1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
West Stanley Inquest, First Day, Thursday, 25th May, 1882 (cont.).
John Mosson sworn. Examined by Mr. Edge.
You are a deputy overman in the west district of the West Stanley Pit? — Yes.
In the Busty Seam? — Yes.
Were you in the back shift on the 18th April last? — Yes.
At what time did you go down in the pit? — Half-past 9 o'clock in the morning.
When did you ride to bank? — Twenty minutes past five at night.
Will you tell me which district you travelled that day? — The East Flat of the South Crosscut.
The East Flat of the North Crosscut and the South Crosscut? — Yes.
Did you fire any shots that day? — No.
Were you on that going board in the East Flat (pointing to the plan)? — Yes.
In to the face? — Yes.
Did you examine for gas that day? — Yes.
Did you examine the end of that going-board? — Yes, the Mothergate Board.
Did you find any trace of gas there? — No.
Did you leave some props there? — I went to set a middle prop in the east going-board, and he would not let me, and I then went to set a pair of gears, and he would not let me.
(The Coroner.) Who was he? — Joseph Nesbitt, the hewer.
(Mr. Edge.) Did you leave some props there? — Yes.
Did you examine any other part of the pit for gas that day? — Yes, every place I went round I looked for gas.
Did you examine the South Crosscut? — Yes.
Did you find any gas there? — None.
Did you find any trace of gas at all that day? — No, not a bit.
How was the ventilation when you came out of the pit that night? — Just as good as ever it was.
Was the air travelling up to the face? — Yes.
Did you see anything that night to cause you any anxiety that made you think there was any danger to the pit? — No.
When you came out was the timber set up to the face? — Within about 15 inches.
(Mr. Morley.) Where was that? — In the working places.
(The Coroner.) Are you speaking of all the working places, or only of some of them ; the timbering would not be the same in all the places? — No, we always set them as close as we could, to get them up to the top stone.
In the east going board where was the timber? — Within 15 inches of the face.
(Mr. Edge.) And down in those fore and back headways in the South Crosscut, how was the timber there? — It was close to.
Was the air travelling freely along the face? — Yes.
Cross-examined by Mr. Bowey.
When did you last see gas in the North Crosscut on the east side in the neighbourhood of Middlemas and McCabe's place? — About a month before the misfortune happened.
(The Coroner.) Is it entered in your book? — No.
(Mr. Bowey.) Is this the only book in which you make any entries? — That is the only book we make our entries into.
Did you enter into this book the gas which you found a month ago in that place? — No, as soon as ever I see it in the morning, I put some canvas up and sent it out.
Did you not report it? — No.
(The Coroner.) Why did you not report it? — Because I had put the canvas on, and cleared away the gas before the men went in.
(Mr. Bowey.) You had found gas and had cleared it off? — Yes.
But you did not report it? — No.
Is that the course you usually adopt? — No.
Do you not usually, when you find gas, and clear it away, report it? — That is the only time I ever see any down there.
Is it your practice, when you find gas and clear it away, not to report it? — I never seen none in any other place.
Nor in this place at any other time? — No.
You are quite sure about that? — Yes.
Have you ever fired any shots in that place? — Yes.
When did you last fire a shot in that place? — I could not say how long before that exactly.
Whom did you fire it for? — I fired one for both Nesbitt and Watson, the two men that was working there.
Have ever fired a shot there for Purdy? — Yes.
When was that? — I could not say ; not to a week.
How many weeks do you think? — It is four months since I fired a shot for him.
Was not there some gas come off then? — When I fired him a shot, it set fire to the brattice.
(The Coroner.) What came off and set fire to the brattice? — The coal dust on the back side of the brattice took fire and burned the brattice ; it set fire to it.
(Mr. Bowey.) Did not some gas come off? — No.
Did you ever know coal dust to cause the brattice to catch fire in that way before? — No, I never was in a pit where there was any brattice before.
You say distinctly that there was no gas coming off? — No, there was not.
Did you report it? — No.
Why did you not report it? — I asked the overman if it was needful, and he said no.
(The Coroner.) What is his name? — William Anderson.
Is he overman now? — Yes.
When did you ask him? — That day, and the next day too.
(Mr. Bowey.) What did you ask him? — I asked him if it was needful to report it, and he said no.
Was it a blown out shot? — It was a side-on shot, and went right on to that side of the brattice.
How long have you been a deputy at this pit? — I have been a deputy for about four years.
Did you ever report anything as happening in the pit? — Nothing has ever happened in my time.
Have you ever reported anything as occurring in the pit? — No.
You have always reported "all right," I suppose? — Yes.
And did you report "all right" on this occasion when the brattice took fire? — Yes.
You mentioned it to the overman? — Yes, I went out of the shaft that morning myself as soon as ever it happened.
And he told you that you need not report it? — Yes.
How often do you examine the working places? — Every morning before the men go in first.
Every morning? — Yes.
When you go in first? — Yes.
Do you always go in first? — No ; we go in turn.
Do you always, when you go in first, examine the working places? — Yes.
Do you ever make any report about the working places? — Nothing, but when I went home, if I thought it was right.
Where do you report it if you think it is not right? — At the office.
In writing? — Yes.
In this book? — Yes.
This is just the style of it? — Yes.
I ask you again, will you swear that there was no gas given off on that occasion when the brattice fired? — Yes.
You swear that? — Yes.
Are these reports in your own handwriting? — No.
Whose handwriting are they in? — Thomas Curry and Coulson when they went together.
Can you write? — No.
Can you read? — I can read a little, but not much.
Have you ever put a mark in the book? — Yes, I always put a cross on.
Has Curry always written in the book? — Curry or Coulson.
What made you suspect it was coal dust that took fire behind the brattice? — Because I screwed my lamp off.
Did you examine behind the brattice? — Yes, right into the end of the brattice.
Did you go into the back side of of the brattice? — No.
Was the shot pointed towards the brattice? — The shot was at the left-hand side of the brattice ; it was not pointing right into the back side of the brattice.
And there might have been gas behind that brattice, where you did not examine it? — I should not go into the brattice.
There might be gas in behind that brattice, and the shot pointing that way (describing) might ignite it, might it not? — No ; there was no gas I could find, not at the brattice end.
Supposing you had gone 5 or 6 yards further, what might you have found then? — I could not have found anything.
There might have been gas in that place, and the shot fired back into it? — Yes.
You talked about a middle prop ; what was your reason for setting that prop? — I went up with this man to put a pair of gears in, and he said I could not get the levels if I did.
Was she getting heavy? — Yes.
Was there any hissing or singing noise? — She was singing a little at the bottom.
What was it? — The water way, I expect it would be.
Did you ever know water hissing off in that way without gas, do not you think it would be the gas coming off, bubbling up through the water making that hissing noise? — There might be a little gas amongst it, but it never showed any upon the lamp.
How do you fire your shots? — With touch.
And wire? — No, we unscrew the lamp.
There was this singing noise on the 18th, that was the day before the accident? — Yes.
Did you notice the stone on the left? — Yes, it was breaking itself down the left nook.
Did you see anything of the hitch leader? — Yes.
Was there any close into the face? — Yes, taken from the base a little bit.
How long is it since there was a shot fired in that going-board? — I cannot say to a week, because our men do not fire many shots.
Why did not they fire shots in that particular place? — Because the stone used to come down itself ; and they did not fire any shots in the coal.
Were there no shots fired in that going-board? — No.
How wide was it? — It might be five or six yards wide.
What is your mode for setting the timber? — Back of the band.
Do you ever prop the band up? — They prop it up themselves as they go in under it.
The South Crosscut is in you district? — Yes.
Did you ever see gas in the South Crosscut? — No.
Did you ever hear any singing noise there? — No.
Was she not singing a day before the explosion? — No.
Are you instructed to report gas in your book whenever you find it? — Yes ; but when I fired that shot he said it did not need my reporting it.
When you found gas in the place? — Yes.
How is it that you did not enter it in your book? — Because we always get it out before the men have to go in.
Is it not your duty to report to the overman or manager, in writing, that gas has been found in a certain place and you have cleared it out? — We never did do it. I never see it but this once.
You said you always got it out before the men went in? — Yes.
Have you done it more than once? — I got it out that time at that place.
And how many times before that? — Never.
Is that the only time you ever said it? — That was the only time I ever see'd it.
When do you make this report, or when is it made for you ; what time of the day I mean? — 11 o'clock.
Do you make the report in the pit? — No, in the office.
If the workmen wanted to see this report on the state of their pit before going into work, they could not see it and therefore they would not be informed of what condition the mine was in? — Do you mean the hewers.
Yes? — No, the book was in the office.
And you have no means of reporting it at the chest at the bottom of the pit? — No.
Have you had the rules read over to you? — No.
Have you read them yourself? — No.
Do you mean to say that you have not had the special rules of the colliery, with reference to your particular duties, read over to you? — No.
Are you a deputy or an overman? — A deputy.
And have you never been told by anyone connected with the pit, what your duties were with reference to reporting? — Well, we always knew that we had to report gas, when we see'd it.
Have you been told that it is your duty to enter it in the book when you see it? — Yes.
Who has told you that? — Mr. Johnson.
Did he at the same time read over the rules to you with regard to deputy's duties? — No.
He merely told you that you were to enter a report in the book when you found gas? — Yes.
On the 18th did you go up the end of this east-going board (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes. I was right in the face.
How far did the brattice extend up? — It may have been three yards from the face right to the tub end.
What is the length of the face at the end of the east-going board to the Stenton? — I am sure I do not know, about 30 yards from the Stenton down to the face.
And the brattice went up ; how many yards? — 30 yards, or close to it.
And the tubs stood beyond that? — Yes.
Where was it that you heard the hissing sound? — Just at the side of the tub end on the left hand side.
Was it in front of the tub? — It was just at the end of the tub.
In by the tub or out by the tub? — The in-by end of the tub.
Would that be close to the face of the coal? — It might be 4 or 5 feet from the face of the coal.
At the top or bottom of the board? — The bottom of the board.
Did you examine at that point when you heard the hissing sound? — Yes.
Did you examine for gas there? — Yes.
Did you find any gas at all? — No.
Did you notice anything on the floor of the board? — No.
Was it heaving at all? — No, not when I was in.
Have you been down there since the explosion? — Yes ; I was in yesterday.
Had you been down before yesterday? — No, never before yesterday.
Can you see whether the floor has been heaving since then? — Yes, she has been heaving.
And has it lowered since the explosion? — Yes.
Did you notice any hissing sound there? — Yes, she is still singing at the bottom.
Did you hear any other noises? — No.
Did you hear what you call a bowk? — No, she was quite still when I was in yesterday ; but I never had been in till yesterday since the 18th.
What is a bowk? — It is a bowk on the stone.
You say you heard the hissing still? — Yes.
But nothing else? — No.
On the 18th you say you examined the South Crosscuts? — Yes.
Were they preparing for any shots then? — No, not when I was in.
You were in the back shift were you not? — Yes.
I suppose you knew that shots were to be fired there? — At night, yes.
You knew that shots were going to be fired there? — Yes.
And you examined up to the heads of those boards (pointing to the diagram)? — Right on the face of them.
Have you ever travelled round to the west of the North Crosscuts? — Yes, I have gone right round them.
Did you examine that part on that day? — No.
There are a number of hitches are there not across the west working? — Yes.
Have you ever found gas about them? — No, never.
And you say that this time when you saw gas was the only occasion on which you had seen gas? — Yes.
In any part of the mine? — Yes.
How far was the shot from the brattice that took fire? — Right straight from the end of it.
But how far is it from the brattice? — It may have been a couple of yards from the side of the brattice.
Was the fresh air going round the brattice? — Yes.
And behind it? — Yes.
I suppose the brattice sent the air up one way and down the other? — Yes.
When you get a working place in like that, and you put up a brattice like that, the air goes up round there and comes down (pointing to the diagram)? — Yes.
(Mr. Morley.) Was that in the same board as they are working now? — That is the board (pointing out the same).
(The Coroner.) Was it the same place that Middlemas and McCabe were working at? — Yes, the same going-board.
(Mr. Edge.) How long before the explosion was that? — I should say about four months.
Was there anything particular about the shot ; did you notice anything particular about the shot? — The shot might have been damp when it was put in. The top was damp in places, and she might get a little damp before I fired it.
What would be the effect of that? — It would blow it out.
Do you know whether it was a blown out shot? — Yes, it was on account of the shot being damp that made it flare out.
(The Coroner.) The shot blew out from the place being damp where it was? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) You have spoken of this singing noise ; have you examined that part where you heard that singing noise? — Yes.
Have you ever found gas there? — No.
Do you know what makes the singing noise? — Gas in the bottom.
But you could not find it? — No.
How long have you been in the pit? — 37 or 38 years.
How long have you been acting as deputy? — About four years.
When you make your reports do you tell anyone what you want to report? — I always tell the man that writes my reports.
You told Curry or Coulson what they were to write down for you? — Yes.
Why did you report "all right" when the brattice took fire? — I asked the overman, and he said I did not need to have reported it when just the brattice took fire.
Was the shot that fired the brattice in a paper cartridge, or was it merely loose powder? — It was in paper in a cartridge.
Was much of the brattice burnt? — About 10 or 12 yards. When I went in I pulled it off to hinder it from getting burnt.
As I understand, you only found gas in the pit once? — That is all.
And the reason you say you did not report it was that you got it cleared off before the men went in? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) What do you say was the cause of the shot blowing out? — Being damp.
Do you say it was so? — I think it would be that way.
Because before, you said it "might" be ; do you say it was damp or not? — I never see'd one blow when it was dry.
(The Coroner.) You say on the one hand you think it was damp, and on the other you never saw one fired that was dry? — Yes.
You say the powder was wet? — The hole was wet.
(Mr. Bowey.) Not the powder? — No.
(The Coroner.) The place itself was wet ; that is what you mean? — Yes.
(Mr. Bates, a juryman.) Had you examined these South Crosscuts that day before you left the pit? — Yes.
How wide are they? — They are about 8 or 9 feet wide ; I would not like to say.
The brattice is a good distance from the wall, is it not? — It might be four feet from the wall side.
Where do they take this band to that they shoot down at night? — It is stowed away into the old boards.
They take it out do they not? — Some of it.
Where do they put the other? — There is part of it lies on places.
In front of the brattice, or behind it? — Behind the brattice.
With regard to this east board, what width is she where Middlemas was found? — Between 5 and 6 yards wide.
It is all stowed there I suppose? — All that it makes itself.
Behind the brattice? — No, on the sides.
There is some behind the brattice, is there not? — Yes.
Did it not get on fire when it came in contact with the coal dust damp? — No, it got put out directly.
Did it start away from the bottom or the top? — On the top.
Was the coal dust going to get fire and climb right up tot the top? — The canvas took hold of the bottom side.
You only found gas on one occasion on this east board. Have you ever had a lamp that has flashed off and lighted up the top? — I never did.
So that the coal dust would take hold and set fire to the brattice? — No.
The brattice would be damp as well? — No, the brattice was just new put in ; just new from the store house the day before.
It is damp substance, is it not? — Yes, it is damp with coal tar.
(The Coroner.) And it readily takes fire? — Yes.
Who was present in Purdy's place when the shot blew out and set fire to the brattice? — Purdy himself.
Who else? — And James Shaw by the side of him.
Was he a hewer? — Yes.
Was the putter anywhere about? — Not at the time. He came in just after.
Was anybody else about except you and Purdy and Shaw? — Yes, there was another man there, but he was in the face of the headways at the time.
(Mr. Bates.) With regard to this shot that you fired ; did she go off, did she make a report? — Yes.
She would be done with then. If the hole was damp she would have a better chance to keep the fire down would she not. You have heard tell of these pit cartridges encased with tin? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) What was done afterwards with the hole ; did you charge it again? — No, it was never charged again.
(Mr. Bell.) Did she do her work? — No, it was in the stone top band.
And none of the stone came away? — No.
Just the stemming? — Yes.
How did you get the stone away? — We wedged it down.
(The Coroner.) Whereabouts was Purdy standing when you fired that shot? — He was back-by.
Then you really were the only person at the place when it was fired? — Yes, and Purdy stood back-by.
But he would not see the operation? — No.
He would have no better chance of seeing than Shaw had, who was in the headways? — He was standing a little bit further back of me ; it may be 10 or 12 yards further back of me.
(Mr. Bates, a juryman.) With regard to this east-going board, it is about four months ago when you talk about this damp shot being fired? — Yes.
Has any shot been fired since? — Yes.
They still continue to fire shots in this South Crosscuts, back and front? — Yes.
Is it true that at this South Crosscut you can walk up (pointing to the diagram)? — No, not at places.
Can you creep up? — Yes.
Is there sufficient space for the air to flow over the top of the band to supply the men? — Yes.
These places were going towards a trouble, were they not? — Yes, they were at a trouble ; at a hitch.
There is very often an extra quantity of gas that comes off, is there not? — There has been ; but I have never seen none of it.
Is not this band taken out by the putter, and stowed away in some of the other boards? — Yes, a portion of it.
Has some been taken away? — Yes.
What distance was the brattice off the face of the Back Crosscut? — It may be 3 yards from the face? — No.
It was not seven? — No.
Nicholson said it was generally bratticed up to within a yard of the face? — I do not know what he said.
(Mr. Bell.) Then I understand you to say that he had got a " trouble " in the South Crosscut? — It is a hitch.
It is not a false slip at the next pitch ; a slip up or down ; it is a roll? — Yes.