|
Whitehaven HeraldArticle from the Whitehaven Herald, 29th November 1831 The Explosion at Croft PitThe termination, for the present, at least, of the investigation of the circumstances connected with the dreadful catastrophe which occasioned the loss of twenty-three lives, has left us at liberty to enter upon the subject, and to lay before our readers our own ideas of its causes and nature, and of the credibility and tendency of the evidence adduced. There are three distinct questions to which the attention of the public will be and ought to be directed. The first is the composition of the court before which, and by which, the investigation was made; the second, is the conduct of that court, whether impartial and legal or otherwise; and the third, is the evidence on which the court decided. With respect to the conduct of the coroner and the jury, as we shall feel it our duty to bring it before a superior legal tribunal, it would be highly improper for us to appeal to public opinion. Of it we shall therefore not say one word. It is true that we have not been treated with equal delicacy. The coroner, who ought to have known better — the jury, of whom nobody could expect any thing better — and the editors of two newspapers, who ought at least to have affected some regard for decency, have assailed our conduct even while in the discharge of a solemn duty, which, in the eyes of the most unprincipled and most ignorant men, ought to have been a protection to us, at least so long as we were actually invested with the judicial function; these persons have assailed us with the foulest imputations, in the most unqualified language. For what can be a fouler imputation against any man, than to say that he has carried "party motives" to the judgment seat, and after he has sworn to do justice without fear or favour "to present no man through hatred or malice," to accuse him of prostituting his brief authority to the gratifying of his private vengeance? No, if we felt ourselves capable of doing any thing so base, if we were conscious of having done any thing to warrant such an accusation, we should feel our-selves clothed with "infamy, as with a garment," and we might then stoop to extenuating our own conduct, or criminating others. But reposing as we do on the purity of our motives, and the correctness of our conduct, we feel no solicitude respecting the opinion of that public whose sympathy we know well is ever on the side of those who brave obloquy and insult in the cause of justice and humanity; and knowing as we do, that it is impossible in a country, where there is even a shadow of respect for the forms of justice, for such conduct as that of the parties who signed the verdict of Tuesday, to pass unnoticed by the superior authorities, we willingly refrain from saying one word to add to the indignation which the bare narration of their proceedings will excite. Before proceeding into the details of the case, it may be as well to observe that it is invested with an awful interest. The destruction of twenty-three human beings, is in itself no light matter; but the suddenness of the catastrophe renders it sill more painful to contemplate. It is an awful thing even for one human being to be hurried to his last account, without one moment for penitence of prayer. In all times, even up to the present, it has been held to be the greatest aggravation of the crime of the murderer, that his stroke leaves the victim no time for repentance. Even our great dramatist has painted a son, burning to avenge his father's death, hesitating to strike the murderer, lest he should plunge a soul into eternity loaded with the weight of the mortal sin he was about to avenge. The sentiment is based alike on natural feeling and religious principle. There are few religious creeds, which do not enjoin it as a pious action to pray for the souls of those who are cut off by sudden death. Many an "antique oratory" and mouldering fane attests the piety of our Romish fathers, who accounted it a holy deed thus to purchase forgiveness for those who had died "unshriven and unabsolved." And though our reformed churches have rejected the doctrine, that mortal intercession can avail between man and his creator, there is yet more urgently imposed on them the duty to omit no effort to save their fellow creatures from that sudden destruction, which thus renders all human efforts unavailable. And though the death of twenty-three human beings is a matter of such grave importance in the eyes of all who are endowed with human sympathies, it is not to this alone that our view of the case must be restricted. This is but one of a series of catastrophes scarcely differing in their nature, some more, some less, calamitous in their effects. The number of persons who have perished in the collieries round Whitehaven, is almost incredible. Upon the most moderate calculation, not less than ONE HUNDRED AND SIXTY persons have been killed within the last sixteen years, principally by explosions, and of these nearly a third in Croft Pit alone. This is an average of about ten annually, and estimating the actual number of persons employed in the collieries at one thousand, it is a fearful average. Lord Lonsdale draws a great revenue — the people of Whitehaven many advantages — eight or nine hundred families their living, from these collieries; but this periodical immolation — this annual sacrifice of the blood of nine men, is a fearful price to pay even for those advantages, great as they are. There is an awful responsibility both as members of a civilized community and as accountable moral agents, upon those who drive the bargain of human life against gold. There is a responsibility, not less awful, shared by all, who, whether as proprietors of such pits, or as judges, or as mere spectators possessing a moral influence, have the means in the smallest degree of controlling the operations of a system; which, like the idol car of Juggernaut, crushes a human victim at every turn. The law of England has wisely provided that no man who has come to a violent end shall be buried without a judicial investigation into the causes of his death. The principal object of this investigation, is to present such individuals, if any, as by force or by neglect, more or less criminal, may have been accessory to the death of the party, in order that they may be punished or absolved by a superior court; or in case there be neither violence nor criminal neglect, so to distinguish the causes of death, as to insure the prevention, as far as human exertions may, of the occurrence of similar calamities. Now the duty of an inquest holden upon the bodies of the persons who perished in Croft Pit, was of a very important nature. Among other matters, it was especially their duty to look into the general system of working the coal, and to ascertain both the general causes which rendered accidents so frequent, and the particular causes which led to this accident; to ascertain that the pit was not worked on a system necessarily destructive to human life; to ascertain that proper persons were employed to discharge every duty connected with the management and working of it, and that, individually, they did discharge their duty properly. In order to answer the ends of justice, it was necessary that the Coroner and Jury should be intelligent and independent men. First of all, it was necessary that they should be intelligent because, if not so, they would be incapable of entering into so extensive an inquiry as it was their duty to enter on, with any prospect of their coming to a proper conclusion. It was necessary that they should be independent, because they had to examine and to judge the conduct of powerful men and of the agents and underlings of such men; if they were not independent, and it became their duty to censure, perhaps to accuse, to impeach of crime, their duty would place them in painful conflict with their interest of feelings, to which their duty might possibly yield; and if they saw no reason, otherwise than for a verdict of acquittal, of absolution, such verdict coming from men who were not independent of the influence of the parties they were judging, would command neither respect nor confidence, and the whole transaction might be regarded as a mere trick to protect powerful criminals. If the parties, who might be criminated or censured, had any influence over the appointments of their judges, a strong argument as to their innocence or guilt might be drawn from the manner in which they used that influence. If they were honourable men conscious of innocence, they would naturally be desirous of being tried by a court, which from character and station might be expected to make a full and impartial enquiry, and whose verdict, if in their favour, would carry with it such authority as would absolve them in public opinion as well as in the eye of the law; of men above the suspicion of servility or interested motives. But if they wished to conceal negligence or misconduct, to smother investigation, and to be allowed to persist in a guilty career, they would instinctively shield themselves behind a tribunal, it such could be found, which from its composition might be expected to be under their own influence. It is impossible for us to say whether the colliery agents or their underlings had or had not any influence over the selection of the jury, which sat on the 12th of this month. We should hope that they had not; because if they had, their making such a selection, would be the strongest evidence, that they durst not trust to a jury of men likely from station and character, to come to an impartial and enlightened judgment. The Coroner of the Court, (Peter Hodgson, Esq.,) is one of the legal agents of the Earl of Lonsdale and is the steward of his Court Baron. In local and general politics Mr. Hodgson is a strong, not to say a violent partisan of Lord Lonsdale. The officer who returned, or ought to have returned, the list of jurors, is Mr. Curwen. Mr. Curwen is assistant overseer or constable, if not both, in Preston Quarter; a district where Lord Lonsdale is predominant and is the principal ratepayer. Mr. Curwen, it is quite notorious, is only kept in his office by the influence of Lord Lonsdale, the proprietor of the pit, wielded by his agents, who are responsible for its management. John Bell is the keeper of the House of Correction; he was placed in office by the Magistrates, who are nominated by Lord Lonsdale. David Frears is an auctioneer and a Sheriff's officer, that is a bailiff. Jonathan Boadle is a publican; and one of Lord Lonsdale's tenants. It was at his house that the jury and witnesses had their guzzle, usual on such occasions in Whitehaven. This has been usually charged to the parish, which has latterly refused to pay. Who paid for the entertainment on this occasion we do not know, though it might be an interesting subject of enquiry, especially as all the witnesses were not invited to it. Oliver Ussinson is an individual whose profession it is rather difficult to describe. He has been occasionally employed as a copying clerk in several attorneys' offices. William Leslie is a pensioner (on Chelsea Hospital, we believe) occupying a small house in Preston Quarter, where he has not resided more than two or three months. Joseph Jackson is now a watchman, bellman, bill- distributor, and bailiff's assistant. He was a policeman, and was discharged, after being imprisoned for a violent assault. Philip Jackson was formerly a staith-keeper of Lord Lonsdale's; is now a sheriff's officer or bailiff. Jonathan Burnyeat is a joiner, and son-in-law to one of Lord Lonsdale's farmers. William Kewley is a Whitehaven police-officer; and in constant attendance at the magistrate's office. Thomas Trohear is a clogger somewhere about the Ginns. Jonathan Bowman is a working shoemaker, some where in the same neighbourhood. James Hewitt, formerly huntsman to Lord Lonsdale, or to Mr. Peile. Was formerly a collier, and has now the care of one of Lord Lonsdale's waggon-ways, and is in his Lordship's pay. There is one other circumstance, which we mention here to avoid any thing like offensive personal allusion. One of the Jury is a near relation of the gentlemen on whom a large share of the criminal responsibility (if any) of this calamitous affair rests. Now, without meaning to say that there was any probability of such an event occurring, we will ask could there be a more scandalous outrage on decency and justice, than to place a father in a situation in which, by any possibility, his duty might call upon him to criminally accuse his own son? We are informed that the only persons in this list who are rated ten-pound householders, are the Coroner and Jonathan Boadle. We are sure that it would puzzle Mr. Coroner and Mr. Foreman to account for the impannelling of this jury on any recognisable principle. We say Mr. Coroner, because as he did us the honour of turning on of these gentlemen out to make way for us, he might just as easily have turned out the other eleven if he had not liked their character & appearance. We do not be any means mean to say that this Jury could not, or did not, act impartially; but we do say, that if the persons whose conduct they ought to have reviewed, were not entirely blameless, a conflict must have taken place between their duty and their inclinations — and whether they were likely to sacrifice their duty, is not for us to judge. Nor do we mean to accuse Lord Lonsdale or his colliery agents of any thing like direct or indirect interference in the appointment of this jury. We believe the abuse has arisen from the improper and illegal practice of treating these Juries at the public expense, which has made it an object with low hungry dependants to be on the panel, and has driven away respectable persons. But we do say that if such another melancholy case occur, and alas it is but too certain that such a one cannot be far distant, and if Lord Lonsdale or his agents have any direct of indirect influence over the constitution of this court — we think they will not deny that they have some. — And if, after this exposure, they do not exert that influence to procure a Jury of the most respectable and intelligent men that Whitehaven contains — we do warn them that the public will conclude that they are conscious of some crime of so deep a dye, that they are willing to suffer public infamy as the price of concealment. But we hope better things of them. So much for the constitution of the court; the conduct of the court, as we observed, is a subject for the consideration of another tribunal than public opinion; the general nature of the enquiry, and the tendency and credibility of the evidence, we must defer until next week. Sure we are that the subject will not speedily lose its interest.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||