1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
West Stanley Inquest, Second Day, Friday, 26th May, 1882 (cont.).
Mr. George Baker Forster called again, examination continued by Mr. EDGE.
You saw this pick and cracket in the back South Crosscut? — Yes, I saw the cracket. I am not quite sure I noticed the pick, but I remember seeing the cracket. I remember the stones seemed as if they had been slightly leveled down ; not like a rough shot just come there.
Cross-examined by Mr. BOWEY.
We know that you are a gentleman of great experience in these matters. You express a very confident opinion with regard to the seat of this explosion and the cause of it? — Yes, I do.
There are no difficulties in the way of your coming to that decision? — No, I do not think there are any difficulties, nothing that cannot be explained.
But you said you were rather surprised at anyone expressing any difficulty in arriving at this conclusion? — I did not say "surprise." I said I never dreamt that anybody would. It never occurred to me that there could be any other way of explaining it.
Looking at the plan, you think the blast went north and south from McCabe's place? — Yes, it went north and south from McCabe's place.
That is to say, up here, and down there (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes. I was not here (pointing).
You have heard with reference to the indication south of McCabe's place that the timber was marked on the south and not on the north side? — Yes, that might be caused by its coming round here and going up again that way. There is no doubt that a portion of the blast came down this headway, because I found two props, one on the north side of the going board and the other on the south, marked with fire ; that, I think, is the place of the explosion, that knocked this stopping out.
Did it come down there (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes.
Are there indications down there to show that it went down? — Crossing here, where you cross this going board.
(Mr. Edge.) That board there? — Yes, the second holing from McCabe's place.
(Mr. Bowey.) Then that stopping was blown down? — Yes, I suppose it might be. I could not see the stoppings, they were all repaired when I was there.
You do not know whether that was blown out or not? — No, but I was told so.
Assuming that stopping to have been blown down, that is the way in which a portion of the force would get up there, and would account for the timber being marked on the south? — Yes.
What did you find with regard to the indications in the South Crosscut, is there no difficulty as regards your theory with reference to the indications being from the main in-take there, at the junction with the South Crosscut to the first pillar out-by? — I say they are in-by.
I think one of the witnesses said they were out? — I saw it there myself.
You give no opinion about it? — Yes, everything I saw on the main line was all in-by.
Nothing whatever out-by? — Not on the main line.
Is there no difficulty with regard to your theory in the Back Crosscut, the description you have heard with regard to the condition of the tubs as top the way in which they were blown and burnt in the Back Crosscut? — I think not.
In fact this is a very clear case? — It appeared so to me.
Did you hear of any gas coming off at that east board? — Yes, of course, on the night of the explosion there was a little gas in the face, and on the Friday afterwards we heard of gas coming off and rumbling.
Was it coming off in bowks? — No so much in bowks, as you might call them gurgles.
As if through water? — Yes.
Was there any hissing noise? — No, I did not hear any hissing noise.
Did you observe the top of the back South Crosscut where the pick was found? — No, I did not observe that. I merely observed that the cracket was on the top of the stones, and from what I recollect my attention was not called to it at the time, but from what I recollect now, I distinctly remember that the top of the stones appeared as if they had been levelled down, as if some one had been working on them.
What were the indications following that Back Crosscut north and west? — From here to there, I was not. I went round into the Back Crosscut, and I was also up through here and in there (pointing to the diagram), and of course I was in the Fore Crosscut, and I was in the east boards, and I was along the North Crosscut and into the face here, and a little on the north side.
Assuming that it took place here in the east board, why should it take more particularly the north way instead of coming up the east narrow board and making through those walls south? — Because the east narrow board would have the resistance of the door whereas here it had the fresh air. That is the in-take.
The door would open with the force of the blast? — Yes, no doubt, but there was no door here, and also, no doubt, this was standing full of gas, it would require fresh air to be mixed with it, and it would cause the gas to go up in that direction ; but I have no doubt that it went up this wall with the enormous power of the fire, because the tubs and everything were dreadfully burnt ; even the tokens were burnt, and the string at the door here was hardly singed, whereas the tokens hanging on the tub here were quite charred.
Would that south wall be likely to fall with the volume of gas coming of the face of McCabe's board? — It depends upon whether the explosion took place immediately on the gas coming off or not. No doubt the gas would extend down here.
Did you observe that the indications from that south wall were northwards? — No.
With regard to the plates, did you see the two plates? — No, I was not down on the south side There was a tub and we could not get in.
Would the fresh air going in that way from the north, travelling southward, be any inducement for the flame to follow the course of the fresh air? — It is generally accepted as a theory that it faces the fresh air. I cannot positively speak to it from practical experience. I think she would blow that away because it was open.
(Mr. Willis.) Would the air in the east flat not be fresh air, in the east narrow board? — Along here (pointing to the diagram), there would only be a scale on there.
But would it not be fresh? — Yes, what there was of it would be fresh, but there could not be very much.
(Mr. Bell.) It was only a single door? — Yes.
Do you approve of single doors in those cases? — I think a canvas door is very nearly as good as a wooden door. It is less likely to get knocked out of order by ponies going through.
It is not your practice to trust to single doors? — No.
You spoke of the blast travelling north from McCabe's place and then at this second cross headway part of it turned down south? — Yes.
Indian called it a recoil but you agree that part of the blast did come this way (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes, from the fact that I found where that headway had touched the going board the prop charred on each side.
I presume there had been a stopping here (pointing to the diagram)? — There should have been a canvas stopping there, merely just to keep the air round the face. You would hardly require a stopping there (pointing to the diagram).
Might not the air be wasted in these stoppings here (pointing to the diagram)? — No. Of course all the air that came round here must eventually get there (pointing), because if there had been no stopping there it would have gone through there.
Is it your experience that the force of an explosion as a rule goes facing the air rather than with it? — I have never had anything that I could speak from experience on, but that is the generally accepted theory.
If there were two ways, it would rather go against than with the current of fresh air? — Yes.
(Mr. Willis.) Much depending upon the movement of the original force, would there not? — Yes, the recoil would require a much larger extent than this, and must have a cul de sac to go into, as it were, that makes it recoil.
(Mr. Morley.) In fact there had been a current down in this direction, which the other witness calls a recoil? — Yes.
You agree that there was a current in the direction in which he puts it? — Yes ; I have seen very extraordinary instances of recoil, which Mr. Bell no doubt remembers, where the force of the explosion had gone up the rolley way and had not sufficient vent at the end. Supposing it had gone up here, and it had been fast and then it got on fire it would have produced and enormous pressure here, and then it comes back again and you find so far up there all the things lying in that direction, and then from that to here you find them lying in the opposite direction.
Adjourned to to-morrow at 10 o'clock.