|
Whitehaven HeraldArticle from the Whitehaven Herald, 15th November 1831 Explosion of Fire-damp in Lord Lonsdale's CollieriesTwenty-two lives lostIt is this week our painful duty to record on of those sudden and terrible events which so frequently occur in coal working, and of which the consequences have plunged between twenty and thirty families into the most agonising distress. About half-past two on Saturday morning an explosion of inflammable air took place in Croft Pit, about a mile to the south-west of Whitehaven. Various reports of the nature and extent of the accident were, in the course of the morning, current in Whitehaven, and excited an intense interest. But though the interest in the event, and the sympathy with the sufferers and their families was great, candour obliges us to state, that nothing seemed do extraordinary to us as comparative strangers in Whitehaven, as the very little excitement if occasioned. An event so awful in its nature, and so dreadful in its effects, would, in any but a colliery district, have excited feelings of horror and amazement, of which the effects would have been visible, in the most unequivocal manner, to the most cursory observer; but though the event was indeed a subject of general conversation, it did not seem in the least to disturb the ordinary course of business, and the destruction of from twenty to thirty individuals seemed to excite less interest, than in other places we have seen occasioned by the untimely death of a single human being. Even the mystery which hung over the causes of the terrible catastrophe seemed hardly to excite a desire to penetrate it; and though we cannot believe that if active exertions could have been of any benefit, they would not have been spared, still, the apathy which prevailed, seemed to us a strange contrast to the deep feeling of awe and interest which elsewhere would have been occasioned by a loss of life to one tithe of the amount. About one o'clock in the afternoon we learned that the raising of the bodies of the sufferers had commenced, and we accordingly repaired to the mount of the pit. On our road thither we saw none of those symptoms of public interest in the fate of the sufferers, which in other towns would have turned out thousands, eager to learn the least tiding of the fate of so many fellow creatures, cut off by so sudden and dreadful a calamity. The streets bore their ordinary aspects of business or of listless indifference. As we receded from the town we met successively four cars, which contained each something covered with straw, and as we learned from casual passengers, the bodies of the wretched victims. On reaching the pit we understood that five bodies had been raised, besides two living men, of whom one had since died. Fifteen or sixteen were collected at the bottom of the shaft ready to be raised, and two or three persons supposed to have perished, were yet missing and unaccounted for. About fifty or sixty persons were collected on the spot; a number of carts were ready to carry away the bodies as fast as raised, and one was pointed to us as containing the body of a young man and waiting to receive the body of his brother, who had perished along with him. Deep agony was painted in many a countenance round us and one poor young creature who had lost her husband rent the air with her wailing's. The corpses were momentarily expected to be raised to the surface but we turned our steps from the scene of horrors. On enquiry we learned that the depth of the shaft was 160 fathoms (one third of the height of Skiddaw!) and that the working, where the explosion took place, was more than a mile, some said two from the bottom of the shaft. A coroner's jury, we further learned, was already summoned, and would meet as soon as the bodies were all raised. About three in the afternoon we were informed, that the inquests were about commencing, and we repaired to the quarter of the town where we were informed they were to be held. We were prepared to find a large concourse of people attracted either by sympathy, or curiosity, to the scene of an investigation so solemn and momentous, as an enquiry into the cause of the deaths of twenty two human beings, must be in the eyes of all who are duly impressed with a tender regard for the life and happiness of their fellow creatures and who are aware that in the Whitehaven collieries alone, many hundreds are daily making their bread with a similar calamity impending over them, but our eyes could discover no trace of any event which might excite human sympathy; we saw no passenger who did not seem passing on his usual avocations, and the inhabitants of the houses around were as usual in the evenings, carelessly lounging at their doors. Our readers will scarcely think it credible but we can assure them of the fact that within one hundred yards of the spot where the inquest was sitting, we enquired of two persons who could not direct us to it, and we only obtained the information from a person officially acquainted with the fact. When we arrived at the spot, the coroner's gig at the door was the only indication of any thing particular going forward within. These may seem but trifling facts, but to us who are unused to such dreadful scenes, they seemed lamentable indications, if not of a want of feeling, at least of the suppression of it. We have seen enough of the men of Whitehaven, in cases of shipwreck, to know, that where active exertions can be useful, they are not slow or timid in affording them, but still it was not the less incomprehensible to us, that on this occasion, no little feeling or sympathy should be visible. On entering the public house, where the inquest was sitting, we found its apartments occupied by a number of persons, principally colliers (Saturday is pay day at the collieries) spending their evening, as usual, in boisterous drinking. The Landlady conducted us to the room in which the coroner was; it was a small back parlour, and letting us into it with a snap-key, she informed us that it was shut in order to keep the room clear from the intrusion of the people drinking in her house, which we have no doubt was the case. We found the coroner, Peter Hodgson, and his clerk, with twelve jurors and a constable at the door, the room being barely sufficient to hold the party. The Coroner was busy swearing in the jury, and on our entry he enquired our name and if we were one of them. We gave our address, and stated that we attended as a spectator- as one of the public. Mr. Coroner immediately replied that perhaps we would like to be on the jury ourselves, and then we could see that every proper investigation was made? Mr. Coroner observed, that in the inquisitions before him the names of twelve jurors ere already recorded, but that we might be included in the next one. The following jury —
were impannelled, successively, to hold inquests on the causes of the deaths of Christopher Fitzsimons, Abraham Taylor, Hugh Hannay, Hugh Smith, John McMinn, George Partleton, Archibald McGahan, John Graham, Thomas Ward, Hector McAllister, and John Graham. Whether the above Jurors were selected by the overseer, or by the Coroner, or by what rule the selection was guided, if by any, we do not know. Mr. Coroner then with great civility, requested us to take a seat at the table, in order "to report every word he said" and was kind enough to say, that he would speak slow on purpose to enable us to do so. We were the only reporter present, and indeed the only individual in the room except the Coroner, clerk, jurors, and constable. Mr. Coroner then proceeded to charge the jury. The charge he had to make to them would by a very brief one indeed. They were assembled on one of those melancholy occasions, which unfortunately but too often occurred. It appeared to be one of those awful and sudden events, which sweep off their victims in numbers, and leave none behind to tell the tale. And it was utterly unknown how it had happened, and it was to be presumed that it was accidental; but if the jury found that any man had willfully ignited the air in the pit, that person would by guilty of the crime of murder, and if they found that any man had willfully taken off the top of his lamp without looking to consequences it would amount to manslaughter. His official duty had at time and time required his attendance on many similar occasions; but never yet could he satisfactorily ascertain the cause of the explosion, for all who were within its reach invariably perished, and he feared that no more light could be thrown upon it now. The most probable cause, and he feared they could arrive at nothing nearer than probabilities, was, that this dreadful explosion which "at one foul swoop" had hurried so many human beings to their long account, was some individual's opening his lamp to get more light than he could otherwise be enabled to have. Mr. Coroner then proceeded to explain to the jury the different circumstances connected with the use of lamps which would warrant them in bringing in a verdict of murder, manslaughter, or accidental death. The charge being over, Mr. Coroner turned round to us rather abruptly, and enquired if we had "put down every word he said?" We replied that we feared we had not, but that we thought we had got the substance we should, however, be happy to submit our report to his correction. This proposal was courteously declined. The jury then proceeded to view the bodies of the eleven unfortunate beings above named. They had to pilot there way through those almost interminable rows of squalid cottages called the New Houses and the Ginns, which belong to Lord Lonsdale, and are exclusively occupied by his workmen. None of these buildings seem very modern, and we have rarely seen any dwellings even of the lowest class of artisans so destitute of comfort or convenience. Whether it be from poverty or from improvidence, their interior and exterior, with the exception that they are all carefully whitewashed, are naked, desolate, and filthy in the extreme; a yet more disgusting circumstance was that a large portion of their inmates both male and female, were either intoxicated or in a state bordering on intoxication. It was the duty of the jury and of the Coroner to take a view, as it is technically termed, of the bodies; and in the discharge of this painful duty they had to traverse the whole of those buildings, and dive into many a recess of wretchedness, and witness the agonizing grief of the widowed, the fatherless, and of destitute old age. The majority of the victims were unmarried, young men or lads. They in general seemed little disfigured, though a respect for the feelings of their relations, and the necessity of getting through the preliminary part of the business that night, if possible, in order to enable the coroner to issue has warrant for their burial on Sunday, prevented anything beyond a very superficial examination. They had been taken out of the pit before the limbs had got permanently contracted, and perhaps the foul air had retarded that process; they were all washed and straightened, and were laid out with that decent regard for the obsequies of the dead, which invariable distinguishes even the poorest of the poor. On the return of the jury, the investigation commenced with chilling evidence respecting the death of John McMinn. James Floody called. It would be difficult to give our readers any idea of this man's appearance and conduct. He commenced a very rude expostulation with the Coroner, who was about to swear him. He declared that the Coroner had asked him something or other (we could not catch what) before, and he had no business to ask him again — he would not take the oath — his conscience pricked him — he would tell the truth first and than swear to it after. The Coroner expostulated with him; the jury expostulated with him. Both reminded him that he was bringing great suspicion on himself. The Coroner threatened to commit him; he told the Coroner to do so if he liked. Neither threats nor reasoning could induce him to take the oath; he protested that he was sober — had not been an hour out of the pit — he would tell the truth but he would not swear. The Coroner ordered him into custody. There was some delay in finding a constable, and in the mean time the witness persisted in talking, and stated that he was going down the pit and felt the blast — that O'Brien and he both found it. This person did not appear to be drink, or at least not particularly so. Two witnesses now appeared, Thos. Dryden and another, both to them manifestly intoxicated. The former was sworn. He went to the pit about half-past four in the morning — deceased was a taker off in a little pit — a hagger. The coroner expressed an anxiety to get deceased's proper designation, and commented severely on the intoxication of the witnesses. Heard no blast — the man was scorched and burnt — blood came from his head. Was certain there had been a fire in the Croft Pit. Witness here showed strong symptoms of drunkenness, was very impertinent with the coroner, and insisted on leaving the room; the Coroner threatened to commit him, expostulated with him, but all in vain. All that could be extracted from him was that he believed there had been a "strong blast" and that deceased had died from its effects. During this examination the service of the only constable in attendance on the court being required, the Coroner desired him never to mind the fellow that had run away, (Floody) he was not worth keeping — that he would report him and see that he never was employed again. Intelligence now arrived that the bodies of two brothers, William Little and Robert Little were got out and taken home. A jury were impannelled, including the same jurors as in the preceding inquests, excepting that James Hewitt, ex-huntsman to Lord Lonsdale (we believe) was substituted for Joseph Jackson, watchman, and Robert Abraham was substituted for Phillip Jackson, sheriff's officer. The jury proceeded to view those bodies, which lay at a little solitary cottage, in the field, about a mile and a half out of Whitehaven. We had an opportunity of examining them more carefully than the others. William, the elder brother, was a little scorched in the face, but not so much, and his breast, where his shirt had probably been open, showed a little appearance of scorching likewise; the skin of his breast had just that rough reddish appearance which marks the incipient stage of confluent small-pox. His face was very livid, which, with the redness of his breast were pretty certain signs that he had, not died suddenly, but had lived ling enough for the blood to get carbonized, and the skin to inflame. His brother Robert showed no exterior sign of injury; he was neither discoloured nor scorched, and it might be difficult for the physiologist to conceive what could be the proximate cause of that swift destruction, which had left so little trace of its agency. His manly countenance had that "mild and placid air, that rapture of repose," which often marks the recent dead. "Before decay's effacing fingers, have swept the lines where beauty lingers." They were both fine young men, remarkable for personal appearance, and were in a great measure, if not wholly, the support of their aged parents, and bore an excellent character. There was not much difference between their ages, and they strikingly resembled each other. As they lay side by side in the humble bed of their lonely cottage, we thought we had seldom seen a more affecting spectacle. The jury returned in the dark and lowering night from this melancholy errand, an on their return found that Patterson Turner, Robt. Garraway, John Bolton, Thos. Daly, Robt. Cook, Jas. Queen, and Clement Ingleby, had been carried to their several houses from the pit. Being sworn on those inquisitions, they proceeded again to search out for the houses of mourning. It would be impossible for us to give any lengthened detail of the appearance of the bodies, and indeed this part of the business was got over a speedily as possible, for the reasons we mentioned above. Some of the bodies appeared much scorched and bruised, especially those of the two Queen's, father and son, the latter a mere boy, who both lay in the same bed. On their return to the inn, the jury were apprised that the body of Cormack Morris was found. This was the last victim known to have perished and they proceeded to the house where the corpse was lying. On our arrival, we found this poor fellow exactly in the state in which he had been taken out of the pit. He was all blackened over with coal dust, his clothes burnt, and his skin looked as if he had been scalded, but from there being no discolouration it was evident he had died very suddenly — that is before re-action could take place. As he lay on his back before us he seemed to be in the position in which the last mortal agony had come over him; his limbs contracted, his countenance sternly fixed. The bodies (twenty-two in all) having been now all seen, and one of the jury having suggested to the foreman that it would be as well, on resuming the enquiry, to have in attendance every one who could throw any light on the subject by a proper account of the preventive measures usually adopted of the state of pits, and especially of their ventilation, in order that no time might be lost in sending for witnesses, the Coroner said that in such cases it was invariably the custom to make such a full investigation and that it was strongly the interest of the noble proprietor of the pits to prevent the occurrence of such accidents, as he made a practice of allowing the widows of the sufferers each a house and coals free for life, with a pension of two shillings a week, and employment to the children on very favorable terms. The Coroner then, in a very handsome manner, suggested that Monday morning at eleven o'clock, at the public office, in Lowther Street, would be a suitable time and place for reassembling; that for himself he was a public officer, and that his time was at the service of the public, and that if any jury could suggest any other time or place as more convenient for their attendance, he should be ready to afford them any accommodation in his power. This proposal being assented to, after a little conversation, the names of the jury were called over and Mr. Coroner proceeded to charge them. He said that this was a case attended with loss of life to a most terrible extent. At present the state of the only witnesses who were likely to throw any light on it, was such that it was utterly impossible to impress on them any adequate idea, either of the solemnity of the occasion, or of the solemnity of an oath. He believed that under all the circumstances it would be better to adjourn, and that on Monday it was to be hoped that the witnesses would be impressed with a due sense of this awful event. The jury were then bound over in their own recognizances of ten pounds each to appear at the police office in Lowther Street, on Monday morning, at 11 o'clock. Thus terminated the preliminary part of this investigation. At it is hardly probable that the inquest will be terminated time enough on Monday (if at all on that day) for us to give so full an account of it as its awful importance demands, and as it would be highly improper in us, pending the enquiry, to offer any comments of our own, our readers must not expect to read in our paper of this week, any further particulars of the investigation, or of the presumed causes of the accident. We have only to add, that though we have in our time seen many a dismal spectacle of human misery and mortality, we never witnessed one, which left on our mind such deep impressions of horror, as that of Saturday night.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||