1882 West Stanley Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
West Stanley Inquest, First Day, Thursday, 25th May, 1882.
The names of the Jury were called over, and all answered to their names.
Mr. John Edge appeared for the owner of the colliery (Mr. John Henry Burn).
Mr. Bowey (of Messrs. Bowey and Brewis, of Sutherland) appeared for the Miners National Union of Great Britain. Mr. Heaviside appeared for the Durham Miners Union.
(Mr. Edge.) Sir, I propose, with your permission, in the first instance to call Mr. Johnson, the manager, to describe in what condition the pit was when it was last seen.
(The Coroner.) Then, with a view to preserving as much order and regularity as we can in the proceedings, and to save time, probably, the proper course will be for Mr. Bowey next to call his witnesses, if he intends calling any, at the conclusion of the evidence on behalf of the owner.
(Mr. Bowey.) I presume Mr. Edge will follow the same course that we have pursued in previous inquiries, namely, call his witnesses first, and then after his witnesses are exhausted I shall be at liberty to call any I think fit, and then will follow the scientific evidence.
(The Coroner.) Quite so. In order to preserve something like regularity in the examination and cross-examination, and so on, Mr. Edge will examine his witnesses in chief ; Mr. Bowey will then cross examine them, and then any questions either Mr. Bell, or Mr. Willis, or Mr. Atkinson may wish to put, will follow. Then Mr. Morley may have some questions, probably, to ask, and if I wish to put any questions I shall succeed Mr. Morley, or if the jury desire to ask any questions they may precede me, and I will come last. Mr. Johnson has been already sworn, and before his examination is proceeded with I would ask him whether he wishes to vary the deposition he has already made, or to add anything to it, so far as the facts stated by him on the previous occasion are concerned, because if not, we need not have it repeated now. (To Mr. Edge) I think you have a copy of the deposition before you?
(Mr. Edge.) Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) The deposition had better be read, had it not?
(The Coroner.) Very well.
The following deposition was then read :—
"I am resident manager of West Stanley Colliery. On April the 19th, 1882, 18 men were in the Busty Seam, of whom two were deputies, and 16 were shifters. The two deputies, Thomas Coulson (13), and Thomas Curry (4) (both deceased), had been down the pit a shift and a half or two shifts, commencing at 9.30 a.m. on the 19th April 1882. Of the 16 shifters two, namely, James Clark (2) (deceased), and John Clark (1) (deceased), went down the pit at 5 p.m. 18th April 1882 ; the remaining 14 all went down at 9 p.m. The back shift men had ridden at 5 p.m. 18th April 1882. On the 19th April 1882, at 1 a.m., I was awakened and informed of an explosion having taken place. I immediately took proper means to collect an exploring and relief party. The down-cast shaft was blocked, and the guides being broken at the bottom by the explosion, I got the brakeman to the up-cast shaft and descended it by the cage to the Hutton Seam, and travelled round to the Busty Shaft ; got the cage up that far, and into the guides, and got down the downcast shaft from the Hutton to the Busty Seam, and when in the South Flat west district, about 400 yards from the shaft, found the dead bodies of John Westgarth (5), John Douglas (6), William John Riley (7), Robert Hutchinson (8). Westgarth, Riley, and Douglas were close together, Hutchinson was a little further in, Westgarth's hair was scarcely singed, but the others were burnt more or less. John Thomas Coulson's (13) dead body was found in the sump at the bottom of the Busty Shaft, and not recovered until the morning of the 20th April 1882. The working place of Coulson and Curry was about 480 yards south of the shaft, but they had finished their job and were at the shaft ready to ride."
(The Coroner to Mr. Johnson.) You have heard your deposition read. Are there any corrections you wish to make?
(Mr. Johnson.) Only with respect to the distances at which the men had been working. In the case of Coulson and Curry the distance was 480 yards from the shaft where the bodies were found. Westgarth was 445 yards from the shaft, Douglas 465 yards, Riley 470 yards, and Hutchinson 494 yards.
(The Coroner.) That is why I thought you should have the opportunity of considering what you had said in your deposition, because your evidence was taken no doubt at a time when you were considerably agitated by what had happened, and it was hardly fair to restrict you to distances and so on, at such a time. Are there any further corrections that you wish to make?
(Mr. Johnson.) No, I think not.
Mr. William Johnson was then called and examined by Mr. Edge, as follows :—
This colliery is the property of Mr. John Henry Burn? — Yes.
You are the certificated manager? — Yes.
There are four shafts at the colliery, are there not? — Yes.
Two of which only go down to the Busty Seam? — Yes.
One is the down-cast shaft and the other is the up-cast shaft? — Yes.
The down-cast shaft you call the Busty Shaft, I think? — Yes.
And the up-cast shaft you call the Lamp Shaft? — Yes.
What is the depth from the surface to the bottom of the Busty Shaft? — 140 fathoms.
From which shaft do you draw the coal in the Busty Seam? — The Busty Shaft.
What distance are the two shafts apart? — 14 feet.
Do you produce a plan, a copy of which is on the wall, showing the ventilations and the workings in the Busty Seam? — Yes.
The unfortunate explosion which occurred on the morning of the 19th of April was confined to the Busty seam? — Yes.
You have also, have you not, a section of the seams in those two shafts? — Yes, but the section is not drawn to scale.
There were in all, I think, 18 men in the Busty Seam at the time of the explosion? Yes, men and boys.
Five of those were saved. In which district were the five men? — In the north side, in this district here (pointing to the plan).
What is marked on the plan as "North Headways Flat"? — Yes.
Now I want you to tell me what does the underground shaft consist of. You are the certificated and resident manager. Then there is the overman and wasteman, William Anderson, an old man, the back overman, Thomas J. Coulson, who is dead? — Yes.
And then the master shifter, Robert Hunter, who is also dead? — Yes.
And four deputies? — Yes.
Two for each shift? — Yes, one of whom is dead.
And 25 hewers per shift? — Yes.
(Mr. Morley.) Did you say that the two deputies were dead? — One deputies.
(Mr. Edge.) What is the name of the deputy who is dead? — Thomas Curry.
How is the ventilation of the colliery managed. I believe it is managed by a fan at the up-cast shaft? — Yes.
The air goes down this down-cast shaft here (pointing to the plan), and works round these blue roads past the working faces and comes back along the returns to the up-cast shaft, and is sucked up by the fan? — Yes.
What is the amount of the ventilating current that passes down the down-cast shaft per minute? — We have 27,600 going into the Busty Seam.
27,600 cubic feet per minute went into the Busty Seam? — Yes.
Can you tell me how much of that went into the North Headways Flat district. I have a little table which I shall put in directly. I will take it in the order in which I have got it here. I will take the intake regularly in order. Have you prepared a table showing the length of the intakes and of the returns, and the quantity of air, &c. that is ventilating the shaft? — Yes.
I will take first of all the North Crosscut. This is the district, I suppose, which is called the North Crosscut in here (pointing to the plan)? — Yes.
What is the length of the intake there from the down-cast shaft to the return? — 1,137 yards.
And that is taken, is it not, in this way : you travel round this intake here, and go round here, and come along here (describing)? — Yes.
(Mr. Morley.) That is the north side of the North Crosscut? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) What is the length from the return to the shaft? — 376 yards.
The working face in that east district of the North Crosscut is 299 yards, is it not? — Yes.
And the main tramways and stall roads are 515 yards? — Yes.
The average area of the intake is 32 square feet? — Yes.
The average area of the return is 36 square feet? — Yes.
The average velocity of the intake before it arises at the Splitting is 202? — Yes.
What is that? — Lineal Feet.
The number of working places in that district was eight? — Yes.
The maximum number of men and boys in that district per coal shift was 15? — Yes.
The number of horses and ponies was five? — Yes.
And the quantity of air in cubic feet per minute going into that district was 6,459 cubic feet? — Yes.
Then take the West Flat of the North Crosscut, that is the district here (pointing to the plan)? — Yes.
The distance along the intakes there to the returns is how many yards? — 1,225.
(Mr. Morley.) That will be from the shaft again? — Yes.
(Mr. Bell.) What district is that? — The West Flat. The 372 yards is from the split.
(Mr. Edge.) From the split here (pointing to the plan), to the north of this North Crosscut is 372 yards? — Yes.
From the end of that return to the upcast shaft was 264 yards?
(The Coroner.) No, that has been corrected, you will see it in the next column.
(The Witness.) It is 527 yards.
(Mr. Edge.) Then the working space in the west district was 66 yards? — Yes.
The main and stall roads 238 tramway yards? — Yes.
Then the average area of the intake there was 32 square feet, and the average of the area of the return 36. The average velocity of the intake before splitting was 139 ; the number of working places three. The maximum number of men and boys per coal shift 5 ; the number of horses and ponies two ; and 4,459 cubic feet of fresh air a minute going in? — Yes.
Then I will take you to the South Crosscut, which is here (pointing to the plan). The South Crosscut along the intake to the returns is 464 yards? — Yes.
And from the return to the up-cast shaft 858 yards? — Yes.
Working face 396 yards? — Yes.
Main and stall roads 572 yards? — Yes.
Average area of intake 32 and 36 for the returns? — Yes.
The average velocity 156, eight working places, 10 men and boys, three horses and ponies, and 5,000 cubic feet going into it a minute? — Yes.
Then there is the South Headways and that is this district down here to the south of the pit (pointing to the plan) the South Headways into the return is 440 yards? — Yes.
The return is 550 yards? — Yes.
The working face 84 yards? — Yes.
The main roads and stalls 286? — Yes.
The average area of intake 32, and the return 35? — Yes.
The average velocity of the intake 145 ; two working places, six men and boys, two horses and ponies, and 4,632 cubic feet of air per minute going into it? — Yes.
Have you allowed 3,000 cubic feet a minute for leakage and for the stables? — Yes.
Then I go to the North Headways Flat, which is this district up here (pointing to the plan). The intake there is 330 yards into the return ; 308 yards to the length of the returns ; 110 yards working face ; 242 main and stall roads , 35 average area of intake, and 35 average area of the return ; average velocity of intake 130 ; four working places ; eight men and boys ; three horses and ponies, and 4,050 cubic feet of air per minute going in, making a total of 27,600 cubic feet of air going into the Busty Seam? — Yes, that is right.
(Mr. Morley.) Then the return from the South Crosscut is 858 yards, whereas the return from the West Flat is 527 yards? — There are no working places beyond that. We measured from the last working place to the shaft.
Then it ought to be marked red from there to there (pointing to the plan)? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) Previously to the accident, on the morning of the 19th of April, when had you been last down the pit? — On the 18th.
At what time did you ride to bank? — At ten o'clock in the forenoon.
Which district had you been travelling in on the 18th? — I had been in the south returns. I met the overman coming over the South Flats, and I went back with him into the North Crosscuts.
What you call the South Flat is marked "South Headway" on the plan? — Yes.
And you went down the returns in the South Headways? — Yes, and I met the overman at the Flats.
Where did you go and he go? — I went down the West Narrow Boards into the West Crosscuts.
You went down on the morning of the 18th April? — Yes.
And you say you travelled into the South Headways district? — Yes.
And you travelled by the returns, or how did you travel? — I travelled by the returns, and I came back over and came out at the door into the stables on the intake and met the overman at the Flat coming out. He had been in to these men.
What overman was that? — Anderson.
Where did you and the overman go then? — Down the West Narrow Boards into the South Crosscuts, and I remained some considerable time with these men in the South Crosscuts arranging with them about their work.
There were men working in the face of the South Crosscuts? — Yes; they had a drill and face. In point of coal there was very little coal to work out.
Where did you go from that? — I went from there to the East Flat here (pointing to the plan) and met Middlemas coming out.
You met him at the Flat? — No, just at the air crossing here (pointing to the plan), and I spoke to him and asked him how they were getting on.
You spoke to whom? — To Middlemas, the fore shift deputy, and I came out with both him and the overman, and went into the shaft, and I went into the drift, and took measurements of the stone drift ; and after doing that I came out and met them at the shaft, and rode with them to bank.
In what condition was the pit when you left it, in the district that you had travelled over.? — All right. I should not have left them had it not been all right.
Did you see any trace of gas that day? — None whatever.
Did any of the men suggest to you that there was any gas in any of the places you had been in? — No.
You told the coroner and the jury on the previous occasion that you arranged for a relief or search party? — Yes.
(Mr. Morley.) What was the time of the explosion? — One a.m. on the 19th.
(Mr. Edge.) Now I will take you very shortly through the remainder of the questions I have to put to you. You had some difficulty in getting down the shaft owing to the cage, had you not? — Yes ; the cage that was in the bottom was out of the guides. The guides being broken at the bottom. the cage when brought up at the Hutton Seam was out of the guides and we were drawn up the best way we could. After getting it replaced we slung the outer cage in the shaft and went down to the bottom of the Busty Seam, and finding that we could not get on to the bottom from the cage that was already slung, and the broken material coming up we went up the upcast shaft again to seek a ladder sufficiently long, and after bringing that ladder down I gave information that no one was either to come up or go down the up-cast shaft, as the return was becoming very strong. We then proceeded with the ladder and got communication with the men, and got the five rescued men out, and the four dead bodies that were lying at the bottom, and we carried on that communication till we recovered all the bodies but Coulson's, which we could not recover, because I was under the impression that he was in the sump, and we had the water to draw off and get other brick material out, which occupied us till 9 o'clock before we recovered his body.
When you got down to the Busty will you show me the district that you went into? — Straight south-west to the west.
Did you find Curry, the two Clarks, and Hunter in the neighbourhood of that downcast shaft? — Yes.
From that shaft where did you travel? — South, to the West narrow Board end.
From that where did you travel? — Straight west.
How far did you get in? — The up-cast No. 1 was blowing out, and we had it replaced with canvas, and we replaced all the stoppings as we went in.
You replaced all the stoppings on the right of the travelling road as you went in? — Yes ; I might say that Nicholson, one of the survivors, told me where the men were working, he being one of the shifters.
You got into the back end of the South Crosscut ; what did you do then? — Turned the air into that South Crosscut and went away round there (describing).
Where it is marked on the plan? — Yes.
Then did you go on further? — We found Douglas next.
And then Riley? — Yes, and Hutchinson about half way through the Stenton.
What did you do then? — We got them sent out as soon as possible, and examined the places and came out.
Which places did you examine there? — Numerous places, the winnings.
Those two places (pointing to the plan)? — Yes, and backwards and forwards there (describing).
What did you find in the innermost place there, the east innermost place of the Fore Crosscut? — We found there a hole drilled and shot in it, and stemmed with a straw and touch paper upon it, which is here (producing the same. )
Is this the touch paper? — Yes.
And this the straw? — Yes.
Was the powder in the straw or not? — Yes, I took it out of the hole.
That had not been fired? — No.
It was made ready for firing, but had not been fired? — Yes.
(Mr. Morley.) Was the straw in the hole? — Yes, it was partly hanging out, sometimes like that (describing).
(Mr. Edge.) Who was with you when you found that? — Mr. Atkinson was with me, and Mr. Colquhoun.
(The Coroner.) Do you mean Mr. Atkinson the Inspector of Mines? — Yes, and Mr. Colquhoun was the other, the workmen were getting the bodies away.
(Mr. Edge.) Whose working place was that? — Douglas's.
It is the east winning place? — Yes. It was Westgarth's place, it was not Douglass', the Fore Crosscut.
Did you examine this other Crosscut? — Yes.
What did you find there? — We found some stones lying there, and at the east side of the Crosscut there had been a shot fired, a nicking shot along the east nook of the place in the Back Crosscut.
(The Coroner.) Whose place was that? — That was Douglas's place, and a pick and a cracket on the top of the stones where the men had been dressing the west side of the place back.
(Mr. Edge.) Were the pit and the cracket on the top of the stones that had come down from the effect of the shot? — Yes.
Who was there with you? — Just the same party. I do not know exactly who may have been in the face, or who may not have been there after me ; it was the same exploring party.
As I understand, the effect of what you say is that in the Fore Crosscut a shot had been made ready to fire, and had not been fired ; you found the kitty primed with touch paper, and you found the workmen's tools, that is to say the pick and the cracket, on the top of the stone that had come down from the shot? — Yes.
The men had been working there after the shot had been fired? — Yes.
From there where did you go? — We came back over to the south way end and changed the stopping, put a stopping into the south way end, and took the air off there.
You got out the men there? — Yes, and we drove the air into the east district.
Were those men that were in the South Crosscut whom you found burnt? — Yes, they were more or less burnt ; they were all more or less burnt about the hands and face slightly ; but in the case of one man, I think it was Westgarth, you could scarcely, in fact, find singeing upon his hair, it was so slight. I think it was Westgarth.
But the others were more or less burnt? — Yes, about the hands and face.
You turned off the air into the North Crosscuts? — Yes.
Why did you turn the air into the North Crosscut? — To recover these other bodies.
You had been told that there were two men working in there? — Yes. Nicholson told us where the men would be, and the deputy was one of the party, and he said he thought he would know where they would be just at that time from the amount of work they would have to do.
You did not go with the exploring party? — No ; at this point I was sent for to come to bank.
Did you leave the exploring party in charge of Mr. Fairlie? — Yes.
And then you rode to bank? — Yes.
When next did you go down? — It would be about 4 o'clock ; it was about 6 or 7 o'clock when we went back again with Mr. Baker Forster.
What time was it when you rode to bank on the 19th? — It would be, I think, about 4 o'clock in the afternoon.
How long had you been down the pit then? — I had been down and home seeing to some men at the bank from the time of the explosion happening.
How soon did you go down after you came up? — It was between 6 and 7 o'clock that I went back with Mr. Baker Forster that evening.
Where did you go with Mr. Baker Forster and Mr. Fairlie? — We went south and west, and turned round to go and join the search party into the No. 2 crossing, and we met them coming out ; they had recovered two bodies.
You went into that West Narrow Board district? — Yes. Mr. Fairlie turned back with us.
They were bringing Middlemas and McCabe out? — Yes.
Did you go into the face of that place? — Yes.
How did you go in? — Travelled up there and down there (pointing to the plan).
That is to say you travelled up that North Crosscut till you came to where McCabe had been found? — Yes.
Did you find where McCabe's and Middlemas' lamp were? — No ; the exploring party found them ; they had them with them.
Did you find any of their clothes in there? — They had also been found within a few minutes by the exploring party.
May I take it that there was no one at all working that night in the North Crosscuts west side? — No.
Were the only two men working in the North Crosscut east side Middlemas and McCabe? — Yes.
What were they? — Shifters.
Can you tell me the condition of that place as you found it? — When we went in they were breaking down timber ; it was cracking, and the place was giving off gas very quickly, and Mr. Baker Forster held the lamp back, and there was stone lying right across the face, and he asked me to measure it, and I found it was 10 inches by 2 or 3 feet, as far as I could measure it across the place, and we retreated back at once because she was foul.
What height was that? — That was the thickness of it, about 10 inches by 2 feet broad.
How long was it? — It was right across the face about 4 or 5 yards.
You say you found gas coming off there? — Yes.
Did you open the lamp? — They stood back with the lamp ; the gas was too strong.
(Mr. Morley.) What is the name of the place where they were found? — The East-going board off the North Crosscuts.
(Mr. Edge.) It is the place near where Middlemas and McCabe's names are put on the plan? — Yes.
What did you do after that? — We examined the pit generally, Mr. Baker Forster and Mr. Berkeley, both north and south that east going board, and came back and went round across the south district there (pointing to the plan), and then came back over and examined as far as we could get, and then came out of the pit.
Did you go into the North Headways Flat at all that night? — Yes.
How far did you go into the North Headways Flat that night? — Into the face.
I think we have not heard where all the men were found except three. You were not present when Jobson and Turner were found? — No.
Were you present when Coulson was found in the sump? — Yes ; after getting each of the bodies out, I found he was in the sump because the others were lying so near it, and there was but one sump, and it was in the sump where they had been working that night, and we recovered his body about 9 o'clock in the morning.
I suppose Coulson had been blown into the sump? — Yes ; I think he had been standing with the wrapper in his hand at the time.
(Mr. Edge.) I do not know whether it would be advisable that I should follow the same system that we have pursued elsewhere, and that is to get Mr. Johnson to speak to the indications.
(The Coroner.) I think you had better take the questions relating to that matter in a group afterwards.
(Mr. Edge.) Very well, sir. (To the witness.) Had you any reason to suspect that there was any danger in the pit? — None whatever.
The pit had been examined? — Yes.
Have you got the examination book of the men. The last occasion that it had been examined on behalf of the men was on the 23rd November last year? — Yes ; they only enter it in the overman's book.
"We, the undersigned, have examined the in-takes, main area, returns and working places, and find them in good working order." And then again, I see this, "We, the undersigned, have examined the Busty Pit and found it all right." (Signed) Alexander Johnson and George Anderson? — Yes. This is what they give the overman, just for my satisfaction (handing in a book).
The examination of the 26th July is certified by William Indian and John Jameson. Will you produce the deputy's report books.
The witness produced a book.
(Mr. Bell.) Is that the only book you have? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) What is the book called? — The overman's pocket book.
(Mr. Edge.) Do you produce the deputy's report books? — Yes (producing the same).
May I take it generally from you that the last report of gas was on the 18th March 1882? — Yes. The inspectors have gone through the books.
(Mr. Bell.) I see that there are three entries since the 1st of January? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) Just turn to the 23rd of February. Thomas Curry reported "South Flat district all right except the high headways off on account of gas"? — Yes. We had only two men shifting at that time. They were not on.
The next report of gas is on March 17th, and it is made by James Knox, "South Flat district all right except second headways off on account of gas"? — Yes.
That is the same place that Curry called the High Headways? — Yes.
The next date is the 18th March, another report by James Knox "South flat, all right, except first headways off on account of gas?" — Yes.
Those are the only reports of gas in the pit since the 1st January? — Yes.
Was the pit properly found in timber materials? — Yes.
Do the staff work well under you? — Yes, very well.
Do you consider the ventilation of the pit satisfactory? — Very.
Were any complaints made of the ventilation of the pit? — I never had any ; the reverse.
There was never any complaint made of the ventilation of the pit, you say? — No, never.
(Mr. Bowey.) I do not propose to cross-examine Mr. Johnson now, but take him altogether afterward.
(The Coroner.) Very well.
(Mr. Bowey.) There is just one question I should like to ask him with reference to the measurements of air before he retires (to the witness). Are these measurements made before the explosion or after the explosion? — Before the explosion. The last measurement was on March 15th.
(The Coroner.) That should appear on the return that has been put in. Will you please have the date when the measurement was taken put on (to Mr. Edge). Which copy do you propose to put in.
(Mr. Edge.) I will gat a fresh copy made for you, sir, and it shall be handed in.