|
22nd July 1834 Fatal Occurrence At Saltom PitOn Friday evening last, a case, to say the best of it, of most culpable negligence and breach of orders, occurred at this colliery, which led to the death of one of the boys employed there as a driver, and who was named Thomas Bint. An inquest was held upon view of the body on Saturday morning last, before P. Hodgson, Esq., coroner; it was at first generally supposed that the occurrence was purely accidental, but during the examination of the first witness, circumstances came to light which led to a suspicion that some parties had been mainly instrumental in causing the death of the unfortunate boy, and therefore the coroner very properly adjourned the inquest until four o'clock in the afternoon, directing the officers of the town meantime to make every enquiry with the view of eliciting all the facts of the case. Accordingly at four o'clock the jury again assembled, and the following evidence was adduced :— John Todd, aged 19, said, I am employed to attend what is called the brake at Saltom Pit; the brake is placed there to lower baskets of coals from the Bannock band, to the Main band in Saltom Pit; from thence they are conveyed up to Ravenhill, and thence by a rail-road to Whitehaven to be shipped. Thomas Bint, the deceased, was employed in the pit to drive a horse which drew a tram with baskets of coals, to a station where some machinery is placed, called a staple pit, being made underground and above the principal shaft. On Friday evening Bint had done his day's work, but in the absence of another boy was on what is called a cradle, that covered the mouth of the shaft, steadying an empty basket which was suspended a few inches above. Patrick Smith and a man called Walter Black, two of the colliers, came out of the pit, and were apparently anxious to save themselves time and trouble in returning home, by descending in an empty basket. Black, however, seeing the cradle over the mouth of the shaft which prevented the basket from descending, exclaimed "pull out the cradle," and no sooner had he said the words than the cradle was pulled away accordingly. At this moment Bint exclaimed "hold on." The cradle is a small square carriage about 4 or 5 feet across, which runs on a platform across the shaft, to receive the baskets when they are about to be moved up or down the shaft. Black and Smith had been working in the Bannock band, and when they came out the former asked me what was the matter? I answered, nothing. He then called out, "pull out that cradle," and he had no sooner said so than it was pulled out by Smith. I did not see Smith pull it out, but I am confident it was he who did so, because he was the only person standing near the spot at the time. Black was then in the house erected for the machinery used at the brake; John Flood and John Hetherton were also in the brake-house at the time. After the cradle was pulled away, it was discovered that Bint had hold of the empty basket; but his grasp relaxed in a few moments, and he fell to the bottom of the shaft and was killed on the spot. After this fatal occurrence Smith and Black did not go down in the basket, but walked homeward by the road made for the workmen. After the occurrence, Smith said he did not know the boy was upon the cradle. Neither of them complained of the other occasioning the death of the deceased in my hearing. I am quite sure they never did, and I say so upon my oath. I heard no such expression from either of them, or anything to that effect. [The question was several times repeated, but the witness persisted in his denial most solemnly.] To the best of my belief and knowledge the empty basket was situated between the deceased and Smith, so that the boy could not be seen from the spot where Smith was standing when he pulled the cradle away. The evidence of Matthew Thornton, miner, was to the following effect; I am in the employment of the Earl of Lonsdale, at Saltom Pit, as superintendent of the workmen there. There were two youths, one named John Todd and the other called Thomas Bint, employed in the pit; the duty of the former was to attend to some machinery called a brake, constructed to raise coals by a shaft and to let down the baskets. In this pit there are two bands or seams of coals. The perpendicular distance which divides those bands is between 17 and 18 fathoms, and that is the length of the shaft in question. There is a road for the colliers to go to and return from their work without ascending or descending the shaft at the top of which Todd and the deceased were employed, but it certainly shortens the distance of travelling, I should say at least 300 yards, if the miners descend by the shaft alluded to, and then go to the bottom of the principal shaft and ascend there, but none of the miners have permission to take that course either in going in, going to, or returning from their work. On Friday evening I saw Walter Black, and Patrick Smith, go from their work by the appointed road. I was within a few yards of the spot where Bint fell, and picked him up; he was quite dead, his skull being fractured and his back broken. This was all the evidence adduced, and indeed it did not appear that the case could be carried any further; it was clear enough that the men had wilfully transgressed orders by attempting to shorten their distance home by the shaft, and that before they made an effort to remove the cradle from over the shaft they had not used the common and necessary precaution of ascertaining whether there was anyone upon it; the poor boy whose life was sacrificed was at that moment employed in steadying the basket, and feeling the cradle moving from under his feet, under the impulse of terror he clung to the basket, but could not retain his hold, and was plunged into the vortex which yawned beneath, and thus terminated his existence. The coroner took great pains to elicit the truth, and repeatedly declared that he hoped this instance would at least have the good effect of begetting a proper caution and regard for the lives of their fellow creatures. Both Smith and Black declared that they had not the most remote idea that any human being was on the cradle, and after the coroner had very distinctly stated how far the law bore upon the case, he remarked that this could not be considered a very aggravated case of manslaughter, and in all probability even if convicted, the punishment awarded to the offence would be of slight description; the suspected parties moreover stood in very different lights, for the party who absolutely caused the calamity would be Smith, whose hand removed the cradle from the shaft, though Black probably was culpable. The jury ultimately returned a verdict of manslaughter against Patrick Smith, who was thereupon committed to Carlisle gaol to take his trial for the offence at the ensuing assizes. Smith exclaimed "It is a very bad job for me, Sir. I did not know any thing of him being on the cradle, and I am very sorry that it has happened to the boy, for I meant no one any harm. I hope, however, you will allow me to be bailed." The Coroner: It is not a bailable offence, but it happens fortunately for you that the assizes are now drawing very near. No doubt it is a hard case for you, but you must remember it is also a hard case for the parent of this poor boy, who has lost her child. Black declared, before he left the office, that the workmen were very generally in the practice of going up and down the pit by the shaft; they knew that the master was not agreeable to the practice and had forbid it, but the men generally agreed among themselves to take that route. The proceedings terminated near six o'clock; during the inquest the office was crowded with colliers, who appeared to take a deep interest in the matter, but remained perfectly silent, neither sympathising with the prisoner, nor expressing any opinion on the matter. Smith has been conveyed to Carlisle to take his trial.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||