|
6th February 1836, Page: 4, Column: 2 Explosion At Hetton Colliery, and Inquest On The SufferersAnother awful explosion occurred at Hetton colliery, near Houghton-le-Spring, on Thursday afternoon, by which sixteen persons lost their lives, and five others were so dreadfully scorched as to afford but faint hopes of their recovery. Upwards of one hundred persons were employed in the pit at the time the explosion occurred, but owing to the accident being confined to one of the workings, namely the Downs Pit, the number of victims was less than might have been expected. On Friday, an inquest was held at the New Inn, in Hetton-le-Hole, before T. C. Maynard, Esq., coroner for Easington Ward, on the bodies of three of the sufferers, — Mark Dodds, John Gardner, and John Milburn ; and by adjournment on Monday last. The evidence taken on the two days was very long ; but the substance of the depositions of the different witnesses was as follows. It will be remarked that the explosion seems to have been produced by the same cause — the negligent leaving open of a trap door — which occasioned the late calamity at Burdon main colliery, near North Shields. John Kendal, of Easington Lane, one of the Deputy Overmen in the Downs Pit, at the first North Board-way, said he went down the pit on Thursday morning, a quarter before two o'clock. He went through the whole workings of the above board-way. When he went in, a part of the men were at work ; but others had not got in. The second-shift men had, however, all come in before he left, which was about ten minutes past ten o'clock. None of the men had made any complaint to him of the workings being in a foul state, and he considered the pit, at the time he examined it, perfectly safe. The pit had not been long worked, and the workings were very small. The air was very good, and there was a sufficient quantity of it to enable the men to work with safety. There would be about 14 men working in that part of the pit when he left. The witness then described the situation of a trap-door in that part of the mine, the shutting or opening of which governed the course of the air. The men worked with candles ; no lamps were used except in the wastes. To direct the air into that part of the pit where the men were working, it was necessary to keep the trap-door shut ; and every possible precaution had been used to prevent accident. The trap-door was kept by a boy, about twelve years of age, named Anthony Cummings ; but about eight o'clock in the morning witness found the door open, though it was close when he was there five minutes before. The tubs in which the coals were carried to the shaft had been placed so as to prevent the door been shut. Witness found fault with the putters for this ; but they complained of the trapper for not keeping them back. Witness removed the tubs backward and closed the door. He pointed out to the trapper and the putters the danger of its being left open, and they all promised that they would not do so again. The trapper and the putters would not be changed in the ordinary course till half-past four in the afternoon. Witness went down the pit yesterday afternoon, about half-past three, and found that the trap door had been blown away, and a stopping substituted to give the air a proper direction. He was of opinion that the door must have been open before and at the time the explosion took place ; because if it had been kept closed there could not have been such an accumulation of foul air at that part of the pit as would have caused an explosion. No person in the pit had any thing to do with the trap-door except the trapper and the putters. The former was dead. Eight putters were employed there ; and three of them were dead — William Halliday, Mark Dodds, and Edward Dodds. Witness had been employed in the pit three months, and never witnessed any appearances to make him apprehend an explosion. Neither had he heard of any complaint, or expression of fear of that kind, from any of the workmen. The last thing witness did, before he left the pit in the morning, was most strictly to charge the trapper and putters to keep the trap-door closed. Ralph Joplin, the deputy Overman who had to succeed witness, had not gone down the pit when he left ; he had to go down at two o'clock. The deputy-Overman of the second North Board-way takes charge of the first for the four hours that there is no Deputy Overman there. About six o'clock in the morning, he met Cummins at the first wall from the flat — the place where the tubs are put upon the rolleys — about ten yards from the trap-door. Witness censured him for leaving his door, and he said William Halliday had sent him. He said he thought there was little harm in doing so when no person was at the flat ; but witness cautioned him not to do so again. Henry Gustard, another Deputy-Overman in the South Pit, said he was at work in the west part of the pit, between 1 and 2 o'clock in the afternoon, when the wind blew so strongly as to induce him to suppose an explosion had taken place in some other part of the mine. He hastened, with the men and boys he had under his charge, to the shaft, The witness then described the state of things at the first north board-way when he reached it, and the positions in which the bodies were found. Witness thought the explosion had taken place there ; and he had no doubt it had been caused by the trap-door having been left open ; he did not think it could have occurred otherwise. The witness then corroborated the last witness's testimony as to the state of the mine. The pit was considered to be so safe that the use of the Davy Lamp was regarded as unnecessary. He had not heard any of the pitmen object to use the Davy. — A slight fire had taken place in that part of the pit a week ago ; but no one was injured by it. Such fires occasionally occur in the best ventilated pits. Had the Davy Lamp been used, and the gauzes perfect, he did not think the explosion would have taken place. The coal in the first North Board-way was worked with gun powder — which was much easier for the men ; and witness did not think there was any danger in doing so in a pit where it was safe to use candles. The workings of the Downs pit were not extensive ; and there could not be so much accumulation of foul air in them as in others more extensive. The nature of the coal was not such as to throw much inflammable air into the workings ; the pit was safer in that respect than many others that witness had worked in. Mr. R. P. Edgar, surgeon, at Hetton-le-Hole, said he went down the pit, in consequence of the explosion, and found Richard Finlay, Thos. Finlay, Geo. Newton, John Gleghorn, Thos. Kay, John Gleghorn (cousin to the former person of the same name), James Cowans, Simon Tate, John Milburn, John Gardner, and John Wears, all lying dead. He had no doubt their fate had been produced by an explosion of hydrogen gas. Mark Dodds was very much burnt, and he died in consequence ; so with William Surtees and Edward Dodds. The latter was got out of the pit alive, but had died that day. Wm. Halliday was also very much burnt ; but witness was of opinion that his death was caused by his skull being crushed, which had been brought on concussion of the brain. Wm. Henry Blake Costde had been killed by something heavy falling on his breast. William Ward, John Walton, and Robinson Harland, had been severely burnt, and were not yet out of danger. Ralph Jobling, the deputy overman alluded to by the first witness, expressed his opinion that the explosion had taken place in the first wide board, close to the trap door. He had examined the pit particularly before he left work at ten o'clock on Wednesday night, and there was then not only no accumulation of inflammable air, but a particularly good air. He had considered the pit perfectly safe for the men to work there without the Davy lamp ; though, had it been used, he did not think the explosion would have taken place, neither did he think it would have occurred with candles had the trap-door been kept properly closed. He concurred in opinion with the witness Gustard about working the pit with gunpowder. Witness had never known the boys who kept the trap dour neglect their charge ; but he had every day cautioned the boy whom he found stationed there to be very attentive to it. William Clark, an overman of the pit, had charge of the mine from two o'clock in the afternoon till ten at night, and had examined it the night before the explosion took place, when every part of the mine was perfectly safe. Attributed the explosion to neglect of the trap-door. Witness had never heard the men complain of the pit being unsafe, nor express any wish for the Davy lamp. John Maugham, another overman, who gave similar evidence to the last witness, had not himself the slightest fear of any danger in the pit. The inquest was here adjourned until the Monday — when Mr. George Hunter, of Painsher, colliery viewer to the Marquis of Londonderry, said, he had yesterday examined the workings of the pit in company with Mr. Buddle and Mr. Appleby, and as he had found the workings quite clear, and the ventilation restored, he concluded that the pit must have been in a safe working state, with the exception of the first Wide Board, where the explosion had taken place. He attributed the explosion to the trap-door having been kept too long open through want of care of the trapper. The ventilation had been so speedily restored after the explosion, that he had no doubt the workings would have been in a proper state had not negligence occurred with regard to the trap-door. He was decidedly of opinion that candles might have been safely used in the pit prior to the explosion, had due caution been observed at the trap-door. He was of the same opinion, with the same reservation, as to the present state of the mine ; candles might now be safely used there, if the trap-door were properly attended to. Gunpowder might be safely used in a mine where candles were employed. Did not think the passing of the tubs through the trap-door would be sufficient to render the air impure. The use of iron tubs in the mine could not, in his opinion, have the effect of at all deteriorating the air. On the contrary, he considered them rather advantageous than otherwise, as they were smaller and occupied less space than others. To the best of his judgment, and speaking from his knowledge of the use of iron tubs in South Hetton Colliery, the use of such tubs did not make the slightest difference in the ventilation. He had not, in his experience, discovered any difference between the use of iron tubs and corves. Mr. John Appleby, of East Rainton, coal-viewer, concurred in Mr. Hurter's statement. Joseph Hall, a pitman, who was at work in the mine on the day before the explosion, said, the first north wide-board was in a very bad state for want of fresh air, when he left about three o'clock in the afternoon of that day. That part was not generally in a bad state ; but it was so at that time. Witness used candles and gunpowder, but thought it was not fit to use candles at that time. He had told Kendal, that morning, that the pit was very slack of fresh air. Kendal had been in the first wide-board before that, and witness saw he had pulled some fresh brattice in. Kendal told him he had pulled some stones off the top of the fall, at the back of the brattice, to let more air in ; but witness found little difference. He thought he was working in a dangerous place ; but he had only wrought there 9 days. Last quarter, he worked in the board adjoining the first wide-board, and found the air slack there ; but the reason was that that board got the hindmost of the air. He made no complaint respecting the adjoining board. He thought it needless to do so, because they could make no better of it, as it was the hindmost of the air. Had he complained, he had no doubt it would have been attended to. The air wholly depended on the trap-doorto be shut. Had that been attended to, he could not say that the pit would have fired ; but he believed the door had been neglected sometimes. Thomas Sanderson, a pitman, said, he had worked 13 years in the colliery, and never knew anything requested but what was done for the safety of the pit. He thought, however, that the big tubs in the shaft injured the air. Neglect of the trap-door would have been quite sufficient to case the explosion. George Weir, another pitman, thought there should have been a door at the first wide-board end. He believed that this would have prevented that part of the mine from becoming foul. He had suggested such a door to Kendal 3 months ago ; and afterwards to Maugham, who ordered one to be put up. — This was done, and it cleared the air at the board. That door continued to be hung there for the last three months witness continued to work there, from pillar to pillar ; but when he left the course of the air was changed, the door was not hung upon the pillar, and the air became slack. Had such a door been continued it would have prevented the explosion. He thought the iron tubs were injurious to the circulation of the air. Robert Patterson, a pitman, also attributed the accident to the trap door being kept too much open. Kendal explained that it was not necessary to hang a door as mentioned by Weir because the air was changed. It would not have prevented an explosion, and it would still have been necessary to keep the trap door shut. George Hales, a pitman, who was in the pit when the explosion took place, said the mine was previously in its usual state. Mr. John Robson, of Lyons, viewer of Hetton colliery, after explaining the mode in which the Downs Pit was ventilated, said he was down the pit on the Saturday previous to the accident. On that day the ventilation was good — quite sufficient for every purpose, and amounting to 20,000 cubic feet of air per minute, through the whole of the workings. He said he went down about an hour after the explosion ; and he described the means resorted to for getting a current of air into the workings. The workmen killed, who had not been burnt by the explosion, must have been suffocated by the after-damp. The witness stated that the use of candles and gunpowder was safe, that the explosion must hace occurred through neglect of the trap door, that the iron tubs could not have produced foulness in the ventilation, and that the ventilation at present was very good and quite sufficient for the purpose. The evidence having been gone through, the Jury returned as their verdict, "That the deceased had come to their deaths by the accidental and casual explosion of a quantity of inflammable air in the pit." The following is a list of the sufferers taken out dead :— Thomas Kay, aged 38, left a wife and eight children ; Jas. Cowens, 25, and John Milburn, 23, each left a wife and one child ; John Cleghorn, 30, left a wife ; John Cleghorn, 24, cousin of the above ; George Newton, 40, left a wife and five children ; Richard Finlay, 31, left a wife and two children ; Thomas Finlay, 27, brother to the above, single man ; Wm. Wears, 35, left a wife and 2 children ; Mark Dodds, 18, young man ; John Gardner, 16, ditto ; Simon Tate, 33, left a wife and three children ; Wm. Surtees, 17 ; Henry Blake, 17 ; Anthony Cummings, 10 ; and Wm. Halliday, 19. — The following were taken out alive severely burnt, and have since died :— Robinson Harland, 23, single ; John Walton, 14 ; Edward Dodds, 14, brother to Mark ; and Wm. Ward, 20, single.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 24 Aug 2023
|
Search |
|
|||