seemed here to have closed a desultory conversation followed upon the reasons alleged by him for leaving John pit.

Mr. Stanley said that there never could be any deficiency of wood at the pits, for his instructions Mr. Tate were that whatever wood was wanted should be got immediately from Mr. Peile's Yard at Harrington.

The Coroner thought that did not affect the question, as it did not appear that Sharp had the power to get wood from Mr. Peile.

The Coroner then resumed his examination of the witness: — You say you could not get wood and iron to carry on John pit? No, not all times.

Were those things not got you as soon as they reasonably might? No, Sir.

You know in all considerable public works it may not be possible at all times to supply immediately what may be wanted, but you say that the things you speak of were not to be got in due season? — They were not. I could name many things that were not got in due season. If I wanted doors as it might be to-day, I was told by Mr. Tate to go to the men, and have often waited for them five or six weeks. Sometimes the men said they had not wood — sometimes that they had not time. I have known them say this when there was more wood on the spot than would have done twenty times what I wanted.

Mr. Tate — Did I never tell you to apply to the workmen and not to me? — No.

Coroner — He says he spoke to you for these things to keep the air right.

Mr. Tate — But perhaps I had something else to do just at the time.

Coroner — That won't do; that makes the matter worse.

Mr. Tate — If Sharp could not get the things he wanted he might have stopped the works.

Coroner — Not so; he would hardly have been justified in doing that. No gentleman would entrust an under servant with power to stop his works whenever he pleased.

Sharp — Mr. Tate never said he would not get me the things I wanted, but always said that he would, but then he did not get me them in due season.

Coroner — Did you ever find John pit in a bad state? — Yes, many times.

That was when Hodgson pit was the upcast pit? — Yes.

Did you then give information to Mr. Tate, the agent, of what had come to your knowledge? — Yes, sir.

What precautions were used after that? — I was told by Mr. Tate not to tell the men when the air was bad, but to mark the workings where the bad air was with chalk.

Mr. Stanley — What, do you mean to say that you white-balled the workings? — Yes, I did; but then the men would not go to work.

Coroner — This is not quite clear — will you explain? — Witness: When I and the deputy overman used to go round the workings, if we found any places where there was bad air, we were in the habit of telling the men who worked in those places the state of the air, and then perhaps, all the men would refuse to go to their work. I told Mr. Tate of this, and he said for the time to come I had better not tell the men which places were dirty, but chalk them. By the chalking they were to understand that their places were dangerous. The men were all told of this plan, but they would not abide by it. They said they would leave the pit first. I also disapproved of the plan, and never went my rounds afterwards.

Mr. Tate here remarked that the practice of chalking the unsafe workings was adopted in many collieries. When some men were openly told that their places were dangerous, all in the pit would often go away, and leave her, whereas when the dirty workings were chalked, those who were employed in them only went away, and the others remained at their work. There was no wish to conceal the motive for the chalking from any of the men.

The Coroner was glad to hear the explanation which had been given, for it was calculated to disabuse the public mind of prejudice, although the matter did not affect the present inquiry.

John Kay, brother of Harrison Kay, said — The last day that I was at work in John pit was on Tuesday last. My brother on that day came to me, and said he was going to clear the bore-holes. On the day before that, when I was working at a straight-end, my brother came and sat beside me, whilst he ate his breakfast, and he then said he had not seen the air so good in the pit as it was on that day and the day before for six weeks. He said there was no dirt to be seen in his district. I never saw him after he told me about his going to clear the bore holes. I worked at the highest place on the south side, and on Tuesday the air was very good; there was no dirt that day. The doors in the main drift were not shut when I left on Tuesday night. I shut two of them after me; a third was so bad that it was no use shutting it. It was the custom for the last man to shut the door after him. If there had been any dirt stirring the doors would not have been left open during the day.

In reply to jurors — My brother did tell me to keep the boys out of the first working on the right hand side of his district, as there was some dirt there; nobody was working in that place. There was no want of materials in the pit that I ever heard of. No want of boards for slides, or partitions. I think the accident did not arise from the want of proper regulations in the pit. Some think it took place one way, and some another. I think the explosion took place on my brother's side, and that it was caused by a door being left open.

William Calvin — I have worked at John pit for some time. I was there on Tuesday evening last, and I then thought that there was a want of air — that it was slacker than it had been for some time before. Sometimes the air was so strong that it was like to blow a candle out, but on Tuesday night it would not turn the flame. I never used a lamp. I never saw any fire in John pit that was ought. It was always a good air pit, and had been much improved since Jane pit was opened out. I worked on Kay's side. I was on the pit bank when the explosion took place, and I afterwards assisted in bringing men up. I can't account for the explosion. I blame nobody for it. Harrison Kay was objected to by the men when he was appointed overman, and I then heard him say that if any one objected to him openly he would resign the place. The men after that all went down with him. I never heard any complaint about slides being wanted.

At this stage of the proceedings, Joseph Holliday, a collier, came into the school house, and communicated to the Coroner that the body of William Hetherington had just been found. He was found far in the north drift lying upon his face, with his lamp about two yards from him. He was not at all disfigured.

The Coroner then proposed an adjournment for an hour and a half, during which time the jury would have an opportunity of viewing the body of William Hetherington. An adjournment for the period proposed accordingly took place.

Soon after five o'clock the coroner and jury re-assembled, and inquiry was made if any other witnesses were in attendance? The constable stated that several colliers were about the doors who wished to be heard, and the Coroner desired one of them to be called.

Andrew Sharp said he wished to speak to the conduct of Harrison Kay. He was not a fit man for his situation. He came to the pit on the Thursday before so drunk that he could not set the men to work. I have seen him use a candle and a lamp in the pit. William Hetherington had no equal authority with Kay. Kay was an ignorant and a headstrong man. I was on the pit top when the accident happened. I was always about the last in going down, because I had a dread upon me of something happening from what Wm. Hetherington had told me.

James Black, a banksman, was also sworn and examined, but he deposed to nothing new; and the other men said that they could speak to no fresh facts of their own knowledge — only to what the had heard from others.

The Coroner then said that so far as his own feelings were concerned, he was quite willing to sit and listen to any persons who might wish to come before him, and give evidence in so serious an inquiry, and even to adjourn until Monday, if requested; but of course it was his duty to take care that the time of the jurors was not wasted by listening to every idle tale that might be abroad, and which could not possibly be made evidence in the case.

As it did not appear that any more witnesses were in attendance, or were likely to be produced, the Coroner proceeded to read over the deposition of the several witnesses, and to recall to the minds of the jury the observations which he had made to them on opening the inquiry.

The Court having been cleared, the jury consulted for a short time upon their verdict, which was to the following effect :— "That the deceased Henry Peel [and the other 39 sufferers, as named in the several returns] being with other workmen in a certain coal pit called John pit, situate near Harrington, and about to do work there, it so happened that when there by some measure or other, the fire damp or inflammable air (which was lodged in the said pit, took fire and exploded, by means whereof he, the said Henry Peel, was then and there suffocated and burnt, of which said suffocation and burning he, the said Henry Peel, did then and there die. And so the jurors aforesaid upon their oaths aforesaid, say that the said Henry Peel, accidentally, casually, and by misfortune came by his death in manner aforesaid, and not otherwise; but lament that due precaution had not been used by Mr. Tate, the coal agent, in securing the main air course, which might have prevented this lamentable accident."

Far be it from us to call in question the correctness of the above verdict and farther still any wish to detract from those solemn feelings and that high sense of public duty, which, we believe, induced the jury to place on record the expression of their opinion; but without underrating the great affliction which the accident has spread around, or the desirableness of inducing greater caution in time to come, we may, in justice to the living, hesitatingly ask if the censure on Mr. Tate which the verdict contains is supported by the evidence? We do not wish to offer any opinion on the general management of the Harrington collieries as developed before the jury, nor on the impropriety of placing a man of Harrison Kay's reckless and fool-hardy character in the deeply responsible situation which he filled; but from the testimony of the various witnesses it is to us clear that Mr. Tate had been undeservedly inculpated. The witnesses tell us that the air in the pit was good on Tuesday evening, after the fall that took place that day — the old man in care of the fire at the Jane Pit air-shaft states that there was a good draught up the shaft until midnight, when it became choked up — that he made Harrison Kay acquainted with the state of the ventilation when he arrived in the morning, but that the unfortunate man took little heed of what he said, and went down into the pit, in his usual way — that was with a lantern and candle — and that in about half an hour the blast took place. Now from the fall of rubbish in the air-course, which choked it up until the pit blew up, no communication was made to Mr. Tate — he was perfectly ignorant of what had occurred — and therefore to cast censure upon him for not using such precaution as would have prevented the accident, seems to us dealing rather hardly by him, and to be affixing a stigma upon his conduct and character not justified by the facts. Had Harrison Kay been a man of common caution and reflection the accident might have been avoided; his recklessness and rashness "did the deed." Under the circumstances Mr. Tate had no power to prevent it.

All the sufferers (save three) were burned to death — they would be destroyed in the twinkling of an eye by the violence of the volcanic-like explosion. Harrison Kay was literally blown to pieces. All his clothes were rent from his body, except the socks on his feet — no feature of his face was distinguishable — and his heart hung dangling by his side.

Hetherington, the deputy overman, who was a most respectable man in his station, was found lying on his face, with his hands clasped over his forehead, and with his lamp about two yards from him. He had expired for want of vital air, and his body was in no way disfigured.

Such had been also the fate of little Hayton in his stable :— he was found with one hand and arm across the neck of the pony which it was his duty to tend, and in the other hand was a piece of bread. He was a beautiful corpse.

In the course of Saturday the whole of the bodies (with the exception of those of Harrison Kay and Wm. Hetherington, which were interred on Sunday) were buried, and the sight was of the most solemn and affecting description. The day was wet and gloomy, and amongst the crowds of sorrowers which attended the affecting solemnities scarcely a whisper was heard, and a deep silence reigned during the whole of the service at the several churches, save when the hush was broken by the deep sigh of kindred or affection. The scene was of a nature never to be forgotten by those who witnessed it.

The following were interred at Harrington by the Rev. John Curwen: — Henry Peel aged 47, and Harrison and Robert (his sons) aged respectively 12 and 10 years; James Wilson, 37; Jonathan, his son, aged 11; John Wilson, (James's brother) aged 34; Harrison Kay, 26; John Richardson, 22; Jos. Metcalfe, 24; Joseph Relph, 20; Ralph Sanderson, 14; Eldred Burnett, 23; and George Edgar, 18.

The following were buried at Distington by the Rev. Henry Lowther: — Joseph Cape, aged 59; Robert Nichol, 41; Thomas Pearson Addison, 29; Wm. Addison, 17; Robert Wynn, 31, John Wynn, 24, and James Wynn, 16 (brothers); James Griminson, 24; John Kelly, 13; George Crennell, 13; and Robert Dunn, 15, and John Dunn, 13 (brothers).

And the following have their final resting place in the church-yard at Workington: — William Hetherington, aged 35; John Ditchburn, 13; Henry Ward, 26; Peter Dobson, 22; Fletcher, John, and Jonathan Benson, three brothers, aged respectively 16, 14, and 10 years; Robert and James Donald, aged 11 and 10; John and Nicholas Hayton, aged 16 and 11; Richard Scruggam, 15; Robert Iredale, 14; and William and Jas. Moore, aged 17 and 15.

Twenty-four children have been rendered fatherless by the above calamity, and 12 wives made widows, three of whom, it is painful to state, are far advanced in pregnancy. But cases of distress equal to any thus occasioned are to be found in aged people being deprived of their children and grandchildren on whom they entirely depended for support. The poverty and grief which the accident has created are appalling and truly lamentable, and those who are left to mourn and to suffer know not where to look for succour or help in their hour of need. To relieve their immediate necessities we rejoice to learn that small sums have been collected in the parishes of Distington and Harrington, and since it has been suggested to us, we beg to say that any trifles left at our office for the same humane purpose we shall be most happy to acknowledge, and to hand over to the ministers in the townships named, to be applied as they may deem best.

We mentioned last week that all the experienced colliers of the neighbourhood had devoted themselves with most praiseworthy zeal, energy, and courage, to rescue the remains of their fellow labourers from the place where they were destroyed, and as an act of justice to those men for their honest heroism and humanity, we have procured a list of the names of all who were active, which we here lay before the public :—

Parton Men :— Mr. James Rankin, Robert Little, John Gill, John Allen, Henry Nutter, James Nutter, Joseph Armstrong, Joseph Griffith, John Griffith, Thomas Patterson, Peter Edgar, William Tinnion, Joseph Brocklebank, John Crennel, John Glyn Wright, Joseph Gowdy.

Workington Men :— William Bland, John Sharp, John Ditchburn, George Vitch, Richard Short, Thomas Hollet, Wm. Thompson, Wm. Ditchburn, Thos. Donald, George Halybrough, Robert Jorden, Robert Hollet, Hugh Gilmour, Michael Currey, John Bell, George Lowther, Anthony Weir, Edward Elliott, Joseph Cameron.

Harrington Men :— John Lowes, Wm. Grimminson, John Hutton, Soloman Ellwood, Robert Jackson, Jonathan Ellwood, Joseph Kay, John Douglas, Andrew Sharpe, James Tyson, Henry Nutter.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Addison, Thomas Pearson   24 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Addison, William   14 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Allen, John    Rescue Worker  
Armstrong, Joseph    Rescue Worker  
Bell, John    Rescue Worker  
Benson, Fletcher   15 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Benson, John   12 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Benson, Jonathan   14 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Black, James    Banksman  
Bland, William    Rescue Worker  
Bragg, William    Coroner  
Brocklebank, Joseph    Rescue Worker  
Burnett, Eldred   13 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Calvin, William    Miner  
Cameron, Joseph    Rescue Worker  
Cape, Joseph   52 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Carr, —    Innkeeper  
Carr, John    Juror  
Cooper, James    Trailer  
Crennel, John    Rescue Worker  
Crennell, George   12 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Currey, Michael    Rescue Worker  
Curwen, John, Rev.    Vicar  
Darling, John    Furnaceman  
Ditchburn, John    Rescue Worker  
Ditchburn, John   12 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Ditchburn, William    Rescue Worker  
Dobson, Peter   30 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Donald, James   16 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Donald, Robert   12 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Donald, Thomas    Rescue Worker  
Douglas, John    Miner  
Dunn, John   13 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Dunn, Robert   12 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Edgar, George   17 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Edgar, Peter    Rescue Worker  
Elliott, Edward    Rescue Worker  
Ellwood, Jonathan    Back Overman  
Ellwood, Soloman    Rescue Worker  
Ewart, Rownson    Juror  
Furness, Joseph    Miner  
Gibson, John    Juror  
Gill, John    Rescue Worker  
Gilmour, Hugh    Rescue Worker  
Gilpin, George Warren    Juror  
Gowdy, Joseph    Rescue Worker  
Griffith, John    Rescue Worker  
Griffith, Joseph    Rescue Worker  
Griminson, Joseph   22 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Grimminson, William    Rescue Worker  
Halybrough, George    Rescue Worker  
Hayton, Jonathan   12 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hayton, Nicholas   14 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hetherington, William   33 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hollet, Robert    Rescue Worker  
Hollet, Thomas    Rescue Worker  
Holliday, Joseph    Miner  
Hutton, John    Rescue Worker  
Irsdale, Robert   10 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Jackson, George    Juror  
Jackson, Robert    Rescue Worker  
Jorden, Robert    Rescue Worker  
Kay, Harrison   24 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Kay, John    Miner  
Kay, Joseph    Rescue Worker  
Kelly, John   12 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Kitchen, Isaac    Juror  
Little, Robert    Rescue Worker  
Lowes, John    Rescue Worker  
Lowther, George    Rescue Worker  
Lowther, Henry, Rev.    Vicar  
Meals, William    Juror  
Metcalfe, Joseph   25 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Moordaff, Shadrach    Juror  
Moore, James   10 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Moore, William   12 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Nichol, Robert   41 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Nutter, Henry    Rescue Worker  
Nutter, James    Rescue Worker  
Nutter, John    Miner  
Patterson, Thomas    Rescue Worker  
Pearce, John    Juror  
Peel, Harrison   13 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Peel, Henry   50 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Peel, Robert   11 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Piper, Henry    Juror  
Ralph, John   20 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Rankin, James    Rescue Worker  
Richardson, John   22 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Robson, John    Juror  
Sanderson, Ralph   11 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Sanley, Matthew    Juror  
Scruggam, Richard   10 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Sharp, Andrew    Rescue Worker  
Sharp, John    Overman  
Sharpe, Andrew    Rescue Worker  
Short, Richard    Rescue Worker  
Stalker, Henry    Juror  
Stanley, —    Agent  
Thompson, William    Rescue Worker  
Tinnion, William    Rescue Worker  
Tyson, James    Rescue Worker  
Vitch, George    Miner  
Ward, Henry   25 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Weir, Anthony    Rescue Worker  
Wilson, James   35 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Wilson, John   30 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Wilson, Jonathan   12 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Wilson, Thomas    Juror  
Wright, John Glyn    Rescue Worker  
Wynn, James   16 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Wynn, John   21 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Wynn, Robert   25 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Harrington Colliery  Harrington Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
24 Oct 1838  Coal-Mine Explosion (Annual Register for 1838)
27 Oct 1838  Dreadful Coal Pit Explosion, Forty Lives Lost! (Whitehaven Herald)
29 Oct 1838  Coal Pit Explosion, And Loss Of 34 Lives (The Times)
31 Oct 1838  Dreadful Coal Pit Explosion — Forty Lives Lost (The Times)
03 Nov 1838  The Late Coal-Pit Explosion (The Times)
03 Nov 1838  The Dreadful Explosion at John Pit (Whitehaven Herald)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Harrington, John Pit
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 12 Mar 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print