Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

West Stanley Inquest, Second Day, Friday, 26th May, 1882 (cont.).

The names of the jurymen were called over, and all answered to their names.

 

(Mr. Edge.) I propose now, Sir, to take the evidence of the explorers and the indications, and I should rather, as Mr. Johnson was not one of the first into the east-going board, take the gentlemen who went in first.

(The Coroner.) Very well.

Mr. James Fairlie sworn.

Examined by Mr. EDGE.

You are a viewer at Craigend Colliery? — Yes.

Did you go down the West Stanley Pit at the Busty seam on the 9th April about 4 p.m.? — Yes, I did.

With Mr. Rutherford? — Yes.

Did you travel into this West Narrow Board district? — Yes.

It is common ground that up to this point here (pointing to the plan) ; in the South Crosscut district the indications were all out-by? — Yes, from here to the shaft the indication was strong (pointing to the plan).

From the crossing to the shaft the indications were strong? — Yes.

The indications from the take-off to the South Crosscut, were they strong? — not so strong as on the West Board.

Now, how were the indications there? — There was not much timber in that part of the rolley way, but there was more in the west portion of the out-by ; but there were indications on the West Narrow Board rolley way. The indications were strong from here to there , out-by (describing the same).

Did you find that the stoppings between the West Narrow Board rolley way and the returns were blown to the north? — Yes.

In towards the returns? — Yes.

Then did you go into the North Crosscut district in order to get Middlemas and McCabe? — Yes.

Just tell me how you travelled in. did you travel in along the rolley way? — Yes, along the rolley way right to the east, and then down here (describing the same on the plan). We went in there to take the ventilation with us.

Did you notice in going in-by an old door? — Yes.

Where did you find that old door? — I found it just by the in-by of No. 2 air crossings.

You do not know where that old door had been before? — No, I have no idea.

I will take you straight in here first (pointing to the plan). You found Middlemas and McCabe? — Yes, lying just where your pencil is.

Did you find a tub there? — Yes, they were lying at the in-by side of the tub.

They were lying partly over one another? — Yes, the tub was standing just here, at this door (pointing to the plan). It was standing on the left-hand side.

Just where the two reds dots are on the plan? — Yes.

How were Middlemas and McCabe lying? — McCabe, I think it was, appeared to me as if he had fallen with his head in at the foot of the tub. Middlemas had been second, and he went up against the tub with his head, and was lying with his right leg across McCabe.

From the appearance they presented they appeared to have been running to the out-by, and the tub had stopped them? — Yes.

Did you notice where McCabe's lamp was? — Yes, I found two lamps. I cannot say which was McCabe's or which was Middlemas'.

Where did you find the first lamp? — In passing down the face below the Mothergate Board we came to a kibble, and immediately behind the kibble I found a lamp.

Was that stowing kibble in-by the place where you found Middlemas and McCabe, or out-by? — As far as I remember it was 20 yards of the face below.

That is in-by? — Yes.

That is 20 yards from where the bodies were lying? — Yes.

How far from the face? — About 6 yards, if I remember right.

Was that lamp locked? — Yes, it was.

Where did you find the other lamp? — About 4 feet from the face, under the stone, and a prop by it, and some coal dust underneath the prop and stones.

Had the stone and prop come down then on the lamp? — Yes.

Was that lamp locked? — Yes, it was locked, but the poles of the lamp were slightly bent, otherwise it was perfect.

Did you find any pick or shovel? — yes, I found a pick and a saw before we got to the stowing kibble.

You found a pick and a saw between the stowing kibble and the men? — Yes.

About how far were the pick and the saw from the face? — I should think 6 yards on the out-by side of the stowing kibble.

How far was the stowing kibble from the face? — About 6 yards.

Then the pick and saw were about 12 yards from the face? — Yes, something like that.

Did you find a white jacket anywhere? — We found the lamp I have mentioned, and I found a new white jacket, and a pair of corded trousers and vest, and a cap and two bottles ; one of the bottles had a cork in.

Were they tin bottles? — Yes, tea bottles ; and one of the bottles had a cork in, but the bottom was damaged, and the tea was out ; the other had the cork out and the tea was in, and in searching for the lamp I found several pieces of bread, and from that I had the impression that they had been sitting there getting their baits. The bread was oozed out, and was lying here and there.

How far were the bread and the bread cans from the place where you found the second lamp? — With regard to the second lamp I should think it was on each side of it ; it was just on the same spot.

Practically it was altogether? — Yes.

Was that where there had been a fall of stones? — Yes, but it was not a heavy fall.

When you found the second lamp about 4 feet from the face you found the two cans, one of them with the tea in but the cork out? — Yes.

Did you examine the gauze on the two lamps? — Yes, I did.

Did it present any appearance? — I could not see anything there, of course I only had a Davy lamp to examine them with, but I could see no defect.

Did you examine the gauze afterwards? — I have seen them since, but I did not see any fault in them. They are slightly bent lying on their side. I suppose they were not standing upright.

Do they present any appearance of fire? — I thought I could detect a slight indication of blue cast on the gauze, but it was very slight, a sort of peacock feather cast.

(The Coroner.) Was that on one lamp or both? — Both, I thought.

(Six lamps were produced.)

(Mr. Edge.) Will you just point out what you say you thought you detected? — That is the lamp I found first, McCabe's lamp.

(Mr. Bell.) Which is McCabe's lamp?

(Mr. Edge.) I will call someone who can identify the lamp.

(Mr. Bowey.) Does Mr. Fairlie identify McCabe's lamp as the lamp he found.

(The Witness.) Yes.

(The Coroner.) It has some blue indications on it you say? — I cannot see them this morning ; there is a slight blue cast next that pole (pointing to McCabe's lamp), but it is very slight now.

(Mr. Edge.) Now look at the other lamp that you found? — That is the one that was lying under the stone and the prop (identifying it).

Just point out what you saw ; you say the poles were bent? — These poles were slightly bent next the gauze here, and the top poles are twisted a little.

Did you examine the clothes that you found there? — Yes.

And you found nothing in them, I think? — Nothing in the pockets.

How close did you get up to the face? — Close to, as close as I could get.

How was that place at the time? — There was gas in her, and I considered it rather unsafe. I requested everybody to go back to the end of the board, and allow only two or three more to go into the face, and another one to hold the lamps, and we had to walk with one lamp upon securing these lamps, and Mr. Rutherford stood back and held the spare lamps. The place seemed to me to be uneasy, and a movement all over from the face to nearly the top of the board.

How is that place for timbering that board? — She was well timbered ; there seemed to be on each side a prop something like 30 inches apart, some of the planks across the tramway, some of them were put in like running planks by the side.

Did you find any trace of gas until you got past in by where the stowing tub was? — Not till we got past the men. There was an indication before we got to the stowing kibble, but she would not fire on the lamp until we got past the stowing kibble.

Did you notice where the brattice had been? — Yes, she was bratticed from the tub, from where the men were lying, but a good deal of it was knocked down the next face, or burnt down, it was not there, but it had been up, and there was evidence of fragments of it here and there next the face.

Did you see a brattice at the fifth pillar where a brattice had been? — The face pillar.

No, the fifth pillar ; that is the fifth pillar is it not (pointing to the plan)? — There was no brattice on there, there was a holing below the fifth pillar ; a brattice was not needed.

Did you examine at all up here? Did you go along north? — I was one wall along.

Did you go south at all from where you found Middlemas and McCabe? — I went into the next board.

You came south here (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes, one wall, the fifth pillar and the south wall again, two walls.

(The Coroner.) You went both up and down, north and south? — Yes, two walls.

(Mr. Edge.) And then you came out-by along the east going board? — Yes.

And you met Mr. Baker Forster, and Mr. Berkeley, and Mr. Hedley? — We met them at the No. 2 air crossing.

I think you sent the bodies out and went back with the other gentlemen into this district where you had been before? — Yes.

Did you after that go into the South Crosscut district? — Yes.

I ought to have asked you this question before we came to that ; will you tell the jury in your own way what indications you saw which enabled you to form a judgement with regard to how the blast had gone ; take the east going board district first? — Before we got into the bodies I noticed that the flat was standing in the second pillar of the East Mothergate board. The tubs on that second pillar were standing on the north side, which was the empty side of the siding ; they had been disturbed and blown westward ; the door was blown down which stood at the bottom of the second pillar.

Was that the door that was in-by at that flat? — Yes, I could find fragments of the door, but I could not satisfy myself whether it was really the door that had been standing there or not, as some one told me that there had been another loose door lying there. I found the batten of the door that had been standing with the band on it exactly in the same position as it had been blown open. The prop, on which the trappers cord hung, was still in with the cord upon it, which gave me the exact position in which the door had stood, and the batten of the door reached just from its position to the trappers prop with the band upon it, and it remained there.

Did that show any indication? — It showed that the force of the blast had been outward, and had driven the door open, and the band and batten remained then, in position.

You say you found pieces of wood, were they out-by or in-by of where the door had stood? — Some of them were out and some of them were in. On and before the examination we found that the bricks of this door were blown to the east.

That is blowing up in the ............ where Middlemas and McCabe were? — Yes into the third pillar. We also found two ............ in the third pillar, or at least just at the entrance of the third pillar.

Do you mean the out-by ............ in-by side of the third pillar? — Just at the entrance of the third pillar travelling east ............ the bricks and the bands were the principal things that gave evidence of the force eastward.

(Mr. Bowey.) That is in ............? — Yes ; From that it appeared to me that there was evidence of two forces. The first one I came to the conclusion had been westward which had been slight, and the second one had been eastward which had been apparently very heavy.

Going along in towards Middlemas and McCabe's place, what were the next indications? — In the third, fourth and fifth pillars we found very little evidence at all.

What evidence, if any, did you find? — I cannot say that there was any ; there was nothing that I could point to as really being evidence in these three pillars.

Did you notice any evidence on the tub where Middlemas and McCabe were, any indications? — Nothing particular, it was bound slightly in the in-by end.

The in-by end of the tub was bound slightly? — Yes it was end ways on, and it had been blown across.

Further in eastward did you notice any indication? — Yes, the small coal and the dust were coked very much, and particularly on the left hand side of the board going down, that is the north side, there was strong evidence of boring and fire in that board.

Did you notice any other indication there? — Not of force.

Now you say you went one pillar north? — One wall north.

Did you see any indications there? — Not much of force but of boring and charring there was.

How did you find the charring? — All round I think on these props and on the dust.

You say the charring was all round the props? — Yes, on the side and the dust.

Did you notice any indications when you went south? — Heavy charring.

Was that charring all round? — It seemed to be all round on the south side I think on the south wall, but there was something very particular in the south wall with the tramway, that is the bridge rails that were laid, and with the brattice in the first board, the brattice in the first board appeared to me to have been drawn out of the board it had been on, and been sucked out, from the way it was lying in the first south wall.

(Mr. Bell.) Which way was it sucked out? — It was drawn out on to the wall, it was in the east board, and it was drawn out of the board.

Was the brattice down or forced or blown towards the east? — No it was drawn out to the west on to the south wall, there was only one wall, it was drawn out of this board.

You mean the second east board? — Yes.

(Mr. Edge.) Is that the place you have been talking about (pointing to the diagram)? — That is the place.

And you say it was drawn out in that direction? — Yes.

(Mr. Bell.) It was drawn from east to west? — It was drawn out of the face pillar. With regard to the bridge rails, in that first wall there were two pairs of them standing up like that (describing), and it appeared to me as if the way had been also drawn out of the wall and brought together something like seven feet because the two four feet rails were standing up in that way, only two feet apart from the bottom out of the wall.

(Mr. Edge.) Did you notice any other indications in that district? — Nothing but charring on the south side, but on the extreme north we found the two first stoppings going eastward on the north rolley-way blown to the south. The first stoppings were blown to the north.

How were those stoppings in here (pointing to the diagram)? — That one is to the north. These I have not been to. You cannot get down there.

How were the stoppings on this east going rolley way going into where Middlemas and McCabe were? — I did not examine them, they were driving the headways and I did not examine them. There were indications here (pointing to the diagram), but this west board is not exactly as shown upon the plan opposite this east board. There is evidence on the west side of this rolley way right opposite the east board here (pointing to the diagram) as if the dust and small coals had been carried on to the west wall side and deposited there. It had come up to the west here (pointing to the diagram) and deposited against the west wall side, and then in the face of these headways there is a deposit in the face there she has travelled west again and come up here and deposited it here straight in and then come off this way.

Were there any indications of the blast coming from the north down the North Crosscut rolley way? — The only evidence is that the stoppings are blown east and west, but that is no evidence of which way the force went, because whichever way the force went the stoppings would be blown the same.

Have you told us all the indications you recollect that were north of the narrow board? — That is all I remember at present.

Now I propose to take you to what you saw in the south narrow board and ask you what conclusion you draw from the two. You have told us that you met Mr. Baker Forster and those other gentlemen and went into Middlemas and McCabe's place and then you came out and went into the South Crosscut? — Yes, I went into the South Crosscut and examined every place in the South Crosscut, so far as I know.

How did you get in? — We came in here (pointing to the diagram). We put the canvas across the main rolley way and forced the air in on the Fore Crosscut and came into the face of that (pointing to the diagram).

What indications did you find travelling into the Fore Crosscut? — There was very little indication in the south there at all of force, but there was a good deal of indication of boring and charring, but very little of force, and the evidence of charring is very conflicting ; you can scarcely form an opinion from it which way it has travelled except that it has travelled every way in every direction. I believe what is caused there is simply by the boring and dust (pointing to the diagram).

In that South Fore Crosscut? — The props are charred on both sides principally on the north side in going in on the Fore Crosscut.

Did you go from the Fore Crosscut through the Stenton, and into the Back Crosscut? — Yes.

Did you notice anything going through there? — No, but after getting past the Stenton here (pointing to the diagram) on the Fore Crosscut we found about 9 or 10 feet of the brattice burned out, leaving a piece next the face perfectly unburned still up, and a little gas in the face.

(Mr. Morley.) How much was standing in the face? — I should think a few yards.

(Mr. Edge.) From that did you go through the Stenton into the Back Crosscut? — Yes.

Did you observe anything going through the Stenton when you were passing through the Stenton into the Back Crosscut? — Nothing particular ; there is no timber in, I think, as far as I can remember to give any indication.

Did you examine the Back Crosscut? — Yes. I was along the face of the Back Crosscut and found a pick and cracket lying upon some rubbish that had been shot down, some band stone or something. There had been a shot fired, and there was a pick and cracket I should say.

Did you see any indications of force in the Back Crosscut? — There was very little indication of force in that south district at all.

I ought to have asked you, did you see that there was an unfired shot in the Fore Crosscut where the kitty was? — I saw the hole, and the pick had been drawn out and straw put in.

You saw the kitty there itself? — Not in the hole, it was taken out before I went in. It was lying on the cracket that was in the place, the straw.

There was a cracket up there too? — Yes.

Now you say that there was not much indication of force in this district, did you see indications of fire in this Back Crosscut? — Yes, charring.

What do you say about the charring there? — Well, the charring was on the north end of the tub, but the tub was standing rather at an angle.

Where was the tub? — There was a tub standing in broad end ; the end of it was rather at an angle with the Crosscut.

(Mr. Bell.) Is that the first west board? — No, the innermost west board. There is one in-bye side of the Stenton ; it is the innermost holing on the next west headways.

(Mr. Edge.) You say that it was charred on the out-bye side? — Yes.

Was there much charring of the timber in that South Crosscut? — not so much up here (pointing to the diagram) as there was on the Fore Crosscut.

Were there any indications either of fire or force that you noticed in that South Crosscut District? — There was evidence in every place of fire ; everything was charred in every place, almost in the South Crosscut ; but I noticed one particular thing, and that was this. I think it was this wall and board, the charring was on the north side of the prop in that wall and on the east side of this board (pointing to the diagram).

This is the innermost west holing. In the Back Crosscut you say the charring was on the east side? — Yes ; and then on the wall above the charring was on the north side, and they had evidently come together here (pointing to the diagram) ; they had bound together, and then right in the face here there was a quantity of small deposit.

Was it at an angle where that innermost first board and the wall met? — Yes.

What did you say you noticed at that point? — A quantity of small ashes had deposited ; small dust.

You told us, I think, the indications that you had seen. Did you see where this door was. There was a door to this west marrow board ; did you notice that door? — I noticed where it had been.

You noticed where the door had been? — Yes.

Did you, having examined those two districts, come to any conclusion in your own mind with regard to the seat of the explosion and how the blast had travelled? — Yes, I have the impression that it had happened in the face of the east Mothergate Board on the north side.

That is up in McCabe's place? — Yes.

Will you tell me in your judgement how the explosion spread from that place? — I believe the bulk of it travelled northward, north and west right away on to the innermost north place.

That would be travelling against the fresh air? — Yes. I believe a small portion of the force had travelled along that board, the east going board, and knocked it all down.

You mean it travelled westward? — I believe it divided, that the greater force went forward and the lesser came up the east-going board.

The greater force went up that way (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes.

And the lesser force from the explosion travelled that way and knocked down that door (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes.

Did any of the blast travel south towards the return? — The greater force that travelled northward came up onto the north rolley way and then came out.

It came up here (describing)? — Yes, on that blue line. This is the north rolley way, and it came up here and passed of here ; it got some relief here owing to this door having been carried away with the lesser force. The force round here and round here would be almost simultaneous ; but the door being knocked down the force would come down here. That was the second force. The first force had been up-over, and the second down-over, and some force came down the Back Headways.

Did you find that one of these regulating stoppings had been blown into the return? — Yes, it stood in that wall (describing).

It had been blown into the return? — Yes.

(Mr. Bell.) Which regulator are you speaking of now? — The east-flat regulator on the south side next the return.

The pillar below? — Yes.

(Mr. Morley.) On the blue line? — Yes, that is the pillar on the blue.

(Mr. Bowey.) Where is that exactly? — Here (pointing to it).

(Mr. Edge.) You say that that had been blown into the return? — Yes.

In your judgement, it has brought the main portion of the force of the explosion to that point, thus coming back here (pointing to the diagram) and causing some damage eastward again, and then coming down south here into this district? — Yes.

What do you say about this South Crosscut? — The force came out here as well as dividing itself there and going down there ; it came right out, and there is a pillar right opposite the north rolley way, and that pillar right opposite is packed with dust, right opposite to the north rolley way. The pillar not opposite to it is free from dust, east of that.

That is to say, the pillar directly south, opposite to the north rolley way, was packed with dust, the pillar to the north of the rolley way? — No, it is all one pillar. The pillar on the north side of this board here (pointing to the diagram) extends just up to the high side of this headway, but it comes down a few yards to the east, and a portion of the pillar opposite to the north rolley way here is packed with dust, but not the pillar opposite to it, that is not packed with dust, which gives me the impression that the force came out of the north rolley way and packed the dust in, and the east of the rolley way was not packed with dust.

You say that that also leads you to the conclusion that the force came out of this North Crosscut rolley way? — Yes.

What was the course taken by the blast then do you think? — There is a little indication in the pillar between the North Crosscut and the South Crosscut ; there is one pillar between the North and South Crosscut, this pillar (pointing to the diagram), and between the North and South Crosscuts there is very little indication in that pillar. I may say none ; but out by the side of that, if you go into that now, I can give you the indications there.

Will you be good enough to tell us what the indications are? — There had been a great deal of timber on that west rolley way, and most of it had been put in with holes being cut in the side. The balks of timber are put in instead of putting-props in, and they are put in with holes cut in the side one end is a fast hole and the other end is a loose sided hole. I found the timber that was put in on this rolley way with the loose holes open to the east, that is, the timber had been driven to the west, and that timber was knocked out.

In which direction? — Eastward ; the balks of timber that were put in the opposite way with the driving holes open to the west, and the timber driven to the east remained in.

(Mr. Bell.) That is not in dispute.

(Mr. Edge.) No ; I need not trouble you about that. At any rate, from this point on the west narrow board the blast must have gone out. But the question is, did it originate in the South Crosscut or the east-going board. (To the witness. ) In your judgement how were these indications that you have spoken to in the South Crosscut produced? — By coal dust getting on fire. I do not think there was anything in the south way, so far as my judgement goes, that led me to think that any explosion was caused in the south way.

I have just received a note to ask you about a regulator from the east board to the return west narrow board ; do you know where that regulator was? — (No answer. )

As I understand it, correct me if I am wrong, the conclusion which you have arrived at is that the explosion originated up in the face where Middlemas and McCabe had been? — That is my impression.

Did you notice any tubs in the innermost west board of the North Crosscut? — Yes.

Just point out where they were? — There was one blown straight down north ; there was one just there, and another one so far up here, up that pillar (describing).

You mean the tubs were separated? — Yes.

Was that tub that was there at that point to the east of the North Crosscut? — It was not east ; it was straight north.

Was it damaged? — The top of it was off.

Was it blown out? — Yes. I came to the conclusion that it had been blown out.

And the other tub was further west? — Yes.

Cross-examined by MR. BOWEY.

Were you the first person in the east-going board? — Yes.

Commencing at the crossing into the North Headways, what is the first indication as you go north which you saw? — You cannot find any indication from that crossing to the face, the whole of the force has travelled there.

You cannot find any indications from that crossing up to where? — Up to this innermost east holing.

There is no indication which way the force has gone? — No.

You mentioned finding a door in-by of that crossing? — Yes, I saw a small man door.

But you do not know where it came from? — No, I do not.

Then going into the east-going board from here (pointing to the diagram), what is the first indication which you saw there? — The first indication is on the right hand wall side upon turning into the east-going board.

Will you just put your finger on it? — Just on this corner of the coal (describing).

What is that indication? — The coal is slightly charred there.

And the next? — It continued down that board, charred slightly on the right hand down to here, and there is a prop standing at the bottom corner of that pillar (describing), and that is charred slightly ; the coal is charred at the top, another is a prop standing charred at the bottom. The second pillar is the flat pillar ; and just there is a siding, and at the left hand side of the siding, the empty tubs had been standing, and the tubs had evidently been blown westward, and one if not more of the tops was blown off the tram.

How are the bottoms of the tubs? — They are not broken much.

Have they been blown? — Yes ; slightly shifted.

Which way? — Westward, I think.

And the tops of the tubs? — Westward from them, just about the length of themselves.

They have been blown westward? — Yes.

You spoke of that door being by the side of the flat? — The door stood at the bottom of the second pillar. That door was not there when I went, of course, but there was one batten and a band there exactly in the same position as it had been blown open.

Are you quite sure that that door had not been blown in? — I think I satisfied myself on that.

Are you quite sure about it? — In my own mind, I am.

Now with regard to the indications from that door up to Middlemas and McCabe's place ; what do you say of them? — Little or nothing ; three pillars, little or no evidence upon the three pillars.

Then it comes to this, that from the South Crosscut there (pointing to the diagram), up here the indications are absolutely nil ; there is nothing at all? — With regard to the direction of the blast.

And from here up to Middlemas and McCabe's place there is nothing, except that the tubs are blown westward? — Yes.

And the door you think was, what? — And the door itself was blown westward, and the bricks it was built with were blown eastward.

You are quite sure that the bottoms of the tubs were not blown one way and the tops another? — They were separated.

Would you say that that was not so ; would you say that the bottoms of the tubs had not been blown one way and the tops another? — No, I would not say that ; because I believe in that pillar particularly (pointing to the diagram) there is evidence of a force both ways. On that south side of that flat pillar there had been a lot of sleepers piled up on the south side, and these sleepers had all been moved eastward, and that was on the out-by side of the door.

You think there had been a force both ways? — Yes.

Without saying anything with reference to your conclusions, let us come down here (pointing to the diagram), or before I go into that South Crosscut, let me ask you this. You did not notice, did you, that there were any bricks blown from this overcast? — No, I did not.

None? — None, not on the main rolley way.

Did you notice any bricks at all? — I have been in the return, and I noticed them there, but not on the main rolley way.

Where were they on the return? — There are bricks in the upper crossing both east and west.

Were you there when Anderson went? — No.

He was there before you, was he not? — I do not know.

He said that he was there on the morning of the explosion, and you were not there till the afternoon? — That is correct. I know nothing about Anderson, but it is correct that I was not there till the afternoon.

Now, with regard to the South Crosscut, you were not the first in there? — No, the men had been got out before I went in.

Who had been in before you? — Mr. Johnson and Mr. Rutherford, I believe, and Mr. Colquhoun.

Which was the direction in which you went in? — On the blue line.

The in-take? — Yes.

You say, I think, that the indications in that South Crosscut are such that you can scarcely give any idea with regard to them? — I say that there is very little indication of force, there is a great deal of indication of fire and charring by fire.

Considerably more than in the east-going board? — Certainly not.

Is that not so? — No. The heaviest indication of fire that I have seen is in the east-going board.

You consider then that in the east-going board there are the strongest indications of fire? — Yes.

Did you notice what the indications were from there, that is the first pillar up to the innermost Stenton in the Fore Crosscut? — The indications were charring on the north side in the first wall, that is to say, what indication there is. On the second it is a little stronger.

Is it in the same position too on the north side? — Yes.

On the second? — Yes, and on the third. I think it is on both sides, and the evidence stronger, the charring on the props is thicker, and we took two pieces of charring off the innermost wall there an inch and a half thick ; it is on both side of the innermost wall, but principally on the north side.

Are there any indications from the Stenton right into the face of the Fore Crosscut? — Yes, there are 9 or 10 feet of brattice burnt out there.

Apart from the brattice, is there anything? — Not much except charring of dust and on the props.

On which side? — I cannot say just where that brattice was on. I was engaged putting some brattice up, and I do know that I did observe the props particularly in the face wall.

Of course you cannot tell anything about the pick and the cracket? — They were lying on the stones when I was in.

They may have been put there after the explosion? — Yes, for anything I know they might, but that is where they were when I saw them.

In the Back Crosscut from the Stenton to the face, what are the indications? — I do not think there is any indication of fire in that Fore Crosscut. The place seemed all right and undisturbed, and the brattice all up.

Did you not find the props as you go along that crosscut charred? — I cannot say that I noticed any charring on the props in the face of the Back Crosscut.

But as you go along the Back Crosscut up there (pointing to the diagram) do you find any evidence of charring not merely at the face? — Yes, there is charring on the innermost wall, that is, between the innermost west wall and the next west board.

That would be where? — Between there and the one further out between the Stenton and there (pointing to the diagram).

There is evidence between there of what? — Between the Stenton and the west innermost hole there is evidence of charring there. It was on the north corner of the tub on the north side ; but there is not such strong evidence on the Back Crosscut of charring as on the North crosscut.

Did you observe anything further between here and coming down here (describing) any indications? — Yes. I think with regard to that pillar from the Back Crosscut there up to the next headways the charring is on the east side, and in the wall the charring is on the north side, and just at the face of the board and the wall both there is a cracket lying there.

Where is that? — Here (pointing to the diagram). The cracket was upside down, and it held a quantity of small ashes, the dust ; and besides what was lying on the cracket there were several shovels full of charred dust and small coal, I should think, lying just there, and it appeared to me as if the burning had gone northward in the wall and westward in the board, and they were bound together. The climax had been just in there (describing).

And you think the indications have gone which way? You said two ways? — Here and here (describing).

(Mr. Bell.) That is southward? — Yes, in the wall, and westward in the board.

(Mr. Bowey.) Did you find any indication from there to here (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes, the charring is on the west side of the board, and on the north side in the wall. There is the exception that I mentioned.

From here to here (describing) what do you find? — That is the highest holing westward, and the evidence of charring diminishes.

What do you call that? — The highest west holing.

The evidence of charring is what? — Very slight.

On which side of the timber is it? — On the north side, I think it is.

Is that so going down again? — I have been no farther west than there.

Do you think you can fairly say that the indications in that South Crosscut are of any definite and decided character from which you can infer anything? — I can infer nothing but that the dust has got fire and burnt all round it.

But I mean taking the South Crosscut alone, without your knowledge of the east-going board, could you say anything whatever with regard to those indications in the South Crosscut without connecting the two together? — I could say nothing, but I thought there had been a fire and it had burnt all round.

And you could not say where it had gone in? — No, I could not.

That is taking the South Crosscut and disconnecting it from what you saw in the West Crosscut? — I could not say where it had gone in.

Could you say that it had not come out without your knowledge of the east-going board? — There is no evidence of it having gone out.

Is there practically any evidence of its having gone in? — No ; there is an absence of force, and an absence of any evidence of burning at the entrance.

You could not say, apart from the east-going board, where it had gone in or come out in the South Crosscut? — No, I could not.

Going back to the east-going board, you say that in your opinion the strength of the force had gone from the east-going board north and west? — Yes, it had travelled north and west.

How is it with regard to the indications there? they are not strong, are they, of its going north and west? You have not spoken of any strong indications going north and west? — Yes, there is on the bearing down brick stoppings there. These stoppings (pointing to the diagram) are blown northward, and these two are blown southward.

The stoppings are blown generally, that is to say they are blown here (describing)? — Yes.

What indications are there to corroborate your view that the strength of the force has gone north and west? — I think the fact of two stoppings being blown southward, and two stoppings as far as we have been able to examine, being blown northward is an evidence that she has faced the fresh air and come up the innermost north board, and then there is the positive dust on the west wall side opposite ; there is a large deposit of dust and rubbish. That plan rather shows to disadvantage what I am saying.

But it is a correct plan, is it not? — It is not correct just there (pointing to the plan).

But it is not so incorrect that it does not enable you to explain? — Well, it does in that case. This board and that is off and on.

It is not in a straight line? — No, the deposit of small coals and stuff and dust lies opposite this eastboard ; there is no deposit upon this headway by the side anywhere but just opposite that eastboard.

(The Coroner.) Has that pillar any particular name at the top of that North Crosscut, the pillar you say is off and on? — It is the first east pillar of the innermost north board.

(Mr. Bowey.) That is the indication you spoke of? — Yes.

(The Coroner.) Do we understand that the charring or coal dust is lodged against the east side? — It is lodged up against the west wall side.

East of the pillar? — Yes, it is east of the west pillar.

The east face? — Yes, it is the west wall side of the North Crosscut.

But as far as that pillar is concerned, it is the east side of that west pillar? — Yes,

(Mr. Bowey.) There is that dust there, and those crossings are blown out ; but is that all that you have to support your idea that the strength of the force went north and west? — There is the indication of two stoppings having been blown north and two blown south, and the dust deposit and beyond there is the dust deposit at this end of the entrance of the North Crosscut.

Assuming for a moment that the South Crosscut was the seat of the explosion, and that the blast had come out here in the Fore Crosscut, would it not have gone up there (pointing to the plan) past Middlemas and McCabe's place, and round to the very position you name, where there is the deposit of dust? — No, there is a regulator stopping there and it is blown into the return.

A regulator stopping here (pointing to the plan), which is not marked? — Yes, which is blown into the return.

What is the exact point where that regulator stopping is ; what do you call it? — I do not know whether they would call it one or two pillars down, it is two pillars down from the crossing, it is one pillar from the North Crosscut.

How do you say that that door is affected by the blast? — Blown into the return southward.

That is the reason why the blast could not have come out of the South Crosscut and round by Middlemas and McCabe's place away to this point where the dust is? — I think it is in evidence that it has come out of where Middlemas and McCabe were.

Assuming that the explosion occurred in the east-going board, would you not have expected to have found that the strength of the force would have been exhibited at some distance from the seat of the explosion rather than its actual seat. You have given in evidence that the strength of the force or the greater evidence of burning is at the Middlemas and McCabe's place? — Yes, but that is not force. The greatest evidence of fire and burning is in that place, down in that district (pointing to the map), but not of force just there.

Assuming the greatest evidence in burning, would you not have expected to have found greater results of force along from Middlemas and McCabe's place, until you come to the junction with the North Headways, than you do? — No, I do not see that. I think that she would be inclined to face the fresh air.

But had she gone against the fresh air? — Face it, I say. I am inclined to think that she would face it.

But would not you have expected an explosion occurring in Middlemas and McCabe's place, right away from there up to the junction with the North Headways, and right away in the other direction from Middlemas and McCabe's place, round here to this place where the dust is deposited, covering all that ground, there would have been greater indications of force? — There is never so much indication of force in the immediate neighbourhood of an explosion.

But this is not in the immediate neighbourhood of the explosion? — That is where we get evidence of force.

You get some dust deposit? — Yes, and two tubs broken to pieces.

But all along here from Middlemas and McCabe's place to the North Headways you scarcely have any indications at all? — Not on those pillars because she has not gone that way. When she gets up here there are two tubs broken all to pieces. She is divided here, and a portion has gone up here and a portion has come out here (describing on the map).

Those two tubs might have been broken up there if the blast had come out from the South Crosscut, might they not? — Yes they might, it is possible, but I think the deposit dust is an evidence that it did not go in.

It is the deposit dust, it is not the tubs? — But you are disputing with me, as I understand that there is evidence of force, that there is want of evidence of force in that particular place.

What I say is this, you gave the tubs as evidence of force coming that way (describing)? — No, I did not say which way, I am contending that she came that way.

And when I was asking you about the indication of force, you gave the tubs. If the tubs being broken at that point is consistent with what you admit, what is the indication of force extending over that wide area which supports your theory that the explosion occurred in Middlemas and McCabe's place? — I told you before, I think, that there is no evidence of force on that North Crosscut ; there is a little indication of force. Of course the stoppings are blown both eastward and westward, but as I said before the stoppings were blown eastward or westward is no evidence of which way the force travelled ; because, whether it travelled north or south, the stoppings would be blown out the same.

It reduces itself then down to this dust? — In two cases it does, but then there is the evidence again of the force on the east-going board.

That is of fire rather than of force? — No, of force. There is evidence of a force two ways in that flat.

Where? — The second pillar on the east-going board, that is the flat pillar.

The tubs do you mean? — The tubs and the door, and the bricks that the door was built with.

But the tubs are blown both ways? — The tubs are blown westward.

They are blown one one way and one the other? — I do not believe that. I would not say it might not be so, but I do not admit it in my own mind.

While you do not admit it you do not dispute that it may have been so? — No, of course I cannot.

If you cannot dispute that they were blown in both ways how do you happen to take it as evidence of your theory or in support of your theory? Does not after all come to this : That it is very doubtful indeed in your opinion where the explosion occurred? — In my opinion it is not doubtful at all ; I am perfectly satisfied in my mind.

You are perfectly satisfied, although the reasons you give for it may be doubtful? — I will make it as plain to the jury and the coroner as I can, but I am perfectly satisfied in my mind that the seat of the explosion was in the face pillar of the east-going board, and that was where these lamps were found.

With regard to the South Crosscut, do not you think that the indications there being of such a conflicting character, it is quite possible, or, I will put it in this way, that there is evidence of great burning at least there? — Yes.

Is not that consistent with the theory of the explosion having occurred there? — No, I do not think it. Of course the dust would be disturbed before the fire had passed from wherever it came from, and I believe it came from Middlemas and McCabe's place. The fire passed the South Crosscuts to its course out ; there is an evidence of burning in the south-west road from the shaft, so that I believe nobody would ever doubt that she fired in the south. There is evidence of the burning there, and of the fire being conveyed there by some means, and I believe it had been conveyed by the same means into that second South Crosscut.

But the fact of the timber being burnt in the Fore Crosscut on different sides, one pillar on one side, and another on another, and some on both, does not that show that the explosion may have occurred there? — There is nothing to convince me that it occurred there, or to give me that idea at all, nothing at all.

What do you give, then, as the cause of the explosion in Middlemas and McCabe's place? — Well, my impression was at the time that the sudden movement of this lamp to my left, I believe it is labelled "McCabe," was the cause of the explosion.

The sudden movement where? — I think the men had been sitting getting their baits, or had just sat down to get them, and immediately on sitting down they discovered gas, and it appeared to me as if the blower had come off recently, the blower of gas ; the men had discovered it, and Middlemas, I think, had taken McCabe's lamp from the fact that there was evidence that Middlemas had come out of the board first. I think he had taken McCabe's lamp and moved forward, and McCabe had followed him, and that the sudden movement of the lamp had set the gas on fire. Immediately the gas was fired he dropped his lamp at that point ; he had run up against the stone probably, but he had gone over all that and run against the coal tub, and they stopped there and were killed ; the other man had not got the other lamp, that had been sticking in the prop next the face after they had got out, and the stone fell down and knocked the prop down, and broke the lamp ; but I think the stone falling happened after they came away.

What is there to show that the blower of gas had come off? — The board was very uneasy, so much so that I was afraid of so many of us being in, and I particularly requested everybody there, but two and myself, to go out of the board and to leave us to ourselves, so that we might hear what was going on, and be able to save ourselves if the board were likely to come down. I was uneasy about the board, it was not comfortable for anybody to be in, and there has been some difficulty in keeping the board up since, I believe.

How long was this after the explosion? — 16 or 17 hours.

That is the afternoon when you were in? — Yes.

Do you think that the lamp was hanging, or was on the ground? — I believe Middlemas's lamp had been hanging on the prop, and the prop had fallen with it, but the other one had been in the hands of Middlemas, or in the hands of one of them, and he had been making out, and the sudden movement of that lamp caused the fire. They discovered the gas, and they jumped up from their baits, and endeavoured to get out of the board for safety, and the sudden movement of the lamp set the gas on fire.

The lamps are not injured to any material extent? — They do not seem to me to be faulty at all. McCabe's lamp is not injured in any shape, not even bent, and Middlemas's lamp is not unsafe, but the poles of the lamp are bent, which you can see.

Do you think it quite probable that a man would sit down to get his bait in a place which was so full of gas and not know it? — I do ; I think it is possible.

How high is the tram? — The bore is about nearly four feet, I think next the face. It was in a little lower next the face. It appeared to me that immediately behind where the jackets and bait were lying they were making two walls of it, right and left, and they had evidently taken the stone right down to the face.

In working in, their heads would be very near the roof? — Yes, except when they were hacking at the bottom.

Still you think that they would not be likely to know anything about the gas until after they had sat down? — I have known strange cases of men not observing gas, and I think it is possible that they did not observe it.

You think it had been there and that in some way or other they did not observe it? — Yes, I think so.

They had used their bait out, and had gone into the face? — Yes, but it was at the face ; the bait was at the face, within a few feet of the face, the loose bait that I found was within a few feet, the clothes that I found, the white jacket, and corded trousers, and waistcoat, and cap, and two bottles, and bread, and the lamp, were all at the face ; and it appeared to me as if the men had intended to have their baits in the face, and that after they sat down they noticed that there was something wrong ; of course it is only matter of opinion from the evidence I saw.

Do you think it likely under those circumstances, the place being only three feet high, or four feet high, that there could have been gas which they would not have found? — It might have been a sudden outburst you know.

There were no falls till after the explosion. You think that the stone fell? — There was every prospect of a fall when I was in.

But that was after the explosion? — I think there was an indication that something was forcing the stone, the board was remarkably well timbered, and but for that my impression is that these lamps would not have been got yet.

That is several hours after the explosion? — Yes.

But there is nothing to show that there had been any fall at the time of the explosion? — No, there was no fall, but this flat stone that I tell you about that was lying on the prop, and the prop lying on the lamp and the lamp pressed down into the small coal and dust.

Was it very large stone? — No, it was not.

Would the lamps be above their heads when they were sitting down? — That I cannot say. Some men have a habit of setting their lamps down on the ground, and some men are very particular not to set their lamps down, but to hang them up ; there is a nail attached to the lamp to hang it up by, and the proper way to do is hang it up.

You think that they might have been sitting down getting their bait, and a sudden outburst of gas might have come off, which they in a place only three or four feet high had not discovered before? — I think it is possible.

Cross-examined by Mr. HEAVISIDE.

Did you notice a chest at the junction of the Main West Way and North Headways? — I noticed a chest the in-by side of the North Crosscut on the Main Straight West.

Near the double door? — Near to the double door.

You found the chest there? — Yes, I found the fragment of one.

Which way were they blown? — It is difficult to say, because I could not ascertain where the door had been standing, exactly, but from what information I could gather about the chest, I believe it had geen blown from the west wall side down against the east, and it was standing just within this wall, the first wall to the south, above the North Crosscut.

Was it much shattered? — Yes, and the spare lamps were all smashed to pieces.

The force of the explosion had been very great there? — Yes.

In the Fore Crosscut did you notice which way the stopping had been blown near the first pillar in the South Crosscut? — In that wall (pointing to the diagram), just where the chest stood.

Do you understand me. This is where I mean (pointing to the diagram)? — But here is a stopping that I omitted to mention where the deputy's chest was standing, and near the double door there (pointing to the diagram), that stopping was blown southward.

Did you notice which way that stopping had been blown? — No. The deputy's chest stood there with some spare lamps in it (pointing to the diagram).

(The Coroner.) Where is that? — It is called the straight west board, west of the North rolley way Cross-cut.

It is the west side of the North Crosscut? — Yes, and on the south side there (pointing to the diagram), and the stopping was blown south.

(Mr. Heavisidel.) Did you notice which way this stopping was blown at the Back Crosscut side at the other end of that road? — There is no stopping in there.

Examined by Mr. BELL.

Might not the clothes and things which you spoke of in McCabe's board have been blown in over? — I do not think it.

Did you observe whether they were burned? — I do not think they were burned ; they were buried. we got them out of the flat stone.

If that stone had fallen before they had got out would it have fallen on the man McCabe? — Yes, I think so.

Would he have been able to get out from underneath it? — The stone was not so heavy as that.

Just look at the first south wall here (pointing to the diagram). Did you observe the indications from the next board towards the east board from there to there? — It seemed to me to be suction.

Why should he have suction there when he had a loose end at the other end of the board, and a direct route from there to the return? — There was no evidence of force from there into the return It was not until you get up into the return that it showed there was evidence of force, it is always difficult to account which way things travel till you get force with it.

Did you observe charring on the props in that wall from the next east board southwards (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes.

Which way did it indicate? — It seemed to indicate pretty much all round, and even the dust lying by the side.

Was not there a very strong indication upon the props on the south side? — I think there was. I think I remember taking some of the charring on the south side.

With regard to the two rails that were set up that way (pointing to the diagram), which side had they been driven from? — From the in-by side.

From the south to the north, towards the east board? — Yes.

And set up in this position? — Yes.

Do you think suction would have done that? — I cannot account for it in any other way.

Then from the board, the east-going board to the first wall north, in what direction do you consider the indications were there? — There was little indication of force there, it was quiet, just charring, you know.

Could you have all that charring about the props without some force? — I find that where there is much charring there is no force.

Did you find charring on the east and west side of the props in the way? — Not on the east and west side. I think it was on the north side.

I mean travelling north? — Yes.

Was the charring on the east and west or on the north and south side of that prop? — I believe it was on the north side.

Did you notice a canvas door at the bottom of that board and before you get into McCabe's place? — Yes.

In what direction was it blown? — I really cannot say, the brattice was still up there, a portion of the brattice was still up in the board, and I cannot speak with reference to the door.

I will not take you all round the workings, but coming back to the South Crosscut, did you notice two doors in the second wall in-by? — Not when I was there.

Did you see any remains of the doors? — We saw several pieces of canvas lying about, but you could not say what they had been for. They had been rolled up into a lump, something like that bag on the table there, and you could not say what they had been used for.

There is the first Stenton stopping (pointing to the diagram) ; where was that driven? — I cannot say. I never examined it.

At the second Stenton there is a canvas door. Did you notice how that was driven? — No, I cannot say.

The third Stenton seems to have been a brick stopping. In what direction did that go? — I cannot say , there is so little evidence of force on the roads that I did not examine these doors and stoppings for it.

You said you were in the Back South Crosscut, where the pick and cracket were found? — Yes.

Did you observe whether there were any pick marks in the roof? — No, I simply saw a cracket and pick lying there.

Did you not examine the place to see if a man had been working in it? — No, I took it for granted that he had.

If he had been working there would you not have expected to find some marks? — Yes, but it did not occur to me to do so at the time. I was very particular, I did not do it.

Do not you think that the evidence of force and the direction of the blast are equally as strong from the south as from the east place, from the South Crosscuts ; are they not equally as strong from here, taking the south towards the north, as they are from Middlemas' place, towards the west? — I do not think it.

You said you found two lamps? — Yes.

Have you examined them carefully? — I have.

Are they securely locked? — I think so.

Is that a proper system of locking a lamp? — It is a system very much used ; but I inquired about the lamps not being screwed up, of course they had not been taken off for me to see ; but I inquired why they were not screwed up, and they told me that there is a washer put in.

Do you think it is a proper thing to send a safety lamp into a pit within two or three turns of being screwed up? — I would not like to do it myself. Of course, I suppose they think they are safe.

Have you ever known a lamp to explode while in the test when it was improperly screwed up? — No, I do not know that I have.

Have you ever tested any lamps? — No.

You will observe that there is a little recess there for the screw to go into, and the screw is not in that recess? — I noticed that.

(A lamp was handed to Mr. Bell.)

This is the little recess for the screw to go into, it is against this little rim or projecting part ; if it had been properly screwed up this part would have been close down on here, and the lock would have fitted into this groove? — Yes.

(The Coroner.) Is the tin above the groove so that it can be unscrewed by it ; could a hewer unscrew it by it? — If it was in the recess that was below he could not, but it gives him a chance that he would not have if it was in its proper place.

You found the lamp as it is? — Yes, just as it is. I noticed particularly when I found them that they were not screwed up, and I made some inquiry about it, and I was told that there was a washer put in there which hinders it from going down.

What kind of washer is that? — I have not seen it.

(Mr. Bell.) I was going to propose, Mr. Coroner, after you have done with the lamps that they may all be put in, and taken away and lighted and tested in the same position as they are now. Of course they will have to be marked so that they can be unscrewed precisely in the same position.

(Mr. Edge.) I may say that on behalf of the men at Trimdon Grange, Mr. Wilkinson went to see the officials, and then they came back and signed a report with regard to the testing of the lamps.

(The Coroner.) I think Mr. Bell would like to be represented.

(Mr. Bell.) Yes, we propose to send Mr. Cowey and Mr. Thompson.

(Mr. Edge.) When shall we have it done.

(The Coroner.) In the afternoon when we are going on with the witnesses.

(Mr. Morley.) We had better have the other lamps produced.

(The remainder of the lamps were produced.)

Examined by MR. MORLEY.

Is that lamp (pointing to the same) in an unsafe condition to be sent into the colliery? — I would not say that, but I would not like to send it out in that way if I did it myself.

Just come down to the South Crosscut in the South Fore Crosscuts, you say that there were some yards of bratticing still standing? — Yes ; there were 9 or 10 feet burnt out, but some yards on the in-by side had not been injured.

And in the Back Crosscuts there was evidence of a bratticing being there? — Yes, it was still there.

It was still standing? — Yes.

How much of the bratticing was standing in the Back Crosscuts? — I think the whole of it.

You mean up to the face? — Yes. I do not remember, but I think that there was a piece in the Back Crosscut.

From the face down to the end? — Yes.

Was that burnt? — No, it was not burnt.

Did it look to you when you went in as if it had been put up since the explosion in the Back Crosscut? — No, I think not. No, it had not been put up.

I am told it had been put up there since the explosion, before you went in? — It never occurred to me.

Can you imagine an explosion coming round there and burning the brattice in the Fore Crosscut, and not burning the brattice in the Back Crosscut? — I do not believe there was an explosion there.

But I am supposing it came from the other place? — I cannot imagine it coming from the Back Crosscut to the Fore Crosscut.

I am supposing it came from the east-going board, passed round by the Fore Crosscut and burnt the brattice there. Can you imagine it passing the Back Crosscut without burning the brattice that was standing there? — No, I cannot.

Probably the brattice had been put up before you got there? — There was nothing that indicated that to me, nor did it ever occur to me that it had been put up.

Did you see any traces of burnt brattice there? — No.

Other parties had been there before you were there? — Yes, they were simply getting out the men.

But to get up to the end of the Back Crosscut they would have to put brattice up? — It looked to me as if it had never been down.

Supposing it had been down they would have had to put up fresh brattice before they could get through there? — Yes. Mr. Johnson had been there before me. I do not know who else.

You say at the end of the east-going board you found a coat and a pair of trousers? — Yes.

And a couple of bottles? — Yes, and some bread.

And you say they were not burnt? — No, there was no evidence of burning, they were under the stone and under the prop.

Were the bottles under the stone? — Yes.

Were they knocked about much? — One of them, the top was separated from the bottom, and the cork was in ; the other bottle was perfect, and the cork was out.

If the explosion had happened to that point would you not have expected more damage to have been done by the violence of the fire? — I never saw any violence in the immediate seat of the explosion.

You would have expected fire? — Yes, evidence of fire, but not evidence of force.

Would you not have expected more evidence of fire upon the clothes that was found in the end of the east-going board than was actually there? — There was a great deal of evidence of fire in that board, but it was principally on the north side of the board, on the brattice side.

Would not that rather point to the fact of the fire coming up from the south and so acting upon the north side of the board? — No, it points to the idea that I have always had, that after she fired she faced the fresh air.

I am now dealing with the north side of the board, at the end of which the two men were burnt? — The fresh air was coming down there behind the brattice, hence if she fired there she would have gone behind the brattice and burnt the brattice out more on that side than the other.

Upon which side of the brattice was the air going? — The brattice was on the north side of the board, and the air was going down the north side of the brattice, and then returning up the board on the south side.

That is the way you account for the north side of the brattice being more burnt than the south side? — Yes.

Coming west along that board to where the fire was, you say that the bricks were blown to the east? — That is in the second pillar from the North Crosscut, the bricks were blown to the east.

And the door to the north? — One bottom and the band were remaining nearly in the same position as it would be when the door was open.

Would you not expect the bricks to have been blown by the first explosion acting upon the doorway? — I think they had been slightly dispersed and they would be easily removed by the second force.

Would that not apply more to the door, and would not the door have been blown to the east with the bricks, and then the return blast would take the light material back again towards the west? — The door opened to the west so that it will blow open easily ; it would resist more if the blast comes against it the way it shuts than it will if the force comes against it the way it opens.

Does not the fact of the bricks being blown to the east and the door to the west rather point to the fact of the blast having gone to the east and then the return blast coming and blowing the door away to the west? — No ; my impression is that the slight effect of the blast had gone westward up that door first and blown the door open and broken it, and then the greater force after that had blown the door open and broken it west-north-west, and came out on the rolley way and had gone down east.

You say with regard to the indications in the neighbourhood of the end of the east-going board that there is very little evidence of force, but more of charring? — Yes, more of charring.

And the same with regard to the South Crosscut? — Yes, the same thing with regard to the South Crosscut.

So that so far as the evidence in the immediate neighbourhood of each of the two points goes there is nothing to point to one or the other? — I see no evidence of force in the South Crosscut. The evidence of force is all found in McCabe's place. It does not matter which way you come or go from McCabe's place there is evidence along it.

Not along the East Flat? — There is only the south wall ; the south wall is the only exception.

You say the evidence upon the South Crosscut is explainable by the coal dust being found there? — Yes.

Is it not equally the case with reference to the east-going board? — No ; there is evidence of force as you get away from it.

I am now dealing with the immediate neighbourhood? — It is the same.

Therefore the remark applies equally to the one as to the other? — Yes.

There are strong marks of charring? — Yes.

And that might be the case because of the coal dust firing? — Yes.

With regard to the pile of cinders and coal dust, you say there was a pile down in the corner near the South Crosscut? — Yes.

And another one at the end of the North Crosscut? — Yes.

That would show equally what the indication was, would it not? — They were not cinders at the end of the North Crosscut. They were quite of a different nature, unburnt dust and small dust and stones in the North Crosscut? — Yes.

You infer from that that there had been less fire there than there had been in the south? — There had been a great deal of force just there, and the consequence was that the dust was not burnt.

The inference would be that there had not been so much fire at that point in the North Crosscut? — The inference was that it was travelling quicker.

As a rule does an explosion travel the faster the further it gets from the point of ignition? — Yes ; and the quicker it travels the less it will burn.

I suppose it does travel faster till it gets to some place of exit? — Yes.

You mentioned two stoppings in that northernmost east board having been blown to the north, and two to the south. Which were blown to the south? — The Back Crosscut was one, and the next, the pillar, down another.

They were blown to the south, and the other two to the north? — Yes.

Do you not infer from that that the blast came up from the east side? — Yes.

Taking away those two to the north and then travelling along the east board, you get into the south again? — No, it would be up here and along here, and then they went through there, and came up here and along here (describing the same).

(Mr. Bell.) Which were the two that were blown to the north? — These were the two that were blown to the south, and these were the two that were blown to the north (pointing to the plan). We have not got down to these.

(Mr. Edge.) Do you use a Clanny lamp in your pit? — No.

(A Juryman.) Do you think it is possible to fire at those two lamps, these, McCabe's and Middlemas's lamps. Would not the lamps have been damaged more? — I do not see what was to damage the lamp.

Unless she had exploded the lamp, would not the gauze have been burnt? — No ; you can light the gas without bursting the gauze.

(Mr. Bowey.) With regard to these stoppings ; the two first are to the south, and the two next to the north? — Yes.

Is that at all inconsistent with the blast coming from the South Crosscut up here (pointing to the map)? — Yes.

On what ground? — I think she had no exit from these face pillars into the fresh air, but came up that way (describing).

If she had come up the South Crosscut to the far end of the North Crosscut might not these stoppings have been blown in the same way? — The first one might, but I cannot see how the second one could have been blown northward ; I cannot see that.

Can you give a reason why they should not. I mean a reason for your opinion? — I cannot say exactly why.

You think not, but you cannot give a reason why they should not have done so if the blast had come in the opposite direction? — I cannot satisfy myself that after blowing the two stoppings southward the blast had travelled in that direction. If the force had travelled north and east I think it would have blown the whole of the stoppings southward.

But why should it have blown the whole of the stoppings southward if it came from the opposite direction to what you think it did? — Because it had a free course down that board.

Had it not a free course, blowing in the way in which you think it did go? — No, it had to travel ; after getting there, it had to come down here and round here (describing on the map).

Further examined by Mr. HEAVISIDE.

Going to Middlemas and McCabe's place, going south, we have it that the props were charred on the south side? — Yes, I think they were.

How do you make that consistent with your opinion that the explosion had occurred in Middlemas and McCabe's place? — I cannot speak positively with regard to the charring in that wall.

On the plates and rails, were there not any indications? — The rails seemed to be drawn out.

But how could the explosion have been in Middlemas and McCabe's place if we have indications of the blast coming from the south? — I did not say that the force had come from the south.

But we have indications? — But I believe it was caused by suction. Of course it is difficult to account for everything ; you find many things and you cannot account for them.

With regard to the suction, is the fire in the suction, you say that it might have been the suction that caused it? — Of the blast.

Yes? — It might be the suction of the fire travelling endways round.

Would there be a flame? — Yes ; there has undoubtedly been fire on the south side. I do not think there would be fire in the suction. I think not.

Then the suction does not account for it if there was not flame in the suction ; the suction does not account for the charring on the south side? — I do not know how to account for it otherwise. These plates were evidently gone something like 7 feet out.

You came across the clothing in Middlemas's place? — Yes.

Was it burnt? — The clothing that I got out from under the stone did not appear to be singed or burnt at all.

It was under the stone? — Yes, there was very little indication immediately in the face just where the clothes were lying. The principal indication was on the north side of the board.

What experience have you had in matters of explosions ; have you any experience at all? — Yes, I was down in the seam.

Immediately after the explosion? — The day of the explosion.

Some time after? — And on other occasions I have been down pits after they have exploded.

Re-examined by Mr. EDGE.

You say that you do not use any Clanny lamps ; do you know that in some places a washer is used to put in between the glass and the flame, both above and below? — Yes, it appears so, but I never saw it used.

Do you know, as a fact, that they are used in different places? — Yes.

They are used as an additional protection and precaution for the safety of the lamp? — Yes, I think so.

Have you ever used Clanny lamps? — Not in the places I am at now.

Have you ever used them? — Yes.

You have not used a washer where you have used the lamp? — No.

You have been cross-examined with regard to the indications down here (pointing to the map) ; did you examine the South Headways? — Yes, only as far as the flat.

Did you find similar indications -

(Mr. Bowey.) I object to that question. We have kept out of that district altogether.

(Mr. Edge.) But I do not know what your theory is. My witness will say this, that they found similar indications in that district to what they found in the other district there (pointing to the map), and it is not disputed that the firing ever came out of that place.

(Mr. Bowey.) We have made it common ground that this had nothing whatever to do with it.

(Mr. Edge.) What I am drawing your attention to is this. It is admitted on every hand that the explosion did not come out of this place ; similar indications were found on the South Headways as were found in the South Crosscut.

(Mr. Bowey.) If that is going to be made a point of in corroboration of your theory and not a point in corroboration of ours, then it ought to have been gone fully into.

(Mr. Edge.) I am quite prepared to go fully into it.

(The Coroner.) It was referred to a short time ago. How far do you mean to carry it, Mr. Edge?

(Mr. Edge.) Only to this extent that they found similar indications here to what they found there (pointing to the plan).

(The Coroner.) It has been referred to before, and therefore it is only right that it should be explained. If Mr. Bowey wishes to cross-examine upon it, he can do so.

(Mr. Bowey.) We are quite out of that district altogether.

(The Coroner.) Except that it has been referred to to-day, and as it has been referred to I think it should be finished with ; and then if any question arises upon it, and you think it worth while to explain away, you can ask questions about it.

(Mr. Edge.) Our object, of course, here is to gain as much information as we can, and if Mr. Bowey says that the explosion took place there (pointing to the plan), I say that it might equally have taken place here (describing).

(The Coroner.) All I can say is that the men were found dead in this particular part of the pit, and it is material to the jury to know how they came by their deaths.

(Mr. Bowey.) But Mr. Edge is getting it out at the fag end of the matter.

(The Coroner.) It is not to be made a point of as far as the explosion occurred.

(Mr. Bowey.) That is all I want. I understand that it did not bear at all upon the question of the explosion.

(The Coroner.) You do not mean to import that as a third place where the explosion took place ; but still as far as fire was found there, and two bodies were found there, it is perfectly relevant to this inquiry that some questions should be addressed respecting it.

(Mr. Bowey.) So far as ascertaining what was the cause of death of these two men, I have no objection to that being thoroughly gone into ; but now this matter is put forward at this stage of the inquiry to support the theory that the explosion by inference occurred in this east narrow board.

(The Coroner.) The jury have nothing whatever to do with the use that is made of it. We will see to what extent the evidence goes, and, if it goes further than I think it ought to go, then I shall stop it. (To Mr. Edge.) How far do you mean to lead evidence respecting it.

(Mr. Edge.) The theory which the gentlemen who instruct me in this matter have formed is, that the explosion took place in Middlemas and McCabe's place. It is suggested by Mr. Bowey that the explosion took place somewhere in the South Crosscut. Whereabouts Mr. Bowey intends to suggest that it took place there is not very obvious to me at present. I say that if any indications there show that that was the origin of the explosion, you can find the same indications where I allege the explosion to have taken place. But I will take it very generally.

(The Coroner.) I cannot shut out evidence of the condition in which the pit was found at that spot.

(Mr. Bowey.) The only ground of complaint that I have is that it was not made an integral part of the information for the jury at the commencement of the proceedings.

(Mr. Edge, to the witness.) How far did you go into the South Headways? — Just into the flat.

Where is the flat? — Here (pointing to the same on the map).

You did not go further in than where Jobson and Turner were found? — No.

Examined by the CORONER.

Will you just look at the plan again with reference to the stoppings which you say were blown, two to the south and two to the north, at the top of the North Crosscuts. The first you say was to the south, and the second to the south, and the third and fourth to the north? — Yes.

A little to the west, I think it is of the fourth pillar, is there a stopping marked on your plan? — Yes.

A little to the south west? — Yes.

Did you notice whether that was in its place, or blown either way? — I think it was blown to the west.

You are not sure about it? — No, I am not sure whether it was brick or not.

You are not sure about it. You think it was blown to the west? — Yes ; I am not sure whether it was brick or canvas.

What stopping do you call it? — That is the back-board stopping.

(Mr. Bell.) A bearing-down or a bearing-up stopping? — A bearing-up, a back-board stopping.

What pillar do you call it? — It is the back board.

It is to the south of the fourth pillar from the North Crosscut? — It is only the second pillar off the back board from the Back Crosscut.

What did you say about that you could not tell? — I do not think it was brick.

Do you think it was blown to the west? — Yes ; and I think it was canvas.

Why do you think it was blown to the west? — The evidence up there seemed to be westward and northward till you got up to the highest pillar.

The next stopping to that, the third from the North Crosscut, is blown to the north you say? — Yes.

How could that be blown to the north unless that stopping which you have just referred to was really blown to the west think it would be blown to the west.

You did not at that time notice that stopping? — It was canvassed ; there were lots of pieces of canvas lying about rolled up, and you could not tell where they came from.

You admit as a fact that the third stopping from the North Crosscut could not have been blown to the north, unless that stopping had been previously blown down? — Yes, and it went westward.

It must have been blown down first? — Yes.

But you did not notice it? — No. I examined all the brick stoppings very minutely, but you cannot find any evidence on the wall side of canvas stoppings. The canvas stopping were simply tight in two props.

The witness withdrew.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print