1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
West Stanley Inquest, Third Day, Saturday, 27th May, 1882 (cont.).
Summing Up.
(The Coroner.) Gentlemen of the Jury, — It is now my province to address a few observations to you, and by way of preface I think I may say that, although in its results this unfortunate explosion, this sad calamity which has befallen this neighbourhood, has not been so extensive, and therefore might not be considered quite so serious in itself as other explosions which have unfortunately occurred in the County of Durham lately, still, so far as relates to its effects in individual instances, I do not think that number has much to do with it. The misfortune of losing one life in a particular family is very great, and it is simply augmented, in particular instances, by large numbers having lost their lives. But in this particular instance the present inquiry, I think, is of special interest in the locality in which we are now sitting from the fact that the explosion has taken place in the Busty seam, a seam which is very extensively worked for some distance in this neighbourhood, and for some distance round about, and probably the information that has been collected during the course of this inquiry may be of some service in view, if possible, of lessening the chance of any similar occurrence, from whatever cause you may find it to have arisen.
With a view to assisting you in arriving at your verdict, not in any way with the slightest intention of indicating the sort of verdict you should return, I thought it well to put several questions to the jury, which I have drawn up, amounting, I think, to half-a-dozen. Some will be of a simple character, others, I am afraid, will present more or less difficulty to you.
Now, gentlemen, as a matter of course, you are familiar, from having unfortunately had to attend on inquests on previous occasions, with the nature of the questions which arise, and the first thing to ascertain is the cause of death, and that has been done by the medical evidence ; and therefore you are relieved from that. In each case, whether the result be asphyxia from after-damp or from burning, or, as in the case of Coulson, from being blown into the sump, or the poor lad, Clarke, from shock, or whatever it might be, still they all relate back to the original cause, namely, explosion. However, the first thing will necessarily be in each case to state the cause of death, and that you will have, as I said before, from the medical evidence, and there will be no difficulty about that. You will find that all the deaths took place on the 19th of April in the Busty seam of the West Stanley Colliery, and that the men whose lives were unfortunately lost, were at the time employed in the service of the colliery owners.
The first batch of questions which I shall have to submit to you, although involving two or three details, will nevertheless really be only one question, namely, "Was the Busty seam in safe working order when the deceased men were allowed to go down on the 18th of April?" When I say "in safe working order," I mean with reference to ventilation, timbering, gas, staff of officials, lamps, and all the other requisites with which you are so familiar, and respecting which abundant evidence has been given in the course of the inquiry, to enable you to form a correct judgement from that question.
The third question, certainly, I am afraid is one which will give you some amount of trouble, but I am certain from what I know of you, from the patient manner in which you have listened to the inquiry so far, and the intelligent questions you have addressed from time to time to the witnesses, that you will give the third question the attention that its importance requires. Really that question touches that crucial point in the case, and in dealing with it you will have to consider the theories propounded by both sides, namely, by the owners on the one hand, and the representatives of the men on the other. The third question is to ascertain, if you can on consideration of the evidence, the place or places where the explosion or explosions took place. If it so happened that there was more than one, you have no evidence of a second explosion, and there being no survivors who were present at the time, you must be guided by the evidence, and therefore with regard to that question, you must consider it irrespectively of whether a second explosion took place or not. And then comes another very important question, and that is to fix the locality where the explosion occurred. That is the first step, you must proceed by gradations.
The fourth question is, "How was the explosion, or how were the explosions caused?" In dealing with that question, you will also bear in mind the theories I have just referred to, because, if you establish the place you will probably have no difficulty in applying the theory ; but I shall not indicate in any way how you will deal with that. I leave it entirely to you.
Then, having settled those points, if you can, the fifth question will be, "Who, if any one is, or are, and in what respect, culpable"? If you think that the explosion or explosions could have been prevented in any way by the exercise of any amount of care or supervision, thought or skill, knowledge or experience, on the part of any persons in a position to exercise all those requisites you are bound to do so for the safety of the men. It will be for you to say fearlessly whom you think is responsible, and in what way, if anybody.
With regard to the sixth question, assuming you are unable to answer the fifth question satisfactorily (and you have arrived at the third and fourth, which do not deal with the fifth), you must consider whether the explosion or explosions were entirely the result of some accident beyond human control, I confess I am on e who has a very strong feeling about accidents. I class them in two ways. I consider there are preventable occurrences which might be called accidents, although I do not consider them so ; and there are accidents which arise from some cause entirely beyond human control, and if you should find that to be so in this case, then, as a matter of course, no one can be held responsible.
Now, gentlemen, if after having fully considered all these questions and applied to them your recollection of the evidence and the conclusions that are to be drawn from the facts, because you have two classes of evidence, you have evidence of facts and you have evidence of opinions or conclusions drawn from those facts, and with regard to the latter you are just as capable of drawing conclusions as any of the witnesses who have been called before you. Facts you are bound by but conclusions you are not. I say it, after having thoroughly considered all these questions, you are able to reply definitely to questions 3, 4, 5, and 6, and are placed in such a position of difficulty that you feel you cannot determine either the place or places where the explosion has taken place, or how caused, or who is responsible, or whether it is the result of accident beyond human control, then you are not expected to perform impossibilities. You are not to remain locked up for an absurdly long time. I shall deem it my duty, if you do not agree, to keep you locked up at all events for a reasonable period, and I am sure you will not grudge being locked up for that time, because this is an inquiry that should be made as exhaustive as possible, and it certainly would not be satisfactory if you came to a conclusion on the seventh question until you had exhausted every possible opportunity in your power and every argument that you may individually be able to advance in support of your opinions, so as to arrive at a correct conclusion with regard to the causes of the explosion. If, however, you are utterly unable to do so you may then take refuge in the seventh question, which is this ; that is to say if you are unable to reply definitely to the questions I have referred to, either through the evidence being too conflicting for you, or in consequence of its being insufficient in material parts, you may then find that you are able to say how the explosion was caused, and in what part of the Busty seam it originated. I hope, gentlemen, that may not be the case and that you will be in such a position as to tell me on your return that you have based your verdict upon one or other of the questions which I have advanced previously to the seventh.
Those, gentlemen, are the questions which I shall put before you, and I thought it better to indicate those questions first, before I had anything further to say about the questions, so that you might have those questions in your mind. But, as a matter of course, in considering the third and fourth questions, that is to say, the place or places where the explosion or explosions took place and originated, you must give the greatest consideration and attention to what has been advanced by both sides. You know as well as I do what their theories are, and lest there be any mistake at all about it, I may just for an instant refer to what the theories that have been advanced are. On the part of the owners the explosion is stated to have taken place in Middlemas' and McCabe's place. I avoid using technicalities for two reasons : first, because I do not wish to flounder myself ; and secondly, I do not wish to bother you with them. That is what is stated on the part of the owners, and the way in which they indicated the theory advanced by their various witnesses with reference to the way in which the explosion took place you remember perfectly well. On the other hand, it is contended that the explosion took place in Douglas' place, or rather that the shot had fired the gas. Those, gentlemen, as you know, are the two theories and the two matters upon which all the evidence has been led, excepting so much as we have had lately about the gas at other times, respecting which I will not trouble you at present ; but the evidence has been all led to those two points. You can dismiss from your minds entirely anything that might have taken place in other parts of the pit, excepting that you will naturally, of course, include in your verdict the deaths that have taken place in consequence of the explosion that has spread nearly all over the pit ; not quite, but which reached to nearly all over the pit, whether commencing at Middlemas' and McCabe's place or at Douglas', or both. The evidence that has been given, you will bear in mind, has been put before you in a sort of way almost to indicate the questions I have put.
In the first place, gentlemen, you will remember that the evidence given to you was to show the condition of the mine on the occasion when these poor men went down to their work. That evidence has all been given at very considerable length. Mr. Johnson the manager, Nicholson the shifter, Pickersgill the hewer, Mossom the deputy overman, Knox, and various others, all the staff, I may say excepting the poor men who have been unfortunately killed, have all been called before you, and you have had placed in proper order an exact account of the condition of the mine. I apprehend you do not require me to go through it because you will have borne it in your minds, no doubt accurately enough. That, gentlemen, is so far as relates to the first question.
Now with regard to the third question, namely, the place or places where the explosion is said to have taken place, you have had opinions given by several gentlemen and very confidently given too, on the one side and as confidently on the other. Mr. Johnson the manager gives his opinion after describing his indications, and so do the others who followed. You have had Mr. Fairlie, who was examined at considerable length, and who gave indications and also his opinion. You have also had Mr. Rutherford, Mr. Colquhoun, Mr. George Baker Forrester, Mr. Hedley, and Mr. Charles Davison. They certainly constitute a very large number of gentlemen who have been called before you, and they all concur, both in relation to the indications and the results. Mr. Davison's evidence is of a most important character. If you judge the value of his evidence by the admission that was made by Mr. Thompson I think you can come to only one conclusion. A question was put to him, and certainly it was a very cogent question : "If the cracket and the pick were put on the stones in Douglas' place by the men who had been working there the explosion could not have occurred there"? To which he demurred, he evidently did not believe that it was so, and although he would not say in the face of the sworn evidence that the cracket and the pick had been placed their afterwards still that was the inference to be drawn from his manner. Gentlemen, that has set up a very important issue indeed. Upon that really seems to me to hang the whole case. You may take a different view of it possibly, but I cannot help noticing that upon that really does hang the whole case. It is a question and a very important question for you to determine, considering the evidence, whether the cracket and whether the pick were there as stated by Mr. Davison, who is said to have been the first who entered the pit, and if so then, as a matter of course, I do not see how you can do other than adopt what Thompson says ; or you must find that someone has been wicked enough to put those articles there deliberately for the purpose of deceiving Mr. Davison or anybody else that might go in, and of influencing the verdict that might be returned when the inquiry took place. Gentlemen, human nature may be very depraved, but I can hardly conceive any man being so desperately wicked and base, as at the moment when a place is first examined, whilst dead bodies are lying in the vicinity, and others still in the pit and not removed, when the search is being made for bodies to try to save the men if any life remains, I say I can hardly conceive any person being sufficiently fiendish to do such a diabolical act as that ; but at the same time it is not for me to say. If you think that that was the case, well then away goes, that part of the evidence entirely, and if the pick and cracket had been put there afterwards, then you are still not relieved from difficulty. You still have to consider whether or not the explosion took place in Middlemas' and McCabe's place or in Douglas'. But still it is a very extraordinary fact. When such a question arises, as in this instance it has certainly, it is very desirable that a witness should be supported by further evidence if it is obtainable. But, gentlemen, you see there is that one witness who is there first, and that witness is Mr. Davison, and upon Mr. Davison you must either rely, or you must dismiss him from your notice ; everybody else who goes in afterwards is second hand.
Gentlemen, I think I have now referred to all the witnesses who have been called on behalf of the owners in support of their theory, but if you wish I should be very glad to read any part of the evidence that has been called for the owners.
(The Foreman of the Jury.) That is not necessary.
(The Coroner.) Then, gentlemen, on the other hand you have some very important evidence given by the witnesses who have been called by Mr. Bowey, William Indian, the check weighman, and John Thompson, the hewer. I am speaking rather from recollection, but were there any other witnesses, Mr. Heaviside, excepting William Indian and John Thompson who spoke to indications, and who expressed their opinions?
(Mr. Heaviside.) No, I think not.
(The Coroner.) Those, gentlemen, then, are the two witnesses who were called by Mr. Bowey, and they have given their evidence with regard to the indications which they found, and their conclusions drawn from those indications. You, gentlemen, are bound to give to the evidence of those two witnesses as much consideration as you will give to the evidence of the numerous witnesses that have been called on the opposite side. If witnesses are telling the truth force does not consist in numbers but reliability. You are quite able to judge between the two, totally irrespective of number. At the same time you are bound in a case of this kind to disbelieve either one set of witnesses or the other. You take the facts that they state according to their observation ; men differ according to their ability to observe, and according to the care with which they do happen to notice ; one man will see what another does not notice, so that if there are are any differences between them they are quite capable, probably, of being reconciled in that way. So far as their relative opinions are concerned one man is just as much entitled to his opinion as another, but it is for you to say which opinion you think coincides best with the evidence of facts. Now, gentlemen, if you desire it I will read Indian's evidence and Thompson's or either of them.
(The Foreman of the Jury.) No, it is not necessary.
(The Coroner.) Very well. Then with respect to the other evidence that has been tendered with regard to gas in the pit on former occasions and so on, I do not think that bears very closely upon this inquiry unless it be to indicate that it is a pit in which gas may be expected to be found ; but on the other hand we have been told that there are very few pits in which gas cannot be found, and it is for you, gentlemen, to consider, having heard the evidence, whether you think that the gas, which has been referred to by the additional witnesses who have been called, amounts to anything of a serious character or not, or whether it is more a matter for the gentlemen on my right, Her Majesty's Inspectors of Mines, who no doubt will take their own course as to whether a colliery is what is called a fiery mine or not. That is a matter entirely for them, and there is no reason, I think, why it should be interposed here, and therefore, in order to save your time, it being a question about which there is considerable difference of opinion with regard to what constitutes a fiery mine and what does not, I thought it better that you should not be troubled with it. So much for that. It is sufficient for you, there having been an explosion, to ascertain the cause of it.
Gentlemen, I think I have now referred to nearly every point which has occurred to me that is likely to assist you in coming to your verdict ; but there is just one concluding observation I would like to make to you, and it is this : You as Jurors, and myself as Coroner, had a very painful task to perform on the first occasion we met. I do not know anything that had affected me more than having to go with you from house to house to witness the sad scenes that were presented to us, one after another. Homes, which up to the time of our visit had been abodes of comfort and occupied by respectable and useful men, are suddenly rendered desolate, and the bread winners gone. Well, now, I am supposed to be rather hardened from the nature of my duties ; I have to see death in its various forms and notice affliction which necessarily results from it, but it cannot be helped. So long as the law remains as it is, requiring bodies to be viewed, it is necessary that you and I should go from house to house to witness those scenes which we observed. As I have taken an opportunity on previous occasions to observe, I hope to live long enough to see that law altered some day or other. It very nearly arrived at that pass a few years ago, and an opportunity may be afforded again when that much desired change will take place, but I refer to it now for this reason : that if I, a stranger, and as I said before, I might be supposed to be somewhat hardened, could not resist being affected, what must have been the state of your feelings, when you are visiting from house to house looking at the dead bodies of men who in life you probably were in the habit of meeting almost daily. They were living in your same village and were probably more or less on terms of intimacy with you, or at all events, you were acquainted with them. Now you are placed in a very difficult position. Human nature is very weak. Sympathy and sentiment are very apt to get the better of judgement, but I have great confidence in you. I have not met you for the first time today. I believe that the interests of justice are perfectly safe in your hands, and that whatever verdict you give will be satisfactory to both sides, although you cannot reconcile both theories, but it will be satisfactory in this sense, that both sides will know that you have brought to bear upon an inquiry, such as this is, at your own doorstead almost, unprejudiced minds, and that you will not be actuated by sympathy or sentiment to the prejudice of justice, and that you will neither on the one hand give way to your feelings of sympathy, nor on the other hand to resentment, if any such exists. I am not at all aware that it does. I hope at all events, that it does not. There are conflicting interests. On the one hand, the relatives of the poor men deceased ; on the other, the owners, whose interests are pecuniary ; but at the same time serious ; and there is a third class of interests, namely, the interests of the manager and his officials who are responsible to you in the first instance, and to the owners afterwards, but you have nothing to do with the interests of either the one or the other ; and I am sure you will not let any feeling, either one way or the other, influence you in recording your verdict. You will only consider the evidence which has been laid before you, and the conclusions that have been drawn from it, you will of course consider as you think best, and return an honest and true verdict ; and now just one word before dismissing you. On this occasion, you as well as myself, have been most ably assisted. Formerly we felt somewhat in a difficulty, because we have had to get to the facts as best we could, and we have had to get the evidence as best we could, and without being assisted in any way, except of course by the valuable assistance of Her Majesty's Inspectors of Mines attending these inquiries ; but to-day we have had eminent counsel for the owners, who has examined his witnesses in such a way as to require very little care from me, for, as you observed, I asked very few questions, and we have also had an able and experienced member of my own branch of the profession acting on behalf of the other side, the friends of the deceased, and he has discharged his duty in such a way as also to relieve me very considerably, and yourselves too, of the difficulty we have also felt ; but above all, on this occasion, we have been further assisted by Mr. Arnold Morley, attending here under the direction of the Home Secretary. Mr. Arnold Morley is not only a member of Parliament, but a member of the Bar, and a gentleman of considerable experience, to whom I am under very great obligations for the kind assistance and countenance he has afforded me. I feel certain that the responsibility that has devolved upon my shoulders has been shared, and in fact I may say I have been relieved from it, and in relieving me you also have been relieved. Then, gentlemen, the Inspectors of Mines, I am glad to say, have attended here in considerable force, Mr. Bell, Mr. Willis, and Mr. Atkinson being present. What further help or what more able assistance could have been afforded I am perfectly at a loss to know. The inquiry, as I have before said, is an exhaustive one. I have remarked at considerable length upon it to you because I think that its importance and the interests which are concerned require it ; and now, gentlemen, I dismiss you to consider your verdict, and when you have been able to answer all or as many as you can of the questions that I have submitted to you, I shall be glad to know, so that your verdict may be recorded.
The Jury retired to consider their verdict at 4.5, and returned into Court at 5.5, and the Foreman handed a paper to the Coroner.
(The Coroner.) — Gentlemen, do you find your verdict as stated in this paper.
(The Foreman of the Jury.) — Yes.
(The Coroner.) — Then the verdict of the jury is this : "Cause of death in each case as stated by Dr. Benson." The answer to the second question, "Was the Busty seam in safe working order when the deceased men were allowed to go down on the 18th of April," is as follows : "We consider by the evidence given that it was in proper working order." With regard to the third question, "The place or places where the explosion or explosions took place," the finding of the jury is, "McCabe's place." The fourth question, "How caused," finding, "Supposed by quick movement of lamp." The fifth question, "Who if any, is or are, and in what respect, culpable," finding, "No-one." Then the verdict amounts to one of accidental death, as no one is responsible.