|
26th February 1833 Crown CourtCharge of Manslaughter — Richard Merrin, aged 23, was charged with the manslaughter of Edward McGraa, of the parish of Saint Bees. Mr. Clarkson and Mr. Fawcett appeared for the prosecution. Mr. Clarkson stated the case to the Jury. The circumstances were briefly these. On the day in question the prisoner, with Patrick Farrel and Patrick Smith, were working in a pit called the Saltom Pit. On the night of that day, they were employed emptying baskets, when the prisoner told the deceased to look sharp; the deceased replied that he was to stop till he had emptied his basket; upon which some words arose, and the prisoner struck him on the head with a tally-stick. The deceased worked out his shift, as it is called, and then went home. His head swelled, and he some time after complained of the place. In a few days he died. The surgeon would be called who attended the deceased, and he would speak as to the effects of the blow. Patrick Farrel, one of the boys who were working at the time, deposed to the circumstances stated by the learned counsel. The prisoner threw the stick at the boy, who was knocked down by the blow; and he lay down on the small coals and cried for some time. The prisoner here produced the tally-stick; it was a piece of wood about four inches long, an inch and a quarter broad, 1/8th of an inch thick. Farrel re-examined — The tally stick had a cord to it about a foot long, and the prisoner swung it by the cord. Mr. Mossop, surgeon, of Whitehaven, deposed to the state of the wound. Witness had attended the deceased, who first complained of a pain in his knee — never complained of his head at all. About a week after, in consequence of deceased having a vacant look in his countenance, witness was led to examine his head, and found the wound, which he attributed to a blow. Witness was at first given to understand that the wound was occasioned by deceased having hit his head against a corner-cupboard; but his mother assured him that it was not. A day or two after, the boy related the story of the blow he had received. Thinks the tally stick swung by a chord might produce such a wound. Had examined the head after death, and found the brain in a diseased state, with considerable suffusion. The symptoms which the deceased had — such as swimming in his head, &c. — were the probable consequences of such a blow; though such a stick might have been thrown a hundred times and not have produced such results. The prisoner in his defence, told a long story about the cause of the quarrel. He attributed disobedience on the part of the deceased as his provocation. He had no witnesses. The learned judge told the jury, that the only question for them to consider was, did the blow occasion the death of the deceased? It might be regarded in the light of an unlucky blow; but that circumstance would only go in mitigation of punishment. The Jury after a minute's consideration, found the prisoner Not Guilty. The Judge asked the jury if they did not think the blow produced death? If they did the prisoner was guilty. He thought the verdict was a most improper one. The Foreman observed, that they thought from the long time that transpired before his death, and the difference in the evidence, it was doubtful that the deceased had died from the blow. The Judge said there was no difference in the evidence; and he thought the verdict likely to have a bad effect — it would encourage the practice of striking on the head, he should not have subjected the prisoner to more than, probably, an hour's imprisonment, had he been found guilty; but it was better for the ends of justice to mark the case as one of guilt.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||