Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mine & Quarry Engineering - Main Index
Mine & Quarry Engineering - Subject Index
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Title Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Title
 
 Mine & Quarry Engineering August, 1940 

III. Detailed magnetic survey near Red Hill farm
(with two magnetometers)

In view of the satisfactory result of the preliminary trial, it was decided to carry out a more detailed survey over similar ground, using a second instrument for base readings. For this purpose an area about 1,000 ft. square was chosen in the field north of Red Hill Farm (see Fig. 1), where the general geological structure had been proved by a number of bore-holes. A total of twelve working days was spent in magnetic surveying with only small interruption by the weather. Approximately 6,000 ft. of distance was surveyed in the traverses (omitting repetitions). This total belonged mainly to nine traverses across an ore-body which was indicated by the "highs" near the south-west side of the area. The profiles are shown in Fig. 8.

Method and instruments. — The Askania vertical field balance (G.S. 229), without any auxiliary magnet, was used as a base instrument. It was found that the balance could not be left released in the open because vibration due to the wind caused continual alteration in the readings. A base hut was therefore constructed and placed near the middle of the area. In it the magnetometer was mounted with the tripod feet upon three wooden pegs driven about 2 ft. into the soft ground. Within this shelter it was possible to keep the balance released for intervals of an hour or more without any apparent change in reading other than the diurnal variation.

Field readings were made with a Watts vertical field balance belonging to King's College, Newcastle. This was of recent pattern : the operation of the release proved much more satisfactory than with the early Askania balance (1927), and for this reason the latter was used at the base. Three readings only were taken at each station, with careful levelling, etc., as already described for the preliminary trial.

Both balances were adjusted to sensitivity 10 gamma per scale division. The three repeated readings of the Watts instrument rarely differed by more than one gamma, and the base instrument could be read with an accuracy of one gamma. To eliminate changes in the earth's field a whistle was sounded after the second reading of the traversing balance, so that a virtually simultaneous reading could be taken by the observer in the base hut. Except in times of severe magnetic disturbance, indicated by lack of equality of the three field readings concerned, the method seems to effect complete elimination of the variations in the earth's field. Comparison of adjacent observed values plotted along the profiles in Fig. 8 will show that the results were accurate to within ±2 gamma or even less on favourable ground. In long traverses there is risk of cumulative error due to temperature and other effects, but if every care is taken and the temperature does not vary rapidly it should be quite possible to obtain the above degree of accuracy with traverses lasting up to 1½ hours.

Temperature correction has probably been the greatest outstanding source of uncertainty in using these magnetic instruments. By repeating observations with rising or falling temperature, e.g. on return to base after a traverse, it is possible to ascertain directly the temperature coefficient of the whole apparatus of survey, including of course both instruments and the auxiliary magnet if used. There were several periods during which the base reading remained constant while changes of two or three degrees took place in the temperature, and from these it became clear that the Askania balance as then adjusted had a relatively small temperature coefficient, and that temperature effects were apparently attributable chiefly to the Watts balance and its auxiliary magnet. Comparison of the results in the present work indicated a coefficient of 4 gamma per degree, the reading increasing with temperature. This was perhaps rather too high; in a subsequent research a value of 2 gamma was obtained, but it must not be assumed that the coefficient had remained constant. It is also generally understood that substantial error occurs if the temperature varies too quickly, and changes exceeding one degree in ten minutes may evidently cause appreciable errors, both through lag between the suspended magnet system and the enclosure, and through convection currents.

Geology. — The area represented in the sketch-map (Fig. 1) is mainly a stretch of level ground at about 15-20 ft. OD. Towards the west near bore-holes 102 and 103 the level rises to over 50 ft. O.D., and Red Hill Farm stands on a little knoll at about 30 ft. O.D. The two fields surveyed, during the preliminary and more detailed work, are fairly level, and the northerly is intersected by a winding system of small water-courses, the channels of which were filled at the time of the survey with flood water, in places to a width of 100 ft.

The geological structure is fairly well known from numerous borings, and, south of the farm road, from mine workings. Red Hill is shown on the geological maps, One-inch O.S. Sheet 48 and Six-inch Cumberland Sheet 90 N.E., but the detailed presentation of the geology will be revised considerably in the new editions now being prepared by W, C. C. Rose. A general sketch-map of the Hodbarrow area has been published (Smith 1919, p1. ii). Red Hill Farm is situated near the mark 10 on this map at about mile S. of Millom. A north-west fault reaching the coast near Towsey Hole is that over which the preliminary traverses were made. Boundaries assigned to the limestone against the Basement Beds are largely conjectural owing to boulder clay cover, and the limestone is now known to extend some distance to the north-east of the farm road (cf. Fig. 1), beyond the limit given in the maps above mentioned.

Borings in the field north of Red Hill Farm showed up to 50 ft. of boulder clay, followed by about 100 to 150 ft. of limestone resting upon Basement Beds. This structure is quite similar to that described with sections for the preliminary traverses south of the farm. The dip is small, and small faults may be expected parallel to the ore-bearing fault south of the farm. Outside the area actually surveyed, to the north-west and east, boreholes 87 and 131 indicated that the limestone was missing, for a thickness of over 100 ft. of boulder clay rested directly upon the Basement Beds. Thus the sub-drift surface contains channels along which the limestone has been completely eroded.

Geophysical tests. — E. Lancaster-Jones (1930) has published a detailed survey of the present area by the electric resistivity method. Contoured maps are given for electrode spacings of 40 and 120 ft., and his Fig. 8 shows the relation of the conductivity to a contoured map of the sub-drift surface derived from bore-holes. The conductivity is mainly due to the boulder clay, and the contours are accordingly related to the depth of the sub-drift surface. As regards the ore-bodies, on the other hand, "there is little evidence that the haematite occurrences can be located by this method. Any fluctuations which might arise . . are practically completely obscured by the more pronounced variations arising from the undulations in the sub-drift surface. . . ." Even if a small effect were found to be superimposed upon that due to the cover of boulder clay, it is evident that in relative speed and precision the magnetic indications would be preferable.

Ore-bodies. — The area south of the farm road (see Section II of this paper) had been fully explored in mining operations, which proved the large ore-body shown in plan along a north-west fault in Fig. 1. A small vein branching diagonally eastwards across the farm road, and another small north-west vein actually beneath the farm, had also been proved and partly mined. As regards the field north of the farm, however, the only available information apart from boreholes was that small veins, the largest about 11 ft. thick, had been encountered in a drift which practically followed the line of traverse F, north-eastwards from the known ore-body. Several of the boreholes encountered a few feet of ore, but it is very difficult to gauge the importance of such indications ; indeed, as will be seen later, the magnetic survey revealed a large ore-body which had been indicated by a relatively small thickness in borehole 99 (cf. G, Fig. 8).

Magnetic survey. — The detailed magnetic survey was confined to the approximate square outlined on the northeast side of the farm road in Fig. l. The chief lines of traverse were parallel at intervals of 150 ft., with intermediate traverses I and K at 75 ft. ; in addition, three traverses M, N and 0 were made in the north of the area, beyond the water-course, but were incomplete on account of the wide extent of flooded ground. The corresponding vertical force profiles are given in Fig. 8 (traverses D-G were made without complete temperature correction, and may not have the same accuracy as later ones). The profiles exhibit three main features (1) a general level extending over the eastern part of the area, well shown in profile L; (2) a very pronounced anomaly of ridge-like form with its crest roughly parallel with, and about 200 ft. distant from, the farm road ; (3) several small "highs" toward the north corner of the area, which may be disposed of at this juncture. They occur near 500 ft. in F, 600-700 ft. in G, 275 ft. in M, throughout N and near 90 ft. in O. They probably correspond with small veins related to a conjectural north-west fault which is indicated with a ? in Fig. l. Complete survey of the area concerned was impossible on account of wide flooding. This ground is probably ore-bearing, and seems in contrast with that represented by the level north-east portions of traverses J and L.

Values marked with crosses at about 100 ft. in profiles D-L were readings in a cross-traverse taken for the purpose of linking the traverses to a common base value.

Interpretation. — The recorded magnetic anomaly over a given area is, of course, the sum of effects due (a) to quite local causes, such as iron objects in the soil or magnetic boulders in the drift ; (b) to distant geological structures, e.g. igneous rocks or magnetic sediments not within the field to he investigated, but sufficiently near, either laterally or in depth, to produce a measurable effect in the area under survey; (c) to near-by magnetic rock-masses, among which would be classed the cover (considered as a whole), the ore-body to be sought for, and the country rock within the region under investigation.

Before the magnetic survey can be interpreted in terms of (c), i.e. taken as evidence for the presence of an ore-body or rock-mass within the region investigated, allowance must be made for effects due to (a) or (b).

(a) Superficial buried objects. Only a large or very magnetic boulder would produce a measurable effect from, say, 30 ft. deep, and in the present ground such boulders are rare or completely absent. Any disturbance from superficial objects will therefore originate in the immediate surface layer ; it will thus be limited in lateral extent to a radius comparable with the depth and is unlikely to affect more than two stations if these are, say, 20 ft. apart. Smaller boulders, or cobbles, are common here in the boulder clay, and there will be always the risk of an error of perhaps one or two gamma if the instrument happens to be directly above a concealed boulder. For this reason it is very strongly recommended that the full height of tripod should be used. In windy weather the tripod is steadier when half extended, but the error caused by an object at ground-level may easily be about four times as great.

Precautions as to buried iron objects demand constant attention. A cast horse-shoe on the ground under the instrument gave an anomaly of about 3 gamma. Iron pipes are sometimes buried and forgotten, e.g. the sharp variation at the beginning of traverses G and H. is probably due to some such object. A known pipe-line crosses the area northwards from the farm (see Fig. 1) and the disturbance due to this was evident for about 40 ft. on either side in the traverses that crossed the pipe obliquely (cf. H and L, Fig. 8).

The effect of iron objects is largely due to permanent magnetization and cannot be accurately forecast. Different sections in a pipe-line may have quite different effects, though there is, of course, a limit to the possible value for a given size. With iron, also, even if permanent magnetisation is subordinate to that induced by the earth's field, the effect is dependent upon orientation. A long iron rod tends to concentrate the lines of force and becomes more strongly magnetised when vertical than when pointing east and west.

Turning to the effects of this class in the present area, it will be seen (cf. Fig. 8) that small irregular differences, of the order of 2-4 gamma, are frequently present between neighbouring stations. In a few cases repeated readings were taken and the reality of the differences was established. These are beyond the error of observation, which may be as small as ±1 gamma between successive stations; they are entirely local and are no doubt due to small superficial objects of the types described. Their presence sets a limit to the accuracy that can be usefully aimed at in the present work; even if the instruments had been capable of ±0.1 gamma accuracy, many irregularities in the curves would still have been almost as much in evidence. In areas of another type, of course, higher accuracy might be advantageous.

By drawing a smoothed curve through the plotted values it is possible to obtain the general form of the anomaly due to deeper structures; but with the smoothing there will have been sacrificed a few of the smallest and most superficial of the effects due to iron ore in the surface of the limestone, where this is under perhaps 30 ft., or less locally, of boulder clay. Close surveying might reveal that these irregularities possessed the elongated ridgelike form associated with veins, but such veins must be relatively small. No doubt some of the larger peaks of this kind such as those near 400 ft. in profiles I and J might be worth further investigation.

(b) Effect of rock masses outside the region. Sub-Carboniferous rocks were proved in borehole 87, which stopped in Coniston Limestone (?) at 615 ft. (Smith 1919, p. 123). Thus sedimentary rocks extend down to at least 615 ft., and there is no reason to expect any magnetic mass to be present for a depth several times that of the orebearing limestone. Beneath the sediments there will at some level be older rocks, which might well be magnetic and would then give rise to an anomaly; but this would be far blunter in form than that due to a near-by ore-body. A very well-marked anomaly of this kind occurs in the Melton Mowbray district (Hallimond 1930 a). Experience in the various areas surveyed in Great Britain shows that in districts with a good thickness of sedimentary rocks there are places where the magnetic difference across 1,000 ft. reaches 50 gamma, but smaller values are far more usual.

Whatever may be the form of the deep-seated effect, it must be deducted from the observed anomaly before an interpretation can be given. If it is not known by direct evidence of borings, etc., that there are no underlying magnetic rocks, the evidence must be sought in the magnetic survey itself. Great uncertainty may arise if the whole of the area is occupied by magnetic irregularities, and an essential feature in any survey is the examination of parts of the area as free as possible from ore-bodies, in order to verify the form that the magnetic surface would have if the ore-bodies under examination were absent.

Wide areas of level or slightly changing force afford good evidence of the absence of local anomalies, for it is most improbable that they could result from mutual compensation between local ore-bodies. Very fortunately such an area is available within the present survey. As already remarked, profile L, nearest to Red Hill Farm, is substantially level (at 20 gamma) along the north-east part of its course, and may be taken as representative of the base surface in the absence of important ore-bodies. This is confirmed, in the direction at right angles, by the level values at the corresponding end of the other traverses: small local effects are present but the general level falls only slightly from 20 gamma to about 14 gamma in the extreme north.

(c) Disturbance from neighbouring rock-masses. The only near-by magnetic material known was the closely adjacent ore-body south of the farm road. This will almost certainly modify the observed profiles at the south-west end, but the effect, presumably negative, will probably not be very large or very steep (cf. Fig. 6). It is permissible, therefore, to assume that the base surface is practically level at from 14-20 gamma and that the observed anomalies can be assigned to local ore-bodies without correction other than allowance for a slight northward fall in intensity.

Cause of the main anomaly. — The profiles shown in Fig. 8 indicate a fairly uniform feature with north-west strike. This is almost exactly parallel with the anomaly found in the preliminary test upon the known ore-body south of the farm, and in view of the similar geological structure it seems reasonable to suppose that the present feature is due to a similar vein. This conclusion is fully supported by the special form of the profiles. In profiles H, I, J, the main anomaly shows a very close correspondence in width, height and slope with those for the trail traverses (Figs. 2 to 5). It would therefore indicate an ore-body, about 60 ft. in horizontal thickness, and 100 ft. in vertical depth, dipping SW. and having a concealed outcrop in the limestone surface along a line roughly parallel with the road but at a distance increasing from 200 ft. in traverse F to 300 ft. in traverse J.

This is considerably greater than the ore indicated in the level near traverse F or in the borehole 99. It is therefore of special interest to note that a level driven from the crosscut for a few yards along the vein toward Red Hill Farm, between traverses F and G, entered an ore-body extending to over 50 ft. in cross-section and of considerable depth.

Drawings and Photographs accompanying the article

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

Article reproduced from a copy of the magazine held at National Mining Museum Scotland, Newtongrange, Midlothian.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 17 Jan 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print