Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Name Index (Local!)
Name Index (Rest of UK)
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

  Disasters - Names Return to Index Disasters - Names  
/ \
Date:  14th October 1906
Colliery:  Wingate Grange
Company:  Owners of Wingate Grange Colliery Ltd.
Cause:  Explosion, firedamp, ignition probably caused by shot firing
Lives Lost:  26
Category:  

Description

The second occurred on Sunday, 14th October, about 11.40 p.m., at the Wingate Grange Colliery in the County of Durham, the property of the owners of Wingate Grange Colliery, and caused the deaths of 25 persons, 24 of whom were killed on the spot, and one man subsequently died on November 24th from pneumonia brought on by the cold and exposure in the pit whilst waiting to be brought to the surface.

Special reports by Mr. A. H. Ruegg, K.C., who attended the adjourned inquest by your instructions, Mr. J. B. Atkinson, the Inspector in charge of the Newcastle District, and myself have already been presented to you, but notwithstanding this I wish to make a few remarks here, in the hope that they will get into the hands of the various subordinate officials of collieries who may not have the opportunity of seeing the special reports referred to.

The explosion occurred in the Low Main seam on a main engine plane about 680 yards from the up cast shaft, and the effects were traceable for about 1,140 yards north from the shaft, for about 490 yards up the stable way, and 50 yards up the 1st east.

The Low Main seam in which the explosion occurred gives off little or no firedamp, and none had been found on the engine plane for many years. There was no goaf near from which gas could have come off, and there were no cavities in the roof where gas could lodge, and a ventilating current of over 26,000 cubic feet per minute was passing along the engine plane. It therefore appears clear from the first that the explosion could not be traced to firedamp. It was found that some geloxite and a length of fuze were missing from the shot firer's box which was discovered intact in a refuge hole close to the scene of the explosion and to where his body was found, and it was eventually found that a shot had been fired with a view to blowing down a small projecting piece of stone on the side of the road. The stone was in no way dangerous and had been in the same position for 25 years at least, and no orders had been given to have it removed. The man who fired the shot, and who lost his life, was a licensed shot firer and was stated to be a very steady man. He had no drilling gear with him and had placed the explosive loose on a ledge of stone and fired it without drilling a hole and without using any stemming, in direct contravention of the Explosives Order and Mines Act, and without a special authorisation which he ought to have had if a shot had to be fired on a main engine plane. Although the road in question was not one which would be considered very dry and dusty, for the floor nearly all through was damp, some very fine coal dust was deposited on the rough surface of the stone, the pack wall, and timbers, the accumulation of many years, and this undoubtedly was ignited by the firing of the explosive and caused the catastrophe.

Had the regulations been observed the shot could have been fired with safety and the explosion would not have occurred.

The danger of coal dust alone without any admixture of firedamp has not been fully recognised until recent years, and even now is not admitted by some mining engineers, and by many officials and workmen.

There can be no doubt about it ; this was clearly demonstrated at the Timsbury and Camerton Colliery explosions in Somersetshire some years ago, and now again at Wingate.

It has been argued that if this danger exists to the extent now claimed, that explosions would be of daily occurrence where gunpowder is used in the coal faces, but the argument is not sound. The dust in the faces in nearly all cases is coarse and heavy and would not readily lend itself to the propagation of an explosion.

The danger lies in the very fine particles of dust, often as fine as the finest flour, which are carried down the shafts from the screens or blown off the top of the tubs in their transit to the shaft and which settle almost unobserved, on the sides, roof, timbers, and floors of the engine planes, and it only requires a small initial explosion whether of gas or some explosive to cause an explosion which may extend throughout the mine.

A great deal has been done in this district and is still being done to remove this danger. Many miles of water pipes with suitable standards and hose pipes at fixed distances have been laid down, water tubs with sprays of various sorts are in use, and a system of spraying the tubs automatically with water before leaving the landings for their journey to the shaft has been found to act very beneficially. Methods of dealing with dust on the screens have also been successfully applied at some collieries. Brushing away and clearing the dust from the main roads has been done for a considerable time in places where watering seriously affects the roof and sides as it does with certain classes of stone.

Given an area free from dust or a zone of road perfectly wet, if an explosion should occur from any cause, the evil effects of it will be greatly reduced and the area much circumscribed, and I hope this is now being more fully realised by the persons responsible for the safety of the mines.

None but the most efficient men, and the fewer the better, should be appointed shot firers, and care should be taken to see that they thoroughly understand their duties and responsibilities before being authorised to act in such a position. I am glad to say that steps are being taken in this direction.

Something might also be done with a view to reducing the number of shots fired, and firing them between shifts or when the majority of the men are out of the mine.

At the same time I do not for a moment wish it to be inferred that there is not great danger from an ignition of firedamp alone. Many lives have been lost from this cause, and every precaution must be taken to keep the working places, returns and all parts of the mine free from an inflammable mixture of gas and air. This has been understood for many years, but what I want to point out is that an additional danger exists which has not been so well recognised, but which is a strong factor in the safe working of a colliery.

The text of the report from the Mines Inspector into this disaster is available in the Disaster Reports section of this website.

Source: 

, Page: 12



Fatalities



Individual page 

Ainsley, James, aged 20, Pumper, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Bainbridge, Thomas, aged 66, Examiner, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing

Individual page 

Bayliss, George, aged 58, Examiner, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Bentley, Lord, aged 66, Shifter, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Broomfield, George, aged 41, Shifter, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing

Individual page 

Dixon, John Guy, aged 62, Shifter, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Dunlavey, Patrick, aged 62, Mason's Labourer, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing

Individual page 

Elliot, Thomas Henry, aged 46, Shifter, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing

Individual page 

Farnworth, Nathaniel, aged 59, Shifter, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing

Individual page 

Gilchrist, Peter, aged 63, Shifter, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: St. Peter and St. Paul (Catholic) Burial Ground

Individual page 

Grafton, Joseph, aged 68, Shifter, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: St. Peter and St. Paul (Catholic) Burial Ground

Individual page 

Hardy, Edward, aged 63, Shifter, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: St. Paul's Churchyard, Trimdon Station

Individual page 

Harris, Alfred George, aged 50, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Hockaday, William, aged 51, Sinker, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

James, Isaac, aged 42, Mason, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Kay, Thomas, aged 51, Shifter, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Maddison, John Thomas, aged 24, Stoneman, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing

Individual page 

Mason, George, aged 60, Shifter, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, died 24th November, death attributed to the explosion

Individual page 

Mason, James, aged 49, Stoneman, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Metcalf, Thomas, aged 64, Shifter, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Morrison, James, aged 44, Shifter, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Station Town Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Pace, Henry, aged 46, Stoneman, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Pearce, James (died: 14 Feb 1907) , aged 45, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, died 14 Feb 1907 from injuries received in explosion, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Smith, George, aged 47, Chargeman, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Stockdale, Charles, aged 35, Sinker, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Holy Trinity Churchyard/Cemetery, Wingate

Individual page 

Studham, William, aged 54, Shifter, explosion of coal dust, the result of shot-firing, Buried: Pelton Cemetery

 
All names found
 
Youngest: 20 years old ; Oldest: 68 ; Average: 51
 

Those names marked with image, have a web page providing individual details of the accident, the page may also include a photograph of the deceased. Click on the image symbol next to the name to see the web page.


Memorial: 1906 Wingate Grange Colliery Disaster

Memorial Image Memorial Image Memorial Image Memorial Image Memorial Image Memorial Image Memorial Image Memorial Image Memorial Image Memorial Image Memorial Image Memorial Image Memorial Image Memorial Image Memorial Image


Poems

The Wingate Colliery Disaster
By Patrick Leavy

As the midnight hour approached fast,
From lip to lip the word was passed :
"The Pit has fired!" In grief and woe
The crowd go rushing to and fro,
With many a sad and aching heart,
Awakened by the dreadful start.
Around the fatal shaft they stand
And watch the brave, heroic band
Of volunteers prepare to go
In search of their dear ones below.
The mother, the wife, are standing there,
Offering to God an earnest prayer.
In anxious groups the children gather,
Hoping to catch a glimpse of father.
An exploring party descends the mine —
Their courage impossible to define;
In their hands their lives those heroes bear,
Yet show not the slightest sign of fear ;
Each determined to do the best he can ;
Viewer and hewer, master and man.
The same noble feelings each heart within,
The one common sorrow made all akin.
Alas! for human hopes and fears,
The worst has happened — grim death appears.
Ere long they gaze upon the face
Of their gallant comrade, Harry Pace,
Who unselfishly had tried to save
A comrade from an awful grave.
Dixon, Smith, and Studholm too,
Were soon presented to their view,
Dunlavey, Bentley, and Isaac James,
And many more familiar names.
Hardy, Bayliss, and George Broomfield
In that pit of death their lives did yield.
Mason, Farnworth, and Maddison,
For them also the sands of life had run.
Amongst those who subscribed the last roll on that fatal day
Were Stockdale, Ainsley, and Hockaday.
Gilchrist, Bainbridge, and Harris also
Were amongst those doomed to perish below.
Morrison, Kay, Metcalfe, and Grafton,
Cold in death at the Low Main Shaft, on
That fatal morn, were reverently laid
By the heroes of the rescue brigade.
Yes, heroes they were, every one.
Some lost a father, some a son.
Each knew he might he next to fall;
It mattered not ; for duty's call
Brought each sturdy miner to his post,
And each man in himself a host.
The one bright spot in this dark disaster
Is the splendid courage of man and master;
Their efforts exceed their fondest dreams.
All alive in the Hutton and Harvey Seams.
Though the task is arduous they never shirk,
But quickly get the ribble to work,
And, like the brave hearts they are, prepare to go
Into the very jaws of death below,
To bring those poor belated souls to bank
From that pit of death so foul and stank.
'Twas with joyous hearts that we did greet
McGonnel, Dawson, Cunliffe, and Peet ;
Those men had been given up for dead,
And for the repose of their souls prayers had been said.
Poor Tom Elliott has not yet been found —
His body is still underground :
May God comfort his wife in her heavy grief,
And to each poor sufferer send relief ;
And may He in His Wisdom teach us to master
And prevent a recurrence of this sad disaster.

On these sad occasions 'tis grand to see
The precept of Christian charity
Practised by every denomination.
Every effort to cope with the situation
Is practised by all in the hour of need —
Shoulder to shoulder is now their creed.
The priest and the parson, the doctor, the nurse,
Vie with each other the gloom to disperse.
When Time, "The Great Healer," brings balm to each sore,
And this terrible disaster's described as folk-lore
By our descendants, in some distant valley or glen,
They'll be proud that their forefathers were Durham Pitmen.


Newspaper Articles

16 Oct 1906  Colliery Disaster In Durham, Many Lives Lost (The Times)
17 Oct 1906  The Wingate Colliery Disaster (The Times)
18 Oct 1906  The Wingate Colliery Disaster (The Times)
19 Oct 1906  The Wingate Colliery Disaster (The Times)
30 Oct 1906  The King and the Wingate Disaster (The Times)
02 Nov 1906  The Wingate Colliery Explosion (The Times)
03 Nov 1906  The Wingate Colliery Disaster (The Times)
16 Mar 1907  The Wingate Grange Colliery Explosion (The Times)

Further Reading


Additional Links


Page The text of the report from the Mines Inspector into this disaster is available in the UK Disaster Reports section of this website.

 

Return Return   Return Return to Top

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 30 Apr 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print