Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

Annual Register for 1834

Article from the Annual Register for 1834, 22nd March 1834, Page: 296, Column: 1


Midland Circuit, Derby

March 22

George Maltby, George Sutton, Joseph Baker, James Goodwin, John Bunting, Thomas Bagshaw, William Stone, Charles Harrison, Daniel Harrison, Isaac Goodwin, Richard Sutton, Jonathan Rowland, Samuel Turner, Abraham Beresford, Abraham Doxey, Benjamin Marsden, and Thomas Skidmore, were arraigned on the coroner's inquisition for the murder of Francis Taylor, Isaac Bagshaw, and Thomas Wager, by suffocation in a mine at Ashford, in the month of September 1833.

All the prisoners pleaded "not guilty."

The grand jury having ignored the bill as against the last named seven of the above prisoners, a verdict of acquittal was taken for them by consent of the counsel for the prosecution, and they were ordered to be discharged.

The remaining ten were then put upon their trial, having been first arraigned on an indictment for the murder of Bagshaw. The indictment in substance charged the prisoners with having, on the morning of the 2nd of September last, feloniously, wilfully, and of malice aforethought, made a fire of straw in a certain mine called "the Great Red Soil Mine," situated at Ashford, in the parish of Bakewell, and put into the fire a quantity of oil of coal, sulphur, and other combustibles, whereby they caused noxious fumes, smoke, and vapour to arise in the said mine, by which the said Isaac Bagshaw, upon descending into the said mine for the purpose of entering upon his lawful business therein, was suffocated and murdered.

The prisoners pleaded "not guilty.

William Wager said he was a farmer and mine-proprietor, living in the Peak of Derbyshire: he is not a proprietor either of the Red Soil or the Magpie mines. He was never down the Magpie mine; but is well acquainted with the other, having gone down into it as a grand juror on the 8th of July last. It is the custom, when there is a dispute about cross veins in these lead mines, to summon a jury of mine-proprietors or miners, and make a presentment to them in the nature of a bill of indictment, which they find or not upon their own inspection and examination of the mine. Their finding is sometimes attended with a fine upon the trespasser. The principal shafts of the Red Soil Mine were the founder shaft, which was the one by which the lead ore was first discovered; the climbing shaft, by which the miners descended and ascended ; the engine shaft, by which the ore was wound up to the surface, and which went down perpendicularly to the waggon-gait, where the ore was collected in the mine, and whence it was conveyed to the surface by the engine shaft. The founder and climbing shafts also reached the surface, but the founder did not descend far, and the climbing shaft was not perpendicular. The latter consisted of a main shaft, and minor shafts, called sumps, leading from it. The climbing shaft of the Red Soil was about twenty-four fathoms deep; the sump leading down directly from it was about sixteen fathoms, and another sump leading down from that again was about twenty fathoms more. There were other sumps, sets-off or projections from these. The depth of the mine altogether was about sixty-seven fathoms. The people in the Magpie had worked up to the waggon-gait of the Red Soil mine, and made an opening into it. The bed of the Red Soil waggon-gait was at least sixty yards from the perpendicular line of the founder shaft of the Magpie mine.

John Hempstock said, he was one of the Red Soil miners. He had been down on the Friday and Saturday preceding the 2nd of September. There was a great quantity of smoke in the shafts and sumps. The waggon-gait was pulled in, or had fallen in, on the Monday, the 2nd of September, when he next went down. The smoke and fumes were then so strong, that he called out to the other men to retreat or they would be killed. Isaac Bagshaw, the deceased, cried out "I am killed already." Witness never heard him speak another word. This was about nine o'clock on Monday. Witness on getting down to the waggon-gait felt faint, and threw himself on his face. Some person threw down water through the shaft, which brought great relief. When he somewhat recovered from his faint, he heard groans from some of the men above him, and as soon as he was able, he rolled into a bucket, and was drawn up the engine-shaft, in the same manner as the ore would be. Between eleven and twelve o'clock on the preceding day, witness observed four men let down two bags, some bottles, and a bundle of straw, into the Magpie mine. He knew none of them. On the same day, he met the prisoner, John Bunting, and Richard Sutton (one of those just discharged), in a field near the mine, shortly after he had observed the straw and bags let down. He entered into conversation with them, and said, "You see you have not killed us yet; our chaps were down on Saturday, and heard you blowing and blasting away." Bunting replied, "Ye are hard chaps to kill ; ye, devils like, would stand fire and smoke, or anything. Our physic is not strong enough yet for ye."

Samuel Houseley corroborated the testimony of the last witness. When he and some of his comrades went down the Red Soil mine, on Friday or Saturday, he saw a hole in the upper part of the waggon-gait large enough for a man's body to pass through. He heard Slack (a man not in custody), who was one of the Magpie miners, and other persons, at work on the other side of the hole. Witness called out to them, to know what they were at, observing, at the same time, that the hole would now decide the dispute. He saw Slack make a hole in the rock with an auger, put powder into it, sod it up, and apply a match to it. Slack and his companions then retreated. Witness feeling that himself and his comrades could not well get out of the way, and were in danger of being killed by the explosion, rushed up to the hole, thrust his arm and part of his body through it, seized the lighted match, and brought it away before it communicated with the powder. The match set the sleeve of witness's jacket on fire; and a spark also fell in the straw on the floor, on which the miners used to sit, and the straw took fire. witness was for a moment greatly alarmed, but he immediately turned his face on the straw, and extinguished the blaze. The witness stated the expedient to which he had recourse for the purpose of extinguishing the fire, which provoked smothered laughter through out the court.

Other witnesses were called, who gave an account of the state of the mine on Friday, Saturday, and and Sunday. One witness, named Wood, was amongst those who went down on Monday morning. The miners relieved each other — one set working for about six hours, and then the other for an equal period more. The smoke with which the shafts and sumps had been filled on the two preceding days, did not appear on the Sunday night. The shafts appeared to be clear on the Monday morning. As the men were going down there was a strong smell of sulphur. Some of the men had gone down before witness, and he found two or three groaning and fainting at the foot of the first sump. He felt faint himself, but he recovered a little, and was able to bring up three or four of the men, one by one, strapped on his shoulders. In the confusion, he could not recollect whether or not he was assisted by any one, but he believed he could not have done what he did unassisted. He then described, as already mentioned the situation in which Bagshaw was found. Several of the men were near being suffocated. The stench appeared to have been caused by oil of coal and sulphur.

These witnesses denied, on cross examination, that fires had been kindled by them to smoke out the Magpie people; but they admitted that, for several days, each party had been guarding the possession of their own mine.

Thomas Smith stated, that he saw the prisoners Sutton and Maltby, come out of the Magpie mine about one o'clock on the Monday,

On his cross-examination, he said he was in the Red Soil mine on the Friday. He had been working in that mine for about fourteen days previously. Mr. Knowles, the overlooker, told the witness, and others of the men, on that Friday morning, that there was straw enough below, and they might fire it as long as they could stand it. The straw had been put down for the purpose of smoking out the Magpie men. Housely, and several of the men were down, and Housely told witness, that he had had a fire in the sump for two hours, and had been near succeeding in driving out the Magpie men, but he had been compelled to leave it, because the smoke came round on himself in the waggon-gait. Witness was directed, by Knowles, to get a pitchfork, that was below, to fire the straw with, but he could not go where it was, on account of the smoke. He went down on the Sunday afternoon, but could not proceed far because of the smoke which filled the shafts and sumps. He was obliged to come back, and he found Knowles there, urging the men down to smoke out the Magpie men, and keep possession of the mine. Knowles told them, that those men who would not go down should not have any more work in the mine. Witness observed Motham, and another man, lying faint on the hillocks. Those hillocks are heaps of gravel and stone, lying near the mouth of the Red Soil shafts, which had been separated from the ore, and been accumulating for ages. These two men had gone down first, in the morning, and been brought up in an insensible state. Knowles told some one, who was assisting Motham, to leave him alone — he was only shamming.

Henry Knowles was then called, and stated that he was the acting superintendent of the Red Soil mine. He was at Manchester, on the Friday. He was at the mine on Saturday morning, and finding that the Magpie men had been firing and smoking the mine, he went to consult the superintendent in-chief, who resided at some distance. On his return, he found the founder and climbing shaft full of smoke. He then ordered the coes or covers to be taken off, to allow the smoke to escape. They continued full of it, however, until near four o'clock on Monday morning, when the shafts appeared to be clear. He had never told Smith, or any of the men, to fire the straw in the Red Soil mine, as long as they could stand it, for the purpose of smoking out the Magpie men; nor had he ever given an directions to that effect. He believed, that when he saw Motham brought up and placed on the hillocks, on Monday, he did say that he was only shamming, because he thought Motham always shunned his work. He did say something to the effect that he was a hypocrite. He wanted him to go down to the men in the mine, and he thought he was shamming illness, to avoid going down. Witness thought the shafts were clear of smoke on Sunday night. When he found on Monday, that the men were in danger of being suffocated below, he yielded to the persuasion of others to put the cover on the climbing shaft. Whilst that was open at top, the smoke and vapour continued to rush up through the shaft like a chimney, but he considered that by closing it the smoke would be driven back on the Magpie men, whose smoke it was, and upon whom, it ought to be put back. He, therefore, put the coe on the shaft, and sodded it down. The witness described the appearance of the deceased when brought up, and also the state of the mine.

George Fiddler, a youth about fifteen years of age, stated that he was at the house of the prisoner Joseph Baker, on the Sunday morning the 1st. The prisoners, Sutton and Daniel Harrison, were there, together with several men and women. He heard Hannah Baker say in their presence, "There is a barrel of brimstone at the bottom;" she did not say, at the bottom of the mine, but merely "at the bottom." On Monday morning, between dark and day-light, he saw the prisoners Bunting and Thomas Bagshaw, and also Abraham Beresford and Samuel Turner, go down the Magpie mine, one after another, as fast as they could. One of them took down a chain, an other a bar of iron, and another a bottle that would contain about three quarts. He had seen the same bottle in the master's apartment before, and heard Harrison say it contained oil of coal. The prisoner Harrison was proved to have purchased a bottle of oil of coal, or coal-tar, at Bakewell, on the preceding Friday.

The medical witnesses stated that the death of the deceased had been occasioned by suffocation, produced by inhaling noxious vapour. They were of opinion that the foul vapour had been produced from burning straw and oil of coal, or coal-tar; but they were satisfied, from the symptoms attending the cases of those who had recovered, that there was nothing sulphurous in the air which they had breathed. A blue mist, described by some of the witnesses, would have been produced by the effect of light on the smoke arising from the other combustibles above mentioned.

The learned Judge, on looking over his notes, expressed his opinion, that there was not sufficient evidence against five of the prisoners, namely, the two Harrisons, the two Goodwins, and Turner, to warrant their being put upon their defence. They were, therefore, ordered to stand down, and the case proceeded against the remaining five, who, on being called upon for their defence, handed in a written statement, in which they complained of the mode of conducting the proceedings before the coroner. They ascribed the death of the deceased partly to accident, partly to his own rashness in going down the mine when he knew, or ought to have known, that it was full of foul air, but mainly to the improper directions and orders of Knowles, the superintendent; as it was well known, they said, that the Red Soil miners had, by his orders, made a fire of straw several times at the bottom of their mine. But whether that fire had been made by accident or design, the prisoners considered themselves justified in pulling down the waggon-gait, and thereby preventing the smoke from entering the Magpie mine. In consequence of that, and of the covers being kept on the tops of the Red Soil shafts by Knowles's orders, the smoke was confined in the Red Soil mine for two days; notwithstanding which Knowles had persuaded his men to descend, on Monday morning, after the two men who had just made the experiment returned, faint from having gone down half way. If due caution had been used, and time given for the foul air to pass away, with proper ventilation, &c., the unfortunate occurrence would never have happened. They denied solemnly having ever intended to do the Red Soil men any injury; and expressed their deep regret at the fatal event which had led to the present inquiry.

Witnesses were then called on behalf of the prisoners. Their evidence was first directed to prove an alibi on behalf of some of the prisoners; but the cross-examination tending to fix some of those prisoners who had not been put upon their defence, that line of evidence was not persevered in. The proofs then went to shew that in 1832, the cross-vein in dispute, between the respective proprietors, had been alternataly presented by grand juries, in 1832, as the property of the one party and of the other, and the question was yet undecided. One of these witnesses also stated, that he had been down the mine on the preceding Wednesday, and perceived that a straw fire had been kindled on the Red Soil side of the waggon-gait in question. Mr. Douglas Fox, surgeon, stated his belief from the evidence he had heard, that if the mouths of the shafts had not been kept closed, no lives would have been lost. Attending to the description given, by the medical witnesses, of the appearances presented on a post mortem examination of the deceased, he was of opinion, that his death had probably been occasioned by suffocation, but it was by no means certain. It admitted of a reasonable doubt, because the appearances were perfectly consistent with the conclusion that death had been produced by concussion, in consequence of the deceased, either through faintness arising from foul air, or through the confusion and hurry of attempting to escape, having fallen down, and thus produced a shock of the nervous system.

The Jury acquitted all the prisoners.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bagshaw, Isaac    Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Bagshaw, Thomas    Miner  
Baker, Hannah      
Baker, Joseph    Miner  
Beresford, Abraham    Miner  
Bunting, John    Miner  
Doxey, Abraham    Miner  
Fiddler, George   15   
Fox, Douglas    Surgeon  
Goodwin, Isaac    Miner  
Goodwin, James    Miner  
Harrison, Charles    Miner  
Harrison, Daniel    Miner  
Hempstock, John    Miner  
Houseley, Samuel    Miner  
Knowles, Henry    Overlooker  
Maltby, George    Miner  
Marsden, Benjamin    Miner  
Rowland, Jonathan    Miner  
Skidmore, Thomas    Miner  
Slack, —    Miner  
Smith, Thomas    Miner  
Stone, William    Miner  
Sutton, George    Miner  
Sutton, Richard    Miner  
Taylor, Francis    Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Turner, Samuel    Miner  
Wager, Thomas    Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Wager, William    Mine Owner  
Wood, —    Miner  



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
22 Mar 1834  Midland Circuit, Derby, March 22 (Annual Register for 1834)

Links to related pages

 

Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print