|
Whitehaven HeraldArticle from the Whitehaven Herald, 15th July 1837 Dreadful Suicide Of One Of Lord Lonsdale's Colliery StewardsIt is this week our painful duty to place on record the details of an event of the most distressing nature, which has created in this town and district a universal of the deepest sorrow, and most poignant regret. This feeling has extended through every class of our townsmen, and the awful calamity which gave it birth has constituted the sole and absorbing topic of conversation in every circle. The occurrence which has created this sensation, and spread a general gloom, is the untimely death of Mr. William Quayle, who for many years filled the situation of steward to the Earl of Lonsdale in his coal mines. On Monday evening, considerable anxiety was felt by Mr. Quayles's friends in consequence of his absence, which anxiety was much increased on Tuesday, when all inquiries respecting him proved fruitless and ineffectual. It having been ascertained that he had not gone out of town, the alarm for his safety continued to increase and the most intense interest pervaded the minds of those who were aware if his being missing, and of certain circumstances which had transpired shortly before he was last seen. On Wednesday morning, about eleven o'clock, the worst apprehensions were fulfilled; the body of the unfortunate gentleman was discovered immersed in water, at the foot of the shaft of an old coal pit on the north side of town, called James Pit — at a depth of more than 400ft from the surface of the earth! His remains were much contused and disfigured. On being raised, the body was placed in a cart covered over with a green cloth, and conveyed to the house of deceased, in Roper Street, about mid-day. In the afternoon of the same day an inquest was held on the body, at the Public Office, by Peter Hodgson, Esq., and a respectable jury. The jury having been sworn, Mr. Hodgson shortly addressed them. He said the first part of their duty would be to view the body of the deceased, William Quayle, as that was one of the requirements of the law in all such cases, but he trusted in discharging it they would occasion as little trouble as possible to the family of the deceased. The coroner and jury then retired for a short time to view the body. On their return the coroner again addressed them, and cautioned them against attending, in the course of the inquiry, to conjectures or opinions, but strictly to confine themselves to the consideration of facts. The first question for them to consider would be whether the deceased had come by his death accidentally, or had purposely sought it; whether he had thrown himself into the pit where the body was found, or had been thrown into it by other parties; and if it should be their opinion that he had thrown himself in, then it would be a question for their consideration whether the act had been committed when deceased was in the full possession of his faculties, or when labouring under an aberration of mind. In other words, it would be for the jury to determine by their verdict whether the deceased had been murdered or had destroyed himself. If the evidence went no further than to show that the body had been found in the water of a certain pit, it would probably be for them to simply find the deceased had been found drowned; but if they were led to believe that he had thrown himself in, he begged to say the evidence ought to be most distinct before they arrived at that conclusion. He called upon them to dismiss from their minds whatever they might have heard of certain transactions at the Colliery Office; with what might have taken place there they had nothing to do — their duty being confined to enquiring how William Quayle came by his death. He (the Coroner) had thought it his duty to address these observations to the jury, and he had no doubt they would come to a proper determination. The following witnesses were then examined: - William Shepherd, a boy about 14 years of age, said — On Monday afternoon last, about two o'clock, I saw Mr. Quayle coming by the end of the Free School, when I was lying in the field. He was going towards James Pit. When he got there, he went in at the door of the paling which surrounds the pit. I saw no more of him. Nobody was with him. He did not close the door after him, but left it ajar, so that any one passing could have seen into the in-closure. Nobody was in the in-closure but Mr. Quayle himself. If any one had been in I must have seen them. I saw nobody come out, and if any person or persons had come out I must have seen them. William Hetherington sworn, said — On Tuesday night I was called upon by my master to go and look for Mr. Quayle. I went first to the Granary Yard, and then to William Pit. From thence I went to James Pit, where I grappled down in the water in search of the body, which we found this morning about eleven o'clock. I went to search there according to my orders, but I do not know what causes there were for searching there. James Reed told me to go there. Searched from eleven o'clock last night until eleven this morning, when I found Mr. Quayle in the water at the foot of the shaft. He was quite dead. One shoe was off. I don't know how he came there. John Temple was the next witness called, and as he also could only speak relative to the search for, and finding of the body, the Coroner declined to examine him. He said part of Mr. Quayle's duty was to visit James Pit. The Coroner again addressed the jury. He thought they could have no difficulty in coming to their verdict. Deceased had been found at the bottom of the shaft, in the water, but how he came there no evidence had been adduced to show. They had nothing in that Court to do with the stories which were abroad. Deceased when he met his death might have been looking into the shaft, overbalanced himself, and so fallen over. His duty was to go to James Pit, and supposing his mind to have been agitated at the time, it was not unreasonable to suppose that he might have lost his balance, and so fallen over. That was certainly only conjecture, but there was no evidence to the contrary, and therefore the proper verdict would be that deceased was found drowned in the water of a certain coal pit called James Pit. A juryman (Mr. Tebay) thought that "Found dead" would be a more proper verdict because it was likely that life was extinct before the body reached the water. The Coroner said that verdict would not do; and a confused discussion arose. William Hetherington and William Thornton were again called forward. The water in James Pit was probably 40 fathoms deep. The body was not at the bottom of the water, nor at the top, but was brought up by their grappling. It was floating when they saw it; they put a rope round it, and pulled it out. The head was much injured. The hat was floating on the surface of the water. The body was 35 fathoms below the hat, and 40 fathoms below where Mr. Quayle's almanack was found. A projecting rail had been newly broken, and they supposed that it had been broken by the descent of the body. The Coroner did not think this evidence altered the case. There had been nothing adduced to show that the deceased had been thrown in, or that he had been killed in falling, but only that he was found dead in the water, and the reasonable inference was that he had been drowned therein. The jury then, in accordance with the Coroner's directions, agreed to a verdict of "Found drowned." Such are the details of this deplorable event as developed in the Coroner's Court; as public journalists we feel it is our duty to go somewhat further, and add what is everywhere stated as having probably led to the unexpected tragedy. The current statement is, and we have every reason to rely upon its authenticity, that Mr. Quayle had that morning been summoned to an interview with the head and confidential servants of my Lord Lonsdale, by whom he had been charged with irregularity in his accounts. We shall not attempt to detail here what is said to have transpired at that interview, further than that the accused is reported to have asked for time to vindicate himself, which was refused, and he was then dismissed from Lord Lonsdale's service. Overcome by feelings too powerful to control, it is believed that deceased had gone straight to the mouth of the worked out pit which has been named, and cast himself headlong down the yawning abyss! — and it is impossible to conceive how long his remains might have lay undiscovered in that gloomy cavern had not the boy Shepherd observed the unhappy man enter the in-closure which surrounds the shaft. The subject is painful to dwell upon, but we cannot dismiss it without a few reflections. The first remark which forces itself upon the mind in viewing this terrific occurrence is, that the system of paying the stewards and servants acted upon by Lord Lonsdale, is the worst that possibly can be — that of paying small salaries, and allowing perquisites of office, which, probably, are undefined: - a system which has a most demoralising tendency, for the conscience is a very accommodating principle in man, and will frequently allow a much greater latitude to his actions than may be approved of; hence it is, that stewards accumulate money with small salaries, but, nevertheless, at a great risk to themselves; for should any misunderstanding take place, charges of peculation are immediately made, and the consequences are of the most awful description. In the case of Mr. Quayle we have an instance before us, which is the more unfortunate as he was about to quit Lord Lonsdale's employ, having taken an extensive colliery, which was likely to have come into competition with the Whitehaven collieries; and that the plan of fraud, which is imputed to have been carried on for a length of time, should only be detected at the last moment, is most extraordinary. It is most unfortunate for the friends of Mr. Quayle that he should have taken so desperate a course, for no doubt Lord Lonsdale will cause a thorough investigation to be instituted into the affairs of his concerns here, and, as dead men can give no account, nor confute the charges which may be brought forward, every deficiency which may be discovered will be put to Mr. Quayle's account. Every thing, in short, connected with this melancholy event is of the most distressing nature. Mr. Quayle's knowledge of mining was considered of a superior kind, and much above that of any other of Lord Lonsdale's agents; so far, therefore, as scientific skill is concerned, Lord Lonsdale will lose an invaluable servant. We may further remark, that if Lord Lonsdale would spend a little more of his time at Whitehaven whence he derives a considerable portion of his income, he would have an opportunity of witnessing the conduct of his servants, and consequently of judging how far they were doing justice to him. Finally, no man in the town of Whitehaven was more sincerely esteemed for kindness, liberality, and inoffensive manners than Mr. Quayle, whose sad and awful exit from the stage of existence will be long remembered in Whitehaven with unaffected grief.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||