|
Whitehaven HeraldArticle from the Whitehaven Herald, 27th December 1831 The Late Coalmine AccidentUnder this head the Pacquet of last week contains three columns of stupid and scurrilous nonsense, by way of reply to our recent articles on the same subject. Somebody must have the last word, and we are quite willing to submit the case to the final decision of the public as it now stands. To attempt to answer an article, the logic in which consists in maintaining that our reasoning's amount to an accusation of murder, and the rhetoric in ransacking the vocabulary of Billingsgate would be preposterous. If assertions that nobody was to blame, and that everything was right, could prove by mere repetition their own correctness, the speeches of Mr. Coroner Hodgson and the evidence of the parties, on whom the blame would rest, if any, they are quite sufficient to establish the position. Whether there was blame attributable to any parties or not let the public judge; we suspect that it has come to a decision, which will not be easily reversed. To what blame, if such there were, amounted, let the Pacquet, if its friends choose, bear witness; but we cannot, in our conscience, admire either the shrewdness or discretion of a advocate, who admits that a failure in his bungling diatribe involves his clients in a charge of murder. One word as to style of the article in question. If the writer, or his friends or employers, think that anything is to be gained at this time of day, by calling opponents "dolts" "idiots" and "fiends", we believe that they will find themselves very far mistaken; and one would have thought that they might have found out their mistake before now. One would have thought by this time they might have discovered the impracticability of either intimidating opponents, or propitiating the public by these disgusting exhibitions of impotent malice. To conclude, we beg to assure the gentlemen connected with the colliery office, that nothing which can be said by their "obtuse and stupid" advocate (to borrow a favourite expression of Mr. Coroner Hodgson) shall ever in the least disturb our customary good humour and (may we add?) politeness; as we shall be proud to show them if ever they fall under our notice. Our tactic is a very different one from our contemporary's, who seems born to give the lie to the old proverb, which saith, that there are more ways of curing an ill dog than hanging him. He once told us in his peculiarly clumsy way, that it was our business "to throw as much dirt as would stick" a pretty fair admission that what we threw did stick. Now here lies the difference between us and him; we are sparing in our censure, cool and respectful in our language, and the "dirt," as he politely calls it "sticks;" but our hydra-headed contemporary, whom we courteously term our brother, scatters his filth with such blind profusion, that he entirely fails of reaching his enemies, and involves his friends in one foetid mass of indiscriminate infamy. We had this far written when the Carlisle Patriot, on the 24th inst., fell under our notice. We were a good deal amused with it. If Bishop and Williams had been rich enough to keep a couple of Newspapers, we fancy that they would have just set to work to prove their innocence in the same style. The whole defence is redolent of the old Bailey. Praise yourself, abuse your opponent, and get as many people as you can to swear that you are the most virtuous and honourable person alive. Let the readers of the Patriot — if it have any, pursue the parallel. It is certainly very prudent and proper for Lord Lonsdale's paper at Carlisle, to copy any thing on the subject which it was not ashamed to copy, from his Lordships paper at Whitehaven, for this good reason, that we have a great many readers at Carlisle, and the Pacquet has few or none. What the Patriot thought of the Pacquet's article of last week is very evident from its not venturing to copy it, assigning its "necessary great length," as a reason for not doing so. That the Pacquet's article was a very long one, and a very stupid one, nobody can deny, but to say that there are not this week three columns of as stupid stuff in the Patriot were a hazardous assertion. The fact is, that the Patriot had sense enough to perceive that, independent of its length and stupidity, it was positively so brutal, that it would even blacken its own very immaculate pages. There is one paragraph, however, which the Patriot ventures to give, proudly describing it as "unanswerable" and unanswerable with a vengeance. "We Grant" says this oracle of Lord Lonsdale "that coal mines ought to be ventilated with all possible care, that ships ought to sail from our ports in a seaworthy state, and that due precaution is essential in every art or pursuit which involves danger to human existences." To be sure they ought. And was not this the tenor of one half of our argument, and did not the other half clearly prove that the precaution taken were so insufficient, that hundreds of people had no more efficient protection for their lives than they would have in a gunpowder manufactory, If walking about with lighted torches? This is no new opinion; it has been reiterated for years, and we can assure Lord Lonsdale and Mr. Peile that, with out supposing them to be any better or worse that other men, there is nothing in either their public or private characters to render unnecessary the most rigid scrutiny into the system by which they profit, and under which human blood is shed like rain. They will no more find a court of justice in the Kingdom, in which the judge will declare that they are such "Honourable" men as to be entitled to exemption from such scrutiny that they will find one in which the presiding judge is "a wicked fraudulent attorney." And if they have any regard for public opinion, we can tell them that they would just have pursued as likely a course to propitiate it, if they had employed half-a-dozen blackguard boys in the street to call us names. The mutual congratulations of the Patriot and the Pacquet on their respective talents and virtues, to which the world is unaccountable so blind, are particularly diverting. The two Dromios complimenting each other's beauty — as of Syracuse admiring his brother of Ephesus, and he of Ephesus priding himself on his resemblance of his dear brother of Syracuse, are irresistible illustrations. Every body knows that there is no man whom they hate and fear so much as the Editor of the Carlisle Journal, for which every body knows equally well, they have had many and substantial reasons. The second share in their affections are we believe, that we ourselves have the honour of holding; and we can assure them that we shall lose no opportunity of making up whatever may be deficient in our claims on their gratitude. Accordingly the good turn which the Patriot tries to do the Pacquet in the latter's battle with us, the Pacquet endeavours to repay the Patriot in its quarrel with the Journal. "The talented Editor of the Patriot" "becoming spirit," "genteel lashing" say the Pacquet; "masterly piece of castigation," "our spirited constitutional contemporary," "eminently entitled to support," responds his brother of Carlisle. Be of good cheer gentlemen! Do not envy each other's beauty and accomplishments. You are as like as two eggs. It is true that one on you may have the advantage in cant, and the other in bluster; but in all the essential parts of your composition your as like each other, as want of sense, want of temper, and want of decency can make you. But the most diverting thing after all, is the plaintive avowal of the Patriot, "that the patriotic principles of constitutional newspapers, such as ours, are not sufficiently diffused." A gentle hint, and a candid confession. The falling away of the circulation of the Tory Newspapers in Cumberland, is attributable both to their own misconduct and to the ruin of the political influence of their patron. The power of Lord Lonsdale, built upon corruptions and intimidation, was certain to give way before the progress of political knowledge, like that of others of his party. But we believe there is scarcely any nobleman in the Kingdom whose friends have so effectually contrived to make themselves odious as well as contemptible. The principal agents in effecting this consummation have been his Lordships two newspapers, which have employed themselves diligently in libelling and insulting every man who presumed to have an opinion different from his Lordships, as if insult and calumny were not the most effectual means of lowering a cause and a party in the eyes of all who have any regard for decency or propriety.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||