|
29th November 1831 Accident at Croft PitThe adjourned inquest upon the bodies of the unhappy sufferers in the late melancholy accident at Croft Pit, was resumed on the morning of Tuesday last, the Coroner having adjourned the Court for a week, in order to gratify one of the jurors, who wished for additional evidence. The rest of the Jury, however, had long been satisfied upon the case, and expressed great unwillingness to be kept so long in attendance; and shortly after the commencement of the proceedings the foreman handed a memorial to the Coroner, signed by himself and ten of his fellow Jurors, in which they expressed their perfect conviction that "the sufferers in Croft Pit lost their lives by an accident over which no human being could have had any control" — that they could come to no other conclusion — that "the conduct of their fellow-juryman, Mr. Robert Abraham, was not calculated to elicit the true state of the case" — and that "the adjournment he had requested was to answer some vexatious design, and not to promote the ends of Justice." The memorial concluded by requesting the Coroner to discharge them as soon as possible. In the course of this day's proceedings, as on the prior investigation, frequent discussion took place between the Coroner and the dissatisfied Juror, but as they were almost entirely irrelevant to the inquiry, we think we shall best consult the feelings of our readers by omitting them altogether. Upon so painful a subject we have no desire to touch upon any topic in the lightest degree irritating. As soon as the Jury had taken their seats, the Coroner proceeded to address them. As the inquiry, he said, had already been prolonged in so unnecessary a manor by the obstinacy of one of their body, it was his intention, in order that they might not be put to further inconvenience, to swear in a thirteenth Juror. It was perfectly competent in him to do so; and as Joseph Jackson had seen the whole of the bodies, and was able to judge from personal inspection of them, he would swear him as a Juror, in order that they might not be any longer detained. He could not conceive how any person could ever entertain the slightest doubt upon the case — the evidence was so clear and unvarying. He then proceeded to explain the law as regards Coroner's Juries, observing, that be the original law that officer might summon four, six or more, and he was not aware of any statute which went to take away that discretionary power. In cases of murder it was not unusual to summon fifteen, sixteen, or seventeen jurors. In cases of manslaughter twelve was the usual number. Lest therefore any further impediment should be thrown in their way, he would take thirteen and twelve of them would be competent to return a verdict. The appointment of an additional juror did not, however, at all interfere with Mr. Abraham's power to act; he was still as much a juryman as ever he was, and he begged he would exercise his rights. He (the Coroner) was there for a purpose, not of stifling inquiry, but of causing the fullest investigation and should be glad to hear any evidence that could be added. Joseph Jackson was then sworn and added to the Jury; upon which the dissatisfied Juror observed that is was an unprecedented proceeding, and a mere expedient in order to silence his voice and stifle inquiry. He had witnesses whom he had intended to have examined, but after the course which Mr. Coroner had thought proper to pursue, he would take no further part in the proceedings. He was relieved from a heavy responsibility for which he was thankful. He should not of course be expected to sign the inquisitions. The Coroner said he had no interest but in the fullest investigation, and characterised the expressions of the juror as a vile insinuation, repeatedly urging him to give the names of his witnesses, which was as often refused. After some further altercation, the following witness were called; James Dodd sworn. — Is a collier, and was in Croft pit at the time the explosion took place, which, to the best of his judgment, happened about half-past two or three o'clock. He was in the air course, and was not injured, though he felt the blast, which blew out their lights. A boy who was behind a door preserved his light, and gave one to them. Witness proceeded into the Bannock Band, and met two men, William Simon and Daniel Kean, of whom he asked what had happened. Proceeding on, witness came to a door which he found tight; opened it and passed through, taking care to secure it after him. Met some men coming up the inclined plane, which leads from the main band. The men whom witness met advised him no to go any further, as the stithe was very strong; he determined, however, to go on and see what was the matter, and upon the rolly roads met Thomas Benson, who was the first man he spoke to. Shortly after Joseph Fox came up, and after holding a short consultation, they proceeded on and came to two doors, both broken — one shattered to pieces. Witness and Fox pushed forward, and found Joseph Freckleton lying upon the ground. They helped him up, and found that he was able to talk and walk. A little further on, they found a boy named Alexander Garraway. During the whole of this time, the air was going the right road, and to the best of his belief, it was about four o'clock. Still further on they found another boy, Alexander MacMean, who was lamed. They sent the two boys towards home. Proceeding on they found a dead boy, John McMean. Came to the air course pit, which they examined, and found that the air was going as usual. Witness held up his lamp, and the air was strong enough to blow the flame to the side of the cylinder. Witness then came back to the points, and went a contrary road to look at a stop. Found a door open, which they shut. Pushed forward, but found the stithe very strong. Met Robert Ellwood, an overman, and told him what they had done. Ellwood went and examined. With some difficult, they got to the top and found several of the men laying dead. This might be about six o'clock. The first that witness came to was Robert Little, who was burned. Lifted his hand and found that he was dead. Heard some one shouting, to whom he replied and found it to be Mr. Peile, Mr. Jackson, and Mr. Williamson Peile. At the place where witness then was, fourteen or fifteen of the bodies were found and amongst these was the other Little. The air was going as usual, during the whole of this time. A tight door sent it direct to the place, and it was never off even for a moment. The explosion made the road dusty, and the air was very thick. When Mr. Peile and Mr. Jackson come, he had nothing more to do, but he assisted in removing the bodies. If Mr. Peile had not come he considers that they could have done, as the air was never off the ground. Examined be a Juryman; — Has been a collier for 50 years, and has worked in Croft Pit for several months. Always considered Croft Pit worked in a proper manner. All the head masters in his time have been anxious to render the pits safe. The Stewards always attended well, and cautioned the men when any danger was apprehended. They were ordered to work with their lamp tops on, on the day the accident happened, as a fall was expected; but some men are bigoted and will not attend to what is said to them. Cannot tell how the accident happened, but thinks the lamps, when found, will show whether the tops have been on or not. In the previous shift they were expressly ordered to keep them on. Thos. Benson sworn; — Is a blaster, and was employed in Croft Pit, on Saturday morning, at the time the accident happened. After the explosion, witness went to the break pit top, and saw two bodies, said to have been those of John Graham, and Christopher Fitzsimmons. Went down and saw John McGaughan lying on his left side dead. The two Littles were lying at the steath bottom. Partleton was lying on his back, with his head downwards, over the remains of a wall, which had been blown away. James McQueen was lying on the steath head with his face in the dust, and witness turned him upon his back — he was dead. Hector McAllister was the next he came to and Clement Ingleby the next. Witness turned each of them over on their backs to see if they were dead. One of the bodies was stripped, but does not know how it came to be so. — The pit was well aired, and properly wrought, and witness had been employed in it three years and a half. Had been in the pit on the previous shift, and was on his road there when the accident happened; but having gone into Kells pit for a spade, he escaped the danger. The pit, in his opinion, was in a good state; and he saw no danger or he would not have stopped there. Witness is a blaster. There was plenty of wood to repair the damage, it could have been got at, and no time was lost. Joseph Frickleton sworn: — Was in the pit at the time the accident occurred, and was struck down by the blast. He does not know who helped him up, but he was carried away by James Fox and James Dodd, who took him down the main band stage, and he was restored. Can give no account how the accident happened. He was sitting between two doors when the explosion took place, and immediately ran, but was overtaken by the blast and fell. He rose and ran a second time, and fell again. At the third time he fell insensible. The distance, which he ran, might be about thirty yards. Has worked in Croft Pit two or three years, and never heard any one object to work in it on account of its being considered dangerous. William Simon sworn: — Was in the pit at the time the explosion took place, and saw Hugh Smith about three quarters of an hour after the accident occurred. At this period, the Coroner again pressed the dissentient Juryman, with great eagerness to produce any witnesses whom he might wish to call, but he declined to do so, alleging as his reason, that the Coroner had sworn the additional Juror for the express purpose of stifling the inquiry. This expression, which was heard with much surprise by the Court, was ordered by the Coroner to be taken down, with a view to ulterior proceedings against the speaker, for impugning his honesty and impartiality as a Judge. William Postlethwaite was the next witness sworn, and being asked if there were any want of wood in the pit, he replied that there was twice as much as was wanted, if it could have been got at. He considers that no one can live longer that three minutes in such an atmosphere as results from an explosion of foul air in a coal pit, and he has been burned two or three times; a single mouthful of foulness is sufficient to make a man fall when a feed is accidentally cut, even though it be not fired, and witness has himself fallen several times from that cause. Alexander Garraway sworn: — He lost two sons by the late explosion in Croft Pit, which in his opinion, was a pure accident, not resulting from any bad management, but from causes which could not be controlled by human means. The evidence of the witness, who seemed much affected, produced a strong sensation in the Court, and the Jury unanimously expressed their unwillingness to hear any further testimony, having long been perfectly satisfied that, the melancholy occurrence was purely accidental. The Coroner then read the inquisitions, which were signed by twelve of the Jurymen, the dissatisfied individual still objecting to the verdict "accidental death." Upon being asked by the Coroner why he refused to sign he replied that that was an illegal question!
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||