|
Whitehaven HeraldArticle from the Whitehaven Herald, 6th December 1831 Explosion at Croft Pit(Concluded from our last)Having now disposed of the question of the composition of the court, we shall proceed to an explanation of the nature, tendency, and credibility of the evidence adduced, and of the general scope of the inquiry. Neither our time nor limits, nor indeed, we may add, our information, permit us to examine systematically all the minute bearing of the case, which we shall be obliged to despatch with a brevity not at all commensurate with its importance. But we trust we shall experience not great trouble or difficulty in showing, that the most important questions to which the attention of an intelligent jury should have been directed, were either left wholly uninvestigated, or else that the evidence was of such a contradictory or inconclusive nature, at to involve the affair in deeper mystery then ever. From the system of terrorism which prevails in coal pits (at least in those where the men have no combinations to protect them;) from the despotic power possessed by the principal agents, which they delegate to little subordinate tyrants called overmen and deputies; from the general impression among the workmen, that any one who may say or do any thing offensive to these people is a proscribed man; — there are difficulties innumerable in the way of getting at the truth of any matter, in which the truth may possible be offensive to any one of these little despots. It is a thing quite notorious — obvious to any man or common sense, that an explosion cannot well, happen in a coal-pit, without the general management being faulty, or some underling neglecting his duty. Now which ever of these be the case — whether one or both, there is always somebody who has an interest and an influence in suppressing the truth; there is somebody whom the poor collier dare not offend by speaking out; and though the men will talk boldly enough where they think they can do so safely, nothing but a rigid cross-examination before an impartial judge can get the truth out of them in public, to their employers' faces. And if the judge of the court be not impartial and discerning; if he do not conduct the inquiry with a rigid determination to get at the truth, and to reject all interested testimony, the thing is absolutely impossible; one can get nothing but general protestations that every thing was right. Having thus far premised, we shall now briefly recur to the different points of inquiry, in numerical order. I. Is the system on which the pits are worked necessarily destructive to human life, and can the loss of life be obviated by an alteration in the system? This was the question entirely untouched at the inquest. That the system is destructive to human life to a horrible extent, the blackened corpses of ONE HUNDRED AND SIXTY victims, in about sixteen years, furnish a damning answer. That it is necessarily so, Mr. Coroner Hodgson in effect affirms, because he the said Mr. Coroner, with the assistance of twelve good men and true, each time, has never been able to discover how the explosion originated; so that, unless the managers of the coal-pits know more than Mr. Coroner, no man can penetrate further than the bare fact of these inevitable consequences of working on the usual system. That they can be obviated every body knows. Force through the workings such currents of air as will sweep away all foulness, and the danger will be much diminished, if not altogether removed. If, after this is done, a single life is lost which even the most "stupid and obtuse" of jurors cannot clearly make out to have been lost from unavoidable accident, then let every man be compelled to work with the top on his lamp, and let his wages be raised, so that he may make, under that disadvantage, as much as he makes now. If these precautions were taken, not, a single life could possibly be lost from explosion. But they would be expensive, and as long as ever interested parties can persuade the public that all is right, colliers will be burnt and suffocated by dozens. When the public become properly informed on the subject, the law will interfere and put a stop to this revolting traffic — these holocausts to Mammon. The most effectual plan would be the levying of a deodand of one, or if need be, of ten thousand pounds for the death of each collier. II. Was the pit properly ventilated? Mr. Williamson Peile and other witnesses stated that it was. Mr. Peile, we suppose, meant that it was so in his opinion, and that it was as well ventilated as the rest of Lord Lonsdale's pits. This is, we doubt not, all correct enough; but repeated explosions, and especially in this very pit, have proved to a demonstration that, though Lord Lonsdale's pits are well enough ventilated to enable him to get his coal out of them, they are not so well ventilated, as to enable the workmen to get at those coals with any tolerable degree of safety; and more especially the loss of well on to FIFTY lives in this very Croft Pit, within the last fifteen or twenty years, is a proof that it is no better, and perhaps something worse that the rest. We should have conceived it to be the duty of a coroner and judge to examine the pit, or plans of it, so as to ascertain the direction of velocity of the different currents of air in it, there direction, and the means of acceleration or regulating them; to have trusted nothing to report or opinion, but to have got directly at the facts. Doubtless Mr. Peile and his friends thought the ventilation adequate; but the question for the jury was, were they correct in their judgement or not? Were their ideas of what was necessary, sufficient? It was on the conduct of those gentlemen, and their subordinates, that the jury were sitting in judgement. III. On the present dangerous system, was due care taken to prevent unnecessary risqué, and to obviate the effects of accidents when they occurred? This question dub-divides itself into a number of distinct queries. 1st. One great point is the comparative safety of the working. On this point, all the interested witnesses, that is, those on whom the responsibility rested, chime in with each other wonderfully. Mr. Peile and Mr. Jackson thought it particularly safe; but some things came out in the evidence rather incompatible with the opinion. The fact of the explosion itself is presumptive proof that there was something wrong. David Johnstone stated that an alarm had been given in consequence of a rush to the preceding shift. Peter Andrew stated, that some times foul air was suffered to fall down. James McCabe stated, that working at pillars was reputed dangerous (a fact every body knows), and that though he could make more money by working on them he would not prefer such work. Hugh Smith stated that two men had been killed by an explosion in the same place not long ago. Joseph Bates admitted that there was never any entire security against the explosion of inflammable air. And James Dodd stated, that a man (of the shift that perished, we suppose), told him that they were ordered to work with the lamp tops on, and that they apprehended a fall. It would require something more than the testimony of interested persons to get over these circumstances quite satisfactorily. Mr. Peile and Mr. Jackson knew nothing of the matter personally. This part of the business lay with the subordinates the leading witnesses in their own favour. 2nd. The next point is, what were the precautions taken against explosions? The most extraordinary circumstance is that though the bodies were found, and both Mr. W. Peile and Wm. Nicholson swore that they had examined the place very carefully, no evidence was given to prove whether in point of fact, the lamp tops were on or off, not does it appear that they are yet found (see the evidence of James Dodd). This is to us quite inexplicable. It appears clearly that their lamps were unlocked. It also appears that they were working with the tops off, and that if a rush of inflammable air took place, their only security was blowing their lights out if they heard it coming; but if they did not hear it — the much more probable event of the two is they would be all involved on one common destruction. It also appeared that there was no classification of workmen (a thing much complained of,) and that they worked in large gangs or shifts, as they are called, in which the young and old, the experienced and the inexperienced men all mixed indiscriminately, and an ignorant foolish or rash man might peril the lives of all. It appeared that there was and is a continual temptation for men to run risqués in dangerous atmospheres, because they can make more money by working with a full light than they can with the gauze tops on their lamps. It appeared that in this instance, among twenty-four people, there were several boys, the youngest 8 years old, and that two or these had safety lamps, and consequently the lives of the whole twenty-four at their disposal. — We should think that such a system, as this cannot long be tolerated in a civilized community. We have also been informed (and but for circumstances detailed in another place, we should have enquired into the fact,) the proper care was not taken in this pit to keep it clear of foul air; that foul air was often suffered to accumulate. We think this might have been got at by cross-examination. We have also been told that if the colliers do not-make up a certain quantity of work in the week, the are fined so much per basket, and that no abatement is made, even though they have left their work on account of foul air. It this be true, there is another direct stimulus to self-murder. And yet it seems a man is to be accused of "party motives" because he insists on hearing and on examining the evidence before he signs a ready made verdict of death "casually, accidentally, and not otherwise"! 3rd. Another important point is, whether or not the persons in charge of the pit were competent to the task. On this point, though no pains were taken to put the Jury in possession of direct information, a circumstance came out sufficiently conclusive. We do not speak here of Mr. W. Peile and Mr. Jackson, whose duties of superintendence seem little more that nominal — one had not been on the spot for about a week, and it did not appear when the other had been there. But Mr. Peile said the ventilation of the working was complete except at the moment of the explosion, and that the attempts made to send the air forward were useless. Now the persons who made these useless attempts were principally the overlookers and the deputies of the pit, so that either Mr. Peile was wrong, and the ventilation was incomplete, or the persons to whose charge the pit was committed, were ignorant of the ventilation and lost several hours in idle attempts to restore it. We leave him the choice of the dilemma. No attention whatever was paid to this point during the inquest. 4th. Another point is, what time elapsed between the explosion and the getting at the bodies? Smith estimated it at four hours, but he stated that he had no clock or watch, and guesses under such circumstances must necessarily be vague. Dodd, whose narrative was more precise, called it three hours and a half, which is probably correct; the explosion is commonly believed to have taken place at half past two, and Mr. Peile confirmed him in the fact of the bodies being got at about six. Smith, against whom perjury was more than insinuated, seems to have been very nearly, if not altogether correct, on the showing of the parties themselves. 5th. What time, if any, was lost unnecessarily? It appears that they had to send to the Granary yard for wood. Now without reckoning the time they might lose in seeking for wood before they sent, and without examining if it was skilfully applied when they did get it, (which Mr. Peile's remark might make one doubt,) not less than two hours could be lost in the journey to the Granary yard and back. Two hours in many cases will make the difference between life and death. Either this two hours was lost by the want of wood, or else through the ignorance of those who had charge of the mines, in sending for the wood unnecessarily. There is no getting out of this dilemma. The Jury were put in possession of no information to enable them to judge whether this time were lost through neglect on the one hand or ignorance on the other. 6th. Since it appears on all hands, that under the present system there is no effectual security against these explosions, and that when they take place, wood is more or less indispensable to the relief of the sufferers, for restoring the door or partitions which are blown down by the explosion, and for directing currents of air to sweep away the stithe or stife which prevents access to the bodies — was there such a quantity of wood in such proper places, under the care of such proper persons, as to ensure the speediest relief possible? — On this point the evidence is incontrovertible, — that if wood were there the persons under whose immediate charge the pit was, did not know where to find it; as to the fact of wood being there or not, nothing appeared on oath but mere vague assertions both ways. But whether it was there or not, makes no matter, if it was not placed so as to be instantly found by those who might momentarily want it. It does however appear a little extraordinary, that a parcel of witnesses should one day swear that they sent to the Granary yard for wood, and the next that they had always plenty close at hand. Mr. Peile, in his address to the Coroner and Jury, observed, "that there was always 300 dozen of wood lying about in the pit, though it might not happen that the wood was lying where every man might lay his paw upon it, just at the moment it was wanted." Lay his paw upon it! It is an ugly phrase; and considering that Mr. Peile was vindicating himself from being accessory to the death of three and twenty men, he might have chosen one more decorous. But let that pass. Setting out of view the question whether or not the number of planks he mentioned were adequate to the wants of the pit, of which the immense galleries traverse in the three levels an extent of very many miles, which we have heard disputed, and which ought to have been enquired into; putting this question out of view, we should like to ask Mr. Peile, of what use was the wood in emergencies, it was not placed where every poor creature whose filthy paws were earning him a subsistence in those dens of wretchedness, and who might rush to save the life of a son, a brother, or a friend, could be furnished without a moment's loss of time with the means of rescue? Of what use was it, when the overmen and deputies preferred sending to the Granary yard, to continuing the search for wood in the pit? That there was wood in the pit sufficient to enable the men to get at the coal is certain enough, and if Mr. Peile meant to state that, he might have spared himself the trouble of doing so; but if he meant to say that there was a supply adequate to those emergencies which it was either his duty or that of some body else to provide against, and that supply distributed in a proper manner, the bare fact proves him in error, and his own statement confirms the fact; for, since an explosion might occur at any moment, the wood should have been placed so that any man might lay his paw on it at any moment. If Mr. Peile had a vessel which drifted upon a lee shore, without dropping her anchor, and the captain on escaping, were to tell his owner that he had plenty of anchors on board — half a dozen or so in the hold or about the deck, but there was not one where a man could lay his paw on it at the moment it was wanted; — what would Mr. Peile think of his story? Is not a supply of wood the sheet anchor in collieries where the ventilation is weakened or interrupted? If Mr. Peile had a friend who fell down in a fit of apoplexy, and the surgeon on being sent for were to be unprovided with a lancet, and if two hours were lost by the neglect, would Mr. Peile think it any excuse, if he were to say that he had a dozen lancet in the house, but not one that he could lay his paw upon when it was wanted? If the surgeons of the Infirmary were to set to work to extirpate a tumour from the neck of a patient and in so doing were to wound a deep seated artery, and the patient were to die for want of a ligature being put round it; — what would the Governors of the Infirmary think of the operators, if they were to allege that there were plenty of ligatures in the place, dozens of hanks of yarn, cotton or silk, but not one where the Hospital Dresser might lay his paws on at any moment it was wanted — even though patients in such a case join in a verdict of died "casually, accidentally, and not otherwise"? 7th. Was there any medical care taken of the bodies of the persons suffocated? On this point there was a very explicit answer; — no care was taken, absolutely none. There was no professional person about the pit who considered it his duty to attend to this business. There was no one there who was competent to distinguish between recoverable an irrecoverable asphyxia. The solitary Surgeon who attended did not get there until eight o'clock and he did not see the bodies. And yet the bodies were, notwithstanding all the delays, recovered much within the time, which medical men consider as limiting the possibility of resuscitation. Orfila the greatest modern authority on the subject, says, and a host of other writers unanimously confirm him, that attempts at resuscitation ought never to be abandoned until at least six hours after, to all appearance, life is extinct. This rule is acted on in England, in France, and in every civilised country where the life of men is thought worth the trouble of preserving. Mr. W. Peile indeed says, that when he got there the bodies were cold and stiff. Mr. Peile, it is highly probable, was in a certain degree mistaken on that point, as he easily might be in the hurry and agitation of the moment. Supposing that they were all instantaneously killed (which we shall presently show was highly improbable) it is impossible that in three hours, or three and a half at most, the limbs should have entirely lost heat and flexibility. A human body retains a large part of its heat for many hours after death, and the muscles do not become permanently contracted for even a much longer period than that mentioned. An uninformed observer easily mistakes the inertness of suspended animation for an unequivocal indication of death. If the limbs of any of them were really stiff at that period, it should rather be taken as an indication that they were alive; — rigidity of the muscles is a very common symptom of asphyxia; the little manual of Orfila, which is in the hands of almost every medical man, is very particular on this point. And there is nothing on which all medical authorities are more thoroughly agreed, than that for a great many hours after the accident — some say so many as twelve, it is impossible for the best physiologist to say, by mere inspection, whether a suffocated person is recoverable or not. 8th. Was there any probability that life was lost for want of due expedition? We have just shown, which indeed is obvious to common sense, that there was a possibility; the question is now as to the probability. To come at this we must take into consideration all the circumstances. Suppose that two or perhaps three hours had not been lost in what Mr. W. Peile declared to be useless efforts to restore the circulation of air; suppose that they had been got at, as on Mr. W. Peile's showing they ought to have been got at, by four o'clock or so. Suppose that those who perished by mere suffocation, like the Little's, had been raised by that time; is it not highly probable that those persons might have been saved? — Those who answer in the negative must, we humbly submit, be entirely ignorant of the nature of human life. A certain portion would doubtless be utterly and irremediably destroyed by the flame of the explosion; but of those who showed no symptoms of having been burnt, of those who had clearly died form suffocation and nothing else, if there be any truth in theory or experience, the great majority would have had a fair chance of being recovered by prompt and skilful application of remedial measures. Mr. W. Peile himself says, and we believe him to be so far perfectly correct in his judgement, that the circulation of air, or the very spot of the explosion, was restored immediately after the moment of the explosion, so that, there was nothing to injure or suspend vital motion beyond the immediate effect of the first blast of foul air which overwhelmed them. If any man chooses to say that a person who is recovered within two hours of his being suffocated by foul air has not a fair chance of being resuscitated, he only displays his own ignorance, if not something worse. But as Mr. Mossop ingenuously admitted "inflammation is not a process which takes place after death," and as the majority of the bodies showed unequivocal symptoms of inflammation, it is highly probable that a large portion of the sufferers were actually alive at the time, when, with reasonable expedition, the bodies ought to have been recovered. It is true that on William Postlethwaite, who swore, according to the Pacquet, that there "was twice as much wood in the pit as was wanted, if it could be got at," (!!!) says that nobody can live more that three minutes "in such an atmosphere as results from explosion of foul air," and he quoted Dr. Fox in support of his opinion, and stated that he himself had been "burned two or three times." We know nothing whatever of Dr. Fox, whose name we never heard in our life before, but if he be a man of common sense and information, he must be ashamed of hearing an ignorant creature like Postlethwaite, who according to his own story, must have had as many lives as a cat, gravely setting his authority against that of all the physiologists in Europe. Out upon the nonsense! It would move the bile of Job himself to listen to it. We have thus, calmly and dispassionately, travelled over the leading points of this momentous enquiry. Of its awful importance we entertain a deep and overwhelming sense. Other times are at hand, and we indulge a hope that we shall yet live to see the day, when the life of man shall not thus idly be sported with. But deeply impressed as we are with the solemn duty, we have suffered no extraneous sentiments to interfere with the discharge of it. We believe that the gentlemen connected with the colliery, if appealed to as gentlemen, and men of honour, will cheerfully acquit us (as indeed they have done) of travelling one step out of our road of fair and impartial investigation; and we, on our part, should be wanting in candour if we did not publicly acknowledge that their conduct throughout the investigation was fair and manly. It is true they were guilty of some interference, which, though perhaps neither strictly legal nor proper, a natural anxiety rendered excusable. How far the blood of these three and twenty men rests on their heads, or on the head of others, "This let the world, which knows not how to spare,
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||