|
Whitehaven HeraldArticle from the Whitehaven Herald, 22nd November 1831 Adjourned Inquest on the Bodies Of the Persons Who Perished By the Explosion on Saturday Week In Croft PitWe stated in our last week's publication, that the inquest was adjourned until eleven o'clock on Monday morning. At that hour we repaired to the public office. In about a quarter of an hour the jury assembled. Five or six witnesses likewise dropped in, and Mr. John Peile, Mr. Williamson Peile, (his son) and Mr. Jackson, Lord Lonsdale's colliery stewards, took their seats on the bench, near the coroner. The names of the jury were then called over, and the coroner then proceeded to charge the jury. They were now reassembled for the purpose of making inquiry, and ascertaining, if possible, the cause of the deaths of the individuals named in the inquisitions before them. If it appeared to them, as he told them on Saturday night, that any one had willfully ignited the air in the mine, the persons who had done so would be guilty of murder. But he believed that they might fairly lay that out of their consideration, as besides the unlikelihood of it, nothing of the kind had even been hinted at. However, if they met with any circumstances leading to any suspicion that such a crime had been committed, they would doubtless feel it their duty to investigate them narrowly. It was utterly impossible to ascertain what took place at the time of the accident, but the shortest method, he believed, would be, to call those who knew the state of the pit immediately before and immediately after the accident. If the heard evidence as to those points and found it impossible to get at evidence showing exactly how the accident happened, he thought they could only come to one conclusion. William Nicholson sworn, and examined by the coroner. I only go occasionally to this pit, and happened to be there on Friday. I go once a week. I am ordered by Mr. Peile to visit it once a week. Was there on Friday at ten o'clock, at the place where the accident happened. The pit was quite clean of any inflammable air. Considered it in perfect safety. Fresh air was gong round it as usual. Have been there since. No inflammable air now. It is now well aired. Was in it as soon as I could conveniently get on Saturday. I think the mischief had arisen from a sudden gush from some part, but cannot ascertain from where of inflammable air, I suppose, which had touched some of the men's lights. Are the men more or less cautious on Saturday nights? I don't know any difference. Some of those men should have been there on Saturday, but were there on Friday to meet their pay. Friday night is a regular working time. Here some of the jury expressing themselves satisfied with the evidence, the deposition was read over to witness, as usual. Mr. Peile (Lord Lonsdale's principal colliery agent) and the coroner, had here some conversation. The witness added, that at other times Wilson Pit was the one he visited. Mr. Williamson Peile sworn and examined by the coroner. — Was at Croft Pit after the accident happened. Went immediately on hearing of it. At that time the air was going round. Went down with my father. Found the air restored — not going entirely round all the parts it formerly went round, but round the principal parts. Considered the pit perfectly safe previous to the accident — the ventilation, especially in that part, was particularly good. I saw the bodies of all the deceased, (here Mr. P. enumerated them) excepting McMinn and Morris. Mr. Peile suggested here that Mr. Jackson could speak to the same facts. The Coroner thought it quire unnecessary to hear Mr. Jackson. He did not think the inquiry could be prosecuted any further. It was clear that the explosion was the effect of accident, and he did not know what further could be made of it. To this opinion the jury seemed generally to assent, but after a pause, Mr. Peile's examination was resumed. — The cause of the accident was mere conjecture. It left no traces behind -no traces before. No inflammable air had been seen before, and none after. The whole of the evidence on these inquests was little more that answers, yes or no, to questions put by the coroner. Not a single question was put by any of the jury. The Coroner charged the jury. They had now heard the whole of the evidence that could be adduced, and it had just turned out as he expected it would, and left them just as much in the dark as they were before. He would read them an inquisition which he had prepared last night, and he presumed that the rest would be much the same, though there might be some difference in specifying the exact causes of their death, whether by suffocation or scorching. An inquisition on Christopher Fitzsimmons, ready filled up with a verdict to the effect, that, Christopher Fitzsimmons being employed in Croft Pit, as a driver, it so happened that on Saturday the 12th of November, a great quantity of inflammable air caught fire, burning and scorching the said Christopher Fitzsimmons, on the back, breast, loins, and various other places, and that he met with his death casually, and by misfortune, and not otherwise, was then read, and the jury declaring themselves satisfied, it was signed by them immediately. It was here incidentally stated by the foreman, Mr. Curwen, that seventeen children were left without fathers, ten of them under eight years of age. The jury impannelled on Hector McAllister was now called over. This was one of the inquisitions, which included our name. Mr. Coroner charged. The jury had heard the evidence on the other inquests, and the same evidence was applicable to all. The death of Hector McAllister had been proved by Mr. Peile, who identified the body. He (Mr. Coroner) supposed that the deceased was very likely known to Mr. Curwen and others of the jury, which would remove all doubt of the death of the party. The foreman read over an inquisition, filled up exactly like the others, affirming that the death of Hector McAllister took place "accidentally, casually, and not otherwise." Mr. Peile here observed that Mr. Jackson, and the viewer, and all the deputies, were present in case any of the jurors wished for further information. Another person (whom Mr. P. named) could also give some account of the circumstances connected with the accident. Mr. Coroner said, he thought further evidence quite unnecessary. We here rose and stated to the Coroner that we ourselves had not heard any evidence touching the inquisition. It would be difficult for us to describe the alteration that took place in Mr. Coroner's demeanor upon our making this remark. It would be altogether impossible for us to give anything like an exact report of the series of violent altercations (violent at least on one side) which from that moment commenced, between him and us on almost every point of what we considered the discharge of our duty as juror. We endeavored throughout to treat Mr. Hodgson with the respect due to his judicial position, and trust that we did do so, though our patience was often sorely tried. Engaged as we were for three hours that morning, in an arduous investigation, and in an active contest with the Coroner, it is entirely out of our power to give a verbatim report of some speeches which we were compelled to listen to, and which we would have given worlds to have had upon record, as illustrations of a "Coroner's quest." With the exception of the evidence, which we took down very minutely, we can give nothing but the faintest outline imaginable of the other proceedings. Besides many things were done and said so extraordinary, that as a party in the contest, we find a delicacy in publishing them on our own sole authority. In reply to our observation, Mr. Coroner said that we had heard the evidence on the preceding inquests, and proceeded at much length to enlarge on its conclusiveness. We replied that there was no evidence before us in our capacity of juror; that even if the evidence we had just now heard wee before us in our judicial capacity, it would not satisfy our mind, and that we had firmly resolved that we would not sign a single inquisition until we had heard all the evidence which could be produced, and which we thought necessary to satisfy our doubts. Here a long discussion took place, and Mr. Peile earnestly advised the Coroner to suffer us to have the evidence we wished for. Mr. Coroner at last enquired what witness we wished to be called, and we named Jas Floody. Floody was not in court — notwithstanding he was one of the witnesses on account of whom intoxication the Coroner had adjourned the court! Indeed at that time there was nobody whatever in the court, except the Coroner, his clerk and constable, the jury, three colliery agents (on the Magistrates bench), and five or six overlookers, &c., brought as witnesses, and a gentleman connected with a paper of which one of their agents was lately proprietor. So little interest did the enquiry excite in Whitehaven, that there was not a single person in the room as a mere spectator. The unpleasantness of our situation may be better conceived than described. We then desired to see William Nicholson, who was re-sworn and put into the box, but not before Mr. Coroner had made a ling speech expressing his conviction that, the "Stewards were anxious for a full and fair investigation." We were at length about to put a question to the witnesses, when to our great surprise, and indeed indignation, on turning round we saw the jury signing the inquisition, and five or six of them had already got their name down! We immediately remonstrated with the Coroner, and told him that we considered it a most indecent thing for a jury to be signing an inquisition while the inquiry was pending. This was put a stop to. We obtained the following evidence from William Nicholson. I have generally gone to Croft Pit once a week, but sometimes I have missed. Am regularly employed at a weekly salary, to examine the pits and see that they are safe. Am five days in the week generally at Wilson Pit, and the sixth day generally at Croft Pit. What reason have you for devoting five days to Wilson Pit and one only to Croft Pit? The Coroner would not suffer this last question to be put — we had nothing to do, he said, with Wilson Pit. Examination resumed. When at Croft Pit employs himself solely in seeing that it is safe. When apprehensive trys it with his lamp. Am I to understand that you try the pit with your lamp once a week? Yes. How do you judge whether it is safe or not? I judge by the spire that goes off the top of the light. Here we asked the witness what were the appearances in the spire itself by which he judged. To this the witness, encouraged, we do not doubt, by observing the contempt and rudeness, to use no hasher terms, with which we were treated by the coroner replied "I am not called here to larn you to be a collier." Mr. Coroner told the witness he need not answer the question; that he had no occasion to state how he arrived at his conclusions. Mr. Coroner also remonstrated with us in no gentle terms on our ignorance and impertinence in asking such irrelevant questions, and told us the business of the court was to ascertain "the when, the how, and the where" the person met his death, and not to instruct us on the working of collieries and the use of Davy's. We possibly knew more about the use of a safety lamp that either Mr. Coroner or the witness suspected, but we contented ourself with coolly making a note of the question and enquiring, if we were allowed to have an answer to it. At last, at the earnest request of Mr. Peile the examination was allowed to go on. If the light had enlarged I would have considered it dangerous, and if it had burned blue. The pit works night and day by alternate shifts of workmen. Can you give me the names of some of the men who worked on the shift before the accident? Mr. Coroner — You need not — it is not relevant — it is idle waste of time. We did not press this question, as we knew that we could obtain the very important information the answer would have involved from other sources. Examination resumed — I was there at ten o'clock on Tuesday morning. Was on the very spot. It is no part of my duty to examine the safety lamps. Here Mr. Coroner observed that we were "putting the cart before the horse," that we should first have ascertained that there were safety lamps, and he asked a question to that effect. This we understood to be done in ridicule of our enquiries. Examination resumed — Are the safety lamps, do you know, made at the pit, or are they bought of some manufacturer, or where are they made? This question was also very much laughed at by the coroner, who professed himself quite unable to see the object of it. Examination resumed — The lamps are made in the town — at the granary yard. The men were not invariably in the way of taking safety lamps with them, the place being considered particularly safe. Mr. Peile here made a remark, the purport of which we missed noting. Examination resumed — Those men behind me were employed to go on regularly in their turns. Am sent to see that they do their duty — am an overman — find fault if I see anything wrong. What do you mean by the place being well aired — how do you know when it is? I mean there was a good strong current of fresh air. Mr. Coroner, who had frequently interrupted us with expressions of contempt and impatience, at our asking such absurd and unusual questions. Here read us a long lecture on the folly of our proceedings. Examination resumed — I cannot say where the inflammable air came from. No part of the works had fallen in to interrupt the ventilation, not was it interrupted. Could not discover any communication with any place in which inflammable air had been known to exist. (The coroner was very humorous on the idea of the air having found its road into that level from any other working, and ironically asked the witness if it could have come from William Pit.) In this case the witness could trace no fresh irruption of inflammable air. They were splitting up one or two of the pillars, but not regularly taking them away. We were enquired if we could see a plan of the working, but the coroner told us that was impossible. He then proceeded again to charge the jury, persisting that there had been no fresh information elicited, not was it possible to get any, that there was no reason to think any body to blame. Several of the jury, if not the majority, expressed their concurrence with this view of the case. We persisted, however, in calling for further evidence as to the state of the pit, and we obtained from this witness the names of three persons who had been in the pit on the previous shift. Mr. Williamson Peile re-sworn — (A prodigious loss of time was occasioned by the innumerable speeches of the coroner, who now told us that we might be allowed to ask a few questions, he would not tolerate such rigmarole. Mr. Peile in the most handsome manner expressed his anxiety to give all the information in his power.) He went down to the pit about six o'clock in the morning. William Nicholson was correct in his statement of his duties — (Here one of the jury observed "Oh, his evidence is quite clear.") There are others whose duty it is to inspect the pit better able to inform you than I am. Mr. Jackson is the viewer of the colliery. I hold an official situation connected with the colliery. Mr. Coroner said that he would let us into the whole secret of that part of the business. Mr. Jackson he stated was the viewer of one part of the collieries, Mr. Quayle of the other. Mr. Peile was over all, and Mr. Williamson Peile was a general assistant to his father. Examination resumed — Does not know that there was any surgeon present when he arrived at the pit. Two boys had been removed alive about half-past four. Mr. Mossop is one of the surgeons. Was there any one at the bottom of the pit capable of distinguishing between a case of asphyxia and one of actual death? These questions raised a storm of indignation on the part of the coroner, which it is impossible to describe. He threatened to make short work of the case; he proceeded in a strain of vehement invective, so rapid that we had only time to note down the expressions "waste of time," "rigmarole," "impertinence," "audacity," and "impudence," during which, Mr. Peile expressed a wish that we would put the questions to Mr. Jackson. Mr. Coroner here hastily swore Mr. Jackson, and appealed to him if the pit was not well ventilated, particularly well ventilated --never heard any one complain, and no one had any cause for complaint, all which Mr. J. confirmed. He then made another speech to the jury, in which he denounced the "villainy" and "rascality" of the person who had "dared to impeach" the gentlemen whose evidence they had heard, and he called on us for the name of the "calumniator." To all this we replied, that we had a duty to perform as well as he; that that duty was narrowly to sift the circumstances of the case — which we fully intended to do, and that by interrupting the examination, he was only wasting time. We persisted in being allowed to re-examine Mr. Peile, to which, at length, the coroner assented. We inquired how long it would take to raise the body of a person really or apparently dead, to the top of the pit? Mr. Coroner declared this to be a most "ridiculous " question; but a last Mr. Peile was allowed to tell us, that it was a mile from the bottom of the shaft to the place where the accident happened — that the pit was 152 fathoms deep — he could not tell how long it might take to raise a body — great delay often was unavoidable — could not name any definite time. Mr. Jackson has the general superintendence of that colliery. The blame would, in the first instance, rest on Mr. Jackson, if the pit was in a foul state. Can only discover a trace of an explosion. No receptacle discovered whence foul air might have issued. Have examined the place pretty carefully since. No considerable fall of roof. If there was a foul state of the pit, would not the blame rest between Mr. Nicholson and Mr. Jackson? (Mr. Coroner made great objections to this question.) Not on Mr. Nicholson certainly; I have already told you that Mr. Jackson is the steward. Would the responsibility rest on Mr. Jackson if the pit were in a foul state? (Mr. Coroner insisted on our defining the word responsibility.) It would rest on Mr. Jackson. He is responsible for keeping the pit in a proper state, as far as is it is within his control. The fresh air reached the place by the gallery — not by boxes — they were not used — they were not needed. I was there by six o'clock. The whole day was occupied in finding the bodies, and sending them out, I personally examined each man. No surgeon went down into the pit to ascertain that the bodies were dead. (A long and tedious interruption by the coroner, who accused us of "brow-beating" the witness.) The bodies were cold and stiff. Mr. Jackson called. Is viewer of the colliery. I reside in Whitehaven. Was called on at half-past four. Went to Mr. Peile, and then went to the colliery. The spot on which the deceased were working was about two hundred yards in extent. The effect of the blast extended all the way to the shaft; the man riding down felt it. I visited the place about a week before the accident. Four or five men are employed under me to inspect the state of the pits. I considered this part of the pit safer than other parts in the ground — it was better ventilated — had fresh air direct from the shaft — the air descended direct on the men — it would have to travel a mile and a quarter before it reached them. There were side galleries, but the did not interrupt the current of the air. The men had their safety lamps, but we did not tie them to work with the tops on — there was an overman to look to them — their working with or without the tops of the lamps was left to the discretion of the overman, excepting I saw it necessary to order different. None of the overmen were killed. These four overmen have all the pit to superintend. There is nobody alive to tell whether they were working with tops to their lamps or not. The overman, whose duty it was to see, was not on the spot. There are locks to put on the lamps, and the overmen puts them on if he thinks necessary, or may be directed. The workmen will smoke, and can contrive to light their pipes through the gauze by holding the lamp obliquely. (We expressed some surprise at this statement, but Mr. Peile, sen., confirmed it.) No person ever objected to me to going into the pit. Robert Ellwood is the overman, and is present. Have since examined the place, and found no trace of any explosion of confined air. Cannot form the slightest idea how it collected. Have you any classification of workmen, according to their experience or inexperience? Mr. Coroner here lost all patience. He insisted that we wanted to know the expense of working the colliers, and that we had no business to inquire into such matters. Of course we disclaimed any such intention, and Mr. Jackson took advantage of the first pause, to inform us that the men went into the pit indiscriminately and each man chose his own partner. Mr. Coroner went on, vehemently insisting that it was not necessary to ascertain how the colliery worked. After much invective against us, he declared that we would suffer no more questions to be asked. He once more began to charge the jury; we tried to stop him, but finding remonstrance vain, let him go on. He told them that all they had to try was "the how, the when, and the where," the subject of the inquisition met his death. He appealed to the jury if they were not all satisfied. When he had done, we coolly asked him if we were precluded from asking any more questions of the witnesses. After a little consideration he told us that if we could confine ourselves to pertinent inquiries he would not prevent us. We told him that we thought that no enquiry could be efficient, unless the men who were at work in the pit, on the shift that was on immediately before that which was blown up, were examined. He assented; and told us to give him the names of the persons we would like to call, and reminded us that we had some of the names down in our notes of Nicholson's evidence. We told him that if we had, he ought likewise to have them in Nicholson's deposition, and that if he persisted in defiance of us in not taking down the answers to the questions he suffered to be put, he could not expect us to assist him. We also told him that before we could agree to any verdict, we must see a young man named Gallagher or Garraway, who, it was currently reported, had been prevailed on by his brothers (who lost their lives in the pit) not to go into it on account of its foulness. The foreman undertook to have this young man and half a dozen of the shifters in attendance on the afternoon. It was half-past two, and Mr. Coroner then adjourned the jury until four o'clock, with another speech. He exhorted them, for at least the tenth time, to confine their attention to three points only "the when, the how, and the where;" that that they should not allow it to be diverted by "chimerical ideas," and that they "might as well suppose that he set the pit on fire" as that there was any thing to blame in the conduct of those who had it in charge. In the course of the morning we had two or three times to remonstrate with the coroner, for only putting down such parts of the evidence of the witnesses as he thought fit, and for suffering persons present to interfere in the business of the court. Adjourned Inquest Monday at four o'clock. On entering the room we found Mr. Coroner and about 8 or 10 jurymen. He was repeating very earnestly his exhortations to the to the jury about "the how, the when, and the where" enforcing on them his own views of the evidence, and his conviction of the folly of pursuing the inquiry any further. As soon as the jury had assembled and had been called over, he charged them again in his usual style; but on this, as on some other occasions, as we have no notes of the epithets applied to us and our conduct, we will not venture to quote them from memory. He stated that he had made up his mind; that he would make short work of it; that he knew what course to pursue, and would pursue it. He then read the verdict with which he had filled up the inquisition, and addressed the juror at the extreme end of the jury bench. "William Leslie, are you satisfied with the inquisition I hold in my hand, and which I have just read to you?" Mr. Leslie, who is a man up in years, very mildly replied, that he would wish to have a question or two asked if any complaint had ever been made to the overseers. This rather posed Mr. Coroner, who directly commenced a speech to Mr. Leslie, to the effect that as there was no evidence that any complaint ever had been made, it would by foolish to expect it to be proved that complaint had not been made, as it was impossible in the nature of things to prove a negative. Before he had got to the end of his speech, Mr. Robinson and Mr. Mossop, the surgeons to the pits' entered; Mr. Robinson (who is in the commission) he invited to take a seat on that bench, with some other allusions, which nobody acquainted with Whitehaven politics could misunderstand, observing that he himself sat on that bench once a month to administer justice, and trusted that he did so, and should do so impartially. He then turned to Mr. Mossop, and told that gentleman that he must be prepared for a very severe examination. Mr. Coroner again charged the jury. They were again assembled for the purpose of investigating the cause of the death of Hector McAllister. He had already told them that the object of their inquiry was exclusively what kind of violence the deceased had perished from. That it was quite unnecessary for them to take into consideration the assertions that the pit was in a foul state, or that Mr. Williamson Peile was mistaken as to the men being dead when taken out, because nobody had come forward to prove either the one or the other. (Mr. Coroner either would not, or could not, comprehend that we had made no such assertions, but merely wished to ascertain that due care had been taken.) He should not have thought it possible for any one to bring forward so heinous a charge against honorable men. I have no objection to the most ample investigation especially if it were necessary to satisfy the public mind, and though I am not accustomed to make the usual proclamations, I have no doubt that the affair has become so public that we have heard every thing any body has say. But I will not suffer "indefinite, ridiculous, and impertinent," enquiries. Mr. Coroner here proceeded at great length to prove that there was no means of ascertaining how the inflammable air became ignited, and finished with his usual exhortation respecting "when he died, where he died, and by what means." The foreman here whispered with a part of the jury, and stated to the Coroner that he thought that most of his brethren was agreed. Mr. Coroner observed that his mind was perfectly made up; he would ask a question, and it would be his duty to take a course, which he had made up his mind to. He then read his own ready prepared verdict, and explained the meaning (after his own ideas of course) of each clause. He thought, he said, there could be no objection to the inquisition, and he should be governed by the majority, and not be the individual. The foreman here stated that himself and ten of his brethren were agreed. We appealed to Mr. Leslie, who again repeated his wish to know if any body had ever made any objection to the state of the pit. The officer of the court was here ordered to make the usual proclamation for all persons to appear, concerned in the matter before the court. We protested against closing the inquest until the witnesses, for whose evidence the court was adjourned, were called. After a long contest of which we were unable to preserve any minutes, a witness was put into the box. David Johnston sworn. The witness answered in the affirmative to the following questions from the Coroner. Are you in employment in the pit where the accident happened? Were you employed there on Friday last? Were you in the place where the accident happened? Was it well aired? Yes, there was a good air, a capital fine air. I considered (here a bystander interfered to explain witnesses meaning) the pit in perfect safety. We worked with the lamp tops on, opening a pillar, and found no dirt (bad air). We left the pit at six o'clock. Question put by Mr. Robinson. In what state did you leave the pit? I had no idea of any danger. Here a running conversation, which lasted some time, took place among Mr. Coroner, Mr. Robinson, the witness and somebody else. Mr. Coroner made another speech in which he accused us of having come for the purpose of making "wanton and foolish delay". Examined by ourselves. On Friday we worked with the tops of our lamps both on and off. We were working with our tops off, but there was some road roven up not far off, and we heard it beginning to rustle, and we blew our lights out; we called out, and then went and got fresh ones, with the tops on, and examined if there was any dirt. We had no reason to fear any danger of any accident happening. By the Foreman. I never complained of danger, nor ever heard any one complain. Here Mr. Coroner declared that he would tolerate no more. That we ought to pay the witness for his loss of time. That we were bound in honour to pay the expenses of those to whom we gave the trouble of coming; and addressing the witness he said "you'll call at the Herald Office for half-a-crown, in the morning." Peter Andrew sworn. Examined by ourselves. Do you recollect making any complaint to Mr. Coroner on Saturday evening? Here Mr. Coroner interfered and would not allow the question to be put. He said he would allow none but substantive questions to be put; which he explained to mean, questions immediately relating to the fact of the death of the party. He took the examination into his own hands. I was employed at Croft Pit, know the Pit — knew it last Saturday — saw it this day fortnight. It was properly ventilated that day. It was aired then, and is now according to the master's regulations; sometimes four-air was suffered to fall down. This spontaneous statement of the witness occasioned a great sensation, and a very irregular examination of the witness by Mr. Coroner and Mr. Jackson took place, of which we were quite unable to preserve any intelligible notes. On this as on other occasions, we protested against interruptions, but in vain. The Coroner commenced a very solemn speech to the witness; "Peter Andrew, did I not see you on Saturday evening in the front of one of those rows of buildings which a benevolent master allows for the use of his dependents free of rent. You were complaining of some air pipes, and did I not tell you to apply to the proper tribunal? Did I not meet you wandering about drunk, and with a pipe in your mouth;" here the speech of the Coroner was rather ludicrously cut short by some of the Jury exclaiming "it is not the man, it is not him Mr. Hodgson," and the witness gave vent to his astonishment and indignation at the charge in no measured terms. When order was at length restored, we asked the witness if Croft Pit was reputed more or less dangerous than other Pits? The coroner would not let this question be answered. He characterised it as "foolish, ridiculous, nonsensical, and absurd." He again took the examination of the witness into his own hands and elicited from him that he did not usually work at that pit, but had worked there that day fortnight. We here thought it our duty to make a formal remonstrance to the Coroner on his proceedings. We told him that we were willing to take it for granted, that he was acting in what he conceived to be the discharge of his duty; but that we also had a duty to perform, which was to inquire into every thing connected with the death of the person named in the inquisition; that this duty we had fully resolved to perform, and that his interruptions might delay our getting the information we wished, but could not prevent it, since we knew well that he could not complete a single inquisition without our signature, which he most certainly should not have while any part of our duty was left unperformed. Mr. Coroner treated our statement of the law with great contempt, and told us that we were far mistaken, that there were two ways of getting rid of a refractory and obstinate juror — one by applying to the court of King's Bench for a Mandamus, and the other by suing out a writ de rebus inquirendo, (as we understood him to call it.) Now that we had heard so much evidence, the Jury should be locked up till they came to a conclusion, only there were one or two old men, and it would be punishing them, not us. The Coroner was on this as on other occasions, earnestly remonstrated with by Mr. Peile, Mr. W. Peile, and Mr. Jackson, who seemed dreadfully annoyed at the suppression of the evidence. At last he suffered Chas. McGahan to be called, and we were suffered to examine him without interruption. Chas. McGahan sworn. It is unnecessary to give this witness's replies to the interrogatories, but he clearly and distinctly declared that there was no foundation for the report of his having been prevented by his deceased brothers from venturing into the pit, as was currently reported. Mr. Robinson, Mr. Peile, Mr. Heywood, and another legal gentlemen (the Coroner's friends) joined in a most long and earnest remonstrance with the Coroner, on the inexpediency and impropriety of interrupting us, and on the necessity of making every investigation which the state of public opinion rendered necessary, and reminded him of the prodigious loss of time he had occasioned. By this time, rumours of the extraordinary enquiry that was going on had spread over Whitehaven, and the room was filling with respectable and influential gentlemen, whose presence had a manifest influence on the Coroner's tone. He asked us what other evidence we would like to have. We reminded him that on Saturday night, when the Jury were viewing the bodies, a poor man who had lost a relative, complained bitterly of the conduct of the Stewards and of the want of pipes, as we were able to understand him, and that we thought that the ends of justice would not be answered if this man were not produced and heard. The great difficulty was to find out this man, for nobody knew his name. Mr. Williamson Peile was particularly anxious that he should be found and made every exertion to identify him. We then said that while this witness was searched for, we should employ the interval in examining the medical witnesses, to ascertain that proper care had been taken to examine the bodies of the deceased, and to distinguish the cause of death from those of asphyxia. This the coroner declared to be of no importance, and under his directions the officer of the court again made the usual proclamation for witnesses to appear. We desired to see Thos. Graham. Thos. Graham sworn — Was at work at Croft Pit on Friday. No danger was apprehended on that day. James McCabe sworn — (examined by Mr. Coroner) — Is a collier. Was at Croft Pit last Friday. Worked where the accident happened. In the forenoon we worked with the tops off until this place began to fall. Then heard a rush and put them on. Tried and found it safe after. Did not consider it material to examine it. The pit was well aired. Have worked there about six months. Always considered it a safe place to work in. The overseer was diligent in looking after the spot. All ordinary caution was used to prevent accident. By ourselves — What do you mean by a rush? The rush was a fall of stone. These rushes are not common — only in a robbery. By a robbery I mean taking away pillars. In a general way it is considered more dangerous to work pillars than the main coal. Would you rather work at the pillars than at the main coal? I would not. And are you better paid for working pillars? I am. Is not the danger owing to the roof falling in in places, and liberating inflammable air? The coroner would not let this question be put. A long conversation ensued in which we protested against the interruption. At last the witness was allowed to answer, and he said it did arise from that cause. They then usually work with the tops on their lamps. An overman is employed to see that the tops of the lamps are on if necessary. We were working on Friday with the tops of our lamps off; and did not put them on until we heard the rush. We blow out our lamps sometimes when we hear the rush. The rush might be about 50 yards off. The rush gives warning; we hear the roof fall. Do you thing there is any danger in working at robbery of pillars from the inflammable air catching? Not unless in dangerous workings. The overlooker was there on Friday, — once in the forenoon and once in the afternoon. We take off the tops of the lamps to have more light. We told all the men of the rush. We did not tell Mr. Jackson, but we told Joseph Bates, the evening overman, of the rush. We told the men that have lost their lives that a rush had taken place. Bates went and viewed it. Joseph Bates sworn — Is an overman. Saw the place last Friday. Left it about a quarter past six in the evening. All was apparently safe. I heard before I got to McCabe that a rush had taken place — a fall from the roof. I went to examine it. Nothing but a piece of following stone. No explosive air. Place quite clean, never heard of any one objecting to go into this pit. Always directed the Davy's to be locked when I apprehended danger. To what do you imagine this catastrophe to be owing? Can't tell that. To the ignition of inflammable air? Yes. Have been there since, and have examined it. We examined with a light every place in the works to see if there were any inflammable air in it. Examined every place strictly, and saw no place whence it could have come. I think it had come out either at the roof or at the sill. Have seen inflammable gas accumulated in old workings, but rarely. It was my business to see that this place was in a state fit for working. Sometimes working at pillars is more dangerous than working at the main coal. When the roof falls, or the sill heaves, it is more dangerous. As soon as ever we start with such a concern our lamps are locked and made safe. After we have repeatedly examined and found all clean (safe) and sometimes not for two or three days after that, we take the tops off. But you have no possible means of knowing that an irruption will not take place? None. If the top is off is there an increase of light, and can the man work more? He can. Are they paid by the piece? They are. The people who were killed were over an extent of about 200 yards — 24 of them in all. Every collier had safety lamps. The youngest boy there, was about 8 years old. Two of the boys had lamps. Could these boys take the tops on and off the lamps as they liked? They could. Hugh Smith sworn — (This was the man who had complained on Saturday night, and about whom so much inquiry had been made.) Examined by the Coroner. I know the place where the accident happened. Saw it about half an hour after the men were lost, and also about ten weeks before. I was not working there — went to inspect — to see if I was able to work there. I considered the work too heavy — it was for able, stout men. I had also an objection to working there on account of so many accidents having happened — men scorched and burned, found alive, and who died afterwards. They were found alive and died afterwards. Dan Maclaughlen and Mike Smith were lost there, working the solid coal. When I saw the pit last, it was in a middling way, some men working with open tops, and in some places they were working with them shut. I could work in some places in safety, in others I could not. They worked with or without tops to their Davy's according to the deputy's directions. I saw danger in some places, one within sixteen yards of where these people were lost. It was not a regular working — it was where they were taking pillars- it was where I would not work. Most of these statements were made, not in answer to the questions of the Coroner, but spontaneously. The Coroner accused him of drunkenness, and asked him why he had not told him and the jury of these things before. The witness repelled the charge of having been drunk on Saturday night with great indignation. The poor fellow said, that his own cousin was among those who were lost, that he had been 26 hours in the pit, and had not left it until he was in danger of his own life from the effects of the foul air, in his attempts to save his relative. He complained bitterly of the composition of the jury, which he assigned as a reason for not complaining to them more particularly on Saturday night. Examination by ourselves — Did not know that an inquest was sitting now. Was in the pit on Saturday night, in a different working — was about a mile from where the explosion took place — it was about three when it happened. Went with the deputy as fast as he could. Did not hear the explosion — was in a separate air. Met two boys carried out alive. Was terribly exhausted with making three attempts to get at his cousin. There was great delay, for want of wood to restore the air. (We believe that "the air" is restored by setting wooden partitions in the different galleries, so as to direct the atmospheric current into the part of the works where ventilation is wanted.) Computes there were four hours lost for want of means of restoring the air. There was plenty of experienced people, but they had not stuff to make their experience of any use. No complaint can be made of the conduct of the deputy overman in restoring the air. Was overcome by exhaustion. I saw there was no air, and no means of getting it. Saw it was all of no use. They had to send to the granary yard for wood — about three miles. I thing four hours were lost. Mr. Jackson here addressed the court, and denied that the air was cut for four hours — the current of air was continued. The Coroner thought the statement of the witness worthy of no credit as he asserted that the air was not restored until six or seven o'clock, which was quite contrary to the statements of Mr. Peile and Mr. Jackson. Here Mr. Williamson Peile made an observation, which though quite extra-judicial, we considered it only due to him to record, and handing him our notes, we requested him to note it down, which Mr. Peile was kind enough to do. It stands as follows:— "The current of fresh air was never taken off the men, excepting for the instant of the explosion, and wood on the place was uselessly used to replace doors in attempting to send it forward." We here again repeated our determination to sign no more inquisitions without more evidence and especially that of the surgeon. Mr. Mossop, surgeon, sworn. Is surgeon along with Mr. Robinson, attached to the pits. Made an external examination of the body of Garraway. The whole body was burnt. What organic changes do you consider indicative of the body being burned? The skin was reddened and inflamed, and especially on the hands, it was thickened and hard like leather. I was called at six; several men had been burned, and brought to the place kept by Lord Lonsdale for receiving them on these occasions. "Saw one boy with his thigh broken." Those persons are doing well. About half-past seven or about eight o'clock, went to the pit top to make inquiry. Have you ever in your own practice or in you reading, met with a case in which animation was suspended for want of fresh air, or that the person seemed dead, but was not really so? (The Coroner would not suffer the witness to be questioned, as to his information derived from reading but he was allowed to answer that he had never meet with such a case in his own practice) Are you aware that it is an established rule of practice not to consider any one dead of asphyxia, until putrefaction has commenced? I believe no man ought to be considered dead whatever disease he may have died of, until putrefaction takes place. In cases of asphyxia is not more precaution required, than, when a person dies of chronic disease? It is — but I was told I could be of no service. The Coroner here objected to the use of the word asphyxia, as unintelligible to any but medical men, and while we were considering how to frame our questions, so as to dispense with this obnoxious word, a pause took place. Poor Hugh Smith, a simple-minded man of warm feelings, to whom all this was quite unintelligible, had, for some time, been sullenly eying the jury, who were in a row in a corner of the room, with the exception of ourselves, who were at the table making notes. He took advantage of the pause to address the coroner — "Please sir, is them yer jury?" "Yes they are." "Did any body ever see such a set? What can they know about it! There's not a qualified man among them!" The Coroner ordered him to be silent — lectured him — reiterated his accusation of drunkenness on Saturday night; on this Smith replied with more warmth than decorum, and the scene, which convulsed all the spectators with laughter, ended in Smith's being ordered into custody, from which, however, he was soon liberated. Mr. Mossop's examination resumed. — Did not consider it any part of my duty to ascertain, when the bodies were accessible, whether there were cases of suspended animation or of death. There is no man attached to the colliery whose business it is. With the exception of Garraway, I do not know whether they died of contusions, burning, or from the want of fresh air. If you were to see a corpse, with the lips and face livid, and blue, and burned, what would think the person had died of? For what of fresh air, or from strangulation. We here, with some opposition from the Coroner, put a question in the following terms. "I and several of the jury saw the body of Commack Morris; the clothes were burned more of less, the surface of the body was pale, and the skin was peeling off as if it had been dipped in boiling water; of what would you think Cormack Morris had died?" From the effects of fire. You saw on Garraway's body marks of inflammation? I did. Is inflammation a process, which takes place before or after death? It takes place before death, not after. Then Garraway must have lived long enough after the infliction of the injury, for that reaction, which constitutes inflammation, to take place. It is not inflammation, but a common appearance after burning. If you were to see a body, with the face blackened and bruised would you think that the person had lived long enough after the receipt of the injury for reaction to take place? I should hardly think so, but I should imagine he had died from want of circulation in his lungs. If you saw a body with face much bruised, and reddened about the bruises, would you think that the man had lived long enough after the receipt of the injury for reaction to take place? I will not answer — if I had seen the men I might have told you. The Coroner here told witness that he need not answer the question; that he wondered at his patience in submitting to be catechised so long. He insisted that we were merely putting these questions for the purpose of showing our learning, and enlarged very humorously on that point. We stated that we considered it a matter of the highest importance to ascertain whether any of the unfortunate persons could have been saved by prompt attention. The coroner said he positively would not suffer the time of the court to be wasted by such foolish and impertinent inquiries. He accused us, for the twentieth time, at least, of obstinacy, obtuseness, and stupidity, of wishing to insult Mr. Williamson Peile and Mr. Jackson, talked again about applying to the superior courts for a writ de rebus inquirendo, and threatened to put a stop to the inquest. He then took the examination into his own hands. Was every thing done that could possibly be done? Yes. Do you believe it possible to have restored any of the persons to life? I think not, but I did not see them. Finding it absolutely impossible to effect any thing like a minute inquiry, subject to the innumerable interruptions, and interminable speeches of the coroner, of which, and of the epithets he applied to us, we could not note one tenth, we offered to strike a kind of a bargain with him, that if he would let us ask one or two more questions of Mr. Mossop. We would have done. Several of his friends near him, and especially the gentlemen, connected with Lord Lonsdale's colliery establishment, urgently requested him to let us make whatever inquiries we thought fit, and, at last, he assented, telling Mr. Mossop, that he need not answer any questions unless he liked. We then proceeded, having previously written our questions. "If Mr. Mossop-----" Here Mr. Coroner again interfered; he would suffer, he said, no hypothetical questions to be put; at last he was persuaded to let us put it our own way. "If Mr. Mossop had had the superintendence of the pit, would he or would he not, have considered it his duty to have had a professional man on the spot, immediately on the bodies being accessible, to ascertain whether any or them were suffocated and recoverable, or not?" Here another long, irrelevant, unreportable (to coin a word) conversation took place, during which Mr. Coroner treated with much ridicule, the idea of a surgeon going to the bottom of a pit on such an errand. We explained, as soon as we could get a hearing, that we meant "accessible" to medical aid, and did not care whether that were at the top or the bottom of the pit, and read the following question: - "Would you have considered it your duty to have a surgeon to them immediately on their being accessible to medical aid?" The witness declined answering the question. The coroner commenced a rapid ironical monologue directed to the witness of which we made the following note: — "Mr. Coroner — It would be a very great insult to send for a medical man under such circumstances." Thinking it of importance to verify this observation, we read our note to Mr. Coroner, and asked him if we were to consider that a faithful record of what he had said. Mr. Coroner said that he had not said anything of the kind, but he would tell us what he had said, and would talk slow, that we might note it down. We wrote down as follows from his dictation. "I said to Mr. Mossop — If you are informed by a person who has charge of a colliery, that half a dozen persons had lost their lives in the colliery, would you deem it necessary to go to see if they were dead or not? Mr. Mossop said No. Then I said would you deem it an insult? Mr. Mossop said Yes." Here Mr. Mossop, who did not seem to relish having his name tacked to such a monstrous absurdity, denied that he had said yes, and said he merely meant that it might be unnecessary. Another long conversation in which Mr. Coroner observed, that the object of all this was to fill the columns of the Whitehaven Herald. We replied that it was too late for that week's publication. He said that was no matter, — it would keep until next week. We replied that we believed it would, and a great deal longer. He observed that he should be laughed at for allowing so many foolish questions to be put. We assured him that if he were laughed at, it would not be on that account. We now intimated that we had no more questions to ask. The jury was once more called over, and Mr. Coroner once more charged them. He said that they had heard all the evidence, which was necessary to enable them to come to the conclusion recorded in the inquisition he had read to them in the morning. (He here recapitulated those parts of the evidence, which were to that effect.) He had previously stated that all must be left to conjecture. As for the actual causes of death, the only way by which you can come to any conclusion, whether the parties were burned or suffocated, is by the external appearance. If any of you have any doubts of the propriety of the verdict, it has already been signed by persons long more conversant with those things, than the individual who has occupied your attention so irrelevantly and impertinently. (Here Mr. Coroner was very hard on that individual, but we were only able to get down the following sentence.) There was no aspersion now rested on the characters of the gentlemen who had come so roundly forward in the face of day — the calumny had recoiled on the head of the infamous calumniator. It was brought home to the most ordinary understandings that no human means could have been devised to save them. In all probability it was a pure accident; there could be no design of setting the pit on fire; and it has long been known that on the part of the colliers in general there is a carelessness, a headlessness, a recklessness of their own safety, which yet cannot be considered felonious. Mr. Coroner here turning round to us, and showing us his ready-prepared inquisition, asked us if we were now ready to sign it. We said "that we had one very strong objection — namely, that 5 of the jury signed it before they had heard the evidence." (A laugh.) Mr. Coroner.- "Oh! that is immaterial" (Laughter.) We replied "that we begged to be understood as formally making the objection. It was within his discretion to entertain the objection or not." Mr. Coroner here said something about his own impartiality and legal precision. Here entered Mr. R. Sherwin, solicitor. "Mr. Sherwin," said Mr. Coroner, "have you seen any thing illegal in my conduct." "I beg to decline answering, Mr. Coroner." "Oh! You don't want to be interrogated, do you not? Mr. Coroner now erased the names from the inquisition with his pen, and handed it down, directing the Jurors who had previously signed to sign again, and all the twelve put down their names, ourselves last. While the signing was going on, Mr. Williamson Peile enquired of us, with much courtesy and with a degree of feeling which did him honour, if we really believed that any lives had been lost for want of medical assistance? We replied that we could not form any decisive opinion on that point, as we had made a very superficial examination of the bodies, never suspecting in the least that medical assistance had not been had; but that we had every reason to believe, from the appearance of inflammation on the bodies, that many of the deceased had lived for some time after the explosion; and that the bodies of the two Littles exhibited no indications of scorching sufficient to account for their death — one of them indeed none whatever, and that if they had died of suffocation, there was no saying whether or not they might have been recovered, unless proper means had been tried. The inquisition on Hector McAllister having been signed; a new difficulty occurred. It having been clearly proved that some of the bodies showed appearances of suffocation and others of burning, it was plain that the standing verdict of "burned and scorched on the hip, back, breast, &c." would not fit all the cases with any decency, so it was agreed to adjourn until the morning, against which time the Coroner and the foreman could get inquisitions ready filled up, and the jury might then assemble formally to sign them. Previous to separation, Mr. Coroner turning round to us said, "Perhaps Mr. Abraham you do not know that it is not usual to have a parchment inquisition filled up, and signed by twelve jurors, but the inquisition is often written on a piece of paper, and signed only by one of the jury. You may not know that this is law, but it is law I can assure you. To which we replied. "Sir, I did not know that it was the case, though, I do know that crowner's quest law has been a proverb, ever since the times of Shakespeare." "Oh that's all your learning is it" replied Mr. Coroner, "Why Mr. Shakespeare's quite a modern author. Crowner's law, as you call it, sir, goes back in — Here Mr. Coroner's memory failed him, and turning to his books, he quoted an act of the Edwards some way about 1500, but we are not very sure of the chronology, nor does it much matter.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||