1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
West Stanley Inquest, Third Day, Saturday, 27th May, 1882 (cont.).
John Thompson sworn, examined by Mr. Bowey.
You are a hewer at West Stanley pit? — Yes.
Did you go down the mine about half-past 8 or 9 o'clock on the 19th of April, the day of the explosion? — Yes, I did.
Upon the morning of the explosion? — Yes.
Did you go into the South Crosscut? — Yes.
Whom were you with? — Mr. Johnson was in, and the deputies were in renewing the stoppings.
Was there no one with you? — No. Mr. Indian was in, but he was in the south district.
Who went through the South Crosscut with you? — I did not get very far up the South Crosscut.
How far did you get? — I got up to the second Stenton.
Of the fore South Crosscut? — Yes.
Did you go into the east-going board where Middlemas' and McCabe's place is? — Not on that particular date.
Did you go afterwards? — Yes, on the 26th of April.
On the 26th of April you went into the east-going board? — Yes.
Who was with you? — Mr. Bell, Mr. Johnson, Mr. Colquhoun, Mr. Indian, and Mr. Crawford.
Did you notice the overcast and the air crossing in the North Headways? — Yes.
Were there any bricks blown there? — Yes.
In what directions were they blown? — They were blown north and south.
Were they blown either east or west? — We could not see at that particular time without getting into the return.
Did you afterwards see that they were blown into the return, either east or west? — They were blown in both directions.
Then they were blown both north, south, east, and west? — Yes.
You heard Indian give his evidence yesterday, I think? — I was not here at the time, I was away with the lamps.
What indications did you find going into the North Crosscut? — The indication that I found going into the North Crosscut was that she had travelled north.
What were the indications? — There was a small door that was lying on the out-by side of the air crossing before the explosion, blown between 20 and 30 yards on the in-by side of the air crossing after the explosion.
That is to the north? — Yes.
Do you know where that door had been before the explosion? — Yes.
Do you understand the plan? — Yes.
There is the crossing, and this is the North Crosscut up here (pointing them out)? — Yes, I understand you ; I was lying by the out-by side, lying upon the canch. The bottom had been taken out.
Where was it before the explosion? — That is what I am pointing to now, it was lying upon this canch by the wall side, at the out-by side of the air crossing, unused and loose before the explosion.
Which side of the road as you were going north? — On the west side.
Are you quite sure about that? — Yes.
When had you seen that before the explosion? — Several times in going to work.
What was the last time you had seen it before the explosion? — I could not exactly say to a day or two, but I generally saw it in passing and repassing to my work.
What district were you working in? — I was working in the east district, or the south side of the east-going board.
And you had to pass it as you went to your work? — Yes.
You must have seen it, I suppose, within a day or two of the explosion? — Yes.
What other indications were there north of the crossing? — The timber that was in, according to my opinion, was blown north. There was very little timber, but what there was indicated that she had travelled north at that point.
And then when you went up to the junction to go along to the east-going board what indications were there? — There was the indication of burning on the roof.
At which spot? — The out-by side of the flat.
Was there anything to show in which way the blast had come? — Nothing particular.
Was there anything to show when you got down to the flat? — There was one tub broken, and the top was off it.
Was the top on the out-by side or the in-by side? — Just on the out-by side, just as if it had been tumbled off the top of the tram.
Did you notice the door on the in-by side of the flat? — Yes.
What was there there to show any indication? — The door was gone, and the remains of the door in my opinion, or the bands belonging to the door, were found at the in-by side of this fall (pointing to the diagram). There was a fall at the in-by side of the door, and at the in-by side of the door we looked back, and there was one band found beneath the stones and another lying on the top.
Do you know that the bands were the bands from that door? — Yes, in my opinion they were. I went through the doorway every day.
Was there any whole door standing? — There was one lying at the out-by side of the flat unused, loose.
Might not those bands have belonged to that door? — I think not.
Why not? — I think this band that was found on the batten and the door where the door stood are a portion of the door that had been lying loose at the out-by side of the flat.
And had been blown in? — Yes.
From the door what further indications, going inwards, did you see? — The indications were on the props, charring on the props as if she had travelled east.
On which side was the charring? — On the west side of the prop.
Did you go into McCabe's place? — I did not get into the face. I went about half way down the pillars, and she was rather uneasy, and I thought it would be unsafe to go in at that time.
Did you go north of McCabe's place? — Yes.
What did you find north of McCabe's place? — The general appearance of the charring was that she had travelled north from that point.
Did you go down south of McCabe's place? — Yes.
What was the first indication you saw going down south of McCabe's place? — The first indication was that props had been blown out and the canvas doors blown down south of McCabe's place.
On which side was the timber charred? — The timber was charred on the south side of the prop.
Now when you were in the Fore Crosscut after the time when you only went a pillar or two along? — On the 26th.
You were in the company of Mr. Bell on that occasion? — Yes, and Mr. Johnson.
What were the indications which you saw there between the main intake and the first pillar of the Fore Crosscut? — The indication there that was to be seen was out-by over up to the first pillar.
What were the indications from the first pillar up to the face? — In-over.
Were you in the Back Crosscut? — Yes.
What did you find in the Back Crosscut, commencing at the face? — There was not a great deal to observe in the face ; but after you left the face there was the charring of the props, as if she had travelled out-by.
On which side were the props charred? — On the south side.
Did you see any tubs there? — Yes.
Where was the first tub that you saw? — It was standing in the Back Crosscut. This is the face and the tub was up here (pointing to the diagram).
How was it blown? — It was blown partly across the way in an angular direction.
Which way, north, south, east, or west? — The end that was blown round was the south end of the tub blown to the right.
What further indications did you find? — At that particular period we went out there (pointing to the diagram), and came back over again to join Mr. Bell and the others, and we followed them.
Have you been in the Back Crosscut since? — Yes.
Did you continue further than you had been before? — Yes.
What was the indication that you found further on? — The indications were out over till you come to the going Stenton.
Which is the going Stenton? — This is from the Fore Crosscut (pointing to the diagram).
Did you see a tub at the next board further out? — On the west.
What position was it in? — It was blown beneath the band.
Blown in what direction? — It was blown to the west.
How was the timber from there to the main in-take from the second tub which you found? — Out-over.
In what way? — as if she had travelled north.
Burnt on which side? — The charring was on the south side of the props, and those that were blown out were blown as if they had been blown to the north.
What opinion have you formed with regard to the explosion as to where it originated? — My opinion is that it originated in the Back Crosscut at this shot (pointing to the diagram).
You have heard that the cracket and the pick were found upon the stone? — Yes, I have heard it.
Could that be if the explosion had occurred from that shot? — According to the appearance of the cracket and the pick, they being found there, if they had been put there by the men working there, we assume that it would not occur there, but it is a question with me whether they were put there by the men that were working there or not.
Now, how do you account for the indications in the Fore Crosscut from the first pillar to the face being in-by, if the explosion had occurred in the Back Crosscut south? — It comes along the going Stenton out of the Back Crosscut, and takes up into the face and meets the men.
Why should she do that? — I cannot give any reason why she should do it.
You still consider, although you cannot give a reason for it, that the explosion did not occur in the east-going board? — Yes, that is my opinion that it did not occur there.
Which of the indications that you saw in the east-going board were against the theory of the explosion having occurred there? — I examined the whole of the flat connected with the east-going board if you come back four walls to the south of that point.
Which point? — Of the east-going board where these men were found. If you come to the south right back to this return board here (pointing to the diagram) the indications are travelling north to this board.
Are there any indications in that east-going board which favour, in your opinion, the theory of the explosion having occurred there? — Nothing whatever in my opinion.
Cross-examined by Mr. Edge.
Did you take any notice of the props between where Middlemas and McCabe were found, between the tub and the face of that out-going board? — We got about half-way down, and the props were partly broken and some of them were whole.
Were they charred? — Yes.
On which side were they charred? — They were charred on the east side.
Did that lead you to the conclusion that the fire had come to the east side? — The conclusion I have come to on that point is that standing unholed she shows the strongest indication that she comes out again.
But does that apply to all parts of the pit? — Generally speaking it does.
Then the strongest indications show that she came out? — Yes.
That is the second blast would show the strongest indications? — Yes.
The first blast would not show as strong an indication as the second blast? — The result of the second blast would destroy the symptoms of the first.
Am I to take it that in your judgement there is always a back lash, and that the back lash show stronger indications than the first blast? — My opinion is that as she returns -----
Will you be kind enough to answer the question. Is that your experience as a pitman? — No, I do not mean the back lash. I mean where she got down here (pointing to the diagram) 26 or 30 yards, she has a fast face, and she goes in, and she comes out again, and as she comes out she leaves stronger traces than when she went in.
Did you see a single sign in that district, north of McCabe's place, of her having come out along the air course? — Yes, two boards from McCabe's place to the north, the second board is down, the pillar not holed, and the strongest indications are out-by in that pillar. In point of fact there are no indications of her having gone in.
Just to illustrate your theory of this back lash you said that there was no -----? — I do not call it a back lash, I call it a return blast.
You do not mean to suggest that there was a return blast where the fire had gone over previously? — Not over every particular part.
Where do you gat the atmospheric air that would burn after the explosion ; do you know that in the gas way a lamp will go out? — Yes, for the want of air.
For the want of air that will burn? — Yes.
Having got the explosion over that area there (pointing to the diagram), how do you produce the back explosion of fire over the same area? — She must come back, or else she must put herself out ; there is only one way or the other for her. It is clear to me that she did not put herself out, and therefore she had to come out.
Were you along the north narrow boards at all? — No.
You do not know whether she went in-by or out-by there? — No.
You have not been there? — No.
You have not been along these narrow boards at all? — Yes, I have.
Which way did the blast travel along the north narrow boards? — West.
Would she not be coming out there so as to get relief there (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes, that conveys my idea of her travelling north. I say that she went north from here (pointing to the diagram).
I understand that if that pick and cracket were upon the stones in the North Crosscut, you cannot explain how the explosion took place in the South Crosscut? — If they were put there by the men working there at the time of the explosion, that would destroy my theory.
Assuming it to be true as has been sworn to by Mr. Davison that the pick and cracket were there when he went in first, and he was the first person there, can you suggest any cause for an explosion in the South Crosscut? — No, that would destroy my theory.
Then she must have exploded somewhere else than in the South Crosscuts? — Yes.
Then do you suggest that what Mr. Davison says is not true? — I have not said so.
Do you say so? — I say it is a question with me whether it was put there by the men.
Do you suggest that it was put there by Mr. Davison? — I do not suggest anything of the kind.
Do you suggest that the pick and cracket were put there by Mr. Davison? — I do not suggest that they were put there by anybody, but it is a question with me whether they were put there by the workmen who had been working there previous to the explosion.
Do you suggest that Mr. Davison put them there and that he is telling an untruth when he says that he found the pick and cracket there? — No, I will not suggest any such thing.
If what Mr. Davison says is true, your theory is true with regard to the South Crosscut? — Yes. At the entry here at this North Headway (pointing to the diagram) there remains a full wall, the bricks are blown.
Do you suggest where that regulating door was, that that door was blown to the north? — No, the regulating door is here (pointing it out).
Will you point out exactly where the regulating door was? — It is where this "r" is.
Do you suggest that that was blown to the north? — No it was blown into the return. I say this, that the bricks stopping at this North Crosscut headways are blown to the north, and for a wall down to its north end.
Will you undertake to swear that the stopping was not up there (pointing to the diagram) near the flat? — No, it was not, it was there (pointing it out).
Examined by Mr. Atkinson.
Referring to this door on the out-by side, which before the explosion you say lay at the out-by side of the crossing, was the door frame along with the door? — No, it was lying loose by itself, the door was.
And the frame was not near it? — No.