Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

Whitehaven Herald

Article from the Whitehaven Herald, 1st October 1833


Explosion At Workington — Inquest

A highly respectable Jury, consisting of the following gentleman, resident in Workington :– Charles Brown, Esq., banker, Foreman, John Fidler, Joseph Walker, James Armstrong, Mark Pearson, Cuthbert Wilson, Joseph Cape, George Lister, Joseph Dickinson, Thomas Mordy, Richard Fell, Henderson Borradaile, was sworn before William Bragg, Esq., Coroner of the Lordship of Egremont, on view of the bodies of Robert Ditchburn, aged 55 years, John Huggan, aged 33, James Donald, aged 27, John Thompson, 24, Samuel Milligan, aged 22, John Brennan, aged 19, Daniel Brennan, aged 14, Nicholas Brennan, aged 12, Thomas Creen, aged 18, Daniel Creen, aged 16, James Ditchburn, aged 10, Symmerson Watson, aged 10, Andrew Jolley, aged 10.

The Coroner briefly charged the Jury that they were assembled to investigate the causes of the deaths of the above named parties. He understood that they had perished in an explosion in a coal pit, and it would be their duty to enquire, first, what was the immediate cause of their deaths; secondly what was the ventilation, and general state of the mine; thirdly, whether their deaths were wholly accidental, or whether any blame was imputable to any body; fourthly, whether every due precaution was ordinarily taken for the safety of the persons employed.

A number of witnesses were in attendance, and, in compliance with Mr. Curwen's anxious wish, a very full investigation was entered into, which lasted several hours.

Joseph Sharp called. This witness stated that he was in Lady Pit, on Saturday last, and when about leaving his work, was told that the pit had fired. Another workman (John Daykin), was with him, and they went forward to examine the pit. Milligan went forward also, but he did not come back; he died. He and Daykin went forward with great difficulty, as the damp was very strong. The light was put out. He and Daykin got out in the dark, they hardly knew how, and witness got beyond the stables where he stayed to render assistance, and then he found his strength failing him, and he went away and brought away with him a man named McCartney, who was very weak. There was no foul air in that part of the pit until the explosion, and plenty of fresh air. He went to his work by the same road in the morning, and after the explosion, it was filled with choke damp.

William Benson had heard that Low Bottom Pit had fired. John Perceval would not believe it when told. Witness detailed his efforts to rescue the sufferers. Found the pit filled with choke damp, which soon cleared away. Had worked in Lady Pit six years, and never knew any danger.

John Ditchburn heard of the accident at home, and would not believe it. He went to render assistance, and found the pit full of choke damp.

Judith Ditchburn works at Lady Pit. Saw Perceval between two and three o'clock in the afternoon. He came past with a light. He said he was going to the Low Bottom Pit, and that he expected he had a man before him. She asked if he was going to let off the air, and he asked how they were coming on, and she replied they were only half done. He made no reply. She was down when the accident happened. She knew that there had been a fire forward, and dirt (foul air) flew about her. This was about half-past five. Did not know where the fire was, but got out of danger as fast as she could. Had worked in Lady Pit 26 years, and never heard of its being unsafe.

Robert Jordan described the recovery of the bodies. The pit was not quite clear of stithe, but almost. Has worked in the pit 8 or 9 years, and considered it safe, and well carried on, except the foul air in Low Bottom Pit. Works with a candle — never with a lamp. Was through the pit today, and it was quite clean. The water stopped the air at Low Bottom Pit, and then it was not safe, but after the water was out it was safe, and then the atmospheric air drove the foul air before it. When the pit was clearing, the men did not work.

Daniel Brennan gave similar testimony. Three of his sons perished. Has worked in the pit 17 years, and considered it well ventilated. Had heard that Perceval turned on the foul air in the Low Bottom, too soon.

John Magee left the Low Bottom Pit about 8 o'clock. He was about the last. Perceval was there, and went to put the air upon the place where the foul air was in the long drift. He said he was going to clear that place as much as he could, but witness did not see him do so. Perceval stopped till he saw the workmen go away, and then witness believes that he turned on the air.

John Hodgson's testimony was immaterial.

John Daykin confirmed the details of the first witness. Both Lady Pit and Low Bottom Pit are well ventilated in their way — no neglect of that. If the foul air had not been lifted into the Lady Pit from some other pit, she would not have exploded. When he went to his work in the morning, the pit was well ventilated.

George Newton was with Perceval on Saturday afternoon, at twenty minutes past three. Went down to the Low Bottom Pit. Went down to lay the air on the foul air in the long drift. It was laid on a little — about 18 or 20 yards to the next thurl. The Low Bottom Pit is a well aired pit. Witness thought there was no danger, or he would not have laid on air. Saw nothing wrong. Cannot say that the air was ever laid on before when people were working. It was put on to clear that part of the long drift. Perceval desired him to open the first thurl, and let in a greater quantity of air, and then to shut it, and Perceval went to the returned air to see what foul air there was. Witness thought there would be no danger before it got to Lady Pit, from the great distance it had to go.

John Perceval is overman at Isabella Pit. On Saturday, went to Low Bottom Pit to lay a little air on the long drift, which he did. When he went down, nearly the whole air of the pit. He stopped there about half an hour, to see if it was going on well, and what quantity of foul air there was. He tried it with his safety lamp. The quantity was so small that he thought it would not do any harm. There was not so much by many times as he had seen before. Did the same thing on Friday. The second thurl was open on Thursday and Friday, and was not shut until Saturday. The only addition on Saturday was one thurl — about 18 or 20 yards. Has done it many times when the men were working at Lady Pit. The workings of Lady Pit have been stopped when foul air has been cleared from the Low Bottom at the time of the water. No complaint was ever made about Lady Pit since Christmas, but at the time of the water.

Nicholas Selkirk was down in Isabella Pit on Friday last. Examined the long drift, where the air had been put on afresh, and found it perfectly clear of inflammable air to the second thurl. Had a naked flame (a candle) with him and was so satisfied that there was no danger, that the next day he gave Perceval orders to close the second, and to open the third thurl. The foul air has been discharged from Low Bottom, though Lady Pit, where the latter has been working for some time past. Had he conceived there was any danger he would have stopped Lady Pit. He did not see the smallest danger in opening between the second and the third thurl. If he had thought so he would have chosen a better opportunity, and given Perceval orders not to do it till men were out of the pit.

This witness's evidence closed the investigation. The Jury returned the following verdict on each of the sufferers, finding that "Working in a certain coal pit, called Lady Pit, it so happened, that by some means or other, a certain quantity of inflammable air, on its passage through the rolly-road of the said pit, ignited and exploded, which caused the said pit, and the workings thereof, to be filled with choke damp or stythe, which was emitted from the explosion and combustion, by reason whereof he did there and then die; but the Jury lament that the removal of the foul air was not delayed till the workmen had quitted the pit, by which means this lamentable accident would have been avoided,"

As soon as the investigation was concluded, Mr. Curwen dismissed from his service the viewer, Mr. Selkirk, and the overman, Perceval, through the ignorance or carelessness of whom, the former as the director, and the latter as the agent, this terrible accident (if accident it may be called) occurred. The nature of it will be sufficiently intelligible to those who understand the method of working coal pits, but for the sake of those who do not, we shall endeavour to explain it.

The seams of coal lie obliquely or sloping, and in order to air the workings, the following process is usually adopted. Two pits are sunk, and at the foot of one them a great fire is kept constantly burning; this rarefies the air, causes it to ascend, and in consequence causes a draught or current of fresh air down the other pit or shaft, which current of air is directed through the workings by means of doors which confine its course to the parts where it is most wanted. In this case, the air was sent down Low Bottom Pit, and ascended Lady Pit. In one corner of the workings near Low Bottom Pit is an immense gallery or drift, 800 yards long, of which the far end was choked with water, so that the natural current of air could not circulate through it. It is a double gallery, with openings between the two, every twenty yards, called thurls. The far ends of these galleries being full of water, there was no regular thorough draft, and in consequence the foul air, fire damp, or sulphuretted hydrogen, which exudes from the coal, collected there. This part of the pit was not worked, but to prevent dangerous accidents, it was customary to clear it whenever the foul air collected to any extent. It was cleared by sending the air which was to go through Lady Pit down one gallery, and then through the thurls, back through the other gallery, the air sweeping the foulness before it, and passing along the rolly-road, to the main working of Lady Pit. On Thursday, and Friday, the air had been passing through the first and second thurl, thus clearing the first forty yards of the drift, and on Saturday, Mr. Selkirk ordered Perceval to clear the next twenty yards, leaving the time to his discretion. Neither, it seemed, apprehended that there was so much foul air as to do any mischief at a distance. Accordingly, Perceval and his assistant went, closed up the doors or valves in the first and second thurls, and opened the third, through which of course, the air rushed, sweeping that part of the gallery clean out. Perceval says he tried with his safety lamp, and thought the foulness was not strong enough to do any harm, though of course that was a mere guess, and neither he nor any man else could calculate what it would do, or what it would not do. The air swept along the rolly-road, or road between the two pits, without doing any harm, until it came to the place where it joins the main working in Lady Pit. Along that working, a boy named Dobson, was passing with a lighted candle, and as he passed the ...............page bottom missing........................................................ thrown down and severely burned, but is now recovering, though he was too ill to be examined at the inquest. The explosion was, of course, followed by what is called stythe, or choke-damp, which consists of carbonic acid gas, and other noxious or irrespirable gases generated by the combustion. This pernicious compound swept on through the workings, until it escaped by the shaft or pit, in its way suffocating the unfortunate victims, and endangering the lives of very many others.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Armstrong, James    Juror  
Benson, William    Miner  
Borradaile, Henderson    Juror  
Bragg, William    Coroner  
Brennan, Daniel    Miner  
Brennan, Daniell   14 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Brennan, John   19 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Brennan, Nicholas   12 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Brown, Charles    Jury Foreman  
Cape, Joseph    Juror  
Creen, Daniel   16 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Creen, Thomas   18 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Curwen, —    Mine Owner  
Daykin, John    Miner  
Dickinson, Joseph    Juror  
Ditchburn, James   10 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Ditchburn, John    Miner  
Ditchburn, Judith    Miner  
Ditchburn, Robert   55 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Donald, James   27 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Fell, Richard    Juror  
Fidler, John    Juror  
Higgins, John   33 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hodgson, John    Miner  
Jelly, Andrew   10 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Jordan, Robert    Miner  
Lister, George    Juror  
Magee, John    Miner  
McCartney, —    Miner  
Milligan, —    Miner  
Mordy, Thomas    Juror  
Mulligan, Samuel   22 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Newton, George    Miner  
Pearson, Mark    Juror  
Perceval, John    Overman  
Selkirk, Nicholas    Viewer  
Sharp, Joseph    Miner  
Thompson, John   24 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Walker, Joseph    Juror  
Watson, John   10 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Wilson, Cuthbert    Juror  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Workington Colliery  Workington Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
24 Sep 1833  Melancholy and Fatal Accident (Cumberland Pacquet)
24 Sep 1833  Dreadful Explosion In Mr. Curwen's Colliery, Thirteen Lives Lost (Whitehaven Herald)
27 Sep 1833  News (The Times)
01 Oct 1833  Explosion At Workington — Inquest (Whitehaven Herald)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Isabella Pit, Workington
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print