Logo Museum Entrance
Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archives
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Colliery Guardian
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Title Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Title
/   \

50 Questions and Answers on British coal

Public Ownership: The National Coal Board

1. What events led to the nationalisation of the mines?

The demand for nationalisation of the coal industry has a long history. It can be traced back to the early efforts of the miners to improve their status and conditions, their desire to form trade unions and their determination to send representatives to Parliament.

As early as 1884 a miners’ leader advocated nationalisation and a report of the Scottish Mines Federation in 1886 stated ". . . Co-operative production under State management should be our goal . . ."

In 1893 the Trades Union Congress accepted the policy of nationalisation of the mines and after 1900 the entire strength of the trade union movement was used to promote nationalisation of the industry.

During the 1914-18 war the South Wales miners came out on strike for wage increases and when another dispute seemed likely in 1916 the Government decided to take over control of the South Wales coalfield. In February, 1917, the entire mining industry came under Government control.

A number of official inquiries into the mining industry were held in the years after the war. In 1919 a Royal Commission (which became known as the Sankey Commission, after the Chairman, Mr. Justice Sankey) stated in an interim report that "the present system of ownership and the working of the coal industry stands condemned and some other system must be substituted for it, either nationalisation or a measure of unification by national purchase and/or by joint control". The final report made it clear that this was not supported by the employers’ representatives on the Commission and a recommendation in the final report read: "No detailed scheme for nationalisation has yet been submitted to the Commissioners, nor has any scheme for joint control been placed before them". The purchase of royalty rights was recommended and agreed to by the whole Commission.

The Government decided to de-control the mines on March 31st, 1921: on April 1st a strike started which lasted 13 weeks.

Further Government inquiries were held in 1924 (The Buckmaster Inquiry) and in 1925 (the MacMillan Inquiry and the Samuel Commission).

During the Second World War a White Paper on Coal was presented to Parliament pointing out the need for more men in the industry and for making the industry more efficient; in 1942 the Government assumed full operational control of the industry to achieve this. A Minister was made responsible, assisted by a Controller-General. A "National Coal Board" was established with regional boards to advise the Controller.

A Technical Advisory Committee was set up in 1944, consisting of six mining engineers under the chairmanship of Sir Charles Reid. Their report called for a complete reorganisation of the industry to eliminate uneconomic units and make possible the thorough mechanisation of the rest. The report also recommended that an authority be established to carry through the necessary administrative changes, stating: "The existence of such an authority, endowed by Parliament with really effective powers for this purpose is, we are satisfied, a cardinal necessity".

A new Government was elected in 1945 and in the same year the Coal Industry Nationalisation Bill was introduced. It passed into law in 1946.

 

2. How was nationalisation carried out?

To administer the industry, a public corporation, responsible through Parliament to the people, was set up — the National Coal Board.

On January 1st, 1947, the Board took over the industry. They became the biggest single employer of labour in the country, with nearly 800,000 workers, running an industry with an annual turnover of about £360 million. (In 1961 the figure was £863 million.)

Opencast mining, for which the Ministry of Fuel and Power was originally responsible, was taken over by the National Coal Board on April 1st, 1952. It had been begun in 1942, and in 1958, the peak production year, produced 143 million tons out of the total national output of 215.8 million tons. Production today is at a substantially lower level.

Under the Act which nationalised the industry, the Board are charged with securing the efficient development of the country’s coal production, and with making the coal available in such quantities and at such prices as may seem to them best calculated to further the public interest. The Board have also to see that over an average of good years and bad the industry pays its way. If a loss is made during one particular year, it must be made good in subsequent years.

The former colliery owners are being compensated for their properties which were nationalised. An independent judicial tribunal fixed the basic value of the industry for compensation purposes at £164 million. That did not include the value of the houses, railways, coke ovens and other ancillaries. The total compensation in cash or Treasury stock brought into the Board’s accounts was £388,110,267.

The Board are responsible to the Minister of Power for redeeming the capital value of the stock and for paying the interest on it. In 1961 the Board set aside for payment to the Minister £42.1 million, which also included interest on money borrowed. This money has to be provided by the Board before declaring their final surplus or deficit. Since Vesting Day the Board have paid £419 million in this way: £345 million in interest and £74 million repaid principal.

There are eight Divisional Coal Boards, appointed by the National Board, each responsible for one of the main coalfields or groups of coalfields in the country. A Divisional General Manager is responsible for the Kent coalfield.

These nine Divisions are split up into 45 Areas, each administered by an Area General Manager with a team of experts on production, labour problems, marketing, finance and science to advise him.

Divisional Boards are composed of a Chairman, Deputy Chairman and Directors in charge of Production, Marketing, Industrial Relations, Staff, Finance and in some cases Reconstruction and Carbonisation. The Divisions had in 1961 turnovers which ranged from £176 million in the case of North Eastern to £7.4 million for South Eastern.

Areas vary in size considerably and may produce anything from one million to over nine million tons of coal a year. The average Area, with a yearly turnover of about £18 million, is a very large business undertaking — larger, for example, than many oil or insurance companies.

 

3. Who appoints the National Board and who are the present members?

The members are appointed by the Minister of Power. After the Advisory Committee on the Board’s Organisation made its report in February, 1955 (referred to in the answer to Question 5), the Board was reconstituted. Its present members are:

Rt. Hon. Lord Robens (Chairman)
E. H. Browne, (Deputy Chairman)
C. A. Roberts (Staff)
H. E. Collins (Production)
J. Crawford (Industrial Relations)
A. W. John (Finance)
F. Wilkinson (Marketing)
A. H. A. Wynn (Science)
J. M. A. Smith (Part-time)
W. J. P. Webber (Part-time)
Sir Reginald Ayres (Part-time)

Though Board members are responsible for departments, they are not concerned with their day-to-day administration.

 

4. How many mines are operated by the Board?

The Board operate about 670 collieries and there are also about 470 "small mines", with 30 or fewer men underground, which are operated under licence from the Board. These small mines produce about 1.2 per cent, of the deep-mined coal.

In addition to collieries, the Board took over many ancillary undertakings such as brickworks, coke ovens and by-product plants.

 

5. Has the Board’s organisation been re-examined?

In December, 1953, the Board appointed an Advisory Committee on Organisation to consider the industry’s organisation and to make recommendations to the Board. Dr. A. Fleck (now Lord Fleck) was elected chairman and the Committee reported in February, 1955. Although it recommended substantial changes inside the line-and-staff formation, the Committee agreed that the National Board — Divisional Board — Area — Colliery structure was correct. Since 1955 the Board have revised their organisation in the light of the Committee’s recommendations.

Divisional Boards have a wide measure of delegated authority. In fact, up to the end of 1961, the Board’s capital expenditure totalled about £1,056 million, of which more than half was expenditure approved in the Divisions without reference to London.

 

6. Is it true that the industry is "over-laden with officials"?

The Fleck Committee (see answer to previous question) described the sort of criticism implicit in this question as "ill-informed", and added: "The proportion of staff — 40,000 out of a total ‘payroll’ of about three-quarters of a million — is certainly not too high. Indeed, we believe that the efficient management of the industry requires a higher ratio, as well as a higher average quality". The Board’s implementation of the Fleck Report increased the number of staff to 56,750; by 1961 economy measures had reduced this number to 50,200. The proportion of non-industrial employees in the coal industry is about half that in industry generally.

 

7. What have been the financial results since nationalisation?

There was a deficit of £23¼ million on the first year’s activities in 1947. In the following years the Board reduced the deficit substantially, but it increased again to £37 million at the end of 1955. The price of coal was increased in the summer of 1955 to check this trend, and by the end of 1956 the accumulated deficit had been reduced to £23.8 million. During 1957 and 1958 there was a considerable increase in operating costs and in 1959 the cost of stocking coal (which was in surplus due to industrial recession) alone amounted to £27 million, resulting in an increase to £52 million in the accumulated deficit by the end of 1959. There was a price increase in September, 1960. In 1961 — before the effects of the increase could be fully realised — the accumulated deficit rose to nearly £82 million. There is no Treasury subsidy to the industry, and none of the deficit falls on the taxpayer. The Board are required to pay back to the Government the capital value of the stock issued as compensation to the industry’s former owners and the interest on it. The capital repayment is spread over 50 years. Interest on money borrowed from the Government to finance part of the capital expenditure programme has also to be met each year and the borrowings progressively redeemed.

 

8. Are royalties still paid?

Until 1938 coal deposits were the legal property of private owners, frequently the people who owned the surface land beneath which coal lay. With the passing into law of the Coal Act, 1938, they became public property and were vested in the Coal Commission; the former owners received Coal Commission Stock by way of compensation. When the National Coal Board was set up, the Commission’s interest in all the unworked coal passed to the Board and the Treasury issued new stock in exchange for Coal Commission Stock to a value of £78,457,000 bearing interest at the rate of 2½ per cent, a year. The Board are liable to the Minister for the repayment of this capital with interest.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print