Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

11th October 1791

From the Gazetteer, {London, October 4, 1791} Lord Lonsdale

The following Statement comes from a Friend of his Lordship. Our accustomed impartiality commands its admission.

The public Papers having for three weeks past, abounded with paragraphs reflecting upon the Right Hon. the Earl of Lonsdale, and his conduct respecting his Coal works in and around the Town of Whitehaven, a Correspondent has favoured us with the following particulars relating to this business, from whence the public will be able to judge, how far the propagators of the reports that gave rise to the paragraphs, or the fabricators of the paragraphs themselves, are entitled to the appellation of enemies to his Lordship, enemies to the peace of the town, and enemies to the public good.

Upwards of twenty years ago, Mr. Samuel Martin, of Whitehaven, applied to his Lordship for the grant or purchase of a piece of ground adjoining the town, for the purpose of erecting buildings or dwelling-houses thereupon, which his Lordship accordingly granted, or sold him, "reserving to himself and his heirs all Mines and Seams of Coal, and other Mines and Minerals whatsoever, as well opened as unopened, or which should or might at any time be opened or found under the said premises, or any part thereof, with full liberty and power for his Lordship, his servants and agents, from time to time, and at all times thereafter, at his and their will and pleasure, to work the same."

It was notorious, at the time of this purchase and sale of the ground, that part of the Coal or Royalty under it had been worked or taken away, visible vestiges of such working being then conspicuous upon the premises, and although it is unquestionable that this Coal or Royalty had been worked by some of his Lordship's ancestors, yet it is not in the remembrance of any person living, nor are any records or writing remaining, from whence it can appear either when, how, or in what manner such Coal or Royalty was worked. Whether, therefore, the Royalty or Coal under the premises had been so worked, as that pillars were left sufficient for the support of the soil, or surface, with the additional weight of buildings to be thereupon erected, was equally unknown to his Lordship and Mr. Martin.

Mr. Martin clearly took the soil or surface, with the visible vestiges of its having been worked, with all the risks that might or could attend such old workings.

Soon afterwards, Mr. Martin erected a dwelling-house upon part of the premises, and regranted some other parts thereof to persons who also erected several small dwellings thereupon.

In the month of January last, the agents of Lord Lonsdale, in the working of his coal or royalty, or in the extension of the works, at a considerable distance from the Royalty of the premises in question, met with the usual impediment of water in their progress towards the new Coal, for it must be obvious, on a moments reflection, even to persons who are strangers to the business of mining or working Royalties, that it is utterly impossible even to approach to, much more to work any Royalty, laying at a considerable depth underground, without meeting water, and, of course, equally impossible to work such Royalty without first taking away the water.

Upon this general, upon this universal principle of working Royalties, by first taking away the impediment to the working thereof, and without which Royalties are inaccessible and useless; the water so met with, whether it was taken away with all the skilfulness and attention necessary to be observed in mining, or otherwise, is, in the present instance, of no consequence, as at all events it was to be taken away to have access to the Royalty; and until that was done, it was impossible to know from whence it proceeded; for, if the Strata of Coal then working in, extended to the ascent, without the interruption of other Strata's, even for the distance of miles, the water would have descended, and come away the whole distance; the body of Coal on all this coast being of so open and porous a nature, as not to hold water, when the other Strata's that kept it pent up are cut or sunk through; so that the unforeseen accident which happened, might, in that case, have equally happened either in his Lordship's Royalties, or those of his neighbours, if old insufficient workings laid at such distance, as the place where it did.

The water being thus taken away, at a considerable distance from the Royalty of the ground so granted, the soil or surface of it, and of some other parts adjoining, shrank or gave way, by which means several of the dwelling houses lately erected thereupon were materially injured, from whence it appeared (and it was impossible till the water was taken away, that it could appear or be known) that the old workings by his Lordship's ancestors, had not been left with pillars or supports sufficient to sustain the surface with the additional weight of the buildings thereupon erected, and which, had they been sufficient, no accident could have happened; nor is it probable in that case, that it could even then have been known by the Miners themselves, from whence the water came, unless by conjecture from the failure of some spring on the surface (and that probably too at a great distance from the place) of which daily instances occur in the extension of the works in Coal or other Royalty.

On this accident taking place, the owner of one of the dwellings so injured, brought an action against his Lordship, which was tried at the last assizes at Carlisle, and a verdict was given against his Lordship.

His Lordship, by this verdict, conceiving himself entirely barred from the working of his Royalties at all, if he was liable to be harassed by continual actions for water taken away, and without the daily taking away of which it is impossible for the Owner of any Royalty in any county to work them; or, conceiving the verdict went to the obliging him to answer for all the consequences of the unskilful workings of his ancestors, at a time when the soil or surface, as well as the Royalty, was their own property, and therefore no injury could arise to any person but themselves, however unskilfully they worked them; or, even conceiving that it went to the obliging him to stand the risk of their being unskilfully worked by such ancestors, after he himself sold or granted the soil or surface as aforesaid, and not only without stipulating or being required to stipulate any risk, but expressly referring to himself, as before mentioned, all Royalty whatsoever, as well opened as unopened, or which might at any time be found under the premises (and which it was impossible either to open or find without first taking away the water impeding the approach to them); and also conceiving that, if the maxim of law, "That no person shall so use his own property as to injure that of his neighbour," should apply to the present case, under all the circumstances thereof, which he was of opinion it could not nor would do; his carrying on his works with all the skill and caution that human ingenuity in mining was possessed of, might, from similar accidents, involve him in damages that no fortune was equal to the amount of; his Lordship was, therefore, in prudence, obliged to declare, that he must suspend his works till he found how far the law would protect him in carrying them on.

The moment his Lordship made known this determination, or probably before, his enemies, or others, without application to his Lordship, who is Lord Lieutenant of the county, or even without his knowledge, lent such representations to the War Office of the town being in a tumultuous state, as to induce orders from thence to be issued for two troops of horse, who had been active in quelling the late riots at Sheffield, to march with unprecedented speed to Whitehaven, and orders were also issued for more troops to march to the same place, which are now within a few miles of it, and several companies of foot are also on their march to it.

When the two troops arrived, they were astonished to find the town in perfect peace, without riot, or the least appearance of any disturbance. On the contrary, they found its principal inhabitants expressing their concern for the difficulties Lord Lonsdale met with in carrying on his works from the verdict given at Carlisle; they found them representing to his Lordship the calamities that must befall the town from the many thousands of industrious poor being deprived of bread by even a temporary suspension of his Lordship's works, though his Lordship had generously offered 100 oxen, 500 sheep, and £1,000 in cash, towards their support during such suspension; they found that these principal inhabitants had submitted to his Lordship, whether it would not be more for the public good, that the works should be continued under a guarantee to his Lordship, from every person whose property might, in the mean time, be injured from similar accidents, until his Lordship could be informed how far the law would protect him; they found themselves treated with all the civility and respect which the good order and regularity observed among them gives them the justest claim to, and, on learning that his Lordship met the wishes of the town, and agreed to the continuation of the works on the terms proposed by the inhabitants, they united with them in the general joy and rejoicings which they had never seen more cordially or more universally expressed on any occasion; and they are ready to testify, that they never were in any town, consisting of such a number of inhabitants, where they witnessed a more peaceable and orderly demeanour, even among the lowest class of the people.

Such is the situation of the town: — While the persons who meant to disgrace the Earl of Lonsdale and this town, by sending for these troops, are busily employed in putting a stop to the march of the others that are on their way to it, being unable to raise a shadow of pretence for their being so unnecessarily harassed by such long marches, to a town in the enjoyment of perfect peace and happiness.

Whitehaven, Sept. 27, 1791.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Lonsdale, Earl of      
Martin, Samuel      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print